• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Gentle Leader head collar

Isa's Mom

Member
Has anybody had any trouble using the Gentle Leader head collar with their Dober-puppies? Mine is six months old and I'm just concerned about how tight the neck/head piece has to be to keep it from slipping. Her "Adam's apple" seems kind of high and I'm wondering if the collar hurts her. She's been making this grunty breathing sound with it on, but it may be her initial dislike of it...? Any thoughts? It works like a DREAM to keep her from pulling, but I don't want it to be at the expense of her safety.
 
They actually aren't recommended with Doberman's because they can pull the head in an unnatural position and damage their neck.

If she's 6 months you could probably try a prong, which is one of the safer training collars when used correctly. :) There are quite a few threads on how to use them correctly, but I don't have time to dig them up right now since I have to get back to work. ;)
 
I strongly recommend simply teaching the dog to follow you respectfully instead of jumping to physical restraining devices like leaders, prong collars or e-collars. They are lots of great videos on loose leash walk training on you-tube.

Your dog should be walking well on a lead long before they get to 9 months or older. The training is the same regardless so it's never too late to start.:)
 
I strongly recommend simply teaching the dog to follow you respectfully instead of jumping to physical restraining devices like leaders, prong collars or e-collars. They are lots of great videos on loose leash walk training on you-tube.

Your dog should be walking well on a lead long before they get to 9 months or older. The training is the same regardless so it's never too late to start.:)
I agree.However,for some strong willed dogs(like mine;)) no method I tried worked.The prong collar made it like leashing up a different dog.
I for one would be grateful for a trainer such as yourself to post a thread with some methods.:thumbsup:
 
I for one would be grateful for a trainer such as yourself to post a thread with some methods.

Thanks for the support. I just got a Go Pro to try to do some small videos. :dance: We'll see what I can do with it when I get the head mount thing. Not sure it will be steady enough but I'll give it a go!

I tried with my regular camera still mounted but it didn't work well enough...no motion, small work area and you couldn't always see the exact expressions I was seeing from a little different angle. A lot of set up and placement work for 1 person. I got frustrated when important things were happening just outside of the camera range...:stomp:

There are already a number of decent training videos on youtube with one still camera. They are a great start but fall short at times by not showing what I consider phase 2-the training beyond calm, quiet and no distractions. It's where I've found owners need the most support because it can go from good fun and progress to seeming to fall apart with distractions of the real world. I'd like to show and indicate with elapsed time how long some training takes with different dogs and show mistakes (including my own) and how to correct and reset the walk/training.

Does this make sense? A loaded question I know!
 
Thanks for the support. I just got a Go Pro to try to do some small videos. :dance: We'll see what I can do with it when I get the head mount thing. Not sure it will be steady enough but I'll give it a go!

I tried with my regular camera still mounted but it didn't work well enough...no motion, small work area and you couldn't always see the exact expressions I was seeing from a little different angle. A lot of set up and placement work for 1 person. I got frustrated when important things were happening just outside of the camera range...:stomp:

There are already a number of decent training videos on youtube with one still camera. They are a great start but fall short at times by not showing what I consider phase 2-the training beyond calm, quiet and no distractions. It's where I've found owners need the most support because it can go from good fun and progress to seeming to fall apart with distractions of the real world. I'd like to show and indicate with elapsed time how long some training takes with different dogs and show mistakes (including my own) and how to correct and reset the walk/training.

Does this make sense? A loaded question I know!
Sure it makes sense.Looking forward to watching you do your thing:)
 
The Gentle Leader is a piece of junk in my opinion. Halters are for horses. So are harnesses. The head collar is not good for Dobermans' necks that have the potential of spinal damage. The Leader is also quite unsafe if not used with a back-up collar. The Halti and Gentle Leader come with safety jumpers that allow you to actually have a leash on your dog if the halter comes off, but I doubt the average user connects the GL or Halti to a real collar. The same safety advice goes for prong collars. I can't think of a training collar that doesn't require backup.
 
I always advocate a short chain or connector from the lead to the collar whenever you use any kind of training devices. It not only makes the exercise much safer, it boosts owner confidence immediately.
 
Well, I will dissent - I like head halters, when used properly. They can be a great tool. There is actually NO evidence that there is any risk in using one in this breed. It's a popular myth, though. I actually prefer the Comfort Trainer (Comfort Trainer Head Halter, Stop Dog Pulling!). I think they fit a Dobe head a bit better and are more comfortable for them. I personally prefer to use a head halter rather than a prong. Of course, it is a tool - you still need to teach the dog loose leash walking, but a head halter helps give you control, especially with a strong dog. There are great videos on teaching loose leash walking on Kikopup's Youtube channel: kikopup - YouTube

Feel free to message me if you'd like to talk about head halters.
 
Just my personal opinion;), too much too soon, puppies necks should be treat gently, no halters or prongs until after one year old, treating the neck gently when they are young makes them more sensitive and a lot less likely to pull, if I put Buddy on a collar and leash he walk like a little gentleman and has done for the last twelve months, just be careful not to de-sensitize the neck until they have grown and settled down a bit.
 
I strongly dislike Gentle Leaders, Haltis, and a couple of the other brands available here in the US. The problem with them is that they don't fit correctly and, as such, can cause damage to your dog's eyes, muzzle, and neck. I have see it personally; I will see if I can dig up one of the articles out there with pictures of the damage.

On top if the potential damage, they always have some amount of weight on them, always some pressure that the dog has to pull against. The Comfort Trainer like MeadowCat mentioned is a much better designed one because it's very lightweight, a type of material that is less likely to cause physical damage, and hard to fit improperly -- although that is possible for anything. If you must you a head collar that clip under the chin, use this one. There are definitely some uses for them.

With that said, I much prefer the head collars that clip behind the head if there isn't a specific reason to use an under-the-chin one. These generally fit more loosely, don't rub as much, and aren't in a constant state of correction (always applying weight on the dog's face). I've found dogs to be more accepting if them as well. Many of them corret by pulling the dog's nose down instead of the head to the side, and as a result, some of them can safely be used with leash corrections (do long as you're not too harsh, of course).

I will get a list of the behind-the-head ones for you later. I'm on my phone right now and am having trouble doing links.
 

Back
Top