• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Prong? Harness? Choke?

Anissa

New Member
So here's my question of the day! Being I am new to Dobermans, but not to strong dogs (have/had Boxers), I am not certain what type of collar to use on Bella. When training with Diego, I used a gentle leader and it worked wonders, but I know different dogs call for different methods. I have never used a prong, and to be honest, they look very harsh, but I have read a lot of your posts and it appears many of you use it/advocate it. What about a no pull harness for Bella? Does anyone use this with success? Right now, I am using a Martingale collar b/c her neck is rather slender and that is what I have used on my boxers during their walks, but only after they were trained and I am not so sure it is working on crazy girl. :) I do have a choke collar (came with her when I adopted her) but I don't feel I have much control when I use it.
 
We tried the gentle leader and our dogs shut down when using it, the prong has been really effective and is actually safer than a choke chain when used correctly, that being said it seems different collars work on different dogs, you may go through a few different types until you find one that you and your dog are comfortable with. Good luck!
 
I personally prefer the prong over the other types too since when used properly they're about the most humane one out there and you have so much more control without any pulling.
Back when I first started using them I actually tried it on my own neck and gave it a couple pops and it wasn't bad at all.

I don't know if you caught this recent thread, but there's a lot of good info on the subject. :)
http://www.doberman-chat.com/community/index.php?threads/choke-chains-and-neck-problems.10971/
 
I prefer to teach loose leash walking without relying on a tool. That said, if you have a puller you need something that you can use to control the pulling while you work on training. I personally prefer the no-pull front attaching harness. Sens-ation harnesses are great, as are the Freedom no-pull harnesses. I don't love the Easy Walk as they seem to have issues with fitting properly. I'd hesitate to use a Gentle Leader on a Doberman for a pulling issue, because of the risk of neck injury in a breed prone to Wobblers. I would never use a choke (slip) collar. If you want to go that route, I'd prefer a prong, but again, I'd prefer to train loose leash walking without using correction. If your dog is not a puller I really like Martingale collars. Both my dogs have them as they can (either accidentally or on purpose) slip out of a buckle collar. Of course, my dogs only wear collars when we leave the house; they are naked dogs at home :)
 
The prong collar is actually the most humane and less stressing collar of all the collars you mentioned so far. It is a great training tool, and though it may look harsh, they truly are not.
The prong was designed to simulate a dogs mouth and teeth. If you watch a mother dog or a higher pack member, discipline a dog for a behavior, they grab them by the neck with their mouths, and the dog understands not to do that anymore. This is how the prong works, it simulates the teeth around the muscles of the neck and is actually the safest of the collars, because it applies even directly spaced pressure to the neck muscles rather than constricting or choking the neck.
Also the dogs react and learn more quickly with the prong collar, as it is a much more natural sensation for them than the others.

I highly recommend using one if your teaching obedience or walking on lead, Its like having power steering for a dog. And you will get much better results than any other collar. Just make sure it is fitted correctly.
 
I also agree with the prong collar, It is the best and safest method to teach you dog. The people who don't like them probably have never used one and base there whole opinion on what they see, which is probably a mid-evil torturing devise, they are just uninformed. The majority of dog clubs in our area that train AKC odedience, all use prong collars for training.
 
I also agree with the prong collar, It is the best and safest method to teach you dog. The people who don't like them probably have never used one and base there whole opinion on what they see, which is probably a mid-evil torturing devise, they are just uninformed. The majority of dog clubs in our area that train AKC odedience, all use prong collars for training.

I don't think it's fair to say those of us who choose not to use a prong are uninformed. I have, in fact, trained with a prong in the past. I do not think it's a medieval torture device, but I prefer to train without one. To each his own. I think when you start thinking people who have different opinions are uninformed you risk being very close minded.
 
I have always heard the prong as long as it is on correctly
does not hurt them either..........if you watch the mom
with her pups she will like Dale said grab their neck and
sometimes the pups will even cry.
 
I did not say those who chose not to use them were uninformed, I said the people who don't like them PROBABLY have never used one and base there opinion what they see. I may be close minded but only when I know I am right.
 
I wonder why the prong is the tool of choice for most professional dog trainers??? So what do we know that others don't??? First used correctly it allows communication and training to advance at a much more rapid pace - Literally I think you can cut your training at worst case scenario in half and remain safe while doing so. Not every tool works for everyone and usually because not everyone knows how to use it correctly. But the prong works allows even those who are not good with training to control their dog - I much prefer it to being drug into the street and hit by a bus.

Used correctly it can also motivate the dog and kick up the drive levels. For those who do competiton that is a key element. For pet owners often don't think it necessary but they also don't always have control of their dog. . It tells my guys we are working and they get so excited they just can't wait to get out and get going.

Are there dogs that don't need the prong absolutely - but a working breed that works is not one of them.
 
If prong collars hurt our dogs they would not come running and sit in front of me so they could have there collars put on when I bring there training gear in from the garage. If I ask them if they want to go work they get excited and run to the garage door. When there collars are on they know it is time to work and they are all bussiness.
 
So true DG - they know when the collar goes on the fun begins. It is always our belief that better safe than sorry. It says to the dog I mean business and they understand it becasue it is terms they relate to.
 
Another vote for PRONG.

I had never used a prong until the re-homed Dobe I am with currently. I've tried a nylon buckle collar, a no pull harness, even have a slip lead. The prong collar came with him and I thought I'd try others just to see what worked, but the prong is truly like having "power steering" for your Dobe....oh and others have stated that their Dobe's just sit there eagerly waiting for the prong to go on.

Good luck

Cya
 
Definately the prong colar as I have a new dog because of it. Most ofhis life he was free to to roam our land without leashes. Recently we've tried every one of the brands available to us. The harness he chewed in minutes andthe chokes, we'll just call it inhumane as I've used them sadly. The prong I have NO issues with at all. No pulling at all and is more obidient when on.
 
I wonder why the prong is the tool of choice for most professional dog trainers??? So what do we know that others don't??? First used correctly it allows communication and training to advance at a much more rapid pace - Literally I think you can cut your training at worst case scenario in half and remain safe while doing so. Not every tool works for everyone and usually because not everyone knows how to use it correctly. But the prong works allows even those who are not good with training to control their dog - I much prefer it to being drug into the street and hit by a bus.

Used correctly it can also motivate the dog and kick up the drive levels. For those who do competiton that is a key element. For pet owners often don't think it necessary but they also don't always have control of their dog. . It tells my guys we are working and they get so excited they just can't wait to get out and get going.

Are there dogs that don't need the prong absolutely - but a working breed that works is not one of them.

I think it's great that prongs work well for you, but I have to disagree that prongs are "the tool of choice for most professional dog trainers" and that working breeds can't be trained without them. Again, I'm not anti-prong, but there are plenty of great professional trainers who use other methods and there are plenty of people who train working breeds, including Dobermans, without a prong, very successfully.
 
I have a couple of questions about the prong. I have looked at webites (Leerburg, among others) that describe how to fit it properly, how to put it on the dog and where it should fall on the neck. I have 2 questions for those of you that use a prong. What size did you get? The medium seems like huge prongs, would it still work as intended if you bought a small (because it has smaller prongs) and added links to make it fit? And do most of you use the dead ring, or the live ring? I havent bought one yet, just thinking about it.
Thank you in advance.
 

Back
Top