Furthering my knowledge

NamVetJoe

Active Member
I have seen pictures of dogs with both an e collar and prong collar on for training my question is which is placed up close to the ears? Or does it matter?
 
Both of those types of collars should be as high up on the neck as possible for them to work with the correct effect.

A prong that is too loose and hanging can do more harm than good and an e-collar won't work correctly if it's loose and lower on the neck.
 
I have seen pictures of dogs with both an e collar and prong collar on for training my question is which is placed up close to the ears? Or does it matter?

As @JanS said, both should be as high up as possible. I prefer the prong first behind the ears and the ecollar second just because I get more ease of use out of the prong and it doesn’t slip too far down as easily when in-between prong sizes. Since dobie necks tend to be dramatically more slender at the top than most dogs, I find it also helps to have a thicker flat buckle collar behind those two tools to keep them up. But all that hardware can get cumbersome sometimes lol.
 
I prefer the prong first behind the ears and the ecollar second just because I get more ease of use out of the prong and it doesn’t slip too far down as easily when in-between prong sizes

I swapped back and forth a few times...and came to the conclusion prong on top....then E collar.
 
With the Trainers I worked with, I was taught to put the prong just behind the ears and then the ecollar just below the prong when using both in the early stages of training. This is for both dog safety and proper use.
 
E collar is high up on the neck. Its good to adjust and train your dog based on an equal reaction to the stim and prong snap.
 
Prong on top for us so it doesn't get caught up on the ecollar when making corrections. Ecollar under that, also high on the neck. With a properly fitted prong, it shouldn't slide down the neck and run into the ecollar that is underneath.
 
Oops, I misread and you thought you meant individually. Yes with both I would put the prong on top closest to the ears.
 
Hi Guys! Very new here. I get Achilles in three weeks roughly right at 8 weeks. Is prong collar and e collar essential for dobie training. I am a first time Dobie owner
 
I feel like prong and e collar is essential for any medium to large size dog. As long as you know what youre doing, all youre creating is a leash that is 1500 feet long. Put the e collar on right away for training but dont use any function besides tone the same way youd use a clicker. This helps get the dog used to it. If you plan on doing some high level training, these tools help you skip alot of useless bullshit. You can train a dog without em, but they make it sooo much easier to communicate your expectations. Dogs enjoy learning, a balance of correction and positive reinforcement (specifically drive focused games) help your dog "learn to learn".
 
Skatchkeb thank you so much I am going to purchase both. I just don't want horror stories that i have been seeing on here. I know mistakes will come but i want to have the knowledge to correct it and move on and bond with Achilles.
 
At 11 weeks your dogs is not too old for an e collar and a prong collar. I have em on them at 8 weeks. Theres prong collars for small dogs. I have been training dogs for decades though, so obviously if youre not experienced you shouldnt be USING them at this point, but its perfectly acceptable to be using an e collar tone for clicker training and get them used to having it on.
 
Screenshot_20200129-124429_Instagram.webp Tank was pronged up pretty much a week after I got him at 6 weeks. And e collared a week later. He does trick routines in front of fire work finales and plays tennis ball in rainstorms. Im a big fan of Bill Koehler, a man who most modern dog people would condem. I tend to do things in a way that make obedient, hardy dogs, and I watch for certain events that could lead to behavioral problems and correct or resolve them as fast as i can. MOST people shouldnt do this for obvious reasons.
 
I went from flat collar (freight train pulling ) to so-called no-pull harness Freight train with occasional stops. Then to prong collar which made a world of difference. BTW Bill Koehler is definitely someone to investigate if you want to get some real-life information
 
Agreed. Ecollar should be high and tight, about a finger and a half should fit between the collar. Prong should sit just loose enough that a light snap is effective, not tight and not too loose that it takes alot of wrist movement, and a harness.
 
Neither a prong collar or e-collar should be used until they're at least 6 months old. Before that they're really babies and can't understand what we're asking of them and harsh correction isn't the right answer while they're still trying to learn so much.
I'm not saying either of those methods are harsh but puppies aren't ready for them yet.
 

Back
Top