Help My Boy Keeps Breaking His Collars

DobieMommy86

Novitiate
we do not have a fenced in yard so when we let him out we will put Sparta on a cable runner so he does not run off and lately he has been literally ripping his collars in half, we have tried both collars with leather and fabric material and both he has broken... so I was just wondering what kind of collar we should try for him.. I know some of you will say don't put him on the cable, but we do not do it all the time and he is never on it for extended amounts of time, we are always out there with him he runs and even though he stays in our yard and does not bother anyone our neighbors have threatened to call the dog warden so we put him on the runner when we are all out in the back yard and it is right beside us where we sit and socialize.. my husband says we need a choke collar but I do not want him to hurt his neck so I was just wondering if there is a really durable kind of collar that he can not destroy.. he is 8 months old
 
May I ask why you choose to put him on a cable and not just a regular leash? I understand not having a fenced in yard and having to work around that, but Dobermans are not dogs that you should cable out. They have VERY sensitive necks and if he is pulling hard enough to break a leather or fabric collar he is pulling too hard and could hurt himself. A choke chain should NEVER be used on a Doberman period for the above stated reason (it can hurt their neck) especially if they are on a chain outside. That could very seriously damage them. I understand that it is probably not convenient to have him on a leash while you are trying to spend time with your family and probably chase kids around, but Sparta is your kid too :) Are you out with him when he breaks his collars? Simply don't let him. There's not a magic collar out there that is strong enough to not allow him to break it. In fact, most collars have a safety feature to prevent choking. Your issue is not the collar :) I would think the best thing to do is to correct the problem while you are out there. Don't let him break his collar. If he starts acting goofy, correct him. Then reward him for being calm and behaving like you want him to. How far away from you is he when you are outside and he is chained? Can he come up to you, or is he at the back of the yard? Dobies are very social dogs with their families and want to be with them all the time. Perhaps he is breaking out because he is not close enough to you. For now, until you can get him trained I would personally buy a flexi lead and have him on leash while he is out with you. His reaction while he is on a cable is just waiting for a disaster to happen. He could very easily choke himself and be seriously hurt.

How much training has he had? How much exercise does he get? If his recall is good, I would take him up to a fenced in area if you have one close by. I use ball parks and school sports complexes (I have a yard but it is 9,000 sq feet and I have three Pinschers) and let him run. Your problem to me sounds like a combo of lack of exercise, training (he is young), and perhaps not being close enough to his family when chained outside. I could be wrong :)

Let us know how things go. And we need to see pictures of your little guy, lol. I have an 8 month old red female. It can be a tough age! This is a great place to come for help. I hope you find what you are looking for and get your neighbors off your back. Geesh! They sound like jerks.
 
Last edited:
That's pretty amazing that he's breaking collars like that on a runner... I have nothing against runners and would actually like to put one up in my unfenced yard. Does your runner have a spring built into the line to soften the blow when he hits the end of the line? I'd be afraid that if he had a collar he couldn't break, he'd cause neck damage from hitting the end of the cable so hard.
 
No dog will do well when tied on a line outside for their entertainment - they can't truly run and Dobermans LOVE to run and they have nothing to do so boredom sets in and they do the natural thing which is to get themselves free. Now that he has learned he can to put him on a choke would be like inviting sudden death.

This is one reason most good breeders are hesitant to place a puppy in a home without a fenced yard. I would start with training classes. This will help occupy his mind and need for human companionship - If he goes outside then put him on leash and walk him then have a long line and play with him. Build a bond so he wants to stay close to you.

I agree on the e fence - it will usually keep your dog in but everything else is free to come inside the area and a dog tied up is a prime target. I myself would worry about him being stolen.
 
Although I'm pro-ecollar, I'm against e-fences. They keep dogs out of their yards if they break out through, and they don't keep strange dogs out.
Yeah carnage would surly ensue with my pack.. We have a neighbor that let's his Dachshund run loose everywhere then gets a corn cob up his but when my dogs bark their fool heads off at the trespassing dog, cuz he works third shift and sleeps during the day.. I lobbed an m-80 at the Dachshund once not close enough to hurt him but close enough to scare him from ever returning.. That was a year ago and have never seen the dog in my backyard since.. Although the owner called the police on me for excessive noise from the fireworks.
 
