• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Does Your Dog Get Along With Other Dogs?

Marinegeekswife

Hot Topics Subscriber
A good article for ideas of how to properly socialize and keep up socialization outside of the uncontrolled environment of the dog park. I wanted to pull this part for you guys, though:

"
It is actually more "normal" for a mature dog to NOT be able to "play nice" with strange dogs in a dog park than it is for the dog to be able to do it! Dogs in the wild are not "social" in the sense of making friends with every dog they meet. This is a human idea, and currently a big fad among people with dogs. It's causing a lot of serious problems.​
"

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/dr-karen-becker/pet-health_b_1205441.html?ncid=webmail11
 
Makes sense Jess. Our dogs play nice with other dogs, but they do tend to be a little reserved when they don't know them, rather than assertive like some of the other dogs. Well, Albert is in the teenage stage too where he will try to hump the girls when opportunity knocks. :blush: :nono:
 
That's why I think play dates are better than the dog park. You know exactly the dog that your dog will be playing with and your dog will be used to that dog too. It's so much better than trying to throw them in a different pack of dogs that may be there at that day and time you go to the park. It's different every day and just asking for trouble. Not all dogs get along and they don't necessarily have to be friends with every dog they come across...just like I'm probably not going to be friends with every person I come across! :p

Great post, Jess!
 
Jess,
That is exactly what I tell clients and others with dogs, all the time. and Is the reason I am a huge opponent of dog parks. They are just trouble waiting to happen, and are more often than not, simply a social zone for people to talk and socialize while allowing their dogs to run around totally uncontrolled.
 
I think problems arise in dog parks (or off leah parks) when people just stand around and chat and let the dogs play with a large group of dogs. I never do that. I always go straight on our walk around the fields. Our off leash park is not fenced and really just consist of several large grass fields a river and a bit of woods. We will meet and greet other dogs but I don't just stand around and wait for trouble.

A pet peeve of mine is when people bring balls to the dog park. Talk about causing friction. And people don't go play with them out in the big field, but rather stay by the parking lot where everyone stand around and let the dogs play because they are too lazy to get the butts going and actually walk their dogs.

Our girls get along with everyone. Even with the cranky ones they just get out of the way in a hurry and move on.
 
Jess - that is the Dr. Becker in the Excellent Breeder thread who thinks it is a great breeding program to breed a 13 year old. So I don't hold a lot of respect for much of Dr. Becker's thoughts. Having said that Dogs do form packs and we fail often fail to realize that we are part of the pack and so they are more likely to want to protect us which can get them into trouble when a strange dog approaches.

In nature dogs are social - they are pack animals but pack is the optimum word. Dogs who run loose and have to fend for themselves usually end up with a pack of dogs they run with. This is to protect themselves within the pack and they set up territories.

A dog that is dog aggressive however is not as good at forming a pack and is just not going to be a good candidate for socialization but instead controlled management at all times.

Another one of the challenges with a dog park - when people go I agree they usually don't pay attention and they go to the dog park as Cesar says because they are not willing to walk their dogs. Usually the dogs that go get to know each other and form a loose pack but let a new dog come in and that can spell big trouble. From the first time I heard about dog parks and I said "Lawsuits waiting to happen." When you add the term risk factor then it really becomes unacceptable to me.

I do agree we need to socialize them. Gunner is socialized but he is not dog friendly unless it is a girl!!!! Shrock can run and play with anyone - when we go visit my son he runs with their Siberian husky who is also a male. I would never turn Gunner loose with Loki even though he is neutered but Shrock was behind the door when they passed out the dog aggression gene. Both were well socialized - one is one isn't but I still only let Shrock run with dogs I know and trust so that is Loki, Zeke and Redman!!! Oh he does run with Helio too.
 
Another one of the challenges with a dog park - when people go I agree they usually don't pay attention and they go to the dog park as Cesar says because they are not willing to walk their dogs.
That's so true, so they think to just let them off the leash to run rampant is the way to exercise them, when there's just nothing like a good old walk on the leash so you and your dog can bond and they'll know who's the alpha in the group. Luckily our group has controlled socialization so if there's one single dog out of line it will be stemmed immediately, and the owner will be shown exactly how to do it as well so it isn't an issue when they're out in public without the trainer there.
 
