• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Prey Drive, dominance or what?

Michael Ellis and Leerburg folks recommend using the 'treat method' exclusively and using the word 'YES" as a reward like a 'clicker' is clicked and it 'marks' the behavior you want to reward.. they use 'YES" when the dog does the requested behavior and tiny tiny bits of treats.. so its barely enough to put in their mouth but it keeps them wanting more and keeps their attention. NO high pitched happy voices and no petting or patting on the head as it is often considered a 'release' as "Zues's mom' stated...
SO yea... you learned something! Like I said "You got this".... its a process regardless of how well you 'got it'!
keep up the good work! :beer:
 
Yes you still need to speak to mark the behavior but a simple quick "yes!" is plenty and less likely to set him off. It can be a frustratingly slow process but you really are on the right track here. Keep it up.
 
I have to say, I've really enjoyed reading this thread. Dylan is 16 months old, and should be over the shenanigans by now. But having had the baby in August, I've had very little time to work consistently with him. He has started popping up off the ground with his front feet, and getting very, um, animated, with his finish and turns. It's been hard to keep him in a tight heel position. I've chosen the route of stopping and sitting when he starts getting goofy, which usually settles him down. I don't want to kill the enthusiasm, but I also don't want him to bust my lip because I just happened to look down. He's so exuberant and willing to work, and I really want to maintain that. But a little self-control would be nice now and then. Again, I have very much appreciated reading everyone's advice on this thread. Thank you!!

Is there anywhere you can get the Leerburg videos a bit cheaper? They're really expensive!
 
Thanks lady's for your comments, yes I can see it now how the pat on the head could trigger an unwanted response as Zoe points out, so no more head pats :)

I've had a small training session today with him as I do for 10 minutes every day during his daily hill romp. He was at one point about to jump but as he exhibit signs that he's about to misbehave I had the opportunity to correct so a quick correction with his new slip lead nipped him in his tracks before he could nip me. :D

Yes you still need to speak to mark the behavior but a simple quick "yes!" is plenty and less likely to set him off. It can be a frustratingly slow process but you really are on the right track here. Keep it up.

Are you saying that this behaviour can be a common problem, something you've been through?
 
I have to say, I've really enjoyed reading this thread. Dylan is 16 months old, and should be over the shenanigans by now. But having had the baby in August, I've had very little time to work consistently with him. He has started popping up off the ground with his front feet, and getting very, um, animated, with his finish and turns. It's been hard to keep him in a tight heel position. I've chosen the route of stopping and sitting when he starts getting goofy, which usually settles him down. I don't want to kill the enthusiasm, but I also don't want him to bust my lip because I just happened to look down. He's so exuberant and willing to work, and I really want to maintain that. But a little self-control would be nice now and then. Again, I have very much appreciated reading everyone's advice on this thread. Thank you!!

Is there anywhere you can get the Leerburg videos a bit cheaper? They're really expensive!

the only other way to get them is to rent them from them instead of buying them. you really can learn alot from a months worth of watching these.
I have two myself that I would be happy to sell to someone who wanted to buy them?
I have "Focused heel" and also 'Power of the tug" videos.

They are pricey at over $60 bux a pop... so they rent them now for $30 something and they are really excellent! but they are worth every penny! :D
 
the only other way to get them is to rent them from them instead of buying them. you really can learn alot from a months worth of watching these.
I have two myself that I would be happy to sell to someone who wanted to buy them?
I have "Focused heel" and also 'Power of the tug" videos.

They are pricey at over $60 bux a pop... so they rent them now for $30 something and they are really excellent! but they are worth every penny! :D

How much would you sell "Focused Heel" for?
 
He was at one point about to jump but as he exhibit signs that he's about to misbehave I had the opportunity to correct so a quick correction with his new slip lead nipped him in his tracks before he could nip me. :D
That right there, is a "Bravo" to you! Some people never recognize that 'moment' (nano second sometimes!) before misbehavior! Great job!:thumbsup:
 
I don't know if anyone addressed this yet but I was reading that some were thinking on going to a pinch collar. I would not introduce the pinch until they are at least 9 months old to a year. A 6 month old is to young to be on anything othe than a leather collar.

I have also ordered videos from Leerburg there are nicely done. You can order them and watch them for up to a year then if you decide you want a copy it is only an additional $ 5.00 to get the DVD. I like the Micheal Ellis DVDs.
 
