Temperament talk please

SonLight

Member
Temperamentally speaking ;) (and all health issues aside) would you say that spending time in person with the sire/dam is a good indication of their litter’s personality? If that litter or puppy (whether 8 weeks or 5 months) is still living with them? I have read something about a temperament test for young dogs/puppies. Can anyone do this when evaluating a pup or does it need to be someone the pup/dog already knows? And can the same tests be done with adult dobes? Can anyone direct me to some good information about these kinds of temperament tests?
Have any of you done these on a dobe prior to your purchase? I realized many times the breeder will choose the dog, however, if you get the opportunity to visit and choose between more than just one how do you choose? Again, all health issues aside.

To let you know where my mind is at the moment…..I’ve been reading many posts on another forum and dobes that turn out with poor temperaments. Some scary stuff! Since I have a family and I’m getting turned away by some rescues because of it I’m beginning to question taking in an adult. Spring is the best time for a puppy and if that’s how I get my dobe then that’s how I get my dobe! Tonight is my first meeting with a local kennel club, and although I hope to meet many people who can guide me it is not a dobe club. :D
 
Very good questions and not easy ones to answer - but yes there are puppy temperament test http://www.workingdogs.com/testing_volhard.htm This is one of the most well known for puppies. It needs to be done by a stranger who knows how to read the different reactions you see in each puppy. It really can't be done correctly if the person doing the evaluation does not know how to read dogs.

For adults it is called showing and trialing the dogs. ALL dogs can appear to be happy confident in their home situation - they feel safe there and more confident. The secret is to put them under pressure and see how they react. The Doberman Pisncher Clubof America has a WAE - Working Appitude Evaluation so dogs with a WAC Working appitude Certificaion have passed the WAE which is a very basic temperament test.

Showing wheter conformation or obedience does at least give you a small idea of if the dog can function outside the home environment under pressure and the ultimate temperament test for working breeds is IPO orSchutzhund with the first basic obedience temperament test being the BH which test the trainability of the dog as well as the dogs willingness to work with his handler. It also has a traffic portion to see how the dog responds to specific things - jogger, bicycle, car horn blaring, people closing in on the dog and circling the dog etc.

You have no idea truly about a couch potato at home. That is why it is important for breeders to learn some of this stuff and apply it. An untrained person would have no clue what they are looking at or how to evaluate it.

To add: Each puppy in a litter will be dirrerent just like siblings are different in personality. That is why some make good show prospect, good obedience prospect and working prospects. Not all puppies ina litter will succeed in these areas. Does not mean they are not a good pet however.

But if the parents have sound temperaments then you have a better chance that the puppies will have a good temperament if socialized, trained etc.
\
Ask them to meet you downtown with all the traffic and people around and see what you get!!!
 
Very good questions and not easy ones to answer - but yes there are puppy temperament test http://www.workingdogs.com/testing_volhard.htm This is one of the most well known for puppies. It needs to be done by a stranger who knows how to read the different reactions you see in each puppy. It really can't be done correctly if the person doing the evaluation does not know how to read dogs.

For adults it is called showing and trialing the dogs. ALL dogs can appear to be happy confident in their home situation - they feel safe there and more confident. The secret is to put them under pressure and see how they react. The Doberman Pisncher Clubof America has a WAE - Working Appitude Evaluation so dogs with a WAC Working appitude Certificaion have passed the WAE which is a very basic temperament test.

Showing wheter conformation or obedience does at least give you a small idea of if the dog can function outside the home environment under pressure and the ultimate temperament test for working breeds is IPO orSchutzhund with the first basic obedience temperament test being the BH which test the trainability of the dog as well as the dogs willingness to work with his handler. It also has a traffic portion to see how the dog responds to specific things - jogger, bicycle, car horn blaring, people closing in on the dog and circling the dog etc.

You have no idea truly about a couch potato at home. That is why it is important for breeders to learn some of this stuff and apply it. An untrained person would have no clue what they are looking at or how to evaluate it.

To add: Each puppy in a litter will be dirrerent just like siblings are different in personality. That is why some make good show prospect, good obedience prospect and working prospects. Not all puppies ina litter will succeed in these areas. Does not mean they are not a good pet however.

