• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Dogs in Europe Vs the US - eCollars

I don't think we could ever settle for a dumber dog! :rofl:

Realistically I think these sort of encounters are just a part of dog ownership unless you are willing to keep them totally confined all the time. :facepalm:
This is quite true. These encounters reveal a lot about who our dogs are at their core, and it can make us realize how much concern we have for their safety. Is Jazz fixed? I have been thinking about whether to get K snipped.
 
This is quite true. These encounters reveal a lot about who our dogs are at their core, and it can make us realize how much concern we have for their safety. Is Jazz fixed? I have been thinking about whether to get K snipped.
Yes, Jazz was spayed quite young, before her first season. Our vets recommend this and I didn't know what I know now so had it done rather than have every male dog for miles fighting it out. Hopefully it won't cause her any trouble with her joints later on but she does have minor problems with spay incontinence :( which is controlled by a weekly hormone tablet. Live and learn, but I would so like to have known that there were chlorophyl tablets that mask the scent! Whether that would have been enough to keep the local boys, (including Dingos), away I don't know.

From what I have read about neutering here recently it seems that it isn't such a big behaviour changer as it was once thought. Something I read about doing the equivalent of a vasectomy for the male so it left their hormones as they should be but you didn't have to worry about unwanted litters?
 
We fixed our female cat at 6 months, before the expected heat cycle, and also before we knew better, but as a single indoor cat household it didn’t seem to matter. Dingo risk is pretty serious from what I understand, they are wild dogs right? No one needs that showing up at the front door!

Just like his jolly balls, Kaiser is “large and in charge” and I think fixing him has become a consideration for me. I’m not looking for behavioral changes, because it is true that most of that is trainable, but I see the risk of fight or flight responses dictating his response, and it has me feeling...conflicted.

I’m not worried about unwanted litters, he takes cues perfectly when they come from well mannered females (and males!).
 
We fixed our female cat at 6 months, before the expected heat cycle, and also before we knew better, but as a single indoor cat household it didn’t seem to matter. Dingo risk is pretty serious from what I understand, they are wild dogs right? No one needs that showing up at the front door!

Just like his jolly balls, Kaiser is “large and in charge” and I think fixing him has become a consideration for me. I’m not looking for behavioral changes, because it is true that most of that is trainable, but I see the risk of fight or flight responses dictating his response, and it has me feeling...conflicted.

I’m not worried about unwanted litters, he takes cues perfectly when they come from well mannered females (and males!).
Yes, Dingos are the native dog. Mostly they have a good dash of domestic in where they overlap with settled areas, and that actually makes them more of a problem as they have less fear of humans. I have a soft spot for them and like to hear them "singing" in the hills, but they aren't good news around your domestic dogs.

Yes, I see your point with an entire male dog. Their drives and responses will likely be more instinctive and intense. Probably a good subject to throw before the board who have both entire and neutered males!
 
Ahah!!! Found out today that the ecollar batteries are flat! That means Jazz was responding mainly to voice, so I shouldn't be too discouraged!
 
So, had to dig this thread up to recount a story I just read.

In my original post, I think I said something having some pretty good conversations with someone in the UK about her questioning why people use eCollars. Is it lazy training? Is it the expectation here? etc. She seemed very open to the idea of them but had never used one herself. I gave her the analogy of it being a Seat Belt.

You don't wear a seat belt when you drive because you think YOU'RE going to cause a crash, but there are infinite variables and situations in which someone or something else could cause a crash.

She just posted a story on IG about her dog who blew a recall, chased an animal in the woods, was gone for upwards of 4 minutes (forever when your dog has taken off), and came back injured.

That 1 time is all it takes.
 
So, had to dig this thread up to recount a story I just read.

In my original post, I think I said something having some pretty good conversations with someone in the UK about her questioning why people use eCollars. Is it lazy training? Is it the expectation here? etc. She seemed very open to the idea of them but had never used one herself. I gave her the analogy of it being a Seat Belt.

You don't wear a seat belt when you drive because you think YOU'RE going to cause a crash, but there are infinite variables and situations in which someone or something else could cause a crash.

