my Dobe getting territorial or possessive of me in relation to the other family pets

Dogs do not get jealous, that is a human emotion. They do however get territorial and possessive, and I think your Dobe is being possessive of you. What you need to do is, not jus correct him and tell him no, but actually have him move away from you. As long as he is allowed to stay next to you there is no consequence for his actions. When you were on the bed I would have told him to get down. When you were on the floor he would need to move away from you, or you could move unto the couch or something like that and not allow him with you. There has to be a consequence when he growls and like Dale said you need a handle on it before it escalated.

In the case of the dog growling when they eat, I would feed the one that doesn't growl first, and make sure the growling one is calm and submissive before being fed.
 
my boy zoo does this........... but I let him. because he is top of the dog pack. often he is up on the couch next to me and will growl if another dog even looks like it might be coming over. the other dog will lower its head and look away...............then go find another resting place. in my home there is a defined pack order that is very plain to see. I do believe my dogs are happy with the order. they all get different perks :) ................but im thinking there might not be a established pack order between your dogs and until there is.......... they will struggle for there spot...............just my thoughts........... I am not 100% sure how I would deal with it with little dogs. but im sure a dog is a dog is a dog........and they all know the que's .
when we had little dogs come to visit my dogs all behaved really well with them. but I didnt let the new commers infringe on the pack rights lol!..............no sitting next to me............and no eating out of anyone's food bowl . good luck with it though I wish you my best
 
I am learning that when it comes to dog behavior and why they do certain thing,why they don't,peoples opinions are all over the board and alot of people think there way is right ,others think theirs is.I think when it really comes down to it,humans don't fully understand a dogs behavior and why it does or doesn't do certain things.Dogs afterall are animals and how can we really know how they think.
I feel in my mind that with living with dogs my entire life and observing their behavior that I somewhat understand my dogs ,but there is always some degree of questions and wondering.I think I will just keep close observations of the situation and deal with it as my gut and instincts guide me.My belief is the in the overall big picture ,I need to come across in their minds as the boss or one is running the show and certain things I will not tolerate.Up to this point I have never had any of my dogs do any harm to another animal or human and I hope if I keep on top of things it will continue.The Doberman does seem to be a bit more stubborn than other dogs and more so of a dog I would not trust with younger kids or in certain situations ,but I think I just need to always keep that in back of my head and keep on top of things.
 
How does he get a handle on it? He's corrected him, but his Dobe is still doing it. Is it going to take more than 3 times of correcting? And how should he be correcting?

You have to understand something, While it sounds like a simple concept, its very hard for most people to wrap their heads around, and that is the fact that dogs do not have the same emotions as humans. There is no such thing as jealousy, it is instead territorial, or possesiveness, or even resource guarding. What his dog is doing is probably possesiveness or territorial claiming. You have to correct the negative behaviors and then remove the dog from the situation, showing him that he is not the boss, and does not get to decide on what territory belongs to him, that is the job of the alpha, or pack leader, IE, the human. Also you need to make sure the dog works for everything, wether it be for his meals, to go out on walks, to get petted etc, IE, in order to get fed, the dog must sit and give me focus in the eyes, i sit the bowl down, and until I release him to eat, he must wait and watch my eyes.
if the dog wants to go for a walk, he must sit patiently by the door and wait for me to get everything ready, and wait until I walk out the door first and then release him to come with me.
When he wants affection, he must sit and wait until I am ready to initiate that affection, NOT on his terms.

Just some examples that might help.

I consider you an expert, your opinion here at DCF is highly valuable!
Thank you, I am glad you find my opinions valuable.
 
I am learning that when it comes to dog behavior and why they do certain thing,why they don't,peoples opinions are all over the board and alot of people think there way is right ,others think theirs is.I think when it really comes down to it,humans don't fully understand a dogs behavior and why it does or doesn't do certain things.Dogs afterall are animals and how can we really know how they think.
I feel in my mind that with living with dogs my entire life and observing their behavior that I somewhat understand my dogs ,but there is always some degree of questions and wondering.I think I will just keep close observations of the situation and deal with it as my gut and instincts guide me.My belief is the in the overall big picture ,I need to come across in their minds as the boss or one is running the show and certain things I will not tolerate.Up to this point I have never had any of my dogs do any harm to another animal or human and I hope if I keep on top of things it will continue.The Doberman does seem to be a bit more stubborn than other dogs and more so of a dog I would not trust with younger kids or in certain situations ,but I think I just need to always keep that in back of my head and keep on top of things.
This is why there are people like me out there, professional trainers and behaviorists, who have spent years and years, in the study of dog behaviors, and how to manipulate and utilize those behaviors to get the outcomes we want in our dogs.
 
