• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Altered male vs altered male

Shiraz

Jr Member
Hello,

I have read mixed reviews regarding having a male dobe in the home with another male dog. In all of this info, It has never been clear if they meant altered or unaltered. I will be picking out my replacement pup in a week. I had a female dobe before. I currently have....

1 altered male boxer 1.5 yr
1 altered yorkie 5 yr.

Do you think an altered male dobe would get along, or should I not chance it?

Thanks!
 
My Logan loves to play with the two boxers next door...one male and one female neither are altered....We had a trainer out last year and said the reason the two get along so well is they are very similar in dispositions...

Good luck and keep us posted.....
 
Punchy is rather laid back and submissive with other dogs. Snaffy is more bossy (leave it to the terrier!) But Snaff is not dog aggressive, and would rather just act like the other dogs are not breathing her air. Both my dogs know I am the alpha bitch around here..and second in command is my guy ROFL!
 
If you have a choice of male or female from the litter rather than risk any problems between the males I would opt for a female, but that is JMO.
 
This is just general information for you.

Dobermans are known to often have issues with same sex aggression. It doesn't seem to make any difference whether the males are neutered or not. The common (and reasonable) recommendation is to pair up an opposite sex member in a home that has has--in your case a couple of neutered males.

The catch 22 in this is that Dobe puppies get along with either sex and it doesn't make any difference if they are male, female, spayed or neutered or intact. But the puppies grow up--and adult male Dobe may or may not continue to get along with another male even they he may have been raised with a non-aggressive neutered male.

It is also the case that very mellow dogs--intact or otherwise may play well with other males (neutered or not) for brief periods of time (play dates) while they would not do well with another male living with them.

I'd hedge my bets unless you have a whole lot of experience with managing multiple Doberman males, and get a bitch to go with the other neutered males in the household.
 
This is just general information for you.

Dobermans are known to often have issues with same sex aggression. It doesn't seem to make any difference whether the males are neutered or not. The common (and reasonable) recommendation is to pair up an opposite sex member in a home that has has--in your case a couple of neutered males.

Sorry , I was not clear....my yorkie is a female. That is one of the reasons I was unsure regarding which sex to get. I am leaning towards a female at this point, just worried about female/female aggression..
 
I've never had multiple dogs but I was wondering if bringing a female into a house that already has two males causes a bit of a riff between the two males? (over the female) Even fixed, I think they still have the 'interest'. I doubt another male would be good either but just wondering about the two men and a woman thing! LOL Anyone have that experience?

Oh! I see we were posting at the same time, Shiraz and I see you have a female.....I think when you wrote 'altered' it's assumed you meant a male.

But actually my question isn't just for your instance...I was wondering in general anyway. I still would like to hear what anyone has to say about this.
 
I agree with Dobebug's comments. There is a lot of information out there about male-male aggression - both neutered or not. While it can happen with female-female your chances are much less than male/male.

In fact unless you are a very accomplished dobe handler I doubt any reputable breeder would let you have a male with a male already in the home.

Go for a female. You would hate to take a chance only to later on have to keep them totally separated or need to find one of them another home.
 
I can tell you from experience My Neutered male has little tolerance for any hyperactive activity from my Natural male. Mars will do whatever he can do avoid confrontation but if my other gets wound up and "crashes" into Mars its on just like that. Otherwise hes pretty tolerant and will do what he has to to steer clear of Daemon. But if Daemon wont give him the same respect theirs no telling how quickly things will escalate. We have a No Rough Housing policy in the house now because of this, and that includes humans and k9's alike. We wont even let the kids play or lay on the floor anymore. Just to be on the safe side of the equation.
 
