• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Remote Collar Training??

phoenixx1978

Jr Member
First off, allow me to apologize for being gone so long. It's good to see this board is still active and healthy. I've always found this forum to be a treasure trove of knowledge, and a lot of these threads have helped me out in many situations I've had with Achilles over the year. (I promise to post up some pics of him now in my replies on this thread.)

On to the topic at hand. Are remote collars effective at in house & outside training?

The scenario: Achilles is amazing on leash. He's been thru a couple courses on obedience, and excelled on leash. He's an angel on walks, and rarely, if ever pulls or creates tension. He heels on command, sits, stays, etc, all near perfectly on leash.

Off leash, however, he becomes a kentucky derby stallion. Once he sees the leash off or missing, he will run solid until he breaks something, knocks someone over, or breaks something bigger. Then he's leashed, taken off to his crate, with the pout face, and the yips and barks. I can even go so far as carry the leash, and he's fine...until the realization kicks in.

The final straw has been him jumping our fence. I have a 6ft wooden fence that he's learned how to hop (one specific spot has a small hill, and he's found he can leap it). I caught him in the 80 yr old neighbor's yard, eating cat food, and running amuck through her flower beds. That cannot happen again. I fear if she had been outside, he might have knocked her over in his running around. As of now, all outside trips are collared.

Back to the question. Does anyone have any experience in remote collars? Does the dog understand the alert sound, and then the minor jolt as a long range collar correction, or is it lost on them? I don't plan on using the escape style training I've read about with these types of collars, but more the transition of prong collar to remote collar correction. I've tried the long leash in the house, but it ends up equating to a tether line that trips people, sweeps people / animals, and causes more destruction. I would eventually love to have an off leash doberman in the house, but I can't seem to find that transition between leash, and off...I have been told to go the remote route, but thought I'd ask all of you here first.

Thanks in advance.


 
I wouldn't necessarily get an electric shock collar for him because he's running around. Have you tried walking him on your bike (on his leash of course)? Maybe he needs to be able to run more while, because it seems like he has a lot of energy. And I also wouldn't use his kennel as a disciplinary tool as he COULD start to resent it. Maybe if he goes jumping your wall again, put him on a leash but keep walking him. That way he knows his freedom was cut short because of what he did.

I do have a shock collar for Linus, but that's so my roommate can sleep while he's in his kennel when I go to work :)
 
I love mine... but the same rules apply when you take the 'E collar' off.. they know its off and they can still run amuck....
trick is to use all the tools you can for each specific scenario, and also to train them OFF LEASH... E Collars can be used to faciliitate that...
Pitts would be the best feedback here as he is a trainer of Schutzhund, so training OFF leash is imperative.
I love the E collar, got a great video on how it works, use it at Dog park and Ms Gemma rose is a absolute angel on it there, use it when she is doing attention getting behavior like jumping up on and opening the door ( a little trick she learned about 8 months ago and has now perfected) and when she is barking in the yard, or when she is generally being a 18 mo. old brat dog.... she has her moments! Its a god send for that, but the misbehavior in the house thing only lands her outside and now we use pig ears and a 'to your place' command for misbehavior. She has now volunteered the "to your place" command to which I always treat her when she offers it... she offers it often for "Pig ears"... then if she continues in the rough housing in the house, I give her a 'toy' which she is instructed as her 'baby' and she sucks on it to calm down and usually falls asleep with it, after about 2 pig ears.
I recommend training "to your place' in the house and giving him some treat that requires some time to consume and when he gets up... its 'NO, to your place" to which he is given another treat. I have used a scenario where I have a handful of hot dogs cut up in small pieces and Gemma is given a down or to your place command and then a 'stay'... to which she is given a treat every few moments, and I watch her, STAY... she has learned that if she stays, she gets a treat over a period of several minutes and then a "Jack pot" treat like a bully stick or a really large pig ear, or another dried treat that takes some time to consume and I just repeat the exercize so that now after several months, she will stay on her 'place' for a hour or more.... it started as a game and now its a regular exercise in the house to encourage her that she must 'be calm' indoors...
IF the rough housing ensues... I give her the "Go outside" command and I slam the door (or she will just knock it open as soon as I leave the room for 2 minutes) and I lock it... she has managed to hit it hard enough that is slams open as loudly as it slammed shut... need to fix this damn door! ITs french glass door so she can see as soon as I leave!! smart little bitch! :)
 
Off leash, however, he becomes a kentucky derby stallion. Once he sees the leash off or missing, he will run solid until he breaks something, knocks someone over, or breaks something bigger.

Wow, this could really be a problem and its not something I have ever dealt with so I don't have a lot of advice from experience. Only what I may try myself. My first thought is there seems to be a LOT of energy that is not drained off. A lot. That should somehow be drained more or it will be very hard to get his attention. Plus, I'm guessing he's not off leash much? And when he is, the wild stallion is released! lol It's like a child that has been over protected and then let loose in the world and goes overboard just because they've never had the chance and/or have never been disciplined in this area.

