• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Dog Breeders Wake Up

Dobs4ever

Hot Topics Subscriber
DOG BREEDERS WAKE UP
by DIANE KLUMB


Hi. My name is Diane, and I am a Breeder. I am good at it, and I am damned proud of it. I bought my first show dog in 1969 and whelped my first litter in April, 1975.


I have, since that inauspicious beginning, in partnership with my long suffering husband and a few good friends produced a few dozen champions, some top producers, a handful of Specials, and a lot of superb close-working grouse dogs and well loved companions. *We kept a fair number over the years and sold the rest. (NOTE: I said sold, not 'placed'.*..we'll address that particular idiocy later.) We owned a kennel for many years, and trained gun dogs. This involved the killing of untold numbers of game birds, all of which we ate. I have more recipes for pheasant, grouse and woodcock than you can shake a stick at. We showed our hunting dogs and hunted over our show dogs.


I do not believe for a minute that the whelping or sale of a single one of those purebred dogs is in any way responsible for the euthanasia of a million unwanted dogs a year at shelters around the country, any more than I believed that cleaning my plate when I was a kid could in any way benefit all the poor starving children in Africa, no matter how much the nuns or my mother tried to make me feel guilty about it.


I couldn't see the logic then and I can't see it now (although today I would maybe refrain from suggesting that we bundle up Sister Edlita's meatloaf and actually send it to the poor starving children in Africa.)


Look at it this way: If I go to a bookstore specifically to buy Matt Ridley's The Human Genome (which, as it happens, I recently did) and that bookstore does not have it, I will do one of two things - I will order it, or I will go to another bookstore that does carry it and purchase it there. What I will NOT do is take the same money and buy Martha Stewart's latest cookbook instead, because this is not what I want.


Guilt without logic is dangerous.

Show breeders are simply not responsible for the millions of unplanned and unwanted mongrels produced in this country. Period. So don't let anyone make you feel guilty about it.


*I do not understand why the top horse farms in this country are not in the least embarrassed by the fact they make a lot of money doing it, yet in the world of dogs if one is to be respected, one is to lose one's ass financially. That is a load of horse shit, pure and simple, yet we accept it meekly and without question


* Why is that?


Basic economic theory suggests that if we are not turning a profit, one of two things is wrong - we suffer from poor management, or we are not asking enough for our product to cover our production costs.


*What are our costs?


Well, if we are breeding good dogs, besides basic food and veterinary costs we ought to be adding in the costs of showing these animals, and advertising, and health testing, which are not expenses incurred by the high volume breeders (puppy mills).


OK, so we have much higher costs involved in producing our healthier, sounder animals. Yet the average pet shop puppy sells for about the same as the average well bred pet from show stock, and often they sell for much more. What's wrong with this picture? We're stupid that's what's wrong.


Q. Why does a Jaguar sell for ten times more than a Hundai?


A. Because it's worth more and everyone knows it. "And everyone knows it" is the key phrase here, folks. But somehow no one knows our puppies are worth more and we're embarrassed to tell them. Why is that?
The difference between the sale price of a multi million dollar stallion and what he's worth as horsemeat on any given day at a livestock auction is quality. Yet we cannot address this issue in dogs because we are embarrassed to talk about money and dogs in the same breath.


Why is that?


OK, I'll tell you, because someone has to come out and say this sooner or later. *There is a war going on. *Unlike most wars, however, this one actually has three sides rather than two.


1. We have Show breeders, who are producing a small number of purebred dogs.
2. We have High-Volume breeders who are producing a large number of purebred dogs.
3. We have Animal Rights Activists, who believe that neither group has the right to breed or even own purebred dogs, much less make a profit at it.


While the first group is busy trying to get rid of the second group because they don't like the way they breed dogs (which by the way ain't gonna happen as long as the American public wants purebred dogs and the first group won't produce them) the third group is winning the war.


You think I'm making this up?


Then how come we've started saying we "placed" our puppies instead of sold them? We talk about the new "adoptive homes" instead of their new owners. What's next? Instead of price of a puppy, we'll charge an "adoption fee?" What's wrong with this new language? I'll tell you -


We didn't come up with it, the Animal Rights Activists did - we are just stupid enough to use it. We are stupid because it's based on the premise that we have no right to own dogs. It is based on the premise that dog ownership is the moral equivalent of human slavery, and that the species Homo sapien has no right to use any other species for any purpose whatsoever, be it food, clothing, medical research, recreation or involuntary companionship.


