Dobermans Not Allowed on Army Bases Due to Aggressive Nature? Huh?

Chad Dressen

Notable member
Hey everyone, I've got some Doberman videos on YouTube and it's always fun to read the comments from people. Most of the time they're positive in nature - including plenty of constructive criticism. Of course I get some nasty ones from people who have nothing better to do. I can even handle those most of time, but a comment I read this morning disturbed me more than any I've ever received before.

If was from a user who mentioned that she would have a Doberman, but they're not allowed on army bases due to their apparent 'aggressive nature', so she settled for a Min Pin.

This absolutely blows my mind. After the years of service Dobermans have given the military and Doberman's lives that have been lost in combat and otherwise, how in the world could the US military turn their backs on these animals? I'm completely disgusted and irate right now!

Does anybody have more info? I wasn't even aware of this. I asked her if she has any idea who I might contact regarding this, but I haven't heard back from her yet.

This is unbelievable.
 
yes Chad we have some threads about that too and yes its true, the military banned specific breeds from their on base housing including the Dobermans. i hope some can pull that thread again and posted here, so you can read about it.
 
Chad i wrote an entire article about this on another website (Doderman Parade.) Unfortunately i let that blog go in favor of some other sites i manage.. And i cant seem to find it on my PC anymore.. We do have a few threads on the subject, and many of of signed an online petition.. We have sent letters to our state representatives. Interestingly enough many of the letter we recieved back seemed very stock and generic... The one thing each and every returned letter had in common was that all our reps are passing the buck and made some of the most ridicules comments on the subject youve ever heard... Ha you think your upset now. wait till you read some of the letter we recieved back.. At one time we even had a retired DPCA board member using Doberman Chat to gather research on this very subject.. Ill see what i can do to dig up some of those thread and or letters. ;)

``````````````````

All i could dig up from that article was a graphic i made to go with it,
 
Oops. I apologize for not searching the forum before I posted this. I was so shocked to hear this that I assumed it wasn't a known problem. I'm ashamed for not knowing about this. And if I wasn't aware of this, I have to think there are lots of other people in the same boat. Something has to be done. At some point I'm going to blog about this and put together a video for YouTube to hopefully reach more people.

Our military should be embarrassed.
 
yep specialy since dobermans and GSd been war dogs for ages and that how they get treated now. i'll look if i can find more about it again.
 
I think I remember signing an E-petition a while ago.Long,long after,I got a non-commital auto-response from my congressman and senator.I think about the only way to have any effect is if servicemen start giving the ban as a reason for not reenlisting.That would get their attention more than any thing else!
 
.
Dear Mr. Coulson: Thank you for contacting me about a U.S. Army policy banning certain breeds of dogs deemed "aggressive or potentially aggressive" on military bases. I appreciate knowing your views. As you know, earlier this year, the Army issued a policy banning certain breeds of dogs from on-base housing. Servicemembers are still allowed to own these breeds; however, they must live off-base. This regulation was meant to standardize the pet policies that were uneven between military installations. It is my understanding that this policy is being adopted by all of the other service branches as well. Thank you again for contacting me. If Congress decides to get involved in this matter, I will be mindful of your thoughts. With best wishes, I am, Sincerely, Vernon J. Ehlers Member of Congress


---------- Post added at 10:58 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:50 AM ----------

.
Dear Mr Coulson, Thank you for contacting me about Doberman Pinschers being added to the U.S. Army's aggressive breeds list. I understand your concerns. As you know, in January 2009, the U.S. Army issued a memorandum outlining new policies for pets under the Army's Residential Communities Initiative (RCI) Privatization Program. Among the changes instituted under this memorandum was to include Pit Bulls, Rottweilers, Doberman Pinschers, Chows and wolf hybrids on the list of dogs that are not permitted to be owned by residents in RCI housing. Currently, there is no legislation pending before the Senate on this issue. However, I would recommend that you write to the Secretary of the Army John McHugh or the Chief of Staff of the Army, General George Casey to voice your concerns as well. You can send these letters to 1400 Defense Pentagon, Washington, DC 20301-1400. Should related legislation come before me for a vote, I will be sure to keep your views in mind. Thank you again for contacting me. Please continue to keep me informed about issues of concern to you and your family. Sincerely, Debbie Stabenow United States Senator
