• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

My thoughts exactly...

Ravenbird

Moderator
$ Forum Donor $
These words come from a FB page called Obsidian K9 Academy in the UK. I thought I'd share it here, as I am passionate about training and behavior and these are words of truth to me. I also witnessed dogs being put down because of behavioral issues that could have been solved with correction and consistent training, but this one animal shelter was horrified by "cruel" training, and opted to gas the animals rather than have them "suffer a choke collar trainer". My soapbox, I'll get off of it now.

"Today, if a dog growls at a child for fishing in its food bowl, the dog is usually at fault, yet one generation ago you would have been told to leave the dog alone and stop pestering it whilst it eats... Which I agree with may I add.
The issues with todays world that I see time and time again are as follows:
Society has grown softer and softer by the day. The vast majority of young people do not understand consequence, hard work, respect, grit etc and it has been passed on to our dogs too. They are fur babies, and it detracts hugely from the essence of the dog. They are amazing because they are dogs, not despite the fact.
Unfortunately it's become the sublime to the ridiculous. Thirty years ago things were very compulsive and dogs behaviour was put before its emotional considerations and I agree that needed to change but what happened was insane.
Instead of moving forward logically we swung in the opposite direction and now people won't say no to their dog. We have to communicate with them somehow and trainers will quote that 'modern scientific methods' are the new thing... However.
Many of these 'scientific papers' do not take into account any of the social, long term ethical or practical aspects into account and many of them have severely manipulated data.
The harsh reality is that dogs are literally dying because people are putting their ideologies ahead of resolutions. Nobody wants to punish their children or their dogs, but they do to help them learn.
Extremism is literally killing dogs... I have seen ENDLESS clients that have been advised to put their dog to sleep (Or use the word murder if it helps put things into perspective) instead of correcting a behaviour. I see it fail week in and week out and I plan to actually prove this in my next PhD paper... Force free, despite what people tell you, does NOT work in every case and if anyone would like to prove to me otherwise, come and train a dog of my choosing and I will happily relinquish my position on the matter.
Ideologies should not come before canine well being. You can love your dog, and set boundaries.
It needs to stop."
 
Really well said. Reward good behaviour, correct unwanted behaviour, pretty simple really. Establishing and enforcing rules, boundaries and limitations is how we provide direction and teach them about what they are supposed to do. Without these it’s just pure chaos!
 
It seems most things (in life) have to reach polar opposites each direction before some sort of balance is found.
Sad when we are not able to alleviate pain and suffering, especially for helpless beings like pets.
 
That is well said.
While I was in the process of learning how to train a young and radical Jazz I read a LOT of different things about training. The positive only methods seemed to prevail, and they Just. Do. Not. Work! with a pup like Jazz was. Even my vet said Positive Only for these types of dogs! All said that anything else would destroy the bond with your dog! Not True!
Progress started when I began making appropriate corrections for the deliberate bad behaviour, while continuing rewarding good behaviour, and I can say quite honestly that there was no real bond with Jazz until she accepted me as her pack leader. Now we are both happy and corrections are very few and far between.
 
I can say quite honestly that there was no real bond with Jazz until she accepted me as her pack leader.
I'm so glad you said this. I couldn't really put my finger on it, but I felt Asha as a young puppy wasn't bonded much to me (or anyone or anything). Very independent and aloof. I was experimenting with "ignoring" unwanted behavior and not being too hard with corrections since she was "just a puppy". I realized she was getting bigger & stronger and giving me the finger so to speak when off leash. I got more serious about training and No means NO. Whether training or age, she is now tight on me and the bond is unbreakable. I think all dogs are different, but these hard dogs respond best to tough love.
 
Bedja around 4-5.5 months was a wild biting shark monster, he did NOTHING but lunge and bite and lunge and bite on-and-on-and-on, no kind of "correction"(was taken as encouragement to be challenged) or ignoring helped. Both my husband's and my arms were black, blue and full of scars after having skin broken all day every day for 2 months. It may seem as if they don't have any brain at this age, if I had been a dog mother I would have bit him back to make a statement. Even redirecting to a toy didn't always help. Only thing I could do was crate (though he was crated mostly only during the night), temporarily block his movements and live through it. Now he has turned into a great, wonderful companion.
Funny thing though, talking about "no brain": even during his worst monster period- in puppy training class he behaved like an Obedience Champion, I'm not exaggerating. Everyone was SO impressed with such a smart well trained young! puppy, even I couldn't almost believe it!:scratch:
 
Last edited:
We have conversations every time we're with our nieces on how they need to behave around the dogs and I am constantly watching our dogs to make sure they are also behaving appropriately. Of either dog or kid does something I feel is incorrect, I have no qualms about telling them so.

