• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Hello Am A Newbie And Need Help

Please stop posting publicly if you feel the need to provide "a better understanding of why your suggestion was not correct." PM's are designed for this purpose. By posing publicly you are just trying to scream louder that you're right.

Ps. I don't think you are correct but until now I was not calling you out publicly.
 
She is showing you either fear or disrespect and each of those will require very different responses. This is why we recommend getting a trainer to observe it in person and help you. The Internet doesn't allow us to see the subtleties that clue us into what is really going on.

Amen, much of animal behavior is best interpreted through observation and sometimes can only be noticed by a professional.

We use the NILIF method with much success. It is one of the best things I have done with my dogs. It also teaches them to look to you for everything. In a Doberman, this is especially important as you don't want to put them into a position where they think they have to lead because you aren't.

I am on the find a professional behaviorist bandwagon. I would not try to handle this as a novice if it is aggression.
 
So sorry to hear that you are having trouble with your girl. It almost sounds like she is reacting out of fear. Once she feels she is cornered she has no escape and then she has to defend herself. I am not sure how you would correct that, perhaps time alone as she becomes more familiar and trusting, but with children at the house I don't know if I would be willing to wait and see, nor would I be willing to try standing up to her or dominating her if that's the case. One of my other previous dogs was a stray, not a Doberman, and she had problems with strangers and being backed into a corner. She never bared her teeth, but you could tell she was definitely getting nervous, nervous tail wagging, licking her lips more, head lowered and no eye contact. I had no way of finding out a history on her, she was always a submissive dog. We took a lot of time with training her and building her trust and she got somewhat better over time, but always was nervous around strangers. I would definitely look into a trainer to help you solve this. In the meantime as stated NILIF. This may help you build more of a bond with her.
 
What's it going to hurt trying positive association techniques like giving the dog bacon to redirect snarling?

Do you really think the dog is going to associate that snarling = treats that quickly?

This is an old dog with an unknown history in a new environment. It's still feeling out the family structure. Instant gratification items like bacon, turkey, beef jerkey aren't likely what this dog is expecting to receive when they snarl. They put the dog at a decision point to either continue snarling or accept the treat.
 
We dont have to worry about the mailman we live in the country and the box is by the drive. I will try to check out Moberly Thanks and Columbia is about 30 min from there Me bout hr and a hslf.
 
What's it going to hurt trying positive association techniques like giving the dog bacon to redirect snarling?

Do you really think the dog is going to associate that snarling = treats that quickly?

This is an old dog with an unknown history in a new environment. It's still feeling out the family structure. Instant gratification items like bacon, turkey, beef jerkey aren't likely what this dog is expecting to receive when they snarl. They put the dog at a decision point to either continue snarling or accept the treat.
2 aint that old.
 
Please stop posting publicly if you feel the need to provide "a better understanding of why your suggestion was not correct." PM's are designed for this purpose. By posing publicly you are just trying to scream louder that you're right.

Ps. I don't think you are correct but until now I was not calling you out publicly.
I'm sorry that you didn't like the response but that kind of explanation is helpful to the public as it explains the alternative view to someone that may not understand. You are always welcome to respond, respectfully, with your own explanation as to why you think your method is appropriate.

What's it going to hurt trying positive association techniques like giving the dog bacon to redirect snarling?

Do you really think the dog is going to associate that snarling = treats that quickly?

This is an old dog with an unknown history in a new environment. It's still feeling out the family structure. Instant gratification items like bacon, turkey, beef jerkey aren't likely what this dog is expecting to receive when they snarl. They put the dog at a decision point to either continue snarling or accept the treat.
Because, just like petting a dog that is fearful, you are rewarding a bad behavior. Now if you could get the dog to do an alternative action like sit or down and then treat it could work as a redirect. However, just offering a treat to a dog with bared teeth would just teach her that this behavior means she gets a reward thus making the behavior worse. And yes, they will learn it that quickly. It only takes once for them to think of trying it again. When they try it again and get rewarded again they'll be motivated to keep trying.
 
Try it and see what happens. You never know. If shes doing it because of fear this could be exactly what's needed. If she doing it out of aggression it's a different issue. You'll know right away if the bacon works or not.

BTW if it is pure aggression what others have suggested is something you should look into. Having kids and a dog that's showing aggression are not a good mix.
 
