• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

How to teach your dog NOT to come

At 6 months of age, she could be hitting that icky juvenile stage when, ultimately, they are teenagers and ignore when they feel like it. This is the time to always follow through with every command given.
As for that list, it is fantastic! I don't know of anyone that hasn't done at least one thing on that list. :)
Also, I just wanted to mention that with clicker training, the recall is usually the first command taught (there seems to be a natural progression of the commands) and continually reinforced throughout training. Something for someone with a new pup to consider or someone having issues with their current training methods. :)
 
As for that list, it is fantastic! I don't know of anyone that hasn't done at least one thing on that list. :)
Thank you ! I agree and I think it's helpful for folks to sometimes read what NOT to do instead of just telling us the correct way because we seem to see ourselves more easily that way! LOL
 
D4E : GREAT input.. love the idea of a flexi lead when they are little and the come to front and the tug on the collar... all stuff that really makes such great sense! wish I had thunk that when we got Gemma at 3 months old.. great stuff! thanx!
 
LOL The hubby has done many of those and wonders why our dog will come to me all the time and not him. A trick I found is if our dog is trying to be a stubborn @ss and trying not to come....I turn around and jog away. He can't help himself, he comes running and I can regain control. ;-)
 
I think we've all done at least one of these at one time or another. :D It's a good reminder what NOT to do! Turning and going in the other direction does work at times. They want to be with us! ;)
 
I have ALWAYS had a hard time teaching Nexus to come when called. From the very first day we started teaching her commands, this was one she would not obey, on leash, off leash, with treats, nothing we did worked to make her obey it. Even now she does not obey it all the time, sometimes, and most of that is when she sees Bella coming to me, but on her own, its maybe half the time. I am still trying to get her to do it 100% of the time, and its frustrating, because she is a very heastrong dog, usually she needs a good reason to come to me, and food rewards do not work, she will stand there, a foot or two away, look at me and not move. Its very hard not to get frustrated and simply grab her and haul her in, or to chase her, which never works because the little devil can run like the wind. Sometimes I will simply say "fine, stay outside" and walk away, which I know isnt really good to do, but within about 5 minutes, she will actually ask to be let in, but after standing at a door for 15 - 20 minutes trying to work on "come" it gets maddening.
 
Starlight, how about using a favorite squeaky toy? You have to use whatever gets your dog excited and if it's not food, then try a toy. I saw a home made film that my sis gave me of someone using a toy and she got such great results by using a fav toy, using a VERY happy voice and only working in like 5 minute lessons. Everything was high level of excitement. Called the dog and as soon as he came and sat in front of her, she threw the toy as a reward. All very exciting. Make it fun for the dog and always give him a reason to want to come to you. I know how frustrating it can be, believe me. There are times when I am being ignored too and I just want to shake him!! But that would be added to the list of 'ways to teach your dog NOT to come to you" ! LOL!!
 
Question: On number 13, you say to make them obey your "Enough" command. How do you do that? I understand how to make them obey your "Come" command, but what do you do to make them obey your "Enough" command?
 
Question: On number 13, you say to make them obey your "Enough" command. How do you do that? I understand how to make them obey your "Come" command, but what do you do to make them obey your "Enough" command?
For me and my dogs, 'enough' means to stop what they are doing. Stop an action that I want stopped. That could be barking, licking, or nosing someone's hand when I've had 'enough!'

I get that done by doing my ''Cesar" stance, a stern look, (remember that 'look' your mother gave you when you knew she was really mad? LOL ) and very few words. Pick a word you would like to use and say it like you mean it. A lot of conversation is not only not effective, the dog doesn't understand it. He will understand your tone, energy and body language.

I get my dogs attention and give the command and wait for his respnse. I stand directly in front of him, even walking into him if he is not listening and/or trying to avoid me.

When he finally settles and sits, I calmly walk away without another word.
 
You do things so similar to the way I do them, MyBuddy! I use "enough" as well, and use the same body language. It's usually my "mommy-is-starting-to-get-pissed-and-you're-gonna-get-a-major-timeout" command. I use it often when visitors come over. I make him sit-stay in the foyer as I invite them in, so he can see that they're welcome. Then I ask him to go to his bed for five to ten minutes, until he can get over his maniacal excitement over visitors. Then I allow him to say hi. If hi turns into him acting like an over-zealous maniac, he gets sent to his bed again. If we get to the "enough" command, he knows he's pushed it too far, and will usually walk away, ears all airplaned out, and find himself a sucky to lie down with to properly pout.

I worked hard on recalls with Dylan, especially when we first got him. I ALWAYS threw a party when he recalled. Every single time. Sometimes, but not always, treats were involved. When he disobeyed, I would repeat the command. He's very sensitive, and if he thought for one second that I was getting upset with him, there was no way in heck he was going to come to me. So after three missed recalls, I would crouch down to the ground and say, "Dylan, come to Mom now. C'mon, it's okay." and he would come running with relief. Something about me getting low and quiet worked every time. After a year of consistent work, I could let him off lead, pretty reliably.

