• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Excessive Whining... In Trouble lol

ArdynBane

Notable member
Hello my Doberman-Family!

This will be a long post, but please bear with me...
I have an 8 month old puppy, 2 weeks shy of 9 months. Ever since I got him, he has been a HUGE whiner, and I am going to say excessive at this point. He whines literally non-stop and it's gone to the point I have received complaints from my neighbours, friend's roommates attempting to "ban" me from their home, kicked out from group obedience class (Although there's more to this, but his whining was incredibly "disruptive" and I was asked to leave) and melting my brain. He literally whines all the time, whether he is standing and staring at me whining or lying down watching TV with me.

Here are the things I have tried:
-Ignoring: He will whine for HOURS on end, even if I ignore. I have ignored literally moment I got him at 3 months, so clearly 5 months later it isn't doing anything. He will never stop whining and my neighbours complain.
-Exercise and mental stimulation:
  • Exercise and training sessions morning, brief in afternoon during my break if I am at work, and an evening exercise and training session. If I am off work, he literally takes up my entire day with training and outside time (Go to a park and hang out there, etc.)
  • He has a chew toy that he loves and his Kong to keep him busy, but it really only lasts maybe 20-30 minutes
  • We currently take private lessons for Obedience and we do incorporate tug training, which he absolutely loves. Even if we are training for 1-2 hours, it does not tire him out physically or mentally and we learn maybe 3-4 different new things each time.
-Negative Attention: I know this isn't ideal, but after HOURS of whining, especially at night time, I will give him negative attention... Whether that be telling him "Quiet!" or making a loud noise close to him that he does not like. The result? He will whine even quieter, but still whining lol Eventually increasing volume as I continue to go back to ignoring. I know this is probably still giving him "attention", but I tried giving him a negative association of constant whining.

I really don't know what else I can do to train him out of the whining. He has things to do in my house which only stimulates him for like half an hour, he does get trained at lest 2x a day, see a private trainer and we learn many new things per lessons (Hope to do Schutzhund/IPO once my situation is figured out), but I really can't deal with this anymore. As mentioned above, his whining has become so excessive, I can't bring him anymore, I can't sleep and my neighbours are pissed, can't gather with friends with my dog due to complaints, and so forth. I have tried EVERYTHING?

His whining is loud, if I get mad (It's really hard not to be mad at this rate anymore), he will just whine quietly. It's worse when he is crated, as he absolutely hates being crated (He was an import and we assume something happened as he will hurt himself till he bleeds and he has escaped a crate before).

He is not my first dog or my first Doberman, so I know they are a demanding, vocal, and an intelligent breed, but I really am at my whits end with this pup! I know he is still young, almost 9 months, but this has been CONSTANT since he was 3 months when I got him and I personally don't think this excessive whining is normal. Yes, he also whines this badly when I leave my house!

He only stops whining when he is sleeping, otherwise, he is whining NONSTOP! My trainer who is also a breeder says he thinks his temperament is just "poorly bred" or specifically "bad nerve." But with being kicked out of group obedience classes, neighbours complaining, and now having a hard time seeing friends (their roommates), I am so lost on what else I can do.
 
Wow, poor you! That whining and whinging is probably one of the least attractive things about a Dobe. Most will only do it for a specific purpose, and not non stop. Do you think it is anxiety? If it isn't fear or anxiety related and he is just acting out because he knows it pulls your strings maybe you could try a spray bottle to reinforce your wish for quiet. And IMHO quiet whining is still whining, and it is likely if you settle for the under the breath whinge he won't get the message, "no whining". But I know you are very familiar with Dobermans and have probably tried many methods. Hopefully someone else will have that one thing that will work for your boy.
 
Wow, poor you! That whining and whinging is probably one of the least attractive things about a Dobe. Most will only do it for a specific purpose, and not non stop. Do you think it is anxiety? If it isn't fear or anxiety related and he is just acting out because he knows it pulls your strings maybe you could try a spray bottle to reinforce your wish for quiet.