Ok so i do actually like Debbie Stabenow. And of all the letters we all received back i believe hers may have been the only one with that gave us an alternative contact..

---------- Post added at 11:02 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:58 AM ----------

Many more comments and returned letters can be found here. http://www.doberman-chat.com/showthread.php?t=3972&highlight=Army+Base
 
VOn i don't remember the banner, but its so cool andi would like it on a shirt :) and i would like it on shirts for dogs to, that would be so cool to have them wear it and walk around so everybody can see it.
 
VOn i don't remember the banner,
The Banner was originally posted on Doberman Parade with an article i wrote on the subject. The article was a huge hit.. With over a half a million page views in less then a week. I think its now a random image on K9BSL..

---------- Post added at 11:15 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:14 AM ----------

ETA: Im wondering if i cross posted that article on K9BSL.COM. Ill have to look... As far as adding that to a tshirt design.. let me sleep on it. ;)
 
Regarding bans on Dobermans... I recently traveled from WA to CA with my 2 Dobermans and made reservations ahead of time to make sure of pet friendly inns along the way. When arriving at one location (Premier Inns) I was met with a posted ban on Dobermans (along with pit bulls). The clerk made an exception for me but I still found the official ban insulting and ignorant. I have contacted their corporate office.
 
If you decide to make it into a shirt would you mind making a USMC version? I find it so sad that after all their service that Doberman's are being forced off bases. You can tell that the ignorance that caused this ban is spreading. We take Spock on base with us from time to time and one of those times I had him on leash sitting with me in front of the entrance to the PX/Commissary. Some people were happy to see him and smiled at us but most of them avoided coming near him like they were afraid he'd eat them alive. He was about 4 months old. I can't imagine what they'll think of him when he's full grown. You see similar reactions out in town but I swear more people avoided him on base.
But I do have to say that I'm not a big fan of the new base housing anyway. Most of it is now run by privatized companies who enforce stupid rules like the BSL. Even if we didn't have Spock, we'd never live in base housing again.
 
But I do have to say that I'm not a big fan of the new base housing anyway. Most of it is now run by privatized companies who enforce stupid rules like the BSL. Even if we didn't have Spock, we'd never live in base housing again.

Our country spends as much on"defense" as the next 5 countries combined,yet we had our soldiers driving around in unarmored Humvees in Iraq and in parts of Afghanistan trying to patch together worn out junk weapons with rubber bands and paper clips.All the money ends up going to Halliburton and Blackwater type contractors and disappearing under the table. I think it's a disgrace!
 
Hey Chad, it's nice to see you here! And yes, there have been multiple articles about the idiotic and disingenuous banning of Dobes in military housing. I could see there being a rule that ALL dogs in military housing (and maybe in all housing projects and other close-quarters dwellings, as well, maybe?) be required to present certificates of basic obedience training, or maybe a CD certification or something - but, for me personally, the only 3 dogs that ever were really nasty to me were an Irish Setter, a Kerry Blue Terrier, and an incredibly nasty little Pomeranian. I grew up with Dobermans, GSD's and Boxers, and a few other assorteds like a Bernese, a GSP, etc. Never met a nasty one, ever.

As an interesting aside, my family comes from Germany, and my great-grandfather owned Dobermans since before they were an "official" breed, in the 1890's and from then on. My grandfather (born 1901) had his first Dobe at age 9, and by the time he was a teenager, he was training them for police work, messenger and SAR for the army, and even some of the earliest service/guide dogs. He had me doing obedience work with our dogs by the time I was 8 or 9. (love you, Mimpy)
 

Back
Top