Can you bike with him for exercise? Sometimes a walk is just never enough. These dogs need some run time. I always remember reading in an old Dog Breed book I have under Doberman that they are sometimes run along side of an ATV for exercise. I've done that too. :D

Unfortunately, jumping that fence, now that he knows he CAN, might always be an issue. :( That would really worry me. I don't know how to correct that one! :eek2:

Nice to see you back again! I sure hope we can help with some useful ideas for you!
 
I am not a fan of the e collar for basic obedience. It is far more effective when used for the serious stuff so you do not devalue its power. It is not somethingyou use on a regular basis.

If you have successfully trained him to succeed in the above then you just need to set rules for when he is off lead and correct it. Teach him to leave it in the house and to settle. Sounds like you are making the crate a punishment You catch him put him on lead and then crate him. You need to correct him and then let him remain loose as you redirect his attention to something positive. the crate should be for times you want a rest and when you leave to keep him out of trouble.

Here is a good link to the NLIF training http://k9deb.com/nilif.htm It is also a good resource.

The fence is harder - if you ues the e collar but are not around he will learn the same thing - it only works when you are there or when it is on. How big is the hill??? Can you dig it down til it is level with the rest of the yard??? If not I would get a electric fence and put it around the hill. I would use two strans just to be sure to catch him.

Now that he has learned what is on the other side he will be more apt to want to do it again as it was fun. As you teach him some basic obedience when off lead he will become more responsive to you. You need to go back to basics and teach him a solid recall. He has just been allowed to get away with too much.

You have already demonstrated you have the ablity to train him on leash - now train him off leash for the house things.
 
Maybe instead of going from a 5-6ft leash to offleash, try putting him on a 30 ft lunge line or long leash. You can find one usually at any feed store or farm supply store such as Tractor Supply, or you could order it online. Here is a 30 foot one and on sale for $10. http://www.doversaddlery.com/cotton-lunge-line-30/p/X1-30073/cn/112/ That is what I used before I went anywhere near taking my lab offleash. I used that to reinforce the "You may be further away from me, but I still can 'touch' you."

The major thing you want to do is practice the recall command. Make it the best thing in the world! And, if they need a little help you can pull in the line. It will take time too. Every dog will be different. Java took a good 4-5 months before I went to the next level of offleash training. You might also want to teach a "release" command. The command to tell your dog "it's time to have fun!" and that it is released from working for the moment. You don't want him turning into a crazy beast until you tell him to, lol. That should help shape him up into paying attention to you, even on the long line, until you give him the release command.

I agree you can practice offleash obedience in the house. Make the sessions short so your dog doesn't lose interest. If you have a basement or garage you can try working there too to switch it up.

I'm not sure on the fence, as I haven't had to deal with that. It does seem like you are pretty limited in correction for that. I'd look into either an electric fence or you may just have to watch him when he goes out to go potty.
 
I actually have the same scenario with my male, Billy. He is wonderful on leash but once off he can become a menace. He chases anything moving faster than himself, including children. cars, and bikes. He barks and acts like a jerk, too. I considered using an e-collar but, I have some concerns. First, I think that you need a professional to teach you how to use the collar properly. The damage that can be done when used inappropriately is huge. I have seen many dogs just cowering from "corrections". I am a positive method type trainer but also do not want to see my dog get into trouble so I will use corrections but mostly, leash back on when Billy misbehaves. This works quite well in the dog park and on our walks when we can be off lead. Also, I believe the temperment of the dog should really show you how to "correct" them. Billy is really just a big baby and he remembers all things that have frightened him in the past (falling baby gates, screen doors that snapped shut) so I would be very cautious using a method that causes any pain or discomfort for him. I have seen many people use e-collars with good results, though.
 
awesome responses, everyone.

@Denissov43 His 'go to your bed' works ok, until he gets bored. If I stay nearby and attentive, he plays along. His stay will last about 3-5 minutes, depending on distraction and food drive. Once my eyes turn to the computer or tv, he bolts to something 'more fun.' I can only imagine he figures 'if he's not working, neither am I.' I swear I can see him saying that behind his eyes.

@MyBuddy Im going to give the bike idea a try. I've heard horror stories about biking, and a distraction (squirrel, cat, etc) = being torn off a bike. I've run with him in the past, but it doesn't seem to diminish his energy at all. I did some off road hill climbing with him, but that ended up being drug up and down muddy hills. Biking would be a blast. I'll look into it.