But if the parents have sound temperaments then you have a better chance that the puppies will have a good temperament if socialized, trained etc.
\
Ask them to meet you downtown with all the traffic and people around and see what you get!!!

Thank you so much for taking the time to write this! It does make a lot of sense. I didn't even think of the adult dobe outside of its home acting different. Do breeders have others test their dogs sometimes then? Is the WAE similar to a CGC? I'll have to look that up.....and it that only given by the DPCA? So it's not an AKC thing? The BH testing sounds intriguing. I would like to know about that too. Still have so much reading......but it's a lot of fun. Don't get much work done though :cool:
 
The WAE was a test developed by the DPCA to test temperament. The CGC is a very very basic elementary obedience exercise which just shows the dog has some training and good manners in public - come when called, no formal heel, does not jump on people, friendly to people and dogs and it is a good place to start and then move on to the CD - AKC companion dog

Anything that is really really good is a trial competition if you are talking about adult dogs. If you go to the DVG web site you can pull up the heeling pattern for the BH - it is a dog leg with an L out in an open field. There will be a dog on the honor down and a dog on the field working. The dog must heel on lead and off lead - figure 8 though the group, moving sit, moving down recall etc. You can read all about it on the DVG web site.

UDC follows the DVG- AWDF rules and guidelines. for the IPO trials. This at least will give you some things to think about!!!

The AKC CD is all done inside in a ring which is a lot more control but the dog will heel on lead, off lead, figure 8, stand for exam, recall and does not involve a temperament test or traffic portion like the BH which stands for Basic handling. ALL dogs must pass the BH to move on in IPO or Schutzhund (which was what it was always called until recently when it changed)
 
The big question is what are you looking to accomplish with your new Dobie? Are you looking to title in obedience, do tracking, protection or just wanting a good pet? You can find one with a great temperament as a pet that wouldn't be good to do schutzhund. I would suggest to train in obedience regardless, it just makes for a happier well round dog.
 
All great advice above! The only thing I have to say is that, a good breeder will be able to match you with a puppy that fits you and what you are looking to accomplish! They have spent 8+ weeks with the pup, they should know them more than anyone else. :)
 
It is my experience that all dobes are 1) protective (but not harmful - they just bark, and mostly do so from BEHIND you!) and 2) very loyal to their people. They are velcro-dogs, glued to their humans at all times. A blessing and a curse!

If you get an adult dobe with some less-than-desirable traits, there are ways to train them out of certain behaviors, but those take time and effort - something you may or may not be willing to deal with. If you get a puppy, you are going to have a lot more control over how your dog behaves because you get to them early in life. BUT... you still have to train them to behave the way you want them to, and you still have to potty train them, so it's not like a puppy is not as much effort!! :) It's just that a puppy is cute, so you can forgive them more easily. :jk: Honestly, dobes are good dogs, and if you get a puppy it's a lot of work in the beginning but takes less time to mold behavior. I've never rescued a dog, but from what I have read here, adult dogs take a lot of effort to re-train. BUT it can certainly be done, you just have to work at it.

That being said, if you are getting a pup, how you raise your dog will have a big effect on temperament. For example, Marco was a very shy puppy when we got him. He is still a shy dog, BUT we did things to help the shyness not turn into fear and become a behavioral PROBLEM. This forum was a huge help for us, we learned a lot about socialization and training and I have to say, Marco is still shy but he is very social and can adapt to his environment pretty quickly. So USE THIS FORUM, it's awesome!!! :)
 
The big question is what are you looking to accomplish with your new Dobie? Are you looking to title in obedience, do tracking, protection or just wanting a good pet? You can find one with a great temperament as a pet that wouldn't be good to do schutzhund. I would suggest to train in obedience regardless, it just makes for a happier well round dog.

I am absolutely going to be involved in obedience. That is my main focus. Other things may come along.....but obedience is my desire at this time. I have my first meeting tonight with my local kennel club....and I don't even have my dobe yet! ;)
 
It is my experience that all dobes are 1) protective (but not harmful - they just bark, and mostly do so from BEHIND you!) and 2) very loyal to their people. They are velcro-dogs, glued to their humans at all times. A blessing and a curse!