Now, I don't know about you, but my politically incorrect opinion is: Our species did not spend the last million years clawing our way to the top of the food chain to eat tofu. The stuff tastes like shit no matter how you cook it, and there is absolutely no sense pretending otherwise.*


Zoology 101:

Animals who kill other animals for their primary food source are called predators. Their eyes are generally on the front of their skulls, they have teeth designed to tear flesh from bone, and a digestive system designed to digest meat (like us). Animals that live primarily off vegetation are called herbivores. They have better peripheral vision, flat teeth for grinding, and the most efficient of them have multiple stomachs, which we do not (like cows). And lastly, Animals who live primarily off what other have killed (carrion) are called scavengers (think about that one long and hard.)


Man like the canis, is a pack-hunting predator, which is probably why we get along so well. (If that fact bothers you, get over it.) How did we get to the top of the food chain? We are the most intelligent and efficient pack-hunters ever to suck oxygen from the atmosphere, that's how. We are certainly intelligent enough to understand that maintaining that position on this small planet depends on responsible stewardship, not guilt. And we are so damned efficient that we can support a tremendous number of scavengers in our midst -- Like the Animal Rights Activists, for instance. (Me, I think we should dump the whole lot of them buck naked in the Boundary Waters and see how well this egalitarian philosophy of theirs plays out, but that's probably too politically incorrect for anybody else to consider )


So what do we do?

Well, to begin with we need to regain control. The first way we do this is with language, which is the tool they have been using on us. These people who don't want us to "own" dogs are likening themselves to Abolitionists. That's a fallacy, unless you accept the premise that dogs are really little humans in fur coats, which frankly is an insult to a species that has never waged war on the basis of religious differences. No, the group they really resemble is the Prohibitionists - remember them? A particularly annoying bunch of zealots who firmly believed and somehow managed to convince our duly elected representatives that alcohol was a bad thing, and any beverage containing it should be illegal in these United States of America. Very few Americans actually agreed with this, by the way, but by the time Congress got its head out of its collective you-know-what, a whole new industry had developed - Organized Crime. We look back at that whole debacle now and wonder how anything that stupid and wrongheaded ever happened. Well, boys and girls, in the inimitable words of the great Yogi Berra: Its's Deja vu all over again. The Prohibitionists are back.
 
Seems to me breeders of quality dogs need to be producing larger quantities.

One thing that wasn't touched on in the writeup is accessibility to quality dogs. People don't buy dogs every day. Because of this they don't know where to go to get them. The internet has helped to get more knowledge out but its also made things more confusing because there's so much information.

Somehow breeders need to get together in a single place and present their products. Sometimes I read German websites and if you want dogs all the breeders present their animals on a couple of sites. The sites are kind of like craigslist but focus on purebred animals only. In English "rescue" groups present their dogs in the same fashion.
 
I don't think anyone on here believes that champion breeders are the reason so many animals get euthanized. I hope no one thinks that. I actually feel like it's the BYB's. I know people don't like for the government to have any more control than it does but I feel any breeder should have to pay a hefty amount to have a license and anyone without a license should have to have their dogs spay/neutered. A/C should be going around and fining people that have dogs that aren't spayed or neutered (at least by a certain age) as well as searching craigslist and other sites and fining these BYBs, unless the owner has a breeder's license and I think it should be fairly expensive to get this license. Although I do think waiting to spay/neuter may prolong life and health of a dog, too many people see $$$ and so therefore I would be fine if I was forced to spay/neuter my dog before bringing it home if it prevented more BYB's from making a buck and exploiting the breed. It would also save millions in tax payer and donation dollars.

One thing that I have found interesting since being on these sites is that so many people don't want "show quality" dogs. I was young when I got my first purebred dog (that I purchased on my own) and I got a very badly bred dog (but he was a cute little runt, that's when I learned to take caution on the runts), that cost a lot in vet expenses. After that I told myself I would only purchase show quality dogs because they are a better form of the breed and tend to be healthier as well. You get what you pay for, not that some fools don't get taken for a lot of money but if you don't pay a lot you're almost guaranteed not to get a lot. What I don't understand is the negativity towards show dog quality. My advice to people now is "more money spent now means less money spent later".

As far as the animal rights crazies I liken them to the super liberals, super right wings, super vegans,... I don't think anyone really takes them seriously and we should because we now see what they're doing in Europe to our beautiful breed. Too many times like this article states, the squeaky wheel gets the oil, most people either are for cropping/docking or don't care and the few who do are squeaking and that's what the government/regulators/rule makers hear. You can't hear people that don't speak up. LET'S SPEAK UP!
 
