Help - neutering and two males

Skybug2000

Novitiate
We got a 4 month old male doberman. We will get him fixed when he is 6 months old. We want to get another one to go with him.
If I get another male and get him fixed at 6 months also will they get along. I have had a few people tell me they would fight but would never answer on if both were neutered?
Also are females more aggressive?
We got a 2 year old grandson they are being raised around.
Please give me your opinion on getting a male or female to go with our male pup.
We always spay or neuter.
 
Welcome from Minnesota!

Six months is way too young to neuter them and no it won't make a difference in same sex aggression. It's best to wait a couple years between pups and get two different genders so you don't have to worry about SSA.

It's best to wait til they're 18 - 24 months to have them fixed so they're mostly done growing.
Also are females more aggressive?
No, none of them should be aggressive with the proper training and care.
 
Neutering will not make a difference in whether or not the will fight. It is best to wait until around 18 months or older if you are going to neuter. It is also better to space your dogs age out by 2 years of age. This will make training easier. Two young pups will need special individual time and training and is much more work. Waiting until 2 with your first dog will be much easier since the older dog will already be trained and the young pup will also learn from that dog.
 
Wait until your first dog is 2 years old for getting another dog. I know you may think they do, but they don't need doggy friends and you'll be thankful that you did wait since you'll have time to train the first one. Getting two and having to train them separately so they don't bond too closely to one another is a handful. You want them to be able to focus on you, and not each other.
 
MY experience and advise...Don't do it!

While I agree with wait till age 2 and get a bitch if you do.
2 bitches 2 or more years apart are usually fine together but can be a problem occasionally.
A dog and a bitch 2 or more years apart usually get along fine.
It is not unusual at all for 2 males to fight for dominance in the pack hierarchy.
2 males together is asking for trouble unless they have a very experienced owner with strong training a leadership skills.

Per the AKC Breed standard on temperament...
An aggressive or belligerent attitude towards other dogs shall not be deemed viciousness. So aggression towards other dogs is not unusual for Dobermans.


I had a friend that after seeing Zeus and Apollo on Magnum PI was determined to have 2 males like he saw on TV.
Which I highly advised against and tried to talk him out of to no avail.

He bought 2 males from the same litter. ( Back yard breeder of course)
His logic was "They are litter mates and brothers they will grow up together be buddies and it will be fine."

WRONG!
Thats what happens when one applies human behavior to canines.
Altho human brothers fighting growing up is pretty common too. Especially if they are close in age.(AKA sibling rivalry)

They fought from about 6 month of age on, constantly over everything.
Their place in the bed, you have my toy. Who runs out the door 1st. Feeding time ,I am getting petted don't come near us! Everything was a reason to growl and snap at the other.

Training both dogs at the same time was a nightmare and a total disaster.
Again their flawed thinking was the husband would train one and his wife would train the other.
"It's something we can all do together... It will be fun!".
Training 1 Doberman can be chore even for people with experience with the breed.
Training 2 at once was impossible for a pair of novices.
(Ever take a puppy to puppy kindergarten or basic obedience class?)
End result neither dog was even remotely properly trained.
Trying to get a doberman puppy to focus on the person doing training is hard enough.
Trying to get them to focus on you when a littermate is in the picture is an exercise in frustration and futility.
Anybody that has raised 2 or more children knows the problem of who did ______? Not me!
Same with 2 puppies..Who pooped on the floor? Who ate the couch when I went to the mail box? Who lifted their leg on the chair ? ...Who knows?

Then they neutered them about about 8 months thinking it would help settle them down and end the aggression. It did not.
The fighting between them just got worse as they got older and more powerful. Resulting in multiple trips to the vet.
Things finally came to head at about age 3 after my buddy got bit bad trying to break up a fight. It resulted in multiple bite wounds needing stitches. And then 6 weeks later his wife got bit and needed stitches too. Again trying to break up fight because "I thought they were going to kill each other."
The ER contacted animal control after the 2nd bite (It's the law)...2nd dog bite in 6 weeks.
To this day I don't think they ever figured out if one dog bit them or if they both did.

That was it, the wife was done with both of the dogs & with Dobermans still to this day.
They ended up having to re-home both of them separately.
And they had a hell of a time finding good homes for them.
"Anyone want a poorly trained 3 year old 95 pound out of control male Doberman, that bit both of his owners? We have 2.. take your pick!."
Not an easy task. I would have taken one but wife put her foot down and said "No way ..Not when we have 4 year daughter"

It's a sad story and not the dogs fault at all...100% human error.
It was a shame even though they were from a back yard breeder they were very nice looking and very smart dogs. They just went to the wrong home.
Inexperienced breeder..Inexperienced owners...Just bad luck for those poor dogs.

I often wonder who got those dogs and how it turned out for them.
My guess is when they were no longer fighting with each other and had the 100% focus of a competent owner and leader they ended up being great dogs.
At least I hope how it ended for them.

Still thinking about getting a 2nd? LOL
Cheers
MR
 
Last edited:

Back
Top