• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

are you challenging me?

jshawstad

Hot Topics Subscriber
Hello everyone, i feel like ive been blowing this place up since i found it... Hahaha. Okay, we are over the skittish part BUT something new has come up. I have followed most of the tips in the being a leader thread, i go out doorways first while she sits. We walk and she stays beside me, and doesnt pull. When outside alone, i make her come, sit, shake (with both paws seperately) and then lay down BEFORE she is allowed inside. But the last few days, she seems to be testing me... Like "what are you gonna do if i dont?" So, if she doesnt go through the come inside routine... She doesnt come inside. I wait 5 min, and try again... And again, and again, and again. She is very smart, she KNOWS what im asking for. I use same commands everytime, and if you have treats in hand, physical gestures on what i want are enough to make it happen. She is 100% if you give her treats for work, but the "you do it because i asked you to" isnt sticking. Is this normal? What is MY course of action to help build her confidence and destroy her attempts at dominating me?
 
I haven't followed your other threads, so my apologies for not knowing your situation. When I think I have a dominance issue with a dog, I do heeling practice. I make the dog do perfect heeling and praise them lavishly when they do it right. If they do it wrong, the prong collar and keeping them tight at my side teaches them to do it right. I don't do it in a punitive way, just insist they do it right for an extended practice session. They learn that whenever they act up, they're going to go heeling, which places them in a very subordinate position. The bonus is you get a dog that knows how to heel.
 
First this is a puppy and they are a challenge. Not obeying is not necessarily dominance. If you see everything as dominance you will make pro thatblems don't exist.

IF you are going to insist on all this routine then you have to do the whole routine then it could be as simple as bordom with the routine. So switch it up. One time only ask for sit and down next time only ask for shake and sit etc. If you don't have a leash on her then you don't have control and that is your problem. Once you ask for any command then you must stay with it til you get it from her. If you leave her for 5 minutes she has no idea why or what it is you really want because she is a PUPPY - short attention span.

So my first command at the door would be sit and put her leash on then ask for just a couple things - she is excited to come in and you expect her to run through a whole routine. Ask for just a couple then let her in and you can then ask for a couple more when she gets inside.
 
Hello everyone, i feel like ive been blowing this place up since i found it... Hahaha. Okay, we are over the skittish part BUT something new has come up. I have followed most of the tips in the being a leader thread, i go out doorways first while she sits. We walk and she stays beside me, and doesnt pull. When outside alone, i make her come, sit, shake (with both paws seperately) and then lay down BEFORE she is allowed inside. But the last few days, she seems to be testing me... Like "what are you gonna do if i dont?" So, if she doesnt go through the come inside routine... She doesnt come inside. I wait 5 min, and try again... And again, and again, and again. She is very smart, she KNOWS what im asking for. I use same commands everytime, and if you have treats in hand, physical gestures on what i want are enough to make it happen. She is 100% if you give her treats for work, but the "you do it because i asked you to" isnt sticking. Is this normal? What is MY course of action to help build her confidence and destroy her attempts at dominating me?

lol i do not think she is DOMINATING you.. i too havent watched ur threads carefully, but it seems were talking about a young pup? welcome to a dobermans way of saying, "im pushing my boundaries to see what I can get away with." Also, if you are feeding her treats EVERY time you are training, she expects them... i always switched it up a bit. Treat, praise or play so she doesn't know what she's going to get. She also may be a bit bored like D4E said... I'd switch up the training & just have some fun with it... Sometimes routine training gets a bit dull. good luck & have fun! :) Puppies are so much joy.. enjoy it while you can!
 
I know its a challenge, and not everything she does makes me think that she is messing with me. I do mix it up, sorry i should have elaborated more. Its not the same drill every time, and the reward is not always the same either. The routine training gets boring for both of us, so i try to make as many different situations and environments as possible. We should be 20 weeks old now, and yes there is very short attention span. I have also had her on the leash inside here lately, that helped a bunch.
 
She's a baby, she's not challenging you. Often we think dogs really "know" something when, in fact, they don't yet. Dogs don't generalize well, meaning they don't understand, at first, that "sit" means "put your butt on the ground" every time. At first, they likely think it means "put your butt on the ground when we are in the living room and Dad is facing me and he stands a certain way." It takes time to teach them that it still means sit in other rooms, out in the world, with distraction...you have to make training fun and make it worth it for the dog so that you eventually get a conditioned response.
 
Yes... Especially true with the distraction part... When we walk, we go right by a peacock farm. And the small babies that escape the crappy fence become stuck outside when they get too fat to get back in. Well, i would have never believed how damn hard a 35 lbs dog can pull. But, when she is in that mindset... She doesnt know her name and is olivious to anything other than what she is fixated on. Its kind of scary to me, she doesnt care about anything but that bird. I want more control over her in these moments, so she isnt a hazard to herself or anyone
 
My theory behind what you described when you first posted is that she either does not know it well enough, is feeding off of your frustration, or doesn't want to work for free. Cookies or treats become a dog's "paycheck". Would you work for your boss if you knew you weren't going to get paid? Nothing wrong with keeping cookies on hand. Also why ask for so much just to go inside? I would ask for one thing, maybe a sit stay, before going inside, but usually if the dog isn't trying to beat me to the door, then I don't ask for anything at all.
 