I agree and disagree as I have had good and bad experiences with show quality dogs. I also live in a part of the world where C & D is not allowed and quite frankly that has no bearing on the quality of the dogs produced by the top breeders. Bits of a dog on or off do not mean good health or good temperament either way. In many ways I am especially pleased with the fact that Dobermanns are rare here (Namibia) as that means minimal to no BYB of them and hardly any in shelters. Even in South Africa they are not all that popular and Dobermann rescue SA does not struggle to deal with the amount of Dobbies it gets in or hears about. I don't want my favourite breed in everybody's hands and my take on it is that if your only reason to get a dog is the way it looks chances are when it gets old and is not so pretty or you change your mind on what a cute/good looking dog, that dog is going to land up on the net or in a shelter.

If I look at breeds like Boerboels, Jack Russels, Min pins, yorkies, GSDs, daxies and pit bulls its the opposite here. Bred by anyone and everyone, liquorice all sorts when it comes to health and quality. SPCA's and shelters overrun with purebreds and mixed breeds of them. Poor dogs are like monopoly money, worthless.

The main reasons dogs land up in the shelters here are: lack of training (daddy bought a pit bull and let the kids raise it now the pit bull is out of control… oops) , moving house (which is BS to me), the cute phase is over and they can't afford to look after it (which begs the question why did you get the dog in the first place). The worst time of the year for shelters and rescues is right now, people go on holiday and literally abandon or surrender their pets. You would think this would only happen to "worthless" dogs but you would be surprised. A Weimaraner (pretty rare here) was found abandoned in a building site 2 weeks ago. Now the SPCA is trying to him home.

I don't blame breeders I blame the human races' general attitude to most things, its disposable. We need to start making it really clear to people that a dog is not a throw away item. Nor is a cat or anything else that you acquire as companion animal/pet. Breeders no matter how good they are, no matter how much they may vet prospective owners once that puppy goes to its new home you loose control. I have seen it happen. Breeders were outraged when they discovered contracts were broken etc but its a whole new process to either get the dog back or rehome it or whatever. People are generally quite lazy and don't want to deal with what it really takes to raise a good dog. People are also generally cheap and when th dog starts to cost too much money they are ready to get rid of it. Yes spay and neuter your pet and do it as soon as possible as the jury is out on the befits of late neater and spay but an intact male or female dog in ignorant persons hands is a danger to generations of dogs and unsuspecting buyers of the litters of oops puppies.
 
I also think that an intact dog should only be in the hands of genuine breeders or people who show dogs competitively, usually breeders anyway. Sounds mean and dictator like but honestly nobody but those guys really need an intact dog. I know I will get flack for saying this but hey. Most pet dogs are easier to train, raise and handle when spayed and neutered anyway.

I saw in the OP the writer compare dogs to cars, something I think is a bit distasteful as a Toyota certainly doesn't have feelings. But if we are going to compare; a car company doesn't sell you a car with the plans and a mini factory to go forth and create a whole line of homemade cars. The same can be said for dogs.
 
I agree with the message of the article but found many of the metaphors to be a stretch to say the least.

The part I agreed with the most was the part about how the show breeders will never outdo the high volume breeders and how the AR people are winning the war.

What exactly is the focus of this article? It's obvious that it is written from a good breeder's perspective for the eyes of other breeders. What is it about though? Getting more money for puppies? Pointing out that breeders need to educate the public on the difference between the quality of one purebred to another? Raising a warning flag about AR agenda?

It comes off more as a big rant than anything, but there are some good points made.
 
I agree and disagree as I have had good and bad experiences with show quality dogs. I also live in a part of the world where C & D is not allowed and quite frankly that has no bearing on the quality of the dogs produced by the top breeders. Bits of a dog on or off do not mean good health or good temperament either way.

While I agree that C+D doesn't effect the health or temperament of a dog, I have come to believe that going natural is a deviation from breed standard that can effect the popularity of the breed. Why would I want the breed to be popular you might ask? Because we need the gene pool to eradicate breed health issues such as DCM. Top breeders can't breed healthy dogs if there are not enough to breed, and they can't track the health and accomplishments (trial titles and conformation titles) of the puppies they in they produce if there is little demand from true fanciers of their breed. Without this data, how can a breeder plan for the future?
 