Well I have a male household, 2 of them are intact, one is neutered on the age of 7,5 years, so he still thinks he is the man, he will be 10 next month. We always have multiple males, we bring them in as a puppy and they grow up together, to be honest never have problems, we are the ones who set up the rules, and we learn them things from the beginning. I had a female too, she died 2 years ago almost 10 years, but she was the one who gave me the headaches, I took her away from a family where they had multiple females, she fight on life and dead with a other female, so I took her, that behavior stays her whole life, I always had to be careful with her with other dogs, it doesn't matter to her if they were males or females, not or own dogs she was ok with.

I strongly believe it all have to do with character, fights between dogs or always awfull, if it is female vs female, male vs male or even females vs males. a lot ot things depend how you raise them, if your not experienced i would suggest keep it with one dog, until you learn and know more about dogs and their behavior. And what I think is important, when you have multiple dogs, train them up, learn them to listen, so that they won't fight out of respect for you. Take them separate from time to time learn them stand on their own legs not depending on the rest of the pack.

Here some pictures of the boys

zondag29maart2009052.jpg


zondag29maart2009063.jpg
 
Thank you all, I think I will go with a female. That is what my gut is telling me anyway. I am very experienced with dogs, even showed my basset hound in obedience successfully.......and to get a basset to do anything is pretty difficult ROLF. I am just new to dobes, and from my reading, came to the conclusion there were exceptions for male/male with this breed. I do not mind females at all. My female aussie, scarlet, was a good girl but had a dominant personality with other dogs.....except for my choc lab Mocha "aka godmother" that was the only dog scarlet was ever submissive to. My yorkie is not dog aggressive, but will take the opportunity to put a puppy in it's place when it gets too rowdy.
 
lol Kali is my baby girl and both Male dogs steer clear of her. Shes never met another dog she didnt sink her chops into. but to be fair she dosent purposely try to hurt them. she just has a message and uses her teeth to get the point across. ;) When Shes pissed the boys run from her but when the boys mess with one another either runs, and both will stand there ground. Fortunately we haven't had an issue in several months now. but we did have to make some major lifestyle changes to prevent male on male fights. I also used to raise hybrid Wolves and never had to make the concessions we do with the male dobermans. I would have thought the wolves would have the same aggression issues but they didn't.
 
Sorry , I was not clear....my yorkie is a female. That is one of the reasons I was unsure regarding which sex to get. I am leaning towards a female at this point, just worried about female/female aggression..

Ooops--sorry Shiraz. I misread your head count on the dogs. I think I'd worry less about bitch arguments between a spayed bitch who is now five and who will be seven by the time a female Dobe would be mature at, say, two. Even though Yorkies can be amazingly aggressive (which shouldn't be all that surprising--they are terriers--just small ones) I would suspect it will be easier to keep the peace with a dog and two bitches than two dogs (both fairly good sized and closer to the same age) and a spayed bitch. Even though female female aggression is known in Dobes and bitch fights can actually be much more serious than fights between males there still is more same sex aggression likely to go on between males than bitches.

I'd still go with a bitch rather than a dog considering the current dog population in males and females and breeds.
.
~~~~~~~
99722f7e.gif
"Double Post Auto Merge"
99722f7e.gif
~~~~~~~
.​
I've never had multiple dogs but I was wondering if bringing a female into a house that already has two males causes a bit of a riff between the two males? (over the female) Even fixed, I think they still have the 'interest'. I doubt another male would be good either but just wondering about the two men and a woman thing! LOL Anyone have that experience?

Oh! I see we were posting at the same time, Shiraz and I see you have a female.....I think when you wrote 'altered' it's assumed you meant a male.

But actually my question isn't just for your instance...I was wondering in general anyway. I still would like to hear what anyone has to say about this.

My Buddy,

Yes, you are correct--bringing a female into a house that already has two males in residence can cause problems. But it really depends a lot on breeds of dogs, ages of dogs etc. I'm just going to talk about Dobermans--or at least mostly about Dobermans.