I personally feel the fact he cannot be crated is definitely anxiety or trauma, because how he behaves is really not normal. He is doing better now, but the whining never stopped... He used to barkk excessively (Example, bark bark bark bark bark no break in between!!!!) the WHOLE night and although terrible, I had to let him out when I have neighbours banging on the door threatening to call the cops at 4am in the morning...

I don't know if it is anxiety if he is whining while I am physically with him, especially if we are doing something like training. He is just always whining? I can be walking him, and he will whine. We will be training and I am praising him for doing the command correctly, he whines again after praise and treats, even tug. Like seriously, why?! He has a clean bill of health so it isn't medical. Even if I am with him, could he be anxious? I really see no reason... So frustrating! 5 months of this lol
 
Wow. I am surprised to hear of this apparently severe whining problem! I will have more time to try to offer my thoughts on this tomorrow morning, @ArdynBane

In the meantime as I sleep and you over there in Australia are awake, @jazzies mum , what is "whinging?" :spit:
 
Is that a Euro?

Is there a smaller room you can put him in for the meantime? I absolutely hate their whining and I regularly joke about it, but this is just crazy.

What type of trainer are you using? All whining is to be ignored, and it sounds like you've done that, but think hard, is it possible that you reinforced this? Even if inadvertently? Coddled? Encouraged?
 
Is that a Euro?

Is there a smaller room you can put him in for the meantime? I absolutely hate their whining and I regularly joke about it, but this is just crazy.

What type of trainer are you using? All whining is to be ignored, and it sounds like you've done that, but think hard, is it possible that you reinforced this? Even if inadvertently? Coddled? Encouraged?

Yes, he is a Euro. I personally imported him from Europe from a shady "breeder" that I found out about her practices a few months after getting him. He was behaviourally a mess moment I got him, but the whining has got so much worse.

My trainer is semi-retired, but he competed and trained his dogs in Schutzhund/IPO, Obedience, and Agility. His credentials are phenomenal and his students are all competitive in sports.

I really am trying to think, but I personally don't think I could have coddled him? I am not new to dog ownership, or owning a Doberman, so I knew very well from the beginning to "cry it out." I have had to give in a couple times, like his crate training and excessive barking, but that was because I couldn't risk getting more complaints and having pissed off neighbours yelling at your door at 4am was more than enough reason for me to give in and let him out of his crate... Could this contribute to his constant whining? Even now, I am still ignoring, negative attention, seeking help... but no improvements and I can't keep let him doing this. :( It's so stressful right now.
 
You stated he prob had behavioral issues when you first got him with some anxiety stuff. Moving towards that train of thought, it sounds like he uses his whining as a self soothing mechanism. In adults, people self sooth by slightly rocking back/forth and/or low humming-singing.

Or like mine, he is just bored and wants attention.

Mine does not whine often and I tried ignoring him but that did not work. A negative stimulus, with a negative verbal tone given works with mine. But if this is done for more of an anxiety/psych issue, then I believe it would only compound it and increase uncertainty and fear. He needs to have a sense of calm and confidence and build from there.

My 2cents.
Good Luck.

Edit: Or can you correlate it to his feeding?? Really stabbing here now... think he may have a longstanding tummy ache or some lingering physical injury??
 
Boy, I haven't heard of such a severe whining problem before. You have my sympathies! It sounds like you got him at between 3 and 4 months (I see you wrote 3 months).

Does he even whine while occupied with a Kong?

My overall guess is that, well, what your trainer said. No offense, but his breeding (and I'm not condemning his breeding, breeder or lines necessarily, but even with "good" breeding one can never really know exactly what type of dog is going to result) has just resulted in an extremely whiny Dobe. I wonder if the breeder has not taken into account temperament enough. He may be a very high-drive Dobe – with some drives very high, and other qualities that make a livable dog less prevalent.

Do you have access to a copy of his pedigree? I understand if you don't want to share, but it might give you some insights. It's always possible there is too much inbreeding in there.