If you get an adult dobe with some less-than-desirable traits, there are ways to train them out of certain behaviors, but those take time and effort - something you may or may not be willing to deal with. If you get a puppy, you are going to have a lot more control over how your dog behaves because you get to them early in life. BUT... you still have to train them to behave the way you want them to, and you still have to potty train them, so it's not like a puppy is not as much effort!! :) It's just that a puppy is cute, so you can forgive them more easily. :jk: Honestly, dobes are good dogs, and if you get a puppy it's a lot of work in the beginning but takes less time to mold behavior. I've never rescued a dog, but from what I have read here, adult dogs take a lot of effort to re-train. BUT it can certainly be done, you just have to work at it.

That being said, if you are getting a pup, how you raise your dog will have a big effect on temperament. For example, Marco was a very shy puppy when we got him. He is still a shy dog, BUT we did things to help the shyness not turn into fear and become a behavioral PROBLEM. This forum was a huge help for us, we learned a lot about socialization and training and I have to say, Marco is still shy but he is very social and can adapt to his environment pretty quickly. So USE THIS FORUM, it's awesome!!! :)

Oh I plan to use this forum a lot! Many nice people here. I am so glad I'm able to get information from people instead of just reading....although reading is good too. I love hearing about real experiences best.
 
The WAE was a test developed by the DPCA to test temperament. The CGC is a very very basic elementary obedience exercise which just shows the dog has some training and good manners in public - come when called, no formal heel, does not jump on people, friendly to people and dogs and it is a good place to start and then move on to the CD - AKC companion dog

Anything that is really really good is a trial competition if you are talking about adult dogs. If you go to the DVG web site you can pull up the heeling pattern for the BH - it is a dog leg with an L out in an open field. There will be a dog on the honor down and a dog on the field working. The dog must heel on lead and off lead - figure 8 though the group, moving sit, moving down recall etc. You can read all about it on the DVG web site.

UDC follows the DVG- AWDF rules and guidelines. for the IPO trials. This at least will give you some things to think about!!!

The AKC CD is all done inside in a ring which is a lot more control but the dog will heel on lead, off lead, figure 8, stand for exam, recall and does not involve a temperament test or traffic portion like the BH which stands for Basic handling. ALL dogs must pass the BH to move on in IPO or Schutzhund (which was what it was always called until recently when it changed)

I'm having a blank moment...what is DVG please? AWDF? Would you do the CGC before the WAE?
 
2 Dobeies - the CGC is a minimum obedience routine just to show the dog is under your control and a Canine Good Citizen it does not address temperament although you would see certain behaviors during the prep period that could give you some insight to parts of the temperament. You can get the CGC on a very young dog and they recommend you repeat it when the dog is older becaue dogs change as they grow and develop.

A dog can take the WAE at 15 months - but for dobermans who are later maturing I recommend waiting til closer til two. A dog does not protect from behind. What you look for in correct temperament for a working breed is a dog that will go to the end of the leash in front of you and stand its ground. That is the last part of the WAE - the dog does not actually bite but it must stay in front and stand its ground. If the dog goes behind the handler it is a NQ.

Then entire test consist of a friendly strnager, a neutral stranger, a rattling can, gun fire, unbrella, walking over different surfaces ex: tarp, grate and then on to the aggressor. Each phase is designed to increase the stressor on the dog. The dog may react but must recover and move forward for example and approach the umbrella once it pops open in its face. The dog must pass each phase to obtain the WAC.
 
I agree that the CGC does not address temperament, but it will give you an idea on how your dog will react in certain situations, I've seen dogs completely shut down and hide behind their owners in CGC classes, among other behaviors that would give an indication that the dog has a less than desired temperament. Unless the guidelines have recently changed the dog needs to be 18 months old for the WAE.

dpca.org/awards/wae/documents/WAEguide-timeline-tips.pdf
 
Sorry - I had a blank moment too - It is the BH you can do at 15 months - not the WAE so you are correct. As in all things everything you do with a dog gives you info about the dogs mental stablity so as you mentioned yes if the dog shys at class it is etiher a lack of socialization or weak nerve but you also have to then read the dogs recovery time. For example under gun fire the dog can startle but then should proceed right on with the exercise.

