Bark Collar Suggestions Please

Caloni

Active Member
I have only used a shock collar once and it was for off leash training. I used the beep more than anything to train the recall and probably could have used a vibrating collar instead. But I don't have the collar any more so it doesn't matter.

Problem I am trying to solve: Luca has started barking in the crate around 8 am. I don't get up till around 10. I am sure he is barking because everyone else in the house is up and about including the other 2 dogs that aren't crated. If I go over and tell him "no" he won't bark again for about an hour. There is rarely ever more than one or two barks. I am trying to eliminate being woke up or having to get out of bed to discipline him.

Does anyone know of a good shock bark collar or device that I can use that won't punish the other dogs by emitting a sound that will stop him from barking? I want a collar that someone has used before and I know will work. If it also has a remote function on it with a beeper that would be even more desirable so that I can use it for off leash recall training in the summer.

I am also not opposed to other devices or collars, but I do not want one that sprays chemicals into my dog's skin or eyes.
 
Can't give you any advice on the collar but, when is the last time he goes out potty for the night?
 
Problem I am trying to solve: Luca has started barking in the crate around 8 am. I don't get up till around 10. I am sure he is barking because everyone else in the house is up and about including the other 2 dogs that aren't crated
IDK If everyone else is up, it's gonna be hard for him to be 'odd man out'. If someone else is up, why can't they let him out with the others while you sleep? My dogs potty about 5:30am. Waiting til 10 would never work. Or is he let out to potty and crated again?

I've never used a bark collar so IDK. I have seen a Worlds Funniest program with people trying out the bark collar on themselves! lol And it wasn't pretty.
 
IDK If everyone else is up, it's gonna be hard for him to be 'odd man out'. If someone else is up, why can't they let him out with the others while you sleep? My dogs potty about 5:30am. Waiting til 10 would never work. Or is he let out to potty and crated again?
I would have to agree with this too. Our dogs go out just before 10 pm and could never make it til 10 am, but I'm guessing you take him out later than that at night?

I had the Pet Safe collar for Boris and it worked well, but you do have to be careful so their tags don't clank around too much or it could set it off (it's a mild stimulation). I never used it when he was in his crate, but only in certain situations where he would bark like a maniac and not even settle down enough to figure out what he was barking at, which was usually strangers coming over.
 
The waiting can definitely be done.
I will sometimes go to bed at 2am on the weekends and sleep till 2pm the next day. Raven just sleeps the whole time.
The problem is that the other two dogs are up. Using a corrective device in a crate may ruin crate training.
They associate being in there with being shocked or sprayed.
I would recommend keeping all dogs down at night, or waking up at 8 for a quick potty break.

To put this into retrospect. My dad has a little fat dachshund, and a chow mix.
The dachshund will jump off the bed at 2:30, climb down the stairs. Now she cant get back up because of how fat she is. So she barks until my dad wakes up. Then he has to let them out and they go right back to sleep.
 
The waiting can definitely be done.
Possibly. I just don't like to make them wait that long. I know I can't wait that long sometimes! :eek2: We're up at 5-5:30 anyway and used to getting up early for babies, work, etc.... now its horses and dogs and work. A weekend may be 7am. That's late! LOL!
 
LOL if me sleeping in meant 7 am i would be a zombie. I love getting a good 10+ hours in on the weekend, I think Raven likes it to. I work him hard during the week.

I just make sure no one is drinking tons of water before bed.
 
Can't give you any advice on the collar but, when is the last time he goes out potty for the night?

He goes out at 9 right after he eats. He usually plays for an hour to an hour and a half...sometimes we train. But he plays hard till he is wore out. Then I send him out to potty again. If we sleep in, on the weekends, he won't bark at all because we all get up at the same time. I am sure he just wants to be out with everyone else because he will let out a little cry sometimes if he is in my office (gated off from the rest of the house) and we are in the kitchen. I give him the "quiet" command and he stops, but I am pretty sure I know what he wants.
 
LOL if me sleeping in meant 7 am i would be a zombie. I love getting a good 10+ hours in on the weekend, I think Raven likes it to. I work him hard during the week.

I just make sure no one is drinking tons of water before bed.
I can work him hard and play with him hard....to an extent....in the house. Our training club has been closed many nights in the past month because of weather and I can't get the car out to go take him somewhere. Any suggestions for wearing him out quickly in a small space? I think we are all getting some cabin fever, but that is not the reason for his barking.
 