Haven't posted in a long time but when I saw this article I decided to weigh in my thoughts. Ever since Ruby was small I have been socializing her, and I go to the dog park pretty often, it is a social gathering zone for us humans but it is also a social gathering zone for dogs. Admittedly there are some humans that are not watching their dog and there are others who are so protective of their dog that they leave them on leash jerking them around whenever another dog gets near their dog. Those are the two worst people you usually encounter and are both easy to deal with. When I go Ruby is a stays at my side and listens to what I am saying, I have total control of my dog at all times I know if I say leave it she will come and sit at my side until I tell her it's ok to go play maybe this was just good training on my part but I think as a doberman owner I would never want something to happen where my dog was to blame for starting something or getting into it with another dog. So sick of hearing doberman horror stories(The I knew a guy who owned a doberman then it turned on him and bit him ... attack a child ...when after a small dog...etc so on and so on.) Not only do you have to watch your dog but you have to be assertive to say your dog is instigating please leave, he is causing fights among-st the dogs and it is not proper park behavior. Not a lot of people are comfortable with confronting another person, but when it comes to your dogs safety and yours as well it is something that you need to train yourself to do. On the second type of person you approach them and say listen you are making your dog nervous and fearful if you are not comfortable being in the park walk the fence line outside it, let your dogs get to see other dogs if it's tail is wagging and has friendly demeanor bring it in and left it off leash. It is all about control though at the park and if you have that control over your dog and others see it they will follow your example. Now onto that note my dogs actually make friends with other dogs and certain dogs they bond stronger with, I can see it in the way they play there was one border collie named maggie that adored ruby and they would chase each other in circles and chew on each others ear and just lolly about with each other and it was like that every time we saw maggie at the park it was like oh hey friend! Playtime and I think it really burned out their energy with how much space they got to run around each other with. A lot more exercise than just the walk I give them everyday, I know this because I am not able to jog with my dogs even though I have two high energy dogs they get their full amount of exercise when we are at the park I can tell my IG really loves flying threw the air after my dobe trying to keep at her heels and that is not something I can provide them with just a walk, I don't think I am being lazy because I still do walks with them but it is a treat for them that they get to burn their pent up house energy!
 
Our Dobe gets along with all other dogs she has met so far,except the little dog in Petco one time.He nipped at her and she just stepped out of his way with a "wtf"is wrong with you look.She wants to play with all dogs.The thing is not all dogs want to play as hard as she does so I have to keep an eye on her.She wants to play too rough with the little dogs,nudging them with her nose and they go sliding across the floor.
Maxie our resident old fart dog has mellowed over the years and could care less if strange dogs come to visit.There was a time she was a holy terror with some other dogs,no matter the size.She had a genuine dislike for black dogs.
We used to camp out a lot,some friends had 2 Rotties,another friend had another Rot.She would tolerate their existance in camp but they better not penetrate the "security bubble" around my wife or kids or she went:machinegun::mad:.It's a good thing for her(and me I guess?) those Rotties were overly well trained and behaved dogs.
 
I have told a few people off in the off leash park, when they picked their dogs up, just because my girls came over. I had to tell them that they caused their dog to get scared and become a target. If you are so afraid of other (loose) dogs why do you take your dog to the dog park? I don't get it.
 
Great topic,


Up until 6 months ago I was a huge fan of Dog Parks. But that one fretful time proved to me that they are just filled with irresponsible people, and not so well behaved dogs. I overlooked the simple little issues that existed at dog parks prior. You know what I mean right ? The simple nips, or the simple threatening growls other dogs give yours. Far too many times had I heard " Hmmmmm he/she has never done that before ". Yeah right I say now........ I remember once a white German Shepard used to come to the park here locally in Duluth. On just about every occasion that dog would nip or growl at all the other dogs. A few times she had done it to Justice, which made me leary of that dog and ever since we had avoided the park when we saw their car in the parking lot.


Back in August Justice and I were heading out west for a contract job I had been offered. Since it was our last week here in Minnesota we had decided to go visit the park one last time to say our good bye's. It was that fretful day that Justice was brutally attacked by two vicious dogs. It broke my heart to see my boy in the jaws of one of the dogs, just crying for his life. It still makes me shake with anger to this day !!! So NEVER again will we attend another uncontrolled dog park filled with ignorance. I'd much rather socialize him on a walk in Canal Park, or Petco for that sake !!! Day after day I stare at his grey hair from his wounds and just kick myself for allowing such a place to exist in his life. I do blame myself for not being more cautious and awake to the surroundings. As most of you state to me in other topics " It only takes one time " which is so true on so many levels. I don't want to live in fear and place my boy in a bubble for any means. We still walk in the deep woods unleashed, he roams our land free for potty breaks and play time, but we will Never, Ever go back to an uncontrolled dog park !!!
 
We still walk in the deep woods unleashed, he roams our land free for potty breaks and play time, but we will Never, Ever go back to an uncontrolled dog park !!!
Stephen,
You two learned that lesson the hard way that day and a lot of us learned it through you. The important thing is that you guys made it through and actually learned your lesson. So many people have to learn those lessons time and time again and still don't get it. I'm not sure how to say this right so I'll just say it, I appreciate you sharing the experience with us so the rest of us wouldn't have to learn it the hard way, too.
 
