• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Doberman too friendly?

Yuriy

Novitiate
Mod note: Moved from Defensive Doberman thread

Question to Doberman experts: my Doberman is in opposite spectrum that was described above. Very friendly to everyone, to strangers, loves everything that moves. Has zero aggression to people, dogs kids, cats, basically loves everybody. Very obedient and smart. I even tried to provoke her for fight, where stranger came in into the house and was acting aggressive, dog did not responded, was not scared, just observed that guy. This is 11 month old female doberman. In situations where we saw other aggressive dogs on the street, my dog was either neutral or friendly ( lol ):).
Not even barked once on the strangers, never in her life. I trained her to bark on command:), but that's not what we are looking for.

Any Ideas how to correct this friendly behavior toward strangers, and get her mildly protective? Do you think this is age related and it is not mature dog at 11month? Or is it just genetic friendliness ?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Most dogs do not know what to do without proper training, so the setup where she didn't do anything when the stranger was aggressive, well she really doesn't know what to do. It would be similar to asking a bird dog to go in the brush and retrieve the bird you just shot and bring it back to you without training. She's also a puppy still. With that said, I think a doberman with the proper temperament and instincts should be protective/alert enough to AT LEAST bark. I know my girl would never just watch a stranger walk down our driveway without barking her dang head off. She went front and center for the aggressor for her WAE, amplifying her bark and charging at him when he ran at her. Without training I don't expect her to do this in all scenarios but I rest better knowing she at least has the natural instinct to want to do so. A doberman with a proper temperament should be neutral and sometimes friendly is ok too, it just depends on the scenario, if you seem comfortable with the person, they will too. It sounds like you have a social butterfly... not uncommon for a young dog although around 7-8 months when my girl went into her first heat she started to be less overly social and more neutral or aloof to strangers.

You can't correct genetics and I wouldn't want to necessarily correct friendliness. If/when you take her out in public you could work on building her focus on you with lots of fun games and less on the people around you. Tell people she is in training and that she may not be pet, she isn't a petting zoo for their entertainment. You could also maybe have her evaluated at a IGP club to see what they think about her. They should be able to tell you what her strengths and weaknesses are.
 
You can't correct genetics and I wouldn't want to necessarily correct friendliness. If/when you take her out in public you could work on building her focus on you with lots of fun games and less on the people around you. Tell people she is in training and that she may not be pet, she isn't a petting zoo for their entertainment. You could also maybe have her evaluated at a IGP club to see what they think about her. They should be able to tell you what her strengths and weaknesses are.
^^^ yes, all this. ^^^

I think the Doberman breed has a full spectrum of temperament and you can usually predict what you'll get (but not always!) by looking at the titles in your pups pedigree. So yes, genetics. Unfortunately they can get an overload in either direction. Working lines can be so strongly ingrained that the dog has difficulty being social (that other thread that caught your interest) and some show lines that discourage any barking or aggressive behavior can become totally stranger-friendly and social, getting further and further from the original reason the Doberman was developed.

I wouldn't correct friendliness, as @Rits said, just discourage it by asking your dog to remain neutral and by asking people to not pet her. If she will play tug I would do that and let her win a lot. Building confidence in herself with some mental games like nose work is always good. It takes a lot of confidence building to create a somewhat suspicious dog from one who is naturally friendly, if that makes sense.

We use to say in the race horse world, they have to have the gotta-wanna. (they gotta wanna do it, you can't make them have the heart)
 
There are so many factors that go into how a dog behaves that it's hard to say the cause of a specific behavior. Every dog owner is a self proclaimed expert. And they may be right when it comes to THEIR dog. Dogs are like people in that every one is different. Add to that we're talking about a puppy! Maturity can be a game changer.
Generally speaking defensive drives don't kick in till anywhere from 12 months to 3 years. No one knows what you get until full maturity.
 
as @Rits said my dog is social butterfly :) . Thanks on advise on reducing petting from strangers. I agree on point that dog without training don't know how to behave in unknown situation (aggressive stranger) . I was expecting to receive at least bark in this case.
@Ravenbird We are practicing with tug, my dog loves this game. But it is just a game for her, very friendly, no growling. Grabs toy very strong, impossible to pull that toy from her. And I am not a weak guy lol. Dog's grip so strong that it can hang on the toy with full body weight in the air (40 kg, or 88 lb). Recently started doing nose work for mental stimulation, enjoys that process. But I am not sure how nose work is related to confidence building, please elaborate.
@GennyB defensive drives don't kick in till anywhere from 12 months to 3 years: I hope that you are right on that, maybe dog is too young for now.
 