If we're in a situation where I feel like either dog won't succeed, then they are removed or do not participate. Some people would NEVER exclude their dog from "fun" because they worry their dog will be "mad" at them :rolleyes:
 
I'm so glad you said this. I couldn't really put my finger on it, but I felt Asha as a young puppy wasn't bonded much to me (or anyone or anything). Very independent and aloof. I was experimenting with "ignoring" unwanted behavior and not being too hard with corrections since she was "just a puppy". I realized she was getting bigger & stronger and giving me the finger so to speak when off leash. I got more serious about training and No means NO. Whether training or age, she is now tight on me and the bond is unbreakable. I think all dogs are different, but these hard dogs respond best to tough love.
I have to agree with you this positive reinforcement only training does not work. Odie gets a beating once a day if he needs or not and we are best buddies..(only joking about the beating)When he does get out of hand I let him know about it verbally or time out !! Unfortunately he’s still as crazy as a bag of frogs!!
 
While I was in the process of learning how to train a young and radical Jazz I read a LOT of different things about training. The positive only methods seemed to prevail, and they Just. Do. Not. Work! with a pup like Jazz was.
This was a huge source of frustration for us too. I kept finding info with positive only suggestions. If you consider how many pet trainers there are out there, it’s no wonder they want to promote positive training - if it doesn’t work, just take more classes! I’ll never forget when our positive-only Rally Obedience trainer recommended we go back to puppy class, lol. What a big waste of time that was! In hindsight, her negative comments (which I tried not to take personally) made me think Kaiser was a bit of a delinquent lol. Even the comments of those trainers do more harm than good.
 
@Kaiser2016 I was just reading a thing to get a water/safety vest for your dog to go boating and it had like 3 days work to get your dog use to the vest! Pairing the vest on the floor with treats, then making treat bag crinkles when you fasten the snap so they associate the snapping on of the vest with treat bag. For the love of god, just put the vest on and go to the lake already!!!!
 
@Kaiser2016 I was just reading a thing to get a water/safety vest for your dog to go boating and it had like 3 days work to get your dog use to the vest! Pairing the vest on the floor with treats, then making treat bag crinkles when you fasten the snap so they associate the snapping on of the vest with treat bag. For the love of god, just put the vest on and go to the lake already!!!!
I just read the same thing lol! I also rolled my eyes. Like really, I’m not spending any amount of time on that. “Stand” is the command that you stand still and I manhandle you until all the straps and buckles are where I want them!
 
Totally agree. If it's such a drama to just put on a life vest, how are other things such as tablet giving and temperature taking going to go?
jazz0415x2.webp If I can do this to Jazz without a battle then a life vest is not a worry. :rofl:
Trust and respect don't come from giving your dog the option of refusing to cooperate!
 
This was a huge source of frustration for us too. I kept finding info with positive only suggestions. If you consider how many pet trainers there are out there, it’s no wonder they want to promote positive training - if it doesn’t work, just take more classes! I’ll never forget when our positive-only Rally Obedience trainer recommended we go back to puppy class, lol. What a big waste of time that was! In hindsight, her negative comments (which I tried not to take personally) made me think Kaiser was a bit of a delinquent lol. Even the comments of those trainers do more harm than good.

I just got back from a training class where the trainer told me my dog is not normal. To be fair, she was the only one barking the whole time and unable to settle even when handled. I too am finding the positive/force free training is not moving things along as they should. I have had 2 trainers tell me that we have an abnormal puppy. I am investigating that now. Our puppy doesn't act the way we expected, hates sleeping on laps or anywhere other than her own bed - I don't feel she is that connected with any of us yet. She's 5.5 and is a little nipping terror.

As for her not being normal, I am still looking for answers to determine whether there is actually something wrong with her brain.
 
Not being unsympathetic by rating your post funny. Just that I had all those exact thoughts about my pup at about that same age. They are all different, but my girl had no true bond with me until she was about 8 months. This is the age that she really started to respect my authority instead of testing me all the way. I believe some Doberman pups are just like this and that independent thinking can make the early training difficult. There has to be a balance of positive training and consequences for deliberate misbehaviour. Just like a human toddler IMHO.

Just stay calm and consistent with all your training and in another few months you will likely suddenly realise things have turned around and from then on they just improve. All the early hard work pays off and you do forget the early hassles! :)
 
@CrisK
4-5 months is a hard age... They are bigger, stronger, and have more energy...and they are braver! So they start listening less to you and start exploring the world more on their own. Stick with the training, she will eventually click with you. Have patience too; she may look big but she is still very much a baby and mentally will be for quite a while. I have to remind myself that constantly with Ripley. To take my time and don't be in a rush. She is 6.5 months and starting to enjoy working with me. Her attention span is fairly short and her threshold for distraction pretty high (squeaker across the room will grab her attention) but we are getting there. Every week I see improvement but it takes time, patience and a lot of work.

