I want to dispel a common myth...

Silent Dobe

Well-Known Member
...Dogs are NOT descended from wolves. If the "so-called experts" on here (self proclaimed of course) would read anything other than a Dog Fancy magazine, they would have found this out a long time ago.

Darwin's Dogs is the book I am talking about. Darwin (I don't care about your religious beliefs here, science is science), talks about how dogs are COUSINS of wolves. A different species all together. Same genus. That is like saying that foxes are also descended from wolves.

Sorry for the rant, but this stemmed from the locked RAW food thread.

http://doberman-chat.com/community/...-so-hard-for-the-neophyte-to-understand.8258/
 
...Dogs are NOT descended from wolves. If the "so-called experts" on here (self proclaimed of course) would read anything other than a Dog Fancy magazine, they would have found this out a long time ago.

Darwin's Dogs is the book I am talking about. Darwin (I don't care about your religious beliefs here, science is science), talks about how dogs are COUSINS of wolves. A different species all together. Same genus. That is like saying that foxes are also descended from wolves.

Prove it :D

Seriously though, wolves can breed with dogs while foxes can't (chromosome mismatch); the general concensus is that dogs are descended from wolves; but even then there's differing views of what type(s) of wolf was/were the ancestor. And again there's even more confusion about when the domesticated dog showed up (probably 14,000 years ago) ?

Bottom line is that none of us where there at the time to be 100% sure :D , and new dates and theories are being put forward all the time so I'd sit on the fence on their exact relationship until it's proven one way or another.

Besides, there could also be a chance that the wolf was reintroduced to the dog at a later stage just to make it more confusing.

But the general evidence in university papers etc seems to show that the wolf was directly involved - but I'm going by what I've read and have no archeological skills :p
 
It is an interesting debate - and there are many genes in common in both dogs and wolves. It is just my unscientific mind at work but when I see the variance in Dogs - and wolves I can't buy into the dogs came from wolf theory and it is a theory. As Ataro said no one knows because we weren't there, but God was and He knows.

The other thing with the scientific theory is when evolution occurs it is usually due to a drastic change in environment (their theory) and the original species as known disappears. We still have wolves today and they are wolves - Why aren't they changing???

It also does not explain why some are flopped eared and some not - wolves are ALL pricked as are the coyotes, foxes etc. I am just saying that even to me there are some big holes in the theory.
 
I don't know the evolution of the dog, but dogs are presently a separate species from the grey wolf. As a separate species, I would not expect dogs to be identical to wolves in behavior, dietary requirements or social structure. There may be similarities between the two species, but there are differences as well. We should look at what is right infront of our faces- a dog is not a wolf any more than a Holstein is buffalo.
 
The theory of dogs being descended from the grey wolf seems to have overly influenced dog behaviorists and nutritionists in the past couple decades which is why I think we saw the rise of dominance based dog training and raw diets. There seems to be a slowing of that trend and even some reversal that is putting our eyes more on what the domestic dog is, how it learns and what it really needs.
 
I can see a lot of similarities between this wolf and a GSD :

wolf.jpg


gsd.jpg



On the other hand, I'm not too sure about this particular "evolution" :D :

white_wolves_.jpg


maltese.jpg
 
I guess Ingrid that is why I am slower to jump on all this new and improved theories. Right now we have some pretty solid tried and true - As we get further down the road we sometimes learn that science did not read mother nature's manual and so got it wrong.

You mean you've been around long enough to not fall for every fad that comes down the road? :rofl:
 
...Dogs are NOT descended from wolves. If the "so-called experts" on here (self proclaimed of course) would read anything other than a Dog Fancy magazine, they would have found this out a long time ago.

Darwin's Dogs is the book I am talking about. Darwin (I don't care about your religious beliefs here, science is science), talks about how dogs are COUSINS of wolves. A different species all together. Same genus. That is like saying that foxes are also descended from wolves.

Sorry for the rant, but this stemmed from the locked RAW food thread.

http://doberman-chat.com/community/...-so-hard-for-the-neophyte-to-understand.8258/
Thanks for the link I missed that thread.

It is an interesting debate - and there are many genes in common in both dogs and wolves. It is just my unscientific mind at work but when I see the variance in Dogs - and wolves I can't buy into the dogs came from wolf theory and it is a theory. As Ataro said no one knows because we weren't there, but God was and He knows.

The other thing with the scientific theory is when evolution occurs it is usually due to a drastic change in environment (their theory) and the original species as known disappears. We still have wolves today and they are wolves - Why aren't they changing???

It also does not explain why some are flopped eared and some not - wolves are ALL pricked as are the coyotes, foxes etc. I am just saying that even to me there are some big holes in the theory.
I'm pretty sure Silent Dobe's remark...... (I don't care about your religious beliefs here, science is science), meant let's keep God out of this;)
 
​

Interesting post..
Honestly ive never gave it much thought.. The Wolf theory is one i learned in school, so it wouldn't surprise me in the least if this is relatively new line of thought for most.​
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'm pretty sure Silent Dobe's remark...... (I don't care about your religious beliefs here, science is science), meant let's keep God out of th

Read more: http://www.doberman-chat.com/community/index.php?threads/i-want-to-disperse-a-common-myth.14519/#ixzz1zP3SU6wV​


Gel - I stated my point of view which is what happens in a discussion - no one has to agree with it, but it is how I see it. I don't believe you can talk about evolution without acknowledging the other side. Do you mean I should just say "no comment"??

I do feel that there are some holes that science can't explain because there are some challenges with the theory and I think Silent hit on one. No one has to agree, but that is what makes it an interesting discussion. If we all agree, what do we have to discuss??? I did not mean to offend anyone.
 
Ever see the siberia experiment with silver foxes? Completely wild foxes bred over years in a experiment, certain ones handled while other ones remain wild...the "tamed" ones over the years begin producing floppy ears, waggy tails, and color patterns not seen in the wild.

View: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YbcwDXhugjw


I think it's possible dogs could have been descended from wolves. It just makes sense for back then, the more docile wolves hanging around man to take advantage of the free food he could get from hunts. Man seeing that wolves could help them hunt and over many years a unique relationship forms to the point where man can use the help of the docile wolves to their advantage. I mean after all, the ones that are leery aren't going to be the ones that hang around humans. I think the reason we don't see wolves evolve into dogs today is because that evolution was driven by man and not naturally. We don't need to tame wolves anymore because we already have the many dog breeds today to choose from to suit our needs. Of course none of us were there but it is certainly all very interesting. I do however believe just like with the appearance of dogs, their insides are different somewhat compared to their "possible" wild ancestors. I do not think dogs are complete carnivores anymore.
 

Back
Top