• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Excessive Whining... In Trouble lol

You're doing great. I shouldn't have written that hopefully you can tire him out. You are clearly already doing a lot! More than I am!

Yes, I totally understand the challenges of trying to work a dog in Schutzhund/IPO. The monetary cost and all the driving involved are the reasons I don't do it. That, and I have always done my own training and would not take well to having someone tell me how to train my Dobe.

Here's just a thought I had as I was washing dishes: Even though it seems like you love your Dobe and are quite committed to making it all work, would you consider letting him go to another home/situation? OF COURSE I don't mean just any average home. I am wondering if your IPO trainer friend would know of anyone who is big into the sport, or even if any nearby police force would want to use him. Of course, he would have to prove via your experienced trainer that he has what it takes first. Just one idea, so I hope you are not offended by the thought.

I am absolutely not opposed to that idea and no offence is taken. In fact, I was just talking to my friend about this. I have never rehomed an animal before, as I'm the type to make it work even if that means 4 hours of sleep for me. I'm stubborn and part of me says "He is your dog, be responsible and fix the problem" but I definitely feel I'm limited in providing his maximum potential. My heart is what is stopping me... I would feel guilty forever.
 
32A4E4FB-EA9D-4C2C-9917-B4858D381EDA.webp I use CANINABIS - HEMP FOR PETS - LIQUID DROPS 600MG/ 60 ML

It knocks Rex the F out and helps with days I can’t properlu exercise him. He usually ends up as pictured above writhing 30-45 minutes of taking it. However when I board Rex when I go on vacation, the person I board him with uses this
Barkless Dog Collar | Barkless Pro Anit Bark Collar - E-Collar Technologies

He whines when crated their and won’t stop regardless of how long he is in the crate. Similar to your problem (he doesn’t do it when he’s at home or when he’s crates by me or mom) She uses that on him and he stops whining. Just a suggestion.
 
I think the whining can be more of a thing with this breed and it sounds like you've tried a lot of approaches. I can't believe they actually kicked you out of a training class because if it though. A good trainer would try to offer suggestions to help with it instead of sending you on your way.
I wonder if that would help settle them for nail trimming time? Della is good about it but Albert keeps jerking his feet so it makes it hard to do a good job. Only problem is that ours sleep almost all the time when they're not eating or playing so I don't think I'd want them to sleep much more because of it. LOL
 
His whining is LOUD when in public. Could be an insecurity thing, but extremely disruptive regardless. Trainer had to yell over him cause no one could hear lol

I tried a PetSafe collar I believe it was called.

I gave him some CBD Oil today: HE HAS NEVER BEEN THIS CALM AND QUIET BEFORE GUYS!! He is napping?! Did I give him too much? He doesn't seem "sedated"... He was chewing on his Benebone for about 20 minutes and played with my cat, now he is sleeping. THIS HAS NEVER HAPPENED! I don't know if I am worried or happy! LOL
 
I think the whining can be more of a thing with this breed and it sounds like you've tried a lot of approaches. I can't believe they actually kicked you out of a training class because if it though. A good trainer would try to offer suggestions to help with it instead of sending you on your way.

I wonder if that would help settle them for nail trimming time? Della is good about it but Albert keeps jerking his feet so it makes it hard to do a good job. Only problem is that ours sleep almost all the time when they're not eating or playing so I don't think I'd want them to sleep much more because of it. LOL


LOL it might help. However, it doesn’t help when applying anything to Rex. He got a scrape on his leg from missing the door on my truck and crashing into the side panel and hitting the the steps for the cab. When I apply his anti septic he still fights me -_-
 
His whining is LOUD when in public. Could be an insecurity thing, but extremely disruptive regardless.

I tried a PetSafe collar I believe it was called.

I gave him some CBD Oil today: HE HAS NEVER BEEN THIS CALM AND QUIET BEFORE GUYS!! He is napping?! Did I give him too much? He doesn't seem "sedated"... He was chewing on his Benebone for about 20 minutes and played with my cat, now he is sleeping. THIS HAS NEVER HAPPENED! I don't know if I am worried or happy! LOL

I think you’d be better off getting a collar from e collar and learning to use it for corrections. Rex whines in public at times and I correct him with his e collar and it stops it. I also suggest getting that bark collar by e collar. The pet safe collars are a piece of junk in comparison to e collar technologies. I think That’s why it didn’t work in correcting the barking.

The CBD oil and the outcome you described is normal.
 