So while you will see things about temperament in the CGC as well as every single thing you do with the dog, the CGC was not designed to evaluate temperament but level of training and the dogs willingness to pay heed to it owner. They do not require formal heeling etc. Just that the dog listens to you and responds to you showing some type of bond.
 
So this is a newbie question. :) These "temperament" evaluations are done around 15 months or later, based on the replies I am reading. Is there anything in existence that will evaluate a puppy's temperament at, say, 3-4 months? Or even at 8 weeks, when you are looking into taking your puppy home?

I ask because it seems a lot of these temperament tests being discussed here would occur after the puppy has had some formative training with an owner/handler... which, to me, is more indicative of how good a job you did training your dog. :scratch:

I guess what I am getting at, is, can the dog be INHERENTLY aggressive, and is there really any way to tell at a very young age? Or is that a learned behavior (training the dog to fight/attack other dogs)? I suppose I am confused by what we are talking about when we say "temperament." Marco is shy. I'd say that was part of his temperament - he was like that out of the gate, so to speak - he was very skittish when we took him home. Marco is also very calm in hardware stores, gas stations, walking through big crowds. I would say this was a LEARNED BEHAVIOR as we worked with him so that he was not fearful of those situations. But is that "calmness" in these situations now part of his temperament? Just curious... :)
 
Our breeder and several others that I know of do the Bio Sensor as well as the Volhard’s Puppy Aptitude Testing , this helps the breeder match the puppies to the right owners and gives them an idea of the puppies temperament, in many cases you can tell what puppies are dominant and what puppies are shy. We wanted high energy for our female and more laid back in our male, in both cases we got what we requested.
 
Liz, that goes back to the whole nature vs nurture thing. There are tests, like those listed before, that will give a general idea of the innate traits in a puppy. However how you raise a puppy, what traits you choose to bring forward or try to train out, is determined by how you train. The temperament tests like the WAE and the BH test a combination of both.
 
Yes there aer puppy temperament test BUT environment, experiences etc can influence a puppy - so a puppy with a great temperament can be ruined if handled incorrectly. A puppy that is shy from the beginning probably has weak nerves or total lack of socialization and human interaction during the first stages from birth til the time you got him.

The bio sensor exercises are exercises you do day 3 through day 16 with puppies to stimulate them and these stimulations help the puppy deal better with stressors, are suppose to improve immune system and cardio - but the observations on how each puppy responds can give little clues. At day 3 through 16 they are just not developed enough mentally to make concrete judgements.

The Volhard is for puppies - again it gives you some guidelines as far as how that specific puppy reacts to things. A more dominant - head strong puppy will have more of a tendency to need a strong leader to guide and train them if left to their own devices this puppy can become dominant aggressive. But again - environment, leadership, training, and socialization are all designed to guide each dog through the maze and grow and develop more confidence. Most puppies get themselves into trouble because the owner does not know what they are doing and or are not consistent and confident in their guidance.

It is really a misnormer to think you can train out a puppies traits - you can mold and reshape them but if a puppy is shy it is something you will deal with its entire life. You can make it better through training but the problem will always be there just under the surface and can emerge at any time.

That is why titles are important to breeders - The test are all designed to see how the dog performs under pressure. Does the dog have good judgement - does the dog just strick out and react - does the dog follow through - does the dog have the confidence to come back after a negative - recovery time is very important in the over all picture especailly when evaluating a puppy.

It is why a puppy should be evaluated by a stranger in a strange location without the litter mates around. I like ot meet poeple in new locations to the puppy so a puppy has a chance to experience new things early - They have things to climb on and fall off of, they have challenges that at 5 weeks really pushes them to excel and be creative. If they learn these things as a puppy it is not as big a deal when at 8 months you want them to walk a dog walk or a teeter totter. So the time before the puppy goes to its family is crucial.
 

Back
Top