Yes I'm wary regarding the use of a prong or choke on him. ATM I am using a half choke that has a wide collar and is set up to give just a little sqeeze, it does the trick, I also have a slip lead wich also works with him but seeing as he responds to the half choke so well I will just stick with that...

I went onto Leerburg and went down the process of buying a DVD, $60 for the DVD and then came shipping to the UK, another $60 :eek: I think not at that price - looks like I may have to go down the streeming video route...
 
Marko you are describing what is called a Martingale collar. I like them on young puppies if you are not experience with a very clever dog slipping out of one. The martingale will keep that from happening and that is one trick I do not ever want one of mine to learn. I use just a regular leather collar but I never put the dog in a pulling back situation where they can slip the lead, but I do like the martingale collars.
 
I just wanted to say a couple of things about this thread, I read some of the post by marko, so that I could get an idea of what has been going on with his pup, and from this I would give the following advice.

The dog is displaying pure excited prey drive, NOT dominance or anything else. He is a puppy, and the time your spending in the training can be whats hurting you as well, he has a short attention span so you need to break up your training into several smaller sessions to keep him focused on the work.
I would also use food as the reward and start by teaching the position of heel and not the movement. Teach the dog what heel looks like, and how to get into that position, rewarding with the left hand from above his head when he gives you the correct picture.
I would then start with about three or four steps at a time to teach him the movement in position, same picture on the reward, left hand from above head.
Use a verbal marker on your reward, this is called a bridge and lets the do know that what he did is correct and the reward is coming, after all we have less than a second to reward for the correct behavior, and thats physically impossible for most all of us, so the use of a word or what I like to use, which is a breath sound, is our marker or bridge, so he does the right behavior and give a fast breath sound and reward.
Also dont praise him and get excited with him during the actual work, this will create excitement and uncontrolled energy bleeding all over the place, you only praise and get excited on the release, as this helps to destress or reset the dog from the working session.
As DG said, do not use a pinch on a dog this young, there is no need, use only positive motivation and take your time, dont worry about a pinch until close to a year old.

I think thats all for now. IF you have any direct questions, feel free to ask.
If you want to know if my advice is sound and about my experience and qualifications, just ask DG and D4E, as they have both attended several of my seminars and have seen my work personally, and can give a true unbiased honest opinion.

Hope it helps.
 
I just wanted to say a couple of things about this thread, I read some of the post by marko, so that I could get an idea of what has been going on with his pup, and from this I would give the following advice.

The dog is displaying pure excited prey drive, NOT dominance or anything else. He is a puppy, and the time your spending in the training can be whats hurting you as well, he has a short attention span so you need to break up your training into several smaller sessions to keep him focused on the work.
I would also use food as the reward and start by teaching the position of heel and not the movement. Teach the dog what heel looks like, and how to get into that position, rewarding with the left hand from above his head when he gives you the correct picture.
I would then start with about three or four steps at a time to teach him the movement in position, same picture on the reward, left hand from above head.
Use a verbal marker on your reward, this is called a bridge and lets the do know that what he did is correct and the reward is coming, after all we have less than a second to reward for the correct behavior, and thats physically impossible for most all of us, so the use of a word or what I like to use, which is a breath sound, is our marker or bridge, so he does the right behavior and give a fast breath sound and reward.
Also dont praise him and get excited with him during the actual work, this will create excitement and uncontrolled energy bleeding all over the place, you only praise and get excited on the release, as this helps to destress or reset the dog from the working session.
As DG said, do not use a pinch on a dog this young, there is no need, use only positive motivation and take your time, dont worry about a pinch until close to a year old.

I think thats all for now. IF you have any direct questions, feel free to ask.
If you want to know if my advice is sound and about my experience and qualifications, just ask DG and D4E, as they have both attended several of my seminars and have seen my work personally, and can give a true unbiased honest opinion.

Hope it helps.

Thanks Dale and no need to sell yourself, I've read many of your posts here and full well know how knowledgeable and experienced you are and as such is a person to listen to and learn from :)

Thank you for your advice, advice I tried this morning on his walk, 3 sessions of a couple of minutes each and it went well. I've read about the 'marker' or clicker so know the concept but have not really tried it, a clicker is just one more piece of equipment to carry around with the lead and the treat and not enough hands so I prefer using my voice as the 'clicker' with an audible 'YES'. I have has 10 inch hessian wrapped piece of wood that I thought I would use as a tug. I'd ask him to sit, as soon as his butt hit the floor he got a 'YES' and a good old pull on the tug, he liked that, as soon as I said 'YES' his eyes widened in expectation and then he got his reward, the tug. Over a couple of minutes he got faster with his sits :)

Later after I put the tug away I used food, I'd have him sit, heel a few yards, sit with a 'YES' and a treat, just a couple of minutes with no jumping (except initially for the tu)g. He does know what to do but is not very tight with his sits or his heel, he can be if I constantly hold a treat over my chest talking to him but he loses interest with the food quickly although he will gulp it down readily enough.