Jess,
Stephen,
You two learned that lesson the hard way that day and a lot of us learned it through you. The important thing is that you guys made it through and actually learned your lesson. So many people have to learn those lessons time and time again and still don't get it. I'm not sure how to say this right so I'll just say it, I appreciate you sharing the experience with us so the rest of us wouldn't have to learn it the hard way, too.


Jess,

Well it's not easy to share that story, but I should proudly say " I hope it helps someone else " !


I was nieve to think all dogs would love my guy since he has yet to meet a dog he didn't like. Truth is your dog might be the friendliest dog you've ever seen, but seconds later another dog will not share your thoughts, and it could quickly be " Over " for your best friend. Justice and I just go lucky that day that he didn't leave this earth in a box full of tears. We were fortunate to get off with a spendy E.R Vet bill and a simple reminder of what not to ever do.
 
Wow Stephen I didn't know about that. :( We take Marco todog parks all the time, but actually just yesterday while we were out for our evening walk, I had an "OH CRAP" moment where two LABS - on leash, Marco was also on a leash - I swear those dogs would have KILLED Marco if they were not on leash. It was a scary moment and after it happened, I remember thinking I can't imagine what I would do if this went on in a dog park while the dogs were off-leash!!! :(
 
Consi
Wow Stephen I didn't know about that. :( We take Marco todog parks all the time, but actually just yesterday while we were out for our evening walk, I had an "OH CRAP" moment where two LABS - on leash, Marco was also on a leash - I swear those dogs would have KILLED Marco if they were not on leash. It was a scary moment and after it happened, I remember thinking I can't imagine what I would do if this went on in a dog park while the dogs were off-leash!!! :(


Consider yourself fortunate and I'm glad they were all on leashes. I'd be interested in seeing a study as to why some dogs just attack other's.
 
I'd be interested in seeing a study as to why some dogs just attack other's.
There are so many factors that could be effecting the situation. I know once with Spock right before we had him neutered there was a female that had just come out of heat at the park and another male, neutered, came into the park. Spock must have felt he was threatening to take the female from him or something and they almost got into it. Luckily we knew just enough about dog behavior to separate them and leave before it got nasty. The weird thing is, since we've had him neutered we've run into that dog at the park a couple times and every time Spock takes an instant dislike to him. He just must remember something about that day.
 
For whatever the reason there are times a dog will just not like another dog and I don't think we will ever know why BUT I can say the word RISK is enough to turn me off dog parks. Sometimes you just can't educated fast enough to prevent an accident. I have alwasy spoken out against them in the hopes of preventing things like Justice experienced. If I save only one dog it was worth it. Every dog is specail and if everyone was responsible then more people could enjoy these parks. But not me - as mentioned sometimes it is dangeorus just going for a walk -

If everyone resepcted the rights of others and did not allow their dogs to run loose there would be far less problems.
 
I don't really care if my dogs play with other dogs or not. If they are around other dogs, all dogs are on a leash and Drake and Greta must at least tolerate other dogs and not be aggressive towards them. Most of their time around other dogs is in therapy dog sitsuations so all dogs are at least tolerant and I am ok with that.
I am not a dog park fan at all. I will say I have found a couple of places where I feel comfortable to let them do some running. One of our favorite places is a sand bar in the middle of the river where they have freedom because no one is around and it is big enough for them to get to top speed with lots of nice driftwood for chasing.
 
I must say this is all new to me as we don't have any dog parks where i live , everyone gets out and walks their dogs on or off leash , we meet hundreds of dogs throughout the week and in over four years have never even seen a dog fight [touch wood], I could never imagine going into a dog park they just seem like a time bomb waiting to go off although i know some of you don't have much choice if you live in a city but you cannot beat walking a dog from A to B get them in the zone no distractions until they have spent some energy, although we meet lots of dog there is no playing until the walk is over then we will go in the fields and they can run and play all they want, the thing that does get to me are people you meet with their dogs who are on the phone or using MP3 or such, when I walk my dogs I give them 100% attention , they get praise for every dog they pass correctly, Buddy gets praised for every wee and poop he has and praise for every time they come back on recall, the problem is with those who do not remember they have a dog with them as what happens in the dog parks it seems, too much chatting going on between the owners and people that have no idea how to read their animal and the down side is what happened to Stephen and poor Justice .
 
I believe we should not "force"a dobie to be a certain way.
Mine has a very strong personality. He allowed gold retrievers to enter his yard, played and shared with them water and bone; walked with another side-by-side, and even a rebellious dalmatian became his walking companion. But, here it comes, a new male pup (6mts-going on) and I cannot get him close. When facing a "battle of wills"it is time to weigh the importance of the situation and its potential consequences. Is it worth forcing a dobie to like a certain dog? No.
 

Back
Top