I want to dispel a common myth...

I personally do belive that dogs descended from wolves, but dogs are different critters now. Studying wolf behavior may shed some light on dog behavior, but it's more an interesting academic exercise than "the" answer to understanding dog behavior. It was probably someone who studied wolf pack behavior who came up with the idea for an "alpha roll" on a dog to assert dominance, and the word "alpha" was injected into the common vocabulary of dog owners by the writings of academics.

The dog is a domesticated animal like horses, cattle, poultry, etc. Like Von's post pointed out, it's unnatural selection that has created our dogs. Despite all of our fiddling with the dogs' appearances, they have retained "dogness" :) At the heart of "dogness" is a willingness to please man and a desire to do what they were bred to do whether it's hunting, herding, protecting, or just warming a lap. A wolf wants nothing to do with man and flees from man like the wild animals they are.
 
I'm pretty sure Silent Dobe's remark...... (I don't care about your religious beliefs here, science is science), meant let's keep God out of th​
​


Gel - I stated my point of view which is what happens in a discussion - no one has to agree with it, but it is how I see it. I don't believe you can talk about evolution without acknowledging the other side. Do you mean I should just say "no comment"??

I do feel that there are some holes that science can't explain because there are some challenges with the theory and I think Silent hit on one. No one has to agree, but that is what makes it an interesting discussion. If we all agree, what do we have to discuss??? I did not mean to offend anyone.
No offense was taken by me D4E,I guess I read it different than you did?You would have to dig much deeper to offend me:)
You probably have forgot more about dogs and our breed than I will ever know,I look forward to reading your post here.We seem to agree for the most part on politics,and the future of the breed and basic morals.We need to agree to disagree on some topics.
I guess I read it as far as domestic dogs and not all evolution?If a poster ask to keep clear of something I will.I guess I read something between the lines,maybe I was wrong? In and of itself,domestic dogs are not part of evolution(imo) as we humans created them.

My appology for my mis-spellings ,I have had an....interesting evening:D:martini::groan:
 
I wonder if it has ever occurred to anyone to try the silver fox experiment on today's wild wolves? You know, try to repeat the original domestication of the wolf (if indeed that's how it happened), using today's scientific study methods, to see if dogs truly did descend from wolves. If we start getting spotted, floppy-eared, waggy-tailed wolves, then perhaps that (in some ways) proves the evolution of wolves into dogs. However, if the subsequent generations of wolves retained their wary demeanor, their wild appearance, etc., perhaps it happened a different way.... Of course, then there's the problem of what to do with all the "subsequent generations." What do they do with all the foxes?
 
The experiment apparently is short on money. They sell some to an exotic trade business in Las Vegas, some to fur trade, a handful to locals and the others that they can't afford basic upkeep for are euthanized.
http://www.slate.com/articles/healt...foxes_in_siberia_an_experiment_in_peril_.html
I'm not typically a bunny hugger, per se, but that's kind of sad. Creating waggy-tailed foxes just to put them to sleep. What's the point? The fur trade, I get. Especially if they're unusual colors and/or color patterns. Locals, even, I can understand, especially if they're to the point that they make decent pets. But inevitably some will be euthanized. I just wonder if it's worth their findings?
 
You know, try to repeat the original domestication of the wolf (if indeed that's how it happened), using today's scientific study methods, to see if dogs truly did descend from wolves

There are several behavorist who do specialize in working iwth wolves. They always say that they are wild animals and that you have to enter their world not expect them to completely enter ours and be trusted with humans. They allow very few humans in the pack. Animal Planet or Nat Geo had a show on a couple different studies on living with wolves.

To add: Cesar had a segment on wolve hybrids and the problems people creadted when they crossed breeds with dogs and that they were not good for pets.
 
I'm not typically a bunny hugger, per se, but that's kind of sad. Creating waggy-tailed foxes just to put them to sleep. What's the point? The fur trade, I get. Especially if they're unusual colors and/or color patterns. Locals, even, I can understand, especially if they're to the point that they make decent pets. But inevitably some will be euthanized. I just wonder if it's worth their findings?
I agree it's a bit sad, but I wonder if most of it started going downhill when the guy that was the head of this experiment passed away, and I imagine so did their funding and energy for the experiment. I wonder what drives them to continue? Edit: Ah, just answered that question by fully reading the article I posted ;) Here: "Belyaev, who died in 1985 and left Lyudmila Trut in charge of the project, was clear about his goal: The foxes would be considered fully domesticated only when they obeyed human commands as dogs do. That part of the experiment is still unfinished"
 
I'm pretty sure Silent Dobe's remark...... (I don't care about your religious beliefs here, science is science), meant let's keep God out of th

Read more: http://www.doberman-chat.com/community/index.php?threads/i-want-to-disperse-a-common-myth.14519/#ixzz1zP3SU6wV​


Gel - I stated my point of view which is what happens in a discussion - no one has to agree with it, but it is how I see it. I don't believe you can talk about evolution without acknowledging the other side. Do you mean I should just say "no comment"??

I do feel that there are some holes that science can't explain because there are some challenges with the theory and I think Silent hit on one. No one has to agree, but that is what makes it an interesting discussion. If we all agree, what do we have to discuss??? I did not mean to offend anyone.

I agree with everything D4E says, she is the best and yes I am a groupie. Lol
 
I don't know the evolution of the dog, but dogs are presently a separate species from the grey wolf. As a separate species, I would not expect dogs to be identical to wolves in behavior, dietary requirements or social structure. There may be similarities between the two species, but there are differences as well. We should look at what is right infront of our faces- a dog is not a wolf any more than a Holstein is buffalo.

You forgot one, line we are to the cavemen. Lol although I have met some guys that where close to it. Ha ha
 

Back
Top