• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Which Crate Style Do You Prefer?

Which is your preferred type of crate?

  • Wire

    Votes: 13 59.1%
  • Plastic (aka Vari-Kennel type)

    Votes: 8 36.4%
  • Soft side

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • X-Pen

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Don't use any

    Votes: 1 4.5%

  • Total voters
    22

JanS

DCF Owner
Administrative Staff
Moderator
Hot Topics Subscriber
So we have an interesting discussion going on crates in the collar thread and I thought it deserved it's own thread since most of us do crate our dogs for at least the first few years of their lives, at shows or when we travel.

So which kind of crate do you prefer for home use or the one they spend most of their time in? And why?
 
Wire kennels only here!! I have never had a dog have any issues with them.

The Vari-Kennels are another story for this house. Sabrina escaped out of several of them by breaking the plastic where the metal door frame inserted into the front of the kennel. She also got a paw stuck in between the top and bottom piece trying to escape. Granted being a Husky mix she was a bit of a Houdini, but still. I have never had a dog have an issue with breaking out of a wire kennel, or any trouble with a wire kennel period.

I also like the more open feel the wire kennels have. You can cover them if your dog needs seclusion and they can have two doors and remain stable.

We use wire at the show site and soft-sided ringside on the show floor.

No matter the crate type, I still would never leave a collar of any sort on a dog in a kennel. Too risky, even if the collar is loose
 
I like the vari-kennel because the purpose of a kennel is peace and quiet more like a den and the wire crates tends make harder for the dogs to settle down if there is a lot of activity around.

I agree with you that if dogs can see things going on around their crate it's harder for them to settle down, but I still use wire cages. The convenience of being able to break wire cages down for travel is a big advantage. Also you can always put a towels over a wire cage if you want it to be more like a den.
 
I see the advantages for both plastic and wire. So far we haven't needed to use plastic here but I am open to using one if needed in the future. However, I have seen injuries with both kennels so I think it just comes down to a matter of preference.

We use wire kennels. I like the airflow for them, being able to see what they are doing, and the ease of putting a kennel cover or blanket over for a more den like feeling. I also like that I can practically crawl in one to clean, lol. The bottom slides out. It folds flat for better storage. They can be a bit of a pain in the butt though to carry even when flat but luckily ours has handles. Still heavier than a plastic kennel. I do think it's important to have a heavier duty wire kennel than a cheaply made wire kennel, mostly for escape artists and extra precaution for accidents in vehicles.
 
Wire, I know they are riskier for hang ups on collars and such but I prefer the air flow from a wire one. I also cover mine with a cotton sheet. Light enough to let the air through but thick enough to keep them from seeing out too much. They do have canvas crates for trips and for the basement on bad weather days.
 
I don't crate.
If I were to I would go wire.That ability to break it down for storage/travel would be a huge bonus.
No one's mentioned it I don't think but the plastic would have me worried in some ways.The sun and just age does its thing on plastic,gets brittle.Maybe more so out west,So Cal,Az,Nevada etc because its so damn dry.The other worry would be that I have seen what these dogs do to a plastic toy in 10 minutes,if determined enough they could chew a hole right through it.
Less ventilation with plastic it would look?
Off the top of my head the only disadvantages to metal is it's heavy and conducts electricity.
 
Wire, mostly for the reasons already listed. That said, it has been a long time since Greta has even been in her crate, I'd say at least 5 years or so. Drake still uses his crate for shows and training.
 
I have three requirements in a crate.
1, it must fold up or otherwise be portable.
2, it must have at least two doors for added convenience.
3, they must be stackable.

So far as I know only a wire crate meets all three of these requirements.

With that being said I have transitioned away from crates to indoor kennels.
 
I voted wire. But I use both wire and soft side. We have a wire for the house which has a crate cover so the den feeling is there and if I want it removed it can be.
I use the soft side for car travel and shows and classes. He does great in it.
 