Now if you could get the dog to do an alternative action like sit or down and then treat it could work as a redirect. However, just offering a treat to a dog with bared teeth would just teach her that this behavior means she gets a reward thus making the behavior worse. And yes, they will learn it that quickly. It only takes once for them to think of trying it again. When they try it again and get rewarded again they'll be motivated to keep trying.

This is reasonable. Next time the dog snarls tell her to sit, down, whatever and then provide a treat. It makes a lot of sense. This way you're redirecting and reinforcing a positive action.
 
If shes doing it because of fear this could be exactly what's needed.
Most dogs acting out in fear will not accept a treat offering. I have to agree that treating a dog while it's baring its teeth at me seems to suggest to the dog, "good doggie". Perhaps a 'switch in mind set' with just the scent of a treat? Never showing it but having it on you would possibly change up the attitude?



Because, just like petting a dog that is fearful, you are rewarding a bad behavior. Now if you could get the dog to do an alternative action like sit or down and then treat it could work as a redirect. However, just offering a treat to a dog with bared teeth would just teach her that this behavior means she gets a reward thus making the behavior worse. And yes, they will learn it that quickly. It only takes once for them to think of trying it again. When they try it again and get rewarded again they'll be motivated to keep trying.
Totally agree with this. :)
 
Try it and see what happens. You never know. If shes doing it because of fear this could be exactly what's needed. If she doing it out of aggression it's a different issue. You'll know right away if the bacon works or not.
I am going to have to highly disagree. This is a tenuous situation and a "try and see approach" is not appropriate with something like this. Especially if the person is not experienced in dog behavior/training and cannot read the dog to properly evaluate the situation for what is really going on. (No offense to the OP, we don't know your background or experience.) If they give the dog a treat to try to get them to simply stop snarling they are rewarding the behavior, plain and simple. Whether that is out of true aggression or out of fear, that approach is totally inappropriate and will only exacerbate the problem, not solve it.
 
Whatever you choose to do it sounds like there's several options available.

Inquiring minds want to know... :-)

Keep this thread updated on what you decide to do and how it turns out.
 
Try it and see what happens. You never know.

Jess has said things much better than I but the point is unless you are willing to pay the medical bills and other bills should someone get seriously hurt by trying something on a whim then a little caution is a good thing. The situations you posted were not even relevant to the discussion as it is pet forms where people were complaining about outsiders giving their dogs treat. And even that can be dangerous. The owner needs to be present so they can direct the situation and makes sure it goes well. I would never recommend anyone give a dog a treat in their yard without the owner present and in control. If it is a policy by then entire postal and UPS service it is not a good policy except for those dogs who meet them with the owner present.

We don't need any more "dog attacks" or people bitten who did not use proper caution around new dogs. We certainly don't need a dog biting their new owner. Thank goodness the OP seems to recognize that it is not the way to go. They have done right by seeking advice and finding a trainer now is the best advice they can get. If you read what I wrote it was to protect you as much as the OP. I would hate to see someone who misunderstood the situation get sued when it could have been avoided.

A PM would not have saved the OP from trying something that would get them into trouble then others come and read and they get into trouble.
 
See if this club will work. It's an AKC club for all breed and I think may be the closest near you. It's not unusual to drive up to 2 hrs for training. Especially if it's only a short term thing and there is nothing else available in the area.
I second practicing Nothing in Life is Free. http://k9deb.com/nilif.htm NILIF is a part of our dog's daily lives and makes things so much easier as there is structure and the dogs pay attention to me, "what's next, ma?" I also recommend if she eats up against a wall, that to be sure she is not eating in a corner, rather move her bowl into the middle of a room while you work through this. You especially don't want her feeling uneasy while she eats. From experience, fixing food behavior issues are not fun! No treats for growling, you are correct...very confusing. Be sure not to totally avoid her when she's in a corner because you don't want to be uneasy about it but maybe try and announce to her that you are walking by so she can be aware the location of someone coming near.

I think implementing NILIF will help by providing structure, obedience and leadership. Give it time and be consistent. :) It would also be a good idea to rule out any eye sight issues with the vet.
People really need to know what they are talking about. I feel so bad we just tried to get ahold of Connie Haley she passed away 4 YRS AGO
 
People really need to know what they are talking about. I feel so bad we just tried to get ahold of Connie Haley she passed away 4 YRS AGO

I'm sorry to hear. Not something I could have possibly known as that is the information that is currently supplied on the AKC website for clubs in MO. I hope Columbia works out for you...
 

Back
Top