Last night at class we had to walk around a bowl on the ground with some high value treats inside. Ripley initially pulled me to them and I just stood there. After 15 seconds of sniffing that way, she looked up at me and I rewarded. We moved on to a heel around the bowl, her head snapped up at me but she would occasionally give the bowl a look, then look back up at me. I'd treat her as soon as she consciously made the right decision. We moved closer and closer to the bowl until eventually she was literally sitting on top of it, her full attention now on me the entire time. 1 month ago? No way. She would have pulled my arm out of my socket. But we've pushed through working on heeling. From baby steps inside, to baby steps outside, to many baby steps at class. Celebrate the small victories. Eventually every one of them will add up to the final picture of success. You have plenty of time to get there.

I'm a fan of balanced training. Positive reinforcement for new behaviors, especially with puppies. Negative punishment isn't "bad" and classes I've been in use this even if they "seem" like positive only type. So, waiting your dog out when they pull and only moving forward on the leash when they give to pressure, that is a negative punishment. You are removing their desire to move forward until they offer the behavior you'd like. A leash correction for not heeling would be positive punishment; which seems to be what a lot of people jump to right away before the dog knows the command or skill and is kinda ironic that it is actually positive. Leash correction being stopped because desired behavior is being given would be negative reinforcement. None of these things are bad when used where needed in a healthy balance.

For the cuddly bit, don't fret. When Ripley is awake, she could care less to cuddle. She went from cute cuddly puppy the first few weeks we had her, to very cat like and only cuddles on her terms. We're sometimes told in class to reward our dogs with just praise instead of treats and Ripley looks at me like I'm stupid LOL.
 
Agree.

Ragnar was completely standoffish. No cuddle, no hi/bye. He would give you a big nose poke and then move on. Really didn’t come lay by me until about 8months. Took him a while but his affection came in his own way and now you can’t keep him off of you.
 
@CrisK as you can see, you aren't alone. There are some very independent Doberman puppies and as you can see in the puppy threads, some are way more difficult than others. At 15 months mine is still not cuddly, but a few times a week now she will lay quietly beside me if she's really worn out from a big day. She still protests being told what to do with an air snap. I'll tell her to get on her bed and she will go, get on it and turn and look at me, and just as I turn away she air-snaps. "I could bite you for this!" attitude. Seriously, she would not ever bite me, but this is her version of giving me the finger. I have to turn quickly to make sure she doesn't see me laughing at her. She's incredibly serious and independent, wants to be Alpha of the household, but at the same time she is velcro on me and her training is finally coming together. I don't expect she will ever be like my first two Dobes who were cuddly and would nuzzle gently (Asha paw slaps and slings her head so hard it would break teeth - this is playing, not being defiant) but I still hope she mellows out a wee bit more as she matures.

So, waiting your dog out when they pull and only moving forward on the leash when they give to pressure, that is a negative punishment. You are removing their desire to move forward until they offer the behavior you'd like.
My AKC teacher wanted me to do this at Star Puppy & again at CGC classes. Asha NEVER gave in, leaning for all she was worth on the leash while I stood my ground. One time, waiting it out as I was instructed to do, she just laid down facing the way she wanted to go, leash tight as a drum ignoring me. Finally I just told my teacher I had to resort to a prong and popping her when she leaned or pulled. To this day I think letting her practice this unwanted leaning resulted in much tougher loose-leash walking lessons. She'll still pull on a prong collar if she gets amped up. Totally oblivious to corrections.
 
I get so much encouragement here! Thanks everyone! @Ravenbird, you described what I experience with Gypsy - the leash pulling business. I was told to hold it too, but she won't give up. It's like a battle of who is strongest, and pretty soon I will be the losing part! I am a petite woman :D
 
I was told to hold it too, but she won't give up. It's like a battle of who is strongest, and pretty soon I will be the losing part!
Exactly. And in your dogs mind, you've already lost because you aren't telling them what you want.

I've had 2 Dobes before and studied animal behavior & training all my life, working with horses, but keen on dog behavior. I have never had a challenge like this one. I would do things differently if I had to do it over. If you want to see her at her very worst here's her puppy tantrums: Puppy Tantrums Videos. Looking back I think I should have crated her, but she already protested the crate anytime that wasn't bedtime and I didn't want to use it for punishment. I still can't quite figure out when "time out" in the crate does not = using the crate for punishment. I tried ignoring this behavior and using NO. Eventually she outgrew the tantrums, much like a toddler finally gets over the terrible twos.
 

Back
Top