I had a plastic kennel in my Van over the winter for Kris but bought a new wire one for the summer. Kris has a wire crate for night time but she started out in a plastic crate till she outgrew it. My little dogs all use the plastic kennels when they do go in them. I have a soft sided one for Remmy when he is at Agility as it is easier to carry around.
 
We use plastic crates in the house, I have custom built wire crates for the van and wire crates when we are at an IPO trial. We also have some soft side kennels when traveling at akc dog shows. I actually voted for wire for there durability and ease for travel but prefer the plastic ones in the home.
 
I use wire in the house and car, and soft crates at shows. I like the ventilation of the wire crates and, in my opinion, they're the securest. I always worry about the zippers in the soft crate.

The sole reason I use a soft crate is because it's easier to hump around the showgrounds.

I have two wire Great Dane crates for the Dobies in the house and one wire Sheltie size crate for Sabrina.

In the car, I have one Dobie size wire SUV crate and Sabrina has a Sheltie size wire SUV crate accessible via the rear passenger door. Cooper rides shotgun in the car when all three dogs are with me.

I use both Great Dane crates and the Sheltie crate in the van when going training. I can take them out of the van and place the dogs in the shade and they have ventilation.

I crate Anna at night because she's very disruptive to our sleep. Sabrina's crate is her security place and she goes there to get away from the Dobies.
 
I voted plastic. I have seen injuries from both. I think it depends on the dog. When Addie was little she HATED the kennel, I think she would have hurt herself in a wire one trying to get out. On a side note on of the girls at work has a GSD that has figured out if pushes up on the top the sides come down!
 
The plastic type has saved my carpet many a times. I have had dogs with blow out poop and projectile vomit. Not to mention the pee accidents that all dogs have :( I tried the wire crate but just for a short while. Good thing it was in the basement. The first time a dog peed it went everywhere. GROSS. I had to drag the whole thing upstairs to clean it. The plastic kennel comes apart in 2 pieces and I can hose it off in the shower. Much more easy for me. My one guy could do a soft sided crate and has for shows, but they get HOT easily and I would never use one in the car. The other dog would eat right through the crate out of boredom. Oh, also the wire crates dogs have been known to get feet stuck in the holes of the wire or even get cut on it or break out (had that happen once :( So I just stick with plastic.
 
I've always had wire. I have a Great Dane crate for Buddy but of course he hasn't been in it in years. ( It folds real nice for storage;) ) But it's the only crate I would have. I always covered mine for security, warmth and quiet. :) But I like that I can see in to check on them if needed.
 
I have always preferred the plastic kennels and we use the Pet Mate brand. Their about as secure as can be and we were able to get the giant size for the boys and it's very roomy.
Primo pad torn up sized down.webp

I did buy a soft side crate for shows but Della is terrified of it and I'm pretty sure it wouldn't keep Albert in.

I do plan to buy a couple wire crates just to keep folded up to keep in case we have to evacuate the house for some reason and stay somewhere like a hotel. It was something that the Red Cross said is very important so you can grab and go if necessary.
 
I like the vari-kennel because the purpose of a kennel is peace and quiet more like a den and the wire crates tends make harder for the dogs to settle down if there is a lot of activity around.
I put a fabric cover over the wire to make it more "den like". I think the thing I like best about a wire crate is that it can be folded down to about the size of a suitcase to travel. I don't travel a lot, but it's nice to flatten that crate down when I do.
 
I use a vari-kennel, mainly since that's what my parents got for me for my birthday several weeks before I got Watson which I had planned on getting a wire one but this one has lasted really well plus at shows its more enclosed.
 
My wire kennels are Great Dane sized in the house. We have 500 series wire kennels for shows and a soft sided crate for ringside. We keep the show kennels in the basement for weather emergencies.

Mainly the big crates at home because Archer stands 30.5" tall (I know he's a mutant) and needs a big one, but I like them to have room to stretch out if they want. Aria especially because the little counter surfing diva thief is grounded to hers when we are gone.
 

Back
Top