Rottweiler vs Doberman

Emerald

New Member
Wasn't sure where to put this, but since it is doberman breed related, I guess it can go on this board.
First of all, disclaimer, I am not asking this question because I'm choosing between getting a rottweiler and a doberman, I just want to find out more information to satisfy my curiosity.

My question is: What is the difference/similarity between the temperaments of the two breeds? What's it like to live with each of them, if you've owned both (together or at different times)?
I know that they are both high-energy, people oriented dogs who are suited for protection, although the Rottweiler is typically slower to respond to a threat with an attack than the Doberman (considering they had proper training, of course). They are both classified as non-beginner breeds by most people, although I have encountered a more 'aggressive' stance from doberman people that dobermans should not be owned by first-timers.
 
Any higher drive type dog is usually not a first time dog owners choice. Typically because the dog will require someone who has had some experience in training and will dedicate the time needed to train the dog. That being said, many of the Dobermans and rotties bring breed these days do not possess these drives anymore. Finding a good one with high drive is more difficult than not. Look into conformation breeders, they typically breed away from drive and can find the right fit for a first time owner. They will still require training just as any dog should be trained. The bigger issue with Dobermans and rotties these days are health, they both are high on the list so research when looking for a Breeder.
 
I think they're both a really nice breed that both need lots of training. I would say that a Doberman is a little more athletic with it's build though.

My boss has always had Rotts and he also stresses that you need to find a good breeder because they can have quite a few health problems, as stated above.
 
Owned/been around both. Currently own a 50/50 mix.

In my experience, Rotts are more laid back. They're not as athletic. More accepting of strangers.

Both can be head strong. Both can walk all over a weak owner.

Dobermans are more clingy. More vocal. More animated.
 
Owned/been around both. Currently own a 50/50 mix.

In my experience, Rotts are more laid back. They're not as athletic. More accepting of strangers.

Both can be head strong. Both can walk all over a weak owner.

Dobermans are more clingy. More vocal. More animated.
Pretty accurate.
I've never owned a Rottweiler but been around many, just spent a week with two mater o fact.
Dobes are definitely more vocal, although I have met a couple rotts in years past that would match a Dobe in animation.

Dobes area bit more high strung and clingy.
Rottweiler dogs are on the gelcoater family short list of potential next dog.
 
I've definitely met a few highly animated rotts. But in general, I think dobies are just more animated. My brother in law's rott is really animated and goofy though (granted, I question that dogs lineage, he is a very strange rott). I've also met some very non animated dobies.

The really huge difference I think is in how clingy dobes are and how much more accepting of strangers rotts are (again, in general, always exceptions). I've only encountered a couple rotts that I seriously would not interact with as a stranger (in a shelter environment). Most rotts I felt perfectly comfortable just walking into their kennels without taking the time to "meet" them. The dobies? No freaking way would I just walk into their kennels. I always had to take the time to get to know them and earn some trust before entering. The rotts were just thrilled to get attention whereas the dobies seemed to question my motives.
 
I used to handle rotts for a friend that was a breeder, so I would say in NY limited Doberman experience that my Doberman is super.clingy, prone to separation anxiety, destructive behavior when not with their human, etc. (And here I worried he'd bond with the bull dog too much, I can't even shower or put Baby to bed without him scratching the door)

The rotties, happy, playful, energetic, and then ready to sleep. Granted show rotties are going to be socialized to the extent a stranger can check their teeth and testicles, but in general I found them to be happy dogs until tested but easily managed.
 
have encountered a more 'aggressive' stance from doberman people that dobermans should not be owned by first-timers.
That is silly, how would you become a skilled doberman owner if you didn't start with one.
Certainly do your research on the breed, visit Doberman rescue places, talk to people, go to shows.
Dobies require a lot of work during their puppy and teenage years but it really pays off when they become an adult.
They are an intelligent breed that needs a leader in their life and imo are easy to train.
Rotties are great dogs but I don't have any experience owning one so I am no help there.
Good luck and keep researching. :-)
 
My neighbor had rotties and I would take care of them when they would go out of town. I fell in love with these big slobber jowls. Once I was introduced to them and spent time around them I found them to be good guard dogs but more accepting of strangers than dobies and a very affectionate breed. These two I cared for were not overly athletic, more a couch potato, but if you came on the property unannounced they were there to greet you with deep barks. Their size alone was intimidating. Hahaha
 

Back
Top