I think you’d be better off getting a collar from e collar and learning to use it for corrections. Rex whines in public at times and I correct him with his e collar and it stops it. I also suggest getting that bark collar by e collar. The pet safe collars are a piece of junk in comparison to e collar technologies. I think That’s why it didn’t work in correcting the barking.

The CBD oil and the outcome you described is normal.

Oh really? I was highly recommended PetSafe from peers around me who have large working dogs!
 
I haven't heard of NILIF? I did a quick search on it, but unsure if I implement this.
Since you mentioned IPO, I made an assumption that you've done working dog training, but...was it positive reinforcement only?

You haven't heard of the term NILIF? But you recognize the concept right? That when your dog has to work for everything he gets. Is he laying in your bed or are you on the floor with him?

What are your thoughts on him just being spoiled?
 
His whining is LOUD when in public. Could be an insecurity thing, but extremely disruptive regardless. Trainer had to yell over him cause no one could hear lol
Oh yes! Oji's whining can hurt my ears! Actually, just yesterday as my daughter and were walking up our street we stopped about two houses away as we discussed where she might hide so we could have Oji find her. From that distance I heard the distinct sound of Oji whining from within our shut house.
 
I gave him some CBD Oil today: HE HAS NEVER BEEN THIS CALM AND QUIET BEFORE GUYS!! He is napping?! Did I give him too much? He doesn't seem "sedated"... He was chewing on his Benebone for about 20 minutes and played with my cat, now he is sleeping. THIS HAS NEVER HAPPENED! I don't know if I am worried or happy!
I think you might have found your solution then so I would be happy. I'm guessing anxiety might be part of the cause of the excessive whining and the oil must sort of take that edge off to allow him to relax and realize he doesn't have to whine all the time.
 
I think the reason why you weren’t seeing results at the highest setting with the PetSmart ecollar is because it’s not a quality ecollar. The Educator (formerly Einstein) by E Collar Technologies is a great one. Reasonably priced and not overly complex like some of the hunting ones. But with that being said, I would not use it if this is a true anxiety issue. That I think would be cruel. It would be like me zapping my Princess for her excessive panting/shaking when there is a thunderstorm. I know it’s aniexty and I ignore it. Now is she was going on barking at a dog behind a fence or a squirrel up a tree. Then yes she needs a correction.

Glad he is responding to the CBD Oil.
 
I am absolutely shocked guys, he literally got the minimum dosage for his weight and he has been so calm and quiet the entire day. He was sleeping a lot at first, like napping, maybe it's because he is finally calm from being so anxious all the time? After his naps, he is still curious and keeps himself busy with all the chews and Kongs. He hasn't whined at all. We went for our regular walk and training, he was still excited for that which was really good.

He's a whole new dog right now lol I haven't left him unattended or in the crate yet as I wanted to keep an eye on him (Luckily I'm off work 3 days) on his response, but so far I'm relieved. My house has not been this quiet in months - my ears are ringing of his whining lol.
 
Wow. I am surprised to hear of this apparently severe whining problem! I will have more time to try to offer my thoughts on this tomorrow morning, @ArdynBane

In the meantime as I sleep and you over there in Australia are awake, @jazzies mum , what is "whinging?" :spit:
Definition of whinging:- grizzling, whining, an annoying continuous sound likely to drive you nuts! Picture the 2yo child who wants something his mom won't give him, and you get whinging. Sort of sounds like it comes through the nose and Just Won't Stop!!!!! :pullhair:

@ArdynBane So glad you have found a solution! :woot:
 
Definition of whinging:- grizzling, whining, an annoying continuous sound likely to drive you nuts! Picture the 2yo child who wants something his mom won't give him, and you get whinging. Sort of sounds like it comes through the nose and Just Won't Stop!!!!! :pullhair:

@ArdynBane So glad you have found a solution! :woot:

He is still a nervous wreck in his crate LOL But I tried putting him in the crate after 6 hours of the CBD oil. At least he isn't whining when he is out of crate!
 
He is still a nervous wreck in his crate LOL But I tried putting him in the crate after 6 hours of the CBD oil. At least he isn't whining when he is out of crate!

Out of curiosity what type of crate do you have?

Rex was never super fond of his old wire crates, he’d go in after coaxing but never was really fond of them. I just recently got him a new crate and he really likes it. Even will sit in front of the door till I open it so he can nap and he views it as “this is mine”. He gets upset if I move it or start tinkering with it lol.
 

Back
Top