Dobermans and other breeds' tolerances for warm/cold temps

Oh Little Oji

Hot Topics Subscriber
$ Forum Donor $
Moderator Note: This thread has been split off from another thread to continue the discussion that went off topic on heat and cold tolerance of the Doberman and other breeds. Please continue that discussion in this thread, thank you!

===============================================================================

Ty everyone. And also to clarify I agree with the above statements about "pitbulls." The APBT is it own breed as well as Staffordshire Terrier,Bull Terrier, staffordshire bullterrier, american bully, american bull dog etc.

We do not have horses :( We live near a lot of places with horses. I love horses. My bitch is gaf bred. I can answer or share anything if someone is interested. My kids love to be pulled on the sled in winter down the street and in the wagon.

Thank you for the nice comments and info!
Well, then, just two quick questions at this point:

I've talked to a woman recently who mentioned the name "American Bully." What is it?

Also: What is "gaf bred?"

Bonus question: :) Do you have knowledge in any Mastiff breeds as well? I've been looking just a bit into those type of breeds in hopes of one day having a dog that has a lower exercise/stimulation demand and that doesn't shut down in the heat like a lot of Dobermans do.
 
Do you have knowledge in any Mastiff breeds as well? I've been looking just a bit into those type of breeds in hopes of one day having a dog that has a lower exercise/stimulation demand and that doesn't shut down in the heat like a lot of Dobermans do.
I don't know much about Mastiff's either, but the ones I've seen at shows shut down much faster than Doberman's in the heat because if their size.
 
I don't know much about Mastiff's either, but the ones I've seen at shows shut down much faster than Doberman's in the heat because if their size.
Yeah, I guess that makes sense.

I've had a fascination – from afar – with Boerboels for years now. They come from a hot climate and are reputed to be able to do well in cold and heat. But that was just a claim I saw on a website.
 
I love Mastiff's but I'd never own one or any other huge breed because of the short life expectancy. The ones at the shows do rally and it takes them over 5 minutes to get through the course because they just saunter along. LOL
 
that doesn't shut down in the heat like a lot of Dobermans do.


Don't you think that is more the people shutting down? I hear people say the dobes shut down in temps, hot or cold, but I have never experienced it. With the season changes I acclimate my dogs to the temps and have never had a problem. We are a very active family and do all kinds of stuff outdoors all year long with the dogs right beside us.
It is 97 outside and we just came in from 2 hours of training and then a game of fetch. Drake is standing here staring at me with the ball hanging out the side of his mouth with a look that says "Seriously? we're done?"
 
I've had a fascination – from afar – with Boerboels for years now.
I took care of a South African Boerboel about 20yrs ago. It was a gorgeous dog but holy cow it was massive and had an attitude to match. The owner was a pathologist at the hospital and worked long hours. She had the dog crated in a spare bedroom in a large wire crate. I met with her and went over the needs of the dog. I expected her to remove the dog from the crate but she had me do it. That was the first red flag. The dog was growling and I got his leash along with a treat and opened the crate door (pretty sure my life as I knew it was about to be over). This dog bolted out, knocked me to the floor and mounted me. I could not get him off me and the owner seemed too afraid of him to help. I know this sounds comical but I have to tell you it was frightening. After a few minutes I managed to get away from him and get his leash on. At this point I was pretty sure I did not want to take care of this dog but she was desperate for help and I agreed. She never told me she had gone through 6 pet sitters, all bitten by Bernie, never told me he was kicked out of obedience class for being aggressive. I found all this out about 7 mos into the job. When he bit me, it was just a snip with his incisors on my finger but it went straight to the bone on my knuckle. That did it for me. You need a lot of exercise space for these dogs. He wasn't getting what he needed in mental and physical stimulation. I heard a few years later that he had to be put down. Was so sad that he didn't have the home and time given that he deserved. The loogers he sprayed everywhere when he shook his head was enough for me not to want that breed. Yuck!
 
Don't you think that is more the people shutting down? I hear people say the dobes shut down in temps, hot or cold, but I have never experienced it. With the season changes I acclimate my dogs to the temps and have never had a problem. We are a very active family and do all kinds of stuff outdoors all year long with the dogs right beside us.
It is 97 outside and we just came in from 2 hours of training and then a game of fetch. Drake is standing here staring at me with the ball hanging out the side of his mouth with a look that says "Seriously? we're done?"
Ooh, I have to disagree. It is definitely the Doberman shutting down and refusing , or all but refusing, to work or play.