One thing that I have found interesting since being on these sites is that so many people don't want "show quality" dogs. I was young when I got my first purebred dog (that I purchased on my own) and I got a very badly bred dog (but he was a cute little runt, that's when I learned to take caution on the runts), that cost a lot in vet expenses. After that I told myself I would only purchase show quality dogs because they are a better form of the breed and tend to be healthier as well. You get what you pay for, not that some fools don't get taken for a lot of money but if you don't pay a lot you're almost guaranteed not to get a lot. What I don't understand is the negativity towards show dog quality. My advice to people now is "more money spent now means less money spent later".

Very well stated C-ya Hag - It is not the fact the dog is bred to be show material - it is the care, research, health testing, socializing of training knowledge of the breeder that is the key point. Breeders who do not do any training or showing usually do not put the care and concern into the decision on breeding - and which one to breed and then do the appropriate health testing. Somehow we have conveyed the wrong message "show breeding". Breeders who work and compete with their dogs are striving to produce better dogs - Hence breeding to improve as opposed to producing puppies just to sell. Good breeders screen their homes and do not just sell to anyone.

So while people might not be looking for a dog to show they should want a dog bred with the care, knowledge, health testing and training knowledge that a "show breeder produces".

The main reasons dogs land up in the shelters here are: lack of training (daddy bought a pit bull and let the kids raise it now the pit bull is out of control… oops) , moving house (which is BS to me), the cute phase is over and they can't afford to look after it (which begs the question why did you get the dog in the first place). The worst time of the year for shelters and rescues is right now, people go on holiday and literally abandon or surrender their pets. You would think this would only happen to "worthless" dogs but you would be surprised.

Kashi we see that a lot here too - I think Paint listed some of the main reasons dogs end up in shelters here. It does make you wonder about the human race for sure!!! Throw away pets - what does it teach children about loving and caring for another living creature???

I personally hate the term "show breeder" because there is so much more to what we do. "Shows" are just were one test ones accomplishments against the standard. We are simply "Breeders" - and we are daily bombarded by the HSUS, PETA and ASPCA commercials trying to make all who own pets as "abusers" and breeders as the problem.

Ingrid - I think the lady who wrote it was on a tangent. I feel her pain as we struggle to educate and combat the negative press that the public is daily flooded with through TV commercials. There are days I feel the same. I just want to sit down and cry at how misunderstood our purebred dogs are. They are not just some accident that happened when a dog jumps the fence and breeds with no planning or research. These are the dogs that for the most part fill the shelters.

"Breeders" carefully research pedigrees, study health, study structure, study the standard and then try to breed true to form and function. The standard describes very clearly the two parts that preserve any purebred dog - the conformation (structure and look) and the temperament.

Just look at the different "types" of dobermans but all clearly recognizable as Doberman. What would they look like without this standard??? I tell you the purebred dog world would not exist at all because everyone would just do what they liked without all the study and hard work that a breeder puts into it to preserve and protect the standard that guards the dogs both form and function.

She took the time to sit down and write about her life as a breeder - the love - the joy - the accomplishment through the years and to state that she was not going to stand by and just let it be trashed by those who know way too little about the purebred dog world - horse world, cat world, rabbit world, etc. People evidently feel good breeding of animals is of value then seem to want to forget it as they want a dog this way or that way throwing out the very parts the preserve and protect.
 
While I agree that C+D doesn't effect the health or temperament of a dog, I have come to believe that going natural is a deviation from breed standard that can effect the popularity of the breed. Why would I want the breed to be popular you might ask? Because we need the gene pool to eradicate breed health issues such as DCM. Top breeders can't breed healthy dogs if there are not enough to breed, and they can't track the health and accomplishments (trial titles and conformation titles) of the puppies they in they produce if there is little demand from true fanciers of their breed. Without this data, how can a breeder plan for the future?

That is true Ingrid it does not affect health or temperament BUT it is a part of the standard and is a 3 point deviation - One for not being cropped (it is a c/d breed) two the ears are not erect and three it gives our breed a soft look which is against it's alert, energetic and intimidating look. The uncropped does not stand erect so that clarifies the breed as c/d.

Sadly it was the vets in many countries and the breed clubs who went along who sold out their breeds and caved in to the AR radicals who are fighting hard to destroy the purebred dog world. It had to start somewhere and since it is the standard the was written to protect and preserve that is what they must destroy. I am not against any doberman. I LOVE all Dobermans both foreign and domestic. For the they are one breed and in either "type" I see the vision and the doberman. Unfortunately not all Doberman lovers have the right any more and for that I am sorry because in the end it will be us who loose this beautiful, wonderful, fantastic noble, loyal outstanding breed.

