*like* *like* *like* Wow, this was so good that I had to comment! THIS is exactly what I do with my horses! I think because horses are so much larger I tend to be harder on them. And it's not always 'when they don't listen to me', it's more direct disobedience. For instance, I take my horses out of their stalls and hand walk them out of the barn, through a gate, into a corral....all by my hand alone. No halter, lead rope etc. They all are well trained in that now, but in the beginning I may have one raise their head out of my hand and 'get away from me' and go eat grass. If I attempt to get them, they might play 'keep away'.I had an hour long drive last night to and from my club, and your problem came to mind. My dogs occasionally play dominance games with me. Sometimes it's an outright challenge, but it most often takes the form of ignoring me when I give a command. (They'll stare out into space without looking at me). If I sense I have a dominance issue, I put them through a mini boot camp until they get their head on right. I'll go through a drill where I stand in front of them and they sit, stand, down, go to heel position, pivot in heel position several times (right and left 90 degree pivots), I go back in front of them and repeat. The commands follow quickly and I don't allow them to dawdle and give an instant correction if the command isn't performed smartly. Dogs hate this drill, but I make them do it to perfection. They don't test me for a while after doing this.
That's when the halter and lead rope comes out and for 15 minutes I am putting them through their paces!!! They quickly learn that when they don't listen to me, they WORK. I am very proud of what I've created with them and get compliments all the time from friends on down to my vet and farrier. In fact, one day my farrier stopped by to check a crack on one of my horses and when I wanted to check the back hoof with him, I dropped the lead rope and walked behind my horse to see. The farrier's young son was with him and he said, "Look dad, that horse doesn't move and no one is holding him!"
I smiled and thought to myself, He knows better!:smoke:Now that all being said, Surprisingly enough, I don't do this as much with my dogs!
lol I know I do once in a while like when Buddy ignores a recall....I will call him and make him sit, call him again, and so forth. But you made a great point and I will remember that now and enforce it on them like I do the horses. I do it on the horses to enforce leadership, why am I not doing it with the dogs?? I probably tend to do it more with horses just for the simple fact that they are larger and I NEED to really make sure that I am head mare. To be walk on by a horse is worse than being walked on by a dog. But it's still just as important. Thanks for the reminder!!

It's easier to let that go with a dog than it is with a horse and I'm afraid I've done that at times.
I will try not to in the future!
Seems like it's working, and it's also a good training tool as well! I like it