I did not have this with my first Dobe which was a Red with a strange full undercoat. When I had him, I heard, a few times, fellow Dobe owners complain that their Dobes will not do anything in the heat. I thought it was weird.

With my subsequent two Dobes I now know what they are talking about. In fact, with Oji, when he's hot he is the slowest-obeying Doberman I've ever met. A simple "sit" command can take 5 - 8 seconds to complete. It's like he's thinking "I don't give a rip. I'm hot here." That, or his brain is just not functioning well.

I can be on a walk in the warm sun and he'll not only pull toward the shade and lag behind while in it, but if he's hot enough he will lay down on some grass and play stubborn mule.

I'm not talking extremes of temperatures here, or extremes of demands on my part.

It's a big weakness in the breed.
 
I took care of a South African Boerboel about 20yrs ago. It was a gorgeous dog but holy cow it was massive and had an attitude to match. The owner was a pathologist at the hospital and worked long hours. She had the dog crated in a spare bedroom in a large wire crate. I met with her and went over the needs of the dog. I expected her to remove the dog from the crate but she had me do it. That was the first red flag. The dog was growling and I got his leash along with a treat and opened the crate door (pretty sure my life as I knew it was about to be over). This dog bolted out, knocked me to the floor and mounted me. I could not get him off me and the owner seemed too afraid of him to help. I know this sounds comical but I have to tell you it was frightening. After a few minutes I managed to get away from him and get his leash on. At this point I was pretty sure I did not want to take care of this dog but she was desperate for help and I agreed. She never told me she had gone through 6 pet sitters, all bitten by Bernie, never told me he was kicked out of obedience class for being aggressive. I found all this out about 7 mos into the job. When he bit me, it was just a snip with his incisors on my finger but it went straight to the bone on my knuckle. That did it for me. You need a lot of exercise space for these dogs. He wasn't getting what he needed in mental and physical stimulation. I heard a few years later that he had to be put down. Was so sad that he didn't have the home and time given that he deserved. The loogers he sprayed everywhere when he shook his head was enough for me not to want that breed. Yuck!
Thanks, Bri! Yes, comical from across the inter web, but no doubt harrowing. That was an very serious thing that happened to you. Thanks for sharing your experience with a Boerboel. I don't at all take it as painting the entire breed. It was just a dominant dog that was not under control.

Now, your insight as to the drool is eye-opening and very disappointing. I mean I knew there had to be drool, but the claims I hear are that the breed drools less than other mastiff-types.
 
Ooh, I have to disagree. It is definitely the Doberman shutting down and refusing , or all but refusing, to work or play.

I did not have this with my first Dobe which was a Red with a strange full undercoat. When I had him, I heard, a few times, fellow Dobe owners complain that their Dobes will not do anything in the heat. I thought it was weird.

With my subsequent two Dobes I now know what they are talking about. In fact, with Oji, when he's hot he is the slowest-obeying Doberman I've ever met. A simple "sit" command can take 5 - 8 seconds to complete. It's like he's thinking "I don't give a rip. I'm hot here." That, or his brain is just not functioning well.

I can be on a walk in the warm sun and he'll not only pull toward the shade and lag behind while in it, but if he's hot enough he will lay down on some grass and play stubborn mule.

I'm not talking extremes of temperatures here, or extremes of demands on my part.

It's a big weakness in the breed.

I wonder if it has to do with lines or acclimation like @GennyB mentioned. Drogon is getting much better about the sun. The cold never bothered him. I only used his coat once or twice and realized he prefers to go without it. If it is cloudy and hot he doesn't seem bothered very much. The sun still gets him but he seems to be acclimating and able to tolerate it more and more.
 
Don't you think that is more the people shutting down? I hear people say the dobes shut down in temps, hot or cold, but I have never experienced it. With the season changes I acclimate my dogs to the temps and have never had a problem. We are a very active family and do all kinds of stuff outdoors all year long with the dogs right beside us.
It is 97 outside and we just came in from 2 hours of training and then a game of fetch. Drake is standing here staring at me with the ball hanging out the side of his mouth with a look that says "Seriously? we're done?"
Conversely, cold temperatures spur on their energy. I find that Dobes do quite well in the cold – as long as they're being active. Now, no, they aren't suited for being left out in cold temps to be inactive. But I walk my Doberman in any and all cold temperature and weather – sub-zero included. This with no doggie jacket or other gear. One of the things that makes Oji most hyper on a walk is an icy headwind.
 