Its just a sit, or a down or a shake.. not all at once. And she is trying to beat me to the door, so i have to do something. And yes, you are 100% correct... I dont work for free either. I try very hard to keep myself calm, i dont always win... But i do try.
 
Hehehe...I always giggle when I read your feeds and I have been following your progress. No, this is not dominance...this is the equivalent of a preschooler and they do not always understand direction. At this point there are going to be good days and bad learning days so please remember to keep a sense of humor and love love love them to distraction even when they are giving you the paw ;)
 
This sounds like a few normal puppy training issues. Don't be so hard on yourself! For any training try to get it rock solid every time before you work on training with distractions. Stay steady and work with the distractions at a big distance, then slowly decrease the distance of the distractions as you get rock solid at each shorter distance. Jumping from a good heel in your backyard to a good heel with birds running around is a huge stretch for any dog, let alone a curious pup.

Mix it up by changing the order of the training , the treats and work in some play time in between short training sessions. Instead of allowing her to control play time and extend it as she pleases with a door routine, work just on recall and make it all positive. Instead of calling her to the door all the time, be out in the yard and move about when you call her to come. Focus on something in the yard and move with a purpose as you call her. That really helps pups focus on me and they're eager to come see what I've found. You don't have to be standing still to give commands.

Don't call her when you see she's really focused on something until she's rock solid in her recall training. Better to wait a minute or 2 when she isn't focused on something and get her to come rather than to try to get her to follow a command she doesn't really know well when she isn't likely to do it.

As she improves with the recall, mix in a different commands here and there with different treats to keep it interesting. The tip on working with heel a lot is great.

Relax. When something doesn't go right examine what you did and how the dog reacted. Don't try repeating the same thing because that exact thing didn't work. Keep walking a bit. Take step back in your command list to something she does very well and "reset" the training atmosphere with a positive note.

Don't use her name for anything except 100% positive things. Happy name or happy "come" and super treat/praise are what it's all about in the beginning and most of the way through for recall training.

Also good to make sure you aren't overfeeding cuz treats don't work well then. It's hard for some people to cut back a little on the food but you have to cut back by the approximate amount of treats you give in order for them to be effective.
 
Lay down... She gets that one great. Almost 100% of the time she will do it, except when i first get off of work... Its like a circus exploded or a carnival puked in my living room. There are more hairy critters, chewed up nylabones, and squeaky snakes in there than your local petstore, and just about as much noise as you can stand. I do try to take her being a puppy into account, it is just she seems soooo smart... I so desperately want her to be good, and i know that I am the one responsible for making that happen ( so, im still gonna be hard on myself). Thank yall sooooo much for the help, i really do appreciate it all.
 
Yes... Especially true with the distraction part... When we walk, we go right by a peacock farm. And the small babies that escape the crappy fence become stuck outside when they get too fat to get back in. Well, i would have never believed how damn hard a 35 lbs dog can pull. But, when she is in that mindset... She doesnt know her name and is olivious to anything other than what she is fixated on. Its kind of scary to me, she doesnt care about anything but that bird. I want more control over her in these moments, so she isnt a hazard to herself or anyone

When you walk past the peacock farm you have to keep control and not let her get beyond that. Start on your walk and as soon as you see is alert, watching, waiting, looking for a peacock stop and ask her to sit and focus on you then reward. Go back 10 feet and start over until you can get her attention back. Keep working on this and if she is denied her reward of moving forward until she is calm she will soon get it. Patience - she is a doberman and peacocks are prey.

If necessary go to the prong collar so she does not drag you. Take her as close as you can and have her sit and just stand there and let her watch but not react. If she does good then take her a little closer and ask for the sit again and just stand there til she relaxes. It takes time. You will get it.
 
Well, tried the sit and not react routine... Hahahaha they called the fuzz on me. Said i was letting my dog hunt their birds (on a leash, from across the street?!?) Anyways, they just told us to move along. I have been keeping her on the leash, within 3 ft of me since thursday night. I think it is helping, alot. I have also doubled our excersice, almost 7 miles a day...ugh, makes me want to not smoke anymore. I think she is starting to get it tho, i got up this morning without the leash in hand and she got up and followed me thru the house. Without saying a word to her. That was pretty nice, so she got an extended sun bath this afternoon. Shes loving it out there.
 
Sounds like you are describing my pup a lot here!! You are not alone! I'm getting a lot out of this thread.
Replace peacocks with squirrels running everywhere getting ready for winter on our walks & in our yard. I swear we have a few that literally are taunting my pup. She's caught 1 now it's even worse!
 
Hahaha squirrels.... Well, i might get bashed for this... But as far a squirrels are concerned, i am the angel of death. After a few years in the service, and all my life in backwoods tx... Im nothing short of surgical with a pellet gun. Glad you are learning from us
 

Back
Top