I keep males. I don't keep bitches at all. I haven't owned a bitch since the mid 60's. I do, however, dog sit for Dobes belonging to friends. This includes an array of bitches both neutered and intact as well as more males--both neutered and intact. You can literally feel the difference in the house when there is a bitch (whether neutered or intact) in residence here. I send any visiting bitches out with males only--the males they normally live with or mine--I just don't send two bitches and a dog out together nor do I send out two dogs (whether neutered or intact or any combination) with a bitch. Things are always much tenser when I have bitches in the house.

I've never really decided whether it's because the males, even the neutered males really have any 'interest'--as in sexual interest or not but the males definitely have a proprietary interest so I just make sure it doesn't get to escalate.

When I had an intact male Australian Shepherd I could send him out with males, females, neutered or not--made no difference. The pack mentality of Aussies is very different than Dobes. There are some same sex aggressive Aussies around but it's uncommon in the breed. And I presently dog sit occasionally for a couple of young male Goldens--same story there--they can go out with almost any dog male or female except for one of my males--that's the one who is very tolerant of very young puppies of either sex but by four or five months unless they live here all the time he has no tolerance and fancies himself the fun patrol and imagines that he is the disciplinarian around here. All this in spite of the fact that he was neutered shortly after he finished his championship.
 
Ok I don't own Dobes, I own American Pit Bull Terriers, but I will tell you having two males in a household or more can be done, and since your other male is already neutered and you are bringing this one in as a pup, you should have no problems as long as the pup also knows that you are in charge and the other dogs have senority. Seeing as how I own a Dog Aggressive breed, I would never bring another intact male into my household as I know that Phoenix would kill it, he would be fine with it as a puppy but when it came into it's own there would be fights and I really don't want to have to crate and rotate, I would, just don't want to have too. same sex aggression can happen whether it be male/male or female/female. hmmm not sure what else I want to say, I am a little bit but its early in the morning and I will rattle, lol
 
Thank you Dobebug...and Tye and Von. You all have good points and I've taken it all to heart. I have never had multiple dogs and at this point in my life, I doubt I ever will. Even before I came to this forum, I knew some of the 'issues' of having several dogs and like I said, if I ever did get at least one more, it would be the opposite sex of what I have. Beyond that, I think I would have to give it serious thought. I'd have to consider all the things Dobebug said, the breed, the sex, the age and temperament. And like Tye said, I don't want to be rotating crates either. If I were younger and wanted to do something special with them, it would make all the difference. But for now, one or two is all I can handle, but this information is all good to know anyway! Never stop learning! :)
 
When we finally decided to get Della, I purposely chose a female because of hearing all the male on male issues (neutered or not), since I didn't want to take chances on not having it work out.
Boris and Della do have their spats; especially now when Della is "coming of age", :eek: but they work it out very nicely as long as Della gets her way. LOL! In all seriousness though, I think you're right in leaning toward a female to keep it on the safer side.
We also have an old altered female Sheltie, and while her and Boris don't get along at all, I was surprised to see her warming up to Della. :dunno: I guess as stated, much of it varies from dog to dog....
 
if i ever bring another one into this household,it would be a female, don't would take the chance again with another male, since i do have two and i'm lucky that they get along well so far, so next one will be a female ;)
 
LOOK OUT FOR YOUR YORKIE!! My friend had a male and two female dobes.. and a female yorkie.. the yorkie was the boss and SO spiteful! LOL, if she got upset she would poop on my friends foot
 
LOOK OUT FOR YOUR YORKIE!! My friend had a male and two female dobes.. and a female yorkie.. the yorkie was the boss and SO spiteful! LOL, if she got upset she would poop on my friends foot

That is no joke LOL. Snaff can be a twit, I have to keep her in line.
 
I think I agree with Jan the most. It all depends on the temperment of the dobes. Both my guys have been altered but my female, Chloe, is definitely the more aggressive of the two. but that is just my experience with my two. Every situation is different. If I had known more about being the alpha when I got Chloe things might be different now. It sounds like you know what you're doing.
 

Back
Top