Is there a reason why he can't be up when everyone else is? Just wondering.
Because out of the crate he likes to find things that are inappropriate to chew on. Such as rugs, blankets, and if no one was watching I am sure he would try a go at the table and couch...lol. There are NO issues with chewing if someone keeps an eye on him or I am the only one in the house. But my husband knows basically nothing about dog training so I would never leave a dog in training running around the house with him.....it's not his job. He also needs to spend his morning time getting ready for work and getting our daughter off to school. So he stays crated up till I get up. Does that make sense? I tried to explain it as best I could.
 
I can work him hard and play with him hard....to an extent....in the house. Our training club has been closed many nights in the past month because of weather and I can't get the car out to go take him somewhere. Any suggestions for wearing him out quickly in a small space? I think we are all getting some cabin fever, but that is not the reason for his barking.
I would just do heavy amounts of training. When physical stimulation isnt an option mental stimulation wears them out just as quick.
 
IDK If everyone else is up, it's gonna be hard for him to be 'odd man out'. If someone else is up, why can't they let him out with the others while you sleep? My dogs potty about 5:30am. Waiting til 10 would never work. Or is he let out to potty and crated again?

I've never used a bark collar so IDK. I have seen a Worlds Funniest program with people trying out the bark collar on themselves! lol And it wasn't pretty.
He is let out around 8 am with the other dogs, and then crated again. That is usually when he lets out his 1-2 barks around 8:30 to 9. When I used the training collar on the other doberman I had I tried it out on myself first. 5/6 was the absolute most I could tolerate on my neck....not sure why they would even have it go to 9....but rarely did I even have to use more than a 1 or 2 if he ignored the beep. Like I said, for a recall I will most likely just use the vibrating collar and NOT a shock collar....I don't see the point if you want to keep the training positive. Any tool can be misused :(
 
I would have to agree with this too. Our dogs go out just before 10 pm and could never make it til 10 am, but I'm guessing you take him out later than that at night?

I had the Pet Safe collar for Boris and it worked well, but you do have to be careful so their tags don't clank around too much or it could set it off (it's a mild stimulation). I never used it when he was in his crate, but only in certain situations where he would bark like a maniac and not even settle down enough to figure out what he was barking at, which was usually strangers coming over.

Thanks for the suggestion. I don't like to crate any of my dogs with their collars. I put them on top of the air liner crate and they go on when they come out. And He doesn't bark any where else so I would not have to worry about the tags coming in contact with the collar. He does not bark outside, at weird noises, or when people come over....even though both of the other dogs DO! LOL He is a really good boy, and since this is really his only behavior I am working to correct I want to do all of the research possible before making a leap into using a training device I have never had to use.

All of my fosters and past dogs (even the 14 year old) make it/hold it from 10pm till 8 am. I would never push them to do it longer. I start them out getting up at 3-4 am and work it every week a half hour longer till they are at 8 am. This is the first dog that I have ever had/fostered in 12 years that has ever barked in the crate....and I have the same routine for every dog that stays here.....husband lets them all out at 8 and any new dog goes back in the crate till 10, then everyone eats and is out for the day. So I guess I am lucky that I haven't come across this problem ever before, but now I also need to learn the correct way to fix it :)
 
Aren't you worried about the chemicals in his eyes and lungs?

Its a very safe chemical. The majority of it hits underneath their lower jaw. Even if it gets in their mouth or eyes it is harmless.
But again though I would use this in a crate.

I tried that for a foster dog who would scratch and bend my crates and she just freaked out even more. I had to completely retrain her after using an e collar in a crate.
The crate should be a safe place, a comfortable place. Just like our home is to us.

If someone were to shock or spray you everytime you went into your house you would want to move right?
 
Its a very safe chemical. The majority of it hits underneath their lower jaw. Even if it gets in their mouth or eyes it is harmless.
But again though I would use this in a crate.

I tried that for a foster dog who would scratch and bend my crates and she just freaked out even more. I had to completely retrain her after using an e collar in a crate.
The crate should be a safe place, a comfortable place. Just like our home is to us.

If someone were to shock or spray you everytime you went into your house you would want to move right?

I completely agree. That is why I have held off using any device at all till I got some suggestions. I have used a device in the past for my loud mouth Schnauzer who barks at every little noise or flyer dropped on the porch. The device emits a sound that deters the barking. IT WORKED! He was a bit scared of the noise at first which is what I think got him to stop barking....but now all loud beeping noises make the poor boy shake. The older dog that wasn't affected by the device (didn't really bark any way) somehow figured out that when the schnauzer was near the device the lab (old guy) would bark to set off the device and send the poor schnauzer into a tizzy! So I returned the device and was leery of using it again because even in a closed room I am sure the other dogs could hear the device if it went off. It would be a great device for just one dog in the home.
 

Back
Top