The problem came when we took him to the farm. 40 acres and a pond full of dragonflies is just too tempting. It worried me, because there is a county road that borders our property, and there are occasionally stray dogs around. So Mommy bought an e-collar. I had a come-to-Jesus meaning with Dylan, and showed it to him, and explained that if he decided to act like an ass, Mommy could still reach him. Not only that, Mommy was more than happy to light his eyes up when memory failed him as to what "Come!" means. He sat there, listening to the entire lecture, tilting his goofy head back and forth. I put the collar on him, determined the lowest setting that would get any kind of reaction out of him (in his case, a small twitch of the ears), and started out with some basics in the house. Then I took him outside on the retractable with the e-collar on, and did some more work. I always started out with the page function. A small vibration to let him know that I was serious. Then, when I felt he was ready, I took him off lead. I made it VERY obvious that I was unclipping the lead. Of course, he set off like a greyhound. "I'm freeeeeeeee!!!!" I recalled him. He didn't even break stride. So I pushed the page button. He slowed down a bit. I recalled again. He stopped and looked at me. I could tell he was thinking about it. So I gave him a second to make a decision. He made the wrong one. Whoops. I recalled a third time, and the second he disobeyed, I gave a loud "NO!" and popped him. He froze in his tracks and I could see his little wheels turning. "How did she do that?! She's so far away!" I said, "Dylan, come." in a relatively quiet, non-threatening voice. He started tentatively toward me, so I encouraged him, by patting my legs and telling him he was good. By time he reached me, he was at full gallop. I threw the requisite party. Of course, he challenged me the next day, as Dobermans are wont to do. But I was consistent, and he hasn't missed one since.

The only other time I had to pop him from a distance was when he decided to eat something unmentionable off the ground out there. We battled tapeworms once. I won't have him eating crap. He sniffed it, I said "Leave it!" He opened his mouth, I cranked the power, and the second his little lips made contact, I popped the crap out of him. I didn't say a word. As far as he was concerned, that thing was no longer worth eating, whatever it was. He came running to Mommy for comfort, which I gave freely.
 
I am having a hard time with recall with my boy - he knows the command and will do it in the house 99% of the time but outside he will totally ignore me - how would everyone correct this ??? I've tried to be more interesting than the leaf blowing by, but I guess I'm not by the response I get !!!! ;)
 
I am having a hard time with recall with my boy - he knows the command and will do it in the house 99% of the time but outside he will totally ignore me - how would everyone correct this ??? I've tried to be more interesting than the leaf blowing by, but I guess I'm not by the response I get !!!!

Outside, loose, is the number one test of time! LOL First off, don't let them off leash before the recall is perfected. A long line is perfect for this. There are some that are a good 30 feet long. Long enough for them to think they are loose and give them some freedom but enough for you to grab when the recall is ignored.

Having a 100% recall, 100% of the time, no matter where you are, in my opinion, doesn't happen. Reality is, there will always be something,....a squirrel, dog, a loud noise, etc that will excite your dog into deafness. So for me, working on the recall is a life long training session. I practice it as much as I can, rewarding and praising every time its done. I teach that knocking on my window means come. I teach blowing a whistle means come. I teach that bending down and opening my arms wide (like for a hug) means come. And I teach that when I say Come I MEAN COME. I also taught that if he didn't come to me when I called, I'm coming after him! :tap::sonic: He learned quickly that I meant business! When I went after him, the MINUTE (SECOND) that he sees me and takes a step towards me, I stopped and allow him to come to me. Does that make sense? I want him to come to me, unafraid. If I continued to give chase, he'd run in the other direction, afraid of my wrath. I just want him to SEE my wrath and that he can't get away with dissing me. When he looks at me and stops running, I immediately stop and change my demeanor (energy) to one of 'Good Boy' and he comes right over. And gets a good boy pat! :D

When you think you have the recall perfected, try him loose in a fenced area so that he can't run far and get into trouble. See how it goes and if its not what you think it should be, go back to the leash and keep working. :D
 
Thanks for all the new ideas for the recall. Brings back memories! I remember what a struggle it was with my first headstrong doberman Jake. I've been working on it now with my new dobie, and she is headstrong too! One thing I've always told people if they ask my opinion on what the best piece of training advice I can give them would be: teach your dog that right in front of you is the best place in the world. Always be happy WHENEVER they show up there, whether on their own, accidentally, or because you've called them to you. So they always know you will be nice if they come to you. Even if after calling them they take their sweet time getting to you (if they are off leash). I grit my teeth and say something nice, and stop training (if that's what I'm doing) until I calm down, and then start again (ON leash this time, lol!). Also, if my dog is blatantly disobeying (or habitually doing something naughty), I GO GET HIM/HER. I NEVER call them to me and then get mad for whatever it was they were doing wrong. Even if it means I "set them up" (in order to solve the problem of running off) by letting them drag their leash while I wait for the disobedient behavior (in my case it was jumping up on the counter to "check" for goodies when they thought I wasn't watching). That way I can get ahold of them without calling them to me, and give a correction. Never let them think you can be fooled.... if you give them an inch - they will take a mile in my experience! :groan:
 
So how do I do it. If i'm standing in the door and say come or inside and she just looks at me, what do I do to enforce it? When she does come inside I give a treat but I think mostly she does it when she wants. Am I trying to quick? Had her exactly one week and she seems to barely pick up on her name.
 
So how do I do it. If i'm standing in the door and say come or inside and she just looks at me, what do I do to enforce it? When she does come inside I give a treat but I think mostly she does it when she wants. Am I trying to quick? Had her exactly one week and she seems to barely pick up on her name.
Believe it or not, "come" is a pretty advanced command. What you do to enforce it is to keep your pup on a long line or leash. Don't say "come" unless you can make your pup come. Yes you are rushing things. Your first week should just be about bonding and adjusting to a new home.
 

Back
Top