ROFLOL - I can just see the police coming over - Gave you a great opportunity to explain to them that if he kept his dog at home you would not have had to resort to such drastic measures!!! Some folks DO NOT GET IT. THEY ARE THE PROBLEM.
 
Although I'm pro-ecollar, I'm against e-fences. They keep dogs out of their yards if they break out through, and they don't keep strange dogs out.
I agree there,but the op isn't complaining about the actions or trespass of other dogs.
Truth be told my first response thought for the op is "build a fence".The e fence is the low buck temporary solution to the problem described.
Without knowing the size of the property,suggesting to just build a fence could be a $1,000 or $30,000 or more.
So,DobieMommy86...what are we talking here?A quarter acre?An acre?20 acres?
Maybe if you're on a rather large patch,building say a quarter acre fenced off area that ties into the house is a compromise solution?
 
Gel you can buy a kennel 10 X 10 for $250.00 to $300.00 dollars in case you had not thought of that option probably about the same as an e fence- Dogs should not be tied and left outside period.
 
Gel you can buy a kennel 10 X 10 for $250.00 to $300.00 dollars in case you had not thought of that option probably about the same as an e fence- Dogs should not be tied and left outside period.
They can't run or exercise at all in a 10x10 though.
When we bought our home it had a 10x20 "dog run" chain linked area with a cement pad for a dog house.I ripped that sucker down,why have a dog if its kept in a cage at the far corner of a yard?
That just creates a frustrated dog with separation issues.
I guess people can do what they think is best for their situation.
Here,we have a fenced back yard and a dog door(s).They can go outside when they want or need to.I can slide the divider on the doors to restrict them from an area if needed.It works here.
 
When we bought our home it had a 10x20 "dog run" chain linked area with a cement pad for a dog house.I ripped that sucker down,why have a dog if its kept in a cage at the far corner of a yard?

I feel it is a better option than chaining them - they can't run and exercise there either but at least they have a place that can be used when needed. Neither option is ideal but the kennel is a far better option for me than a chain especially when the dog continues to break the collar. However, now that he has learned he can escape he will be far more determined.

They need tons of human contact, socialization, going places and training ............that is the best option
 
We put up a small fence out of the woven wire and t-posts. They're very inexpensive (maybe $75) and it will give you a good 25 x 25' area for them to stretch their legs.
This is our and we seldom use it anymore since they're e-collar trained and we have lots of land, but it's much better than tying them out. It's the front fence and the back one is just our garden.
Fence and garden from br.webp

And you're very correct that it would be very dangerous to tie her to a choke collar.
 
I have an e fence. Works great, I guess it doesn't keep other dogs out, but I have never had an issue with other dogs......ever.
 
It only takes once. A squirrel and your dog runs through it and there is a car - the rest is history and everyone wonders how it happened.
 
I understand. I had a pair of deer run by this morning and she never moved. Every dog is different tho, and every yard and area is different too
 
I understand. I had a pair of deer run by this morning and she never moved. Every dog is different tho, and every yard and area is different too
That's when Della goes deaf on us. She has a wonderful recall, but if a squirrel, fox or something else come through she's obsessed. That's where the e-collar comes in handy with her. Albert respects it after a couple good zaps trying to bolt down the driveway after heavy equipment coming by so now he knows his circumference and stays within it. I've only had to use it twice since last spring when he was trained for it and it saved his life both times.
 
Although I'm pro-ecollar, I'm against e-fences. They keep dogs out of their yards if they break out through, and they don't keep strange dogs out.
If you train them properly they won't go outside of the fence. If you are worried about strange dogs, then I would suggest that you just walk your dog rather than use the runner or tie out. The tie out doesn't keep strange dogs out either.
 

Back
Top