• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

What size prong collar?

Atingles10

Notable member
We originally got a pet store prong collar to see if it was something we would use before we went with a herm Springer. We are at the point where we want to buy the real deal but I'm torn on the size and was looking for opinions. Of course our guy has the skinny neck and if I remember correctly it's only about 17 inches behind his ears. The part that has me torn is that he is 100lbs and according to his weight on the website we would end up getting a larger size.

What are thoughts from our friends that use the prong collars on size?
 
We originally got a pet store prong collar to see if it was something we would use before we went with a herm Springer. We are at the point where we want to buy the real deal but I'm torn on the size and was looking for opinions. Of course our guy has the skinny neck and if I remember correctly it's only about 17 inches behind his ears. The part that has me torn is that he is 100lbs and according to his weight on the website we would end up getting a larger size.

What are thoughts from our friends that use the prong collars on size?

You can remove links to get proper fitment. Or are you referring to the width?

I use the 3.25mm and it fits fine. However I know people use smaller ones.
 
You can remove links to get proper fitment. Or are you referring to the width?

I use the 3.25mm and it fits fine. However I know people use smaller ones.
I was referring to the width, I was having a brain cramp when trying to explain myself better. I know that some have said the 2.25 is fine but was looking at the weight recommendations and it calls for a larger width
 
I was referring to the width, I was having a brain cramp when trying to explain myself better. I know that some have said the 2.25 is fine but was looking at the weight recommendations and it calls for a larger width

I wouldn’t worry about the recommendations based off weight. I know some use the smaller prong because their dogs have less sensitivity. However, it’s based off the dog. You can’t go wrong with either size.
 
We have the silver one in 2.25. The links are removable so you can adjust the size up or down. The neck size is more important than weight. Although, wait, 100 lbs?
 
We have the silver one in 2.25. The links are removable so you can adjust the size up or down. The neck size is more important than weight. Although, wait, 100 lbs?
We were just at the emergency vet a couple weeks ago and almost at 100lbs, he was 99 and he's 14 months:facepalm:he's actually smaller right now than in the photo. He went through a phase of picky eating.20190714_104519.webp
 
So what I’m trying to show with the above pictures is that they are the same length but with the smaller sized link you have a more points making contact. There are 6 links of the wider vs 11 with the narrower.
 
They’re both effective but I prefer the smaller. The issue I had with the larger one is if I had to remove a link there were only 5 links making contact where as with the smaller it had 8. Does that make sense?
 
So what I’m trying to show with the above pictures is that they are the same length but with the smaller sized link you have a more points making contact. There are 6 links of the wider vs 11 with the narrower.
After seeing your photo I am leaning towards the smaller width since it has more points of contact. I appreciate the visual!
 

Back
Top