The Doberman does seem to be a bit more stubborn than other dogs and more so of a dog I would not trust with younger kids or in certain situations ,but I think I just need to always keep that in back of my head and keep on top of things.
I don't agree with the Dobe being stubborn and untrustworthy with kids. I would trust my two completely with kids. Our Golden however did not at all like kids.
 
The average time for testosterone to diminish in the system once a dog is neutered is about 4-6 weeks. BUT, I say again, this does not change or alter already defined behaviors in a dog.

Well I can see that I'm gonna give Pitts a case of carpel tunnel when he corrects all my bad advise or my misinformation. LOL I clearly need to do more research...if I don't Pitts won't have enough time to train dogs with all the corrections.

I always thought it took several months for the testosterone to work itself out of the dogs system...now I find out it's 4-6wks....wow I was way off. I sincerely apologize for my bad info.

Cya
 
I have a pack order in my house and it's me, top dog. :D I would never allow Buddy OR Kali to growl at each other, other than in play. Kali loves to play tug and she is real vocal at that time, growling up a storm, but its all play. Buddy has never growled at Kali......never is a big word...:p....he did do it a couple of times but I was on top of it immediately. It was mainly because he had something that she wanted and he gave a little warning growl. I wouldn't let her have it and they were both corrected. Her for trying to take it and him for growling. :nono: Regardless of what the pack order may be after me, I still do not allow any aggression showing between them. It's a bit different (in my eyes) between a large and small dog like mine, than two larger dogs. Even though he was here first, she is more easily harmed. So care has to be taken. But I can love up on her or him and don't feel the other should interfere or show aggression (teeth/growl) Sure, there is some jealousy but it's shown differently.....I could be loving one and the other comes running for some loving too. :D I have two hands! I just encompass both! But there is no growling. Just joining! :) I can have her on my lap and if Buddy comes up there is no growling from her or him. Again, I would never allow that. As far as I'm concerned, not nipping growling in the butt, will just lead to worse. But that's just the way I handle it. :D
 
If you think about it puppies, cats, leopards, lions, tigers - animals in general all have play games that later prepares them for stalking, chasing, pouncing, and killing their food for real. It is practice for later when they are grown and have to fend for themselves. It is like testing the waters. That is why it is important to manage it from puppyhood on up.
 
I am again starting to get some issues concerning me between my 3.5 year old male neutered Doberman and my wifes chihuhuas. THe CHihuahuas are definatley not best behaved but with the size difference I really need to be sure I don't get any issues. THe Doberman nipped the Chi in the head on one occasion and my wife wants to keep them separated at all times now in the house,which I understand but is very difficult. I love my Dobe to no end but can not stand to see him hurt a small dog. THe Dobe is now in crate while I am at work as my wife doesn't want to take any chances. I feel so bad to see him in there and want to find a remedy. The Dobe seems to have the biggest issues with possession of things ,objects,places, people. He will sometimes growl when the Chi comes near. The female Chi is most problematic but sometimes the male has issues as well. Do I need to keep them separated at all times, put a muzzle on the Dobe? IS there even a muzzle that is humane and that would be trustworthy to stay on? I could use some input please. When separated the Dobe is fine. No aggression to humans and real good to me. Is there just no way of peace here?
Thanks
 
It would be nice if there was a collar that shocked 2 dogs if they got too close to each other. Then you could leave them in the house all day by themselves during the day and work on training at night.
 
In my experience with small dog/larger dog households I tend to make sure the pack order is set up and maintained with the large dog at the bottom of the pecking order. I have a chi, an italian greyhound and a dobe. My dobe is the youngest, biggest, lowest pack member. It sounds maybe a little horrible but I make her do and get everything last. Italian greyhound first, then chi then dobe, always in that order, getting food or getting in the car. The reason the larger dog is at the bottom is purely because a 35kg dobe can kill a 2kg chi in a matter of seconds but a chi going to be hard pressed killing a dobe. Dobermanns really do appreciate strong and consistent leadership.

Its more difficult when you are dealing with a mixed dog and owner household as you haven't trained the chis. I suggest you and your wife work together on this and seek a good trainer near by to guide you though the process. Keep in mind peace can only happen if both you and your wife are equally committed to making this work as its your Dobe and her chis.

Ps I learnt from my mom that in a home their should be one ultimate pack leader (she has a pack of 8 ranging from chis to boxer x) and I have followed that in my home, its me then my husband finally my dogs. Its easier for the dogs to understand the pecking order.
 

Back
Top