My first Doberman was from a sort of hobby breeder. He lacked some of the abilities it took to, for instance, do IPO work. He could not full-mouth bite. It was simply not in his DNA. What he did excel at was being a great pet! He was capable of a lot of stuff, and I trained him to a very high level and he was an amazing Dobe, but he was naturally good at being a pet.

My subsequent two Dobermans have been from working lines. As soon as I started to live with the one before this one, I began to see just how powerful breeding could be. In years past, I had always pretty much dismissed it when people would talk about their dogs' lines. I thought it was mostly just talk. I mean like I'd hear folks say things like "He's from hunting lines and you can really see it in him." But boy, I learned quickly about how different a Dobe from serious working lines is from a sort of hobby or whatever pet Dobe.

Of course, in talking and being interviewed by the breeder of my current boy, Oji, this breeder threw out there the fact that my previous boy's sire was one of the more inbred sires in the breed. So that Dobe of mine was a machine – full-mouth bite from young puppyhood with no training or encouragement required. He was a very cool, formidable Doberman. He also would unpredictably lash out at people, including my wife on multiple occasions. This, despite my informed, careful training from the age of about 9 weeks. In talking to the breeder about returning him (which I never could bring myself to do, despite that we now had a baby child) I was told that his littermate had to be put down for aggression.

Aside from breeding, I wonder if your Dobe spent his first about 4 months in a very loud, barky, whiny environment at the breeder's facility/home. Do you think that may be the case?

I feel ya' on the being forced to give in to your Dobe's noise making. I was forced to sleep with Oji on the dining room floor for the first few nights, or at least the first night, I forget. There was no place in our house, including the basement that he could be put to bed where his loud whining and yipping/barking could not be heard. Heck, on the 8ish hour drive home, I was exceedingly glad that I happened to have earplugs within reach in the car. Ear-piercing whining right behind me! :rp: Oji is just an extremely vocal Doberman! He vocalizes in so many situations! He goes off with wild barking when he sees another dog down the street. He blasts your ears when being left home alone. He barks when frustrated by me demanding he follow a command when he is driven to do something else. He explodes into massive barking when I shut the door and walk away. Yes, he does have separation anxiety, and the first handful of nights in our home, I could not walk out of his sight without him barking.
 
And you thought YOUR post was long, ha! Here's more from me. I hope my experiences can shed some light on your struggle:

Oji was terrible to crate train. He would poop and pee in his crate every time!! For months!! Not because he needed to go, and not because housebreaking was not going well – it was. It was like a mental breakdown when being left in the crate. Oh, and of course, bark like crazy and chew up anything left in the crate (be VERY careful about this) and try to break out of the crate, though not as severely as some dogs in terms of hardcore trying to escape.

One amazing thing about Oji is he is not a chewer of things – I mean besides anything left in his crate in the early days. So, actually, he might have done better if I had taken the risk of just leaving him loose in the house in the earlier days. Seems he is just not cut out to be crated, though he will largely accept it now. I can get into that more if you want.

He is fine to be left in the house now. Of course, he blasts your eardrums when he gets the hint that we are about to leave him home alone. With this, it's actually humorous but I actually give him the silent command as I am nearing ready to go out the door I get out the door of the house, shut the door almost all the way, perhaps plug the ear that is closest to the door, then I give him the release command and he explodes into barking. :rofl:

So, one thing I'm so very very grateful for is that I now live in a single-family dwelling. Yes, you can hear his barking loud and clear from outside and even like 1/2 a dozen houses down the street :wow: but since I'm not in an apartment or condo, I figure I'm doing all I need to do. My dog is inside my own private house with the windows and doors shut. Sorry neighbors, but that's all you can ask.

Are you in an apartment or something? Are you saying neighbors come over and knock on your door in the night due solely to his whining? Or is it barking/yipping too?
 
I’m no expert but from what you’re describing I think it’s an anxiety/ mental issue. This doesn’t sound like your typical whining Doberman thing - I have a “talker” so I know what that sounds like. I think @Ddski5 hit the nail on the head when he mentioned it might be a soothing mechanism.