We must always have a strong gene pool to pull from and as we develop MORE DNA testing we must have a strong gene pool to go to or we have no way to eliminate the problems without destroying the breed we wish to preserve. Breeders do not look at today - they must look down the road to the future of the breed and for now we must struggle on as we juggle - conformation - temperament - health and now to add to the problems we must fight to defend our right to protect our breeds.
 
Part of the standard in the USA not here. Anyway not gonna get in C and D debate. Unfortunately a dog being popular does not always mean a big gene pool. They did some research into the pug population in the UK and the whole massive population equalled something like 10 individuals. Remember when you have puppy mills and irresponsible BYB it cancels out the benefits of that big gene pool you would think you are getting from your breed being "popular". Of course you want interested in it but you don't want every tom, dick and harry wakling around with one.
 
While I agree that C+D doesn't effect the health or temperament of a dog, I have come to believe that going natural is a deviation from breed standard that can effect the popularity of the breed. Why would I want the breed to be popular you might ask? Because we need the gene pool to eradicate breed health issues such as DCM. Top breeders can't breed healthy dogs if there are not enough to breed, and they can't track the health and accomplishments (trial titles and conformation titles) of the puppies they in they produce if there is little demand from true fanciers of their breed. Without this data, how can a breeder plan for the future?
Interesting. So you want our breed to be popular. I'll have to think that one over.
 
The article makes good sense but I'll say this:

I was actually eating tofu while I chose to read that article. :moon: For me, there is no such a thing as "animal rights." I believe humans have been charged with caring for and responsibly using animals. Not eating meat is a choice I have made, however, and references to tofu by haters of vegetarians and vegans are lazy and stereotyping. The author lost me when she digressed into that type of speech.

The author seems to think that breeders of quality dogs (and she apparently feels that only conformation dogs are quality) should charge more money. I'm not so sure about that.

Finally and by the way: There is a lot more to eat than tofu for those who choose to not eat meat. Please don't make yourself appear uninformed and small-minded with this anti-vegetarian talk.
 
Interesting. So you want our breed to be popular. I'll have to think that one over.
IMO It beats a population bottleneck that breeders are already feeling. Especially when it comes to breeders like myself who refuse to mix NA and Euro lines..
 
Last edited by a moderator:
They did some research into the pug population in the UK and the whole massive population equalled something like 10 individuals. Remember when you have puppy mills and irresponsible BYB it cancels out the benefits of that big gene pool you would think you are getting from your breed being "popular". Of course you want interested in it but you don't want every tom, dick and harry wakling around with one.

Not popular as the # 1 most registered bred by anyone anywhere kind of popular but they must find a large enough favor to support a healthy gene pool. You are right it does not take 80,000 reg a year like we saw in the 70's but it must be large enough to sustain the breed and have enough to pull from that we can avoid some of the issues our breed has. As the gene pool narrows the problem increase with no place to go to.
 
The question is will popularity equal a good gene pool as when a dog becomes more popular it seems that the puppy mill types, BYB types start to really take an interest in the breed perhaps degrading the gene pool even more? As I mentioned with the pugs in the UK?

BTW dobermanns ranked number 12 for popularity in the US this year which is really not bad at all,
 
The question is will popularity equal a good gene pool as when a dog becomes more popular it seems that the puppy mill types, BYB types start to really take an interest in the breed perhaps degrading the gene pool even more? As I mentioned with the pugs in the UK?

BTW dobermanns ranked number 12 for popularity in the US this year which is really not bad at all,

I don't want the sort of popularity that occurred with Dalmations after the film "101 Dalmations" was released. The sort of popularity I'd like to see is with enthusiasts such as ourselves and with sports people (conformation and work).

I didn't realize that the Doberman was #12. That's pretty darn good :) You'd never know the breed is that popular in my area. I've only ever seen 1 other Doberman in my town and it was sitting in a car from another state. #12 seems popular enough for me :)
 
Ingrid I think that just goes to show you all breed registrations are down. The purebred dog world is hammered daily by the HSUS, ASPCA and PETA commercials and propaganda and since we have such a large urban population that has no concept of animal husbandry as many have never even been to a farm the commercials are all they hear. The next 10 years will determine if purebreds will survive anywhere except possible in a few hold out pockets.
 
Most people I know would still prefer a purebred dog the problem being where they are acquiring the purebred dogs from and that fact that those breeders aren't doing registering of their dogs, most likely because they are shitty breeders.

I also think we would need to compare the registrations per a year to validate it either way.
 

Back
Top