We are practicing with tug, my dog loves this game. But it is just a game for her, very friendly, no growling. Grabs toy very strong, impossible to pull that toy from her. And I am not a weak guy lol. Dog's grip so strong that it can hang on the toy with full body weight in the air (40 kg, or 88 lb).
That's great! - and it displays a good attitude and desire to combat with you in play.
Recently started doing nose work for mental stimulation, enjoys that process. But I am not sure how nose work is related to confidence building, please elaborate.
If you have joined a group or are taking lessons, all the better, but even hiding food or toys in the house works the same. Basically the bottom line is that you never tell the dog where the hide is, you play dumb and the dog shows YOU where it is to get rewarded. All your other puppy training is you teaching the dog what to do sit, stay, come, leave it, heel, etc etc. You have always been in charge. This NW game lets the dog be in charge. She sets her pace, she uses her own style, and she must do this thing without your help or hints. Many nosework groups cater to shy or weak nerved dogs to boost their confidence in daily life and it's been proven that it does. I don't think your dog has that problem, but just the idea of being her own boss at this game can boost confidence in other areas. So if she's not quite bold enough to stand up to a stranger on her own right now, this may help boost that thought. The process of training protection dogs for sport or for real life involves having a very self-confident dog. Defense (barking at a stranger) is high stress, whereas prey drive (tug) is high arousal, but not very stressful.

I'm not an expert by any stretch of the imagination, but I studied animal behavior and training and have spent a lifetime revolving around it and I like to help people learn. My first Doberman was much like you describe yours, my second was very balanced, much like @Rits current dog Ripley, and the one I have now has more than her fair share of defense, which I've spent years now trying to tamp down. I have no doubt at all that she was born this way. She was barking at innocent strangers (to my embarrassment & horror) before she was 4 months old if they stared at her too long.

You may find it fun to read through some of the nose work threads under the performance sports section and some more conversations about protection in the Schutzhund Bite Sports threads.

Most of all, have fun & love your dog. :hearteyes:
 
You can try and find a good Schutzhund Helper. They can bring certain traits out of your dog. Some dogs have them and some don't.

Our boy goes nuts when he sees something outside. Is still a little leary when first meeting a stranger.
 
I am so glad you asked this question. Our pup is good when her e-collar or prong is on. Or if cheese is in my pocket. Just a beep beep on the collar makes her comply right away if she hesitates, but off those collars she is a lunatic. Rough play, pulling like a mule, and loving folks to death. She barks at dangerous things like cats and golf carts and old men who look like Santa. You are not alone!
 
Mod note: Moved from Defensive Doberman thread

Question to Doberman experts: my Doberman is in opposite spectrum that was described above. Very friendly to everyone, to strangers, loves everything that moves. Has zero aggression to people, dogs kids, cats, basically loves everybody. Very obedient and smart. I even tried to provoke her for fight, where stranger came in into the house and was acting aggressive, dog did not responded, was not scared, just observed that guy. This is 11 month old female doberman. In situations where we saw other aggressive dogs on the street, my dog was either neutral or friendly ( lol ):).
Not even barked once on the strangers, never in her life. I trained her to bark on command:), but that's not what we are looking for.

Any Ideas how to correct this friendly behavior toward strangers, and get her mildly protective? Do you think this is age related and it is not mature dog at 11month? Or is it just genetic friendliness ?
Sounds like a good confident girl. I would not try to change her. I want my dogs to show indifference when in public. They should be ok with other people and dogs that may be outside and around us, but without the need to meet them or play with them. Being overly friendly is not a bad thing but I would stop her from meeting strangers and other dogs.
You taught her to bark on command so she can be taught to scare off a stranger coming in the house. You can have someone come in looking shady then encourage her to bark, when she does have the person act scared and run off. Do this as training and she will donor in her own once learned.
If she does not possess the genetics to protect (most do not) don’t try to push her into defense, it can create more problems and ruin her confidence.
 
I know people who felt they owned a Dobe that would not protect them...(myself being one with our Clarke!) and I did not feel he would pass the WAE in the last Agressor exercise, and he surprised me and went off! I did the WAE when he was only 2, now that he is 6, he is far more protective....even when people walk up to our fence :thumbsup2:. Glory has always been more protective...but I have seen that in females.
Also, the few folks I know who felt they had a dobe that would not protect; were in a situation where a REAL stranger was acting odd, and the dogs went into action immediatley - just with a defensive posture, and low growl.
I think if there is a legitimate threat, most of these guys become Dobermans....just my opinion ;) In this video, I didn't really correct them, because one of the people at the fence was our neighbor; and they people he was with were workmen he had hired. Our dogs knew our neighbor, but not who he was with.
 
I had a rescue that was a total mush ball. He never met a stranger and loved everyone. He would go to work with me and couldn't wait for someone to come to the office so he could lean on them and get petted. Every dog is an individual.
 

Back
Top