So I’ll share a story with you - When I was in a puppy class with Shadow the trainer approached me after class and asked my opinion on a young Doberman she was working with. (prior to owning her training facility she was a Great Dane breeder and handler). So she brings out this young Doberman in a thunder shirt and beings to tell me what’s going on- the dog paces non-stop. She cannot get it to stop - the dog doesn’t rest/settle. She tells me her client purchased the puppy to be a service dog from a reputable breeder that has had several of her dogs become great service dogs etc. Since the client wasn’t getting anywhere in the group training classes she offered her client a board and train. And so that she can observe first hand what the owner was dealing with at home. The trainer tells me she is stumped - she’s never seen anything like it and that this is the first time where she feels that training alone will not help and is going to recommend getting calming meds/Prozac. Unfortunately I wasn’t much help - I felt bad for the dog because it clearly had something going on and it needed help.

Have you tried a thunder shirt or CBD oil? Is there a behavioralist in your area?
 
so I knew very well from the beginning to "cry it out." I have had to give in a couple times, like his crate training and excessive barking, but that was because I couldn't risk getting more complaints and having pissed off neighbours yelling at your door at 4am was more than enough reason for me to give in and let him out of his crate... Could this contribute to his constant whining?
It never occurred to me about the self soothing whining as mine does it when he's under exercised, but I think that's a real possibility in your case. I would bet that CBD oil will help you, but be sure of the quality before you buy. It should be human grade. Some of the pet grade products aren't potent enough.

How is he with suckling a blanket or his bed? Mine, also a Euro, is a blanket suckler, and he specifically targets the blanket before snoozing in the evening.

Travelling by air - Kaiser only flew to his new home for 40 minutes (or potentially double that if you include boarding time) in an airline carrier which is largely plastic. Do you have a plastic or wire crate? Maybe switch the type. We found he had a preference for wire despite that most Dobermans (from what I've heard) prefer plastic and cannot handle drafts. Do you cover the crate at all? Failing the crate, a small room would be my next attempt.
 
Yes, to boil this down to bones:

Perhaps basically a high-strung specimen of a breed that is notorious for whining. Our designer (old version of the word) purebreds are developmentally stunted to begin with.

I hope you can maybe find something that tires your Dobe out physically and mentally to a great extent, and you can find something that soothes him.

Find what is important to your particular Doberman. For Oji, it is consistency and comfort. The day he finally stopped peeing in his crate was the day warm weather finally arrived. He was hot and does not do well in warm sunshine :facepalm:. I happened to switch him back to the plastic crate and place it in the basement that was fairly dark and quite cool compared to outside. This apparently made him sufficiently content to be in the crate.
 
Thank you for all your input.

Due to a bad situation in my life, I currently live in a bachelor unit constructed from a condo. I have a fenced in yard and everything, but our space is definitely smaller than it was before (My ex and I had a house). However, he was a huge whiner prior to the move and at the house...

I tried the plastic crate at first as that was what he was flown in (It was huge for him as a 3 month old and fit in it till 5 months), but he chewed that up. I upgraded to a metal crate (Good quality one too), and he escaped that TWICE and he made his gums all bloody trying to get out. I used to cover the crate, but he would drag the covers in and chew it up, even though he has a Kong and chew toys in there... Also never left in crate without enough exercise. He chewed up his beds in the crate as well, so he just gets old blankets instead.

At one point, I was over exercising him as a puppy I was gravely worried for his growth (Luckily he is fine). Mental stimulation I am trying with his obedience training every day, and trying to build up his drive for IPO. Someone recommended Agility being great for confidence building for dogs, so I am looking into that for January (December all clubs stop for the holidays and weather). I feel he would do well with some bite work to let all that energy out and mental stimulation from all IPO training, but I personally am unable to do this right now as I lost my car from my break-up and financially in debt for a variety of reasons ($550 annual club fee, plus training and other memberships to join the club). I hope in January things will start calming down and I'll be able to take him out (Mom and grand-sire have IPO1 titles).