She just posted a story on IG about her dog who blew a recall, chased an animal in the woods, was gone for upwards of 4 minutes (forever when your dog has taken off), and came back injured.

That 1 time is all it takes.
Just like anything else, there will always be people who ruin people’s opinions on different subjects. Yes there are many people that use ecollars that are lazy trainers. People that don’t want to teach their dog to understand behaviors they are looking for but instead just correct the dog for being wrong when the dog doesn’t know it is wrong. This is unfair training to the dog. Not all dogs require an ecollar to be trained, even as Drogon states about Ivan training his dogs, I know Ivan only uses an ecollar in certain dogs he owns. Not all of my dogs require an ecollar for training. They don’t wear them in public either. We have a leash law so no need to have them on if I have a leash on them. Not a perfect world and there will always be lazy people with pets that don’t want to take the time to learn or train their dogs.
 
Just like anything else, there will always be people who ruin people’s opinions on different subjects. Yes there are many people that use ecollars that are lazy trainers. People that don’t want to teach their dog to understand behaviors they are looking for but instead just correct the dog for being wrong when the dog doesn’t know it is wrong. This is unfair training to the dog. Not all dogs require an ecollar to be trained, even as Drogon states about Ivan training his dogs, I know Ivan only uses an ecollar in certain dogs he owns. Not all of my dogs require an ecollar for training. They don’t wear them in public either. We have a leash law so no need to have them on if I have a leash on them. Not a perfect world and there will always be lazy people with pets that don’t want to take the time to learn or train their dogs.

Yes, and she and I talked about that. If there is a training tool to use, it will be mis-used by someone out there. I'm sure there are ways to screw up training recall on a long lead just as there are ways screwing up using a prong collar, eCollar, or clicker. Rubie knew recall before we ever used an eCollar to reinforce it and I agree, if she's on-leash, she doesn't have an eCollar on. Moo might never need to be eCollar trained while off leash. With leash laws much more prevalent here than in other places/countries, I think dogs are raised with different expectations. Off leash freedom is an exception, not the norm and it's very exciting. Thus the reason for this post! If being off leash nearly everywhere was the norm from day 1, how does that effect their recall and training overall?
 
Interesting isn't it when a point is made clear through experience! I have never needed to even think about an e collar before Jazz, or a prong collar either. All the dogs I have owned previously were super active working type dogs, but they all learned to obey without question with very little correction. If some one had asked me back then if I thought these things were necessary training tools I would have said absolutely not! But now I have had an education and would say absolutely, with some dogs.

As to the question of off leash as the norm I think it depends on the dog. My last dog was very rarely leashed on walks unless we were in busy city situations. She was never tied at home from about 3yrs and would stay there alone with no fences, even overnight if that was what needed to happen. Her recall was absolute and solid and had been almost from the start. Jazz on the other hand will probably always need to be leashed in public, but is happy to just come along for walks without needing to race around out of control. Once I have overcome her inclination to chase kangaroos, she will be reliable with recall, but once again will probably always be easily distracted and need an occasional reminder. She doesn't go nuts when let loose because it is normal.
 
Interesting isn't it when a point is made clear through experience! I have never needed to even think about an e collar before Jazz, or a prong collar either. All the dogs I have owned previously were super active working type dogs, but they all learned to obey without question with very little correction. If some one had asked me back then if I thought these things were necessary training tools I would have said absolutely not! But now I have had an education and would say absolutely, with some dogs.

As to the question of off leash as the norm I think it depends on the dog. My last dog was very rarely leashed on walks unless we were in busy city situations. She was never tied at home from about 3yrs and would stay there alone with no fences, even overnight if that was what needed to happen. Her recall was absolute and solid and had been almost from the start. Jazz on the other hand will probably always need to be leashed in public, but is happy to just come along for walks without needing to race around out of control. Once I have overcome her inclination to chase kangaroos, she will be reliable with recall, but once again will probably always be easily distracted and need an occasional reminder. She doesn't go nuts when let loose because it is normal.

Thank you for your perspective!
 

Back
Top