Prong Collar Too Tight?

RexsMom

Notable member
This is a quick release 2.25mm Herm Sprenger collar: Pawmark Herm Sprenger Prong Training Collars (Scissor Snap), Training Collars

I've watched many tutorials on how to fit a prong collar properly, and I'm stuck between my current size I have in the pictures attached or adding one more.
The current way I have it, I'm not sure if it is too tight or not. It is definitely more effective, but he has yelped a couple times. Is that normal?
With one link added it slides down once he starts pulling. I don't want to hurt my boy, but I also want to make sure I'm training correctly. So I was wondering your experiences with fitting! :)
 

Attachments

  • 53660827_401299357119931_5918380365981941760_n.webp
    53660827_401299357119931_5918380365981941760_n.webp
    149.2 KB · Views: 90
  • 53435348_396701334211954_8311866366168662016_n.webp
    53435348_396701334211954_8311866366168662016_n.webp
    142.1 KB · Views: 83
Yup waaaay too tight... So that quick release collar has a "safety" ring... the way you fit any prong collar with a safety ring is to buy one with the dog as an adult in mind.... take the links out to fit it for the puppy and just add links back in as they grow up. The way to fit it is to put it on where the two "chain rings" touch the "safety ring" and the prongs apply gentle pressure to the neck... when released the collar should be loose and move freely....

The way prong collars work is that when you "Correct your pet" the prongs apply gentle, even pressure on the neck and this simulates a mother biting down on the neck of the puppy... it releases endorphins and calms the dog down.

The prongs should, in no way, cause pain... Also a good guideline is to remove all other collars when using a prong collar so that nothing gets "pinched" or stuck

Finally... I would get a slightly wider one (meaning wider in width)... Dobies have a lone neck and therefore a long trachea... that narrow collar can damage the trachea much like a choke chain... which, in my opinion, you should never use on any dog...

Hope that helps!
 
TOO tight but in the correct position on the neck. Those quick release are dangerous, please make sure you attach another collar to that. They have been known to come undone on their own. I believe Herm Sprenger even has a video on the problem...let me see if I can find it.
 
Last edited:
Leersburg talks about the quick release issues...can't find the picture I posted a while ago of the set up I use with my prong, but it is basically a buckle collar underneath the prong collar attached to both with a clip. It keeps the prong collar from slipping AND if the prong were to release your dog is still attached with the buckle collar. Hope that makes sense.
 
I do have a back up collar attached, but it doesn’t keep it from slipping down. Maybe if I add a link or two to the prong collar (I bought 3 additional links) and tighten the back up collar it could work. I talked to a couple people from sites selling the collars who are also trainers, all recommending the 2.25mm collars because they are more effective.
He does not yelp when getting the collar on or corrections, but he yelped twice when darting to bushes to smell.

Is the safety ring one of the O or D rings? Or what does it look like?
 
Well if he does not yelp when putting it on or corrections then I would say its a good fit. If he darts off and it gives him a correction he shouldn't be darting off. Or if you know he is going to dart off and you want him to. Just give him more leash.
You can add one more link. But if its sliding down his neck it is not the correct fit.
 
I use and like the 2.25mm prong collar. The smaller links get the point across. I rarely have to give him a stern correction anymore. The smaller links communicate well.

Looks like the right placement....the collar needs to be tight enough that it’s not sliding down his narrow neck.

At 10months I was in between links. Too tight or add a link and it was sliding down his neck. I went with the added link and had his flat collar under(bottom side) to hold it higher on his neck. That worked well and he grew into the added link and it stayed high on his neck for a while. Currently, I am in between links again. Haha.
 
Honestly, my prong collar looked like this on Java. I maybe have an a 1/8 inch more room but it certainly isn't not touching her skin when the leash is relaxed. Shes in a weird spot where another prong link is too big and she hasn't been growing anymore for a long long time, lol. The collar doesn't dig into her skin but with ever so slight pressure, she self corrects, which is exactly what I want. A well fitted thickish leather collar underneath the prong may help keep it from sliding too far.

Remember to read him before he reacts enough to "dart off". You should be giving him short quick flicks of the wrist pops to get his attention back to you when you tell him to "leave it" and he chooses to ignore (ears perked towards object, staring etc). Then follow up with a reward for continued focus past the trigger. Ideally, you get his attention before he starts pulling. The tool is only that and if you wait too long to correct some dogs learn to pull through the prong regardless.
 
I use and like the 2.25mm prong collar. The smaller links get the point across. I rarely have to give him a stern correction anymore. The smaller links communicate well.

Looks like the right placement....the collar needs to be tight enough that it’s not sliding down his narrow neck.

At 10months I was in between links. Too tight or add a link and it was sliding down his neck. I went with the added link and had his flat collar under(bottom side) to hold it higher on his neck. That worked well and he grew into the added link and it stayed high on his neck for a while. Currently, I am in between links again. Haha.
We are at 10 months and in the same boat :facepalm:
 

Back
Top