I don't think he "suckles" his blanket or anything, he just destroys them. He doesn't touch the blankets that are in his crate though. Hasn't chewed or "suckled" on my blanket either.

My "breeder" is extremely shady, so I really do question what he went through.

I am trying CBD Oil today, borrowed some from a friend but I don't think it's that good of quality (It's mixed with coconut oil and salmon oil). Are there any brands you recommend? I'm in Canada. I am willing to try anything at this point lol
 
Hey @Kaiser2016 you’re in Canada what brand do you use?
Ya there should not be any salmon or coconut oil, should be hemp oil.

I use Brad Pattison and luckily they sell online! I use the first one (for my tiny cat) but maybe you should spring for the second one (larger bottle).

Products

Great timing as I just tested this on Kaiser too. I gave him 8 drops. 1 drop for every 10 lbs, potentially requiring double the amount depending on the response, but you should always start on the low side and observe first. He definitely had himself a "lazy" (for a Doberman) day.

Others who give their dogs CBD, @Antman408 and I believe @Tropicalbri's but not sure if it works on her dogs.
 
Due to a bad situation in my life, I currently live in a bachelor unit constructed from a condo. I have a fenced in yard and everything, but our space is definitely smaller than it was before (My ex and I had a house). However, he was a huge whiner prior to the move and at the house...
Given this, how truly calm and relaxed are you? Not that anyone could blame you, but he must be feeling your stressed energy more than you realize. Even when you were in the house, perhaps tensions were so high that he learned to be tense or nervous as a normal state of being? Maybe he saw no established leader? Do you use NILIF? Also, I have seen members on here with previous Doberman experience dealing with a much more stubborn dog. Each dog is unique.
 
See, I think they all have a point here..... does he have anything that soothes him or calms him down?

I wonder how many times does Bane actually nap and sleep during the day? Ragnar may nap on the couch but he does not truly sleep unless he is in the crate.

In all actuality, a Doberman going into his crate is a soothing quality. It is his safe haven, his own part of the house that is his alone. Yours hates the crate.

Yours doesn’t suckle on blankets? At first I was anti-blanket sucking. I thought my badass Doberman is not sucking on any blanket! But then his butt was running me ragged and I couldn’t get him to calm down for anything. Drive me crazy in the house. Then I caught him sucking on a blanket and how calm he was so I let him be. Now, I realize that it is a immobile distraction that calms him down.

Now, I think my next train of thought goes against recommendations of just ignoring and playing tough love. But just read through and take the information as you will. I worked in pediatrics for a couple of years and dealt with a lot of children that had delayed nervous systems. So much in a way that their nervous system could not regulate to a neautrality. They were either hypersensitive and always jacked up or they were hyposensitive and just “blah” all the time. The way we treated each of these deficits was to provide sensory stimulation enough to regulate their system to normalcy. We did this through tactile and vestibular stimulation. Things like brushing their skin, putting on sit and spin or a swing, compression garments(kinda like a thunder shirt), joint compression and mobs.

What does this have to do with Bane?? As said earlier, take info as you will but I question if his nervous system is yearning for a way to calm down or handle a sort of anxiety and whining is the only thing he can control in order to do this. I tend to wonder if you brush him or put a light sweater for compression if it will help- if this is a true nervous system issue.... I know, I know- -dude, that is some way out there stuff. I can tell you that it works really good on kids and normalizes their tendencies and actions.

Something else, I know my Ragnar has a hard time calming down. Sometimes when he lays down in my lap and naps, he will slightly tremble. I think this happens when his system can’t calm enough to be calm....Weird I know, but there’s nothing else I can rationally explain.
 
Something else, I know my Ragnar has a hard time calming down. Sometimes when he lays down in my lap and naps, he will slightly tremble. I think this happens when his system can’t calm enough to be calm....Weird I know, but there’s nothing else I can rationally explain.
Same with both of mine. If Bogie doesn’t get enough full out running and exercise/fun he will whine, sass back and bark. The worst is he redirects his frustration onto Bacall.
Their energy level is high and so is mine. I have a very difficult time just relaxing and I know these two will play off that.