Ooh, I have to disagree. It is definitely the Doberman shutting down and refusing , or all but refusing, to work or play.

I did not have this with my first Dobe which was a Red with a strange full undercoat. When I had him, I heard, a few times, fellow Dobe owners complain that their Dobes will not do anything in the heat. I thought it was weird.

With my subsequent two Dobes I now know what they are talking about. In fact, with Oji, when he's hot he is the slowest-obeying Doberman I've ever met. A simple "sit" command can take 5 - 8 seconds to complete. It's like he's thinking "I don't give a rip. I'm hot here." That, or his brain is just not functioning well.

I can be on a walk in the warm sun and he'll not only pull toward the shade and lag behind while in it, but if he's hot enough he will lay down on some grass and play stubborn mule.

I'm not talking extremes of temperatures here, or extremes of demands on my part.

It's a big weakness in the breed.



Interesting, I've never experienced it. I'm not just talking about my dogs either. I have been to dog trials as well as training and never saw a dog shut down because if temps. I would bet money it has something to do with acclimation for the most part.
 
Interesting, I've never experienced it. I'm not just talking about my dogs either. I have been to dog trials as well as training and never saw a dog shut down because if temps. I would bet money it has something to do with acclimation for the most part.
I agree with you. Temps never bothered my red boy. He could go all day regardless of heat, even when I would make him rest he would be immediately ready to do anything again. Neither of my dobes ever shut down due to heat or cold. They were the proverbial energizer bunny.
My pups are the same way but I am careful with them and the heat, humidity here. I keep my AC at 80 and usually have the front door open. I feel claustrophobic with it closed when I am here.

My Beagle given her age cannot handle extended periods of heat in conjunction with activity even though she tries her best. :-)

There a quite a few mastiff type breeds here and they do not handle heat as well as they are purported to.
 
I agree with you. Temps never bothered my red boy. He could go all day regardless of heat, even when I would make him rest he would be immediately ready to do anything again. Neither of my dobes ever shut down due to heat or cold. They were the proverbial energizer bunny.
My pups are the same way but I am careful with them and the heat, humidity here. I keep my AC at 80 and usually have the front door open. I feel claustrophobic with it closed when I am here.

My Beagle given her age cannot handle extended periods of heat in conjunction with activity even though she tries her best. :)

There a quite a few mastiff type breeds here and they do not handle heat as well as they are purported to.
So strange! Well, as I said, my Red boy did not shut down in the heat. But I tell ya', I'm not making this stuff up. I am reminded of an old acquaintance in Tucson. One of the last times I talked to her she said she was looking to switch breeds due to the Doberman's lack of ability to deal with heat. She was considering Ridgebacks. I remember thinking: traitor! ;)
 
But I tell ya', I'm not making this stuff up.



I know you are not making it up. I hear it all the time. I have just never experienced it. It's pretty hot and humid here. When it starts heating up, we acclimate by starting off in the mornings. We extend the time gradually and by the time the heats really fires up, we are ready for an all day outing.
We do the same when the temps start dropping. Really cold weather is not that common here, probably just below zero and not for extended periods but my dogs handle it just fine.
 
I know you are not making it up. I hear it all the time. I have just never experienced it. It's pretty hot and humid here. When it starts heating up, we acclimate by starting off in the mornings. We extend the time gradually and by the time the heats really fires up, we are ready for an all day outing.
We do the same when the temps start dropping. Really cold weather is not that common here, probably just below zero and not for extended periods but my dogs handle it just fine.
Ah. So you actively acclimate your Dobes. I wonder how many breeds need this special effort to get them to cope with the normal changes of season. Just being objective and inquisitive as usual here :)
 
I wonder how many breeds need this special effort to get them to cope with the normal changes of season
I would think it would be the same as with humans. I am probably no help to you because our winters consist of a few weeks of 50+ degree weather. One day it will be 72 and the next 54. It makes it difficult to acclimate. Us locals put on socks with our sandals in the winter. Lol
I would put a shirt on my girl because she had very little hair and would get chilled during those 50 degree days. But again, our weather doesn't lend well to acclimating.
 
Around here actual temps are from -40° in the winter to close to 100° in the summer, and if you factor in the "feels like" it can go from -75 to +110 so it's a big swing and it does take time to acclimate. Darn it, I hit a wrong key and my font went all funky. ;)

 

Back
Top