@dobs4ever He has a solid recall IF I have a treat. Without it, no dice. Also, I'm looking at adding a small section of a chain link extension to that spot. Unfortunately, the spot is where my two tier backyard meets the sloping fence. I can see when he's gonna go for it, and it becomes a race to see who gets there first. It's not a habit I want to build upon, hence the idea of an invisible tether between me and him. As far as the crate goes, it's punishment when it's the living room crate, but he also has all his toys in there. He sits there, staring at me with these 'please let me out' eyes once the toy is depleted of treats. The one in the bedroom is his bed, and he gets treats whenever he goes in that one, so he's never sad to bolt to that one.

@Rits I have tried the long tether in the house. It was very reminiscent star wars 2 with the AT-AT's in the snow (for you fellow nerds). People, tables, kids, even the other dog was getting tripped and taken out by this long tether coming at you at 10 mph. The short leash I attach one end to my ankle, and the other to him. He'll lay at my feet like a champ. It's just that transition from leash to off leash that's driving me nuts...

Thanks again, everyone. This is helping. It gives me ideas on how to move forward.
 
Catch up on this thread on biking. Some good tips and great tools! I've never tried this 'springer' thing but it sounds like it works great! :thumbsup: If you can wear him out a bit more, when you come home, that would be the time I would be doing a little off leash OB in the house. A tired dog is a happy dog.........add a treat and some commands and you just might have his attention! :D
http://www.doberman-chat.com/community/index.php?threads/anyone-bike-with-your-dog.4472/

NILIF "Nothing in life is free" is a great way to bring everything back to YOU. Check out that link and see if that doesn't help.

I know adding a string of electric to the top of your fence may be a lot of trouble, but it's the only thing I was coming up with too. :down: Unfortunately, if he is racing you to that corner it's already a habit and, to him, a lot of fun! lol
 
@Rits I have tried the long tether in the house. It was very reminiscent star wars 2 with the AT-AT's in the snow (for you fellow nerds). People, tables, kids, even the other dog was getting tripped and taken out by this long tether coming at you at 10 mph. The short leash I attach one end to my ankle, and the other to him. He'll lay at my feet like a champ. It's just that transition from leash to off leash that's driving me nuts...

Oh my, I was referring to a long tether outside! I could not imagine in the house. Haha, very nice visual. Give it a try outside. ;)
 
@Rits I've tried the long leash out in the back yard. Is it just me, or do they seriously AIM to poop on that damned long leash every time they're out?
 
Don't give up, it takes lots of work in short sessions over a long period of time to reinforce a good behavior!
 
The way that I use the E collar in training is simple, BUT, as with any tool that is created to give the dog a correction, you MUST be sure the dog understands what is expected of them, and what the correction means.
Therefore, I use the prong and e collar together at first, to teach them they both mean the same thing, I correct with the prong and e collar at same time. Once the dog understands the correction I then take the prong away and work with the E collar, once the dog is doing well there, I take it away and use the prong, and so forth and so forth, so that the dog does not get used to any one correction tool, and does not get to make the decision, as to hey, I dont have that collar on anymore so I can do what I want. Instead, he learns that no matter what tool is on him, he must behave, for they all can have a consequence. BUT, make sure your praise and reward, I always immediately praise and reward the dog for the correct behavior, just as I would correct them for the wrong, to not do this would be unfair to the dog, so he is learning a balance of both the positive and the negative in the training, if he messes up he gets a correction, but if he does it right, he gets praise and treats. This makes the dog want to work FOR you, NOT because he has to work to avoid a correction.

I hope this makes sense.
 
@Pitts absolutely agree 100%. I treat 1000x before I correct once, and after that confused looks get treats, while that sideways 'go eff yerself' look gets a correction.
Any recommendations on e-collars? Im really liking the idea of an e-collar combined with a springer, in case of emergencies. I've found a couple innotek's on the local craigslist, but I'd love a recommendation from someone with first hand knowledge.
 
I personally use a dogtra. I have used both tri tronics and dogtra and just prefer the dogtra, the model I have is a two dog model and is for the sport dog. but you can check on their site for a model that will be best for you.
 
The Tri Tronics and the Dogtra are pricey and the less expensive ones work just as well...
I have a $100 model
SportDOG SD-105S Yard Trainer System for Stubborn Dogs

and it works and has worked now very well for about a year... I have referred it to several other doberman owners and they too love it... but to each their own, if you have the budget for either of the style that Pitts uses, buy the best one you can afford.
they have a four to five star rating by all reviewers of the collar and its good at dog parks, yard, and within 50 yards... to about 75 yards away.
You can get the one I bought on Amazon... for 100 and
this place has them for $86 bux...
http://www.furrypetsupplies.com/pro...5S-Yard-Trainer-System-for-Stubborn-Dogs.html

it requires batteries that I buy on Amazon in bulk and they last for about a month to a month and half... and they are super cheap at Amazon and sony batteries and work well...
 
I ended up getting the sportdog 400 yrd one. it was a little more, but it had enough features for me, yet simple enough for the wife to try it out without a class on it.
 

Back
Top