Thanks again Dale ;)
 
You have received a lot of awesome replies here!!!

My two cents and my own experience with my dog is this:

She's 10 months old now, and we had started her in puppy class immediately at 10 weeks old... which we followed with a couple of other obedience classes. All of these classes were "positive reinforcement" only classes with treat training and flat collars allowed only... which don't get me wrong is awesome for a puppy learning behaviours, etc, but after a certain point i found the treat training didn't work. Purely positive training works for some people through out their dobes lifetime, but for me, I feel like its not enough. I think dobermans are a sensitive breed that do not respond well to yelling and a lot of harsh corrections.. and I also feel on the other hand that they are too powerful and high driven to respond purely to "soft" training such as treat training. I am glad you got another trainer... purely based on the fact that she told you to get in your dogs face and yell "NO!" when he jumped on you. A more effective route for that would be to body block him by turning around and away from him.. Teaching him an "off" or "leave it" command and then make him sit.

We have just completed level one obedience with our breeder who is someone very experienced with dobermans and a trainer of over 25 years, so we knew we were getting lessons geared towards this breed specifically. A couple months ago we started using a choke chain and said bye bye to the prong and treats... She has shown amazing improvement and 100% attitude change. What it was, was me learning how to be a proper handler and understanding doberman specific behaviours. Excerting leadership, and letting her know that when I give a command, I expect a prompt response. I accomplished this through encouraging her with a ball in my hand, did a few steps of heeling and turns, and when she completed it properly, she would get the ball for a minute and lots of praise. Corrections should only be done if a dog already knows the behaviour but is not giving you the behaviour when you command it. At that point, they get a quick, slight correction to the side and IMMEDIATE "good girl!!" once they get into the behaviour you have asked. Each correction is followed by an upbeat immediate praise once they give you what you ask for. Eventually, corrections fade on the behaviours they perfect... but praise is always there to let them know they are doing a good job and to keep the session upbeat and positive! A few months ago I couldn't even walk Scarlet on a prong she pulled me so much.... now, I can walk her on a choke with the leash over my shoulder... just a few slight corrections sometimes, but other than that wow! What a difference different training methods and tools make... And when you look at yourself as a handler and see your errors you will understand why the dog is confused.

If i had to do it over again I would do everything the same.. I would do the positive classes, etc, but at a certain point around 7 - 8 month, I would definitely introduce a choke chain. As with any training tool or collar, if you know how to PROPERLY use it, then use it... If you have no idea what you are doing, that is when you can cause harm to their neck... Use these tools with caution and my advice is to seek out a trainer experience with dobermans... they are such a unique breed and so so smart, that sometimes it makes them hard to train too! lol. They are always one step ahead of you.

Around the 6 month old mark is where my pup started to test me as well, doing the things that you are describing. You must be firm, and follow through with your commands. Thanks for reading that novel! weeew! lol:thumbsup:
 
I would do the positive classes, etc, but at a certain point around 7 - 8 month, I would definitely introduce a choke chain. As with any training tool or collar, if you know how to PROPERLY use it, then use it... If you have no idea what you are doing, that is when you can cause harm to their neck...
Please reconsider using a choke chain over a prong. There have been studies that show that they cause far far more damage to the neck. Even used properly the way they work is going to cause trauma. You say she pulled on the prong, was it fitted properly and on the live ring? Did you give quick pops on the lead or pull? Used and fitted properly the prong is the training collar to use.

"A Study on Prong Collars was done in Germany:

* 100 dogs were in the study. 50 used choke and 50 used prong.
* The dogs were studied for their entire lives. As dogs died, autopsies were performed.
* Of the 50 which had chokes, 48 had injuries to the neck, trachea, or back. 2 of those were determined to be genetic. The other 46 were caused by trauma.
* Of the 50 which had prongs, 2 had injuries in the neck area, 1 was determined to be genetic. 1 was caused by trauma.

The numbers seem to speak for themselves.
(Information about above study taken from an Anne Marie Silverton Seminar)

Here is the rest of the info from this particular quote and it is some interesting reading.
http://cobankopegi.com/prong.html"
 

Back
Top