Ignoring is not good to do even though I understand why you do it. It’s hard but learn to read their body language and try different special routines with him.
Take time to groom and play a bit. Reward when he does good and try to downplay the whining.
Some dobes are just big whiners.


Edit: CBD oil did not work with mine.
 
I haven't tried a Thundershirt/Anxiety before, and I honestly haven't considered it. Would it potentially help?

I have never seen this dog nap actually. He will cuddle with me while I watch a movie and relax and he will get sleepy, but I haven't actually seen him nap unless I nap myself. As I type this, he is lying with me and whining lol He was grooming himself and then boom, back to the whining. He had his training and exercise less than an hour ago.

I haven't heard of NILIF? I did a quick search on it, but unsure if I implement this. He does not get rewarded, whether that be play time or treats, when he isn't behaving or doing commands when I ask for it. I do treat him when he is quiet as a reward and praise him when he is quiet and not whining, same for commands he obeys.

I didn't want to give him attention when he is whining or getting anxious, as I feel that is reinforcing whining = mum?

I just got some CBD Oil to give it a try. It's been frustrating for sure dealing with this for 5 months, additional stress from this behaviour, etc. as people around me seemed to have not believe me when this level of whining is "abnormal."
 
Thank you for all your input.

Due to a bad situation in my life, I currently live in a bachelor unit constructed from a condo. I have a fenced in yard and everything, but our space is definitely smaller than it was before (My ex and I had a house). However, he was a huge whiner prior to the move and at the house...

I tried the plastic crate at first as that was what he was flown in (It was huge for him as a 3 month old and fit in it till 5 months), but he chewed that up. I upgraded to a metal crate (Good quality one too), and he escaped that TWICE and he made his gums all bloody trying to get out. I used to cover the crate, but he would drag the covers in and chew it up, even though he has a Kong and chew toys in there... Also never left in crate without enough exercise. He chewed up his beds in the crate as well, so he just gets old blankets instead.

At one point, I was over exercising him as a puppy I was gravely worried for his growth (Luckily he is fine). Mental stimulation I am trying with his obedience training every day, and trying to build up his drive for IPO. Someone recommended Agility being great for confidence building for dogs, so I am looking into that for January (December all clubs stop for the holidays and weather). I feel he would do well with some bite work to let all that energy out and mental stimulation from all IPO training, but I personally am unable to do this right now as I lost my car from my break-up and financially in debt for a variety of reasons ($550 annual club fee, plus training and other memberships to join the club). I hope in January things will start calming down and I'll be able to take him out (Mom and grand-sire have IPO1 titles).

I don't think he "suckles" his blanket or anything, he just destroys them. He doesn't touch the blankets that are in his crate though. Hasn't chewed or "suckled" on my blanket either.

My "breeder" is extremely shady, so I really do question what he went through.

I am trying CBD Oil today, borrowed some from a friend but I don't think it's that good of quality (It's mixed with coconut oil and salmon oil). Are there any brands you recommend? I'm in Canada. I am willing to try anything at this point lol
You're doing great. I shouldn't have written that hopefully you can tire him out. You are clearly already doing a lot! More than I am!

Yes, I totally understand the challenges of trying to work a dog in Schutzhund/IPO. The monetary cost and all the driving involved are the reasons I don't do it. That, and I have always done my own training and would not take well to having someone tell me how to train my Dobe.

Here's just a thought I had as I was washing dishes: Even though it seems like you love your Dobe and are quite committed to making it all work, would you consider letting him go to another home/situation? OF COURSE I don't mean just any average home. I am wondering if your IPO trainer friend would know of anyone who is big into the sport, or even if any nearby police force would want to use him. Of course, he would have to prove via your experienced trainer that he has what it takes first. Just one idea, so I hope you are not offended by the thought.
 

Back
Top