Solid Recall

Oh, dang! You remember that!?

@Cranekc35 I'm sorry if I missed it but what situations are you in where your dog is off leash?

I would say there are very few situations in which a dog needs to be off leash where a long lead won't suffice (trialing is a different story but you aren't generally allowed any gear and dogs are generally contained, somehow). Off leash privilege's are earned (via @Ravenbird 's story, above!) but it takes a long time to build up that trust and it's scary when it's tested.

Is recall still important to train? Absolutely! More so curious about what off-leash opportunities you're looking at.
No situation in particular. Just something I am wanting to build on. I have been keeping him on the long lead and working with him daily. I have started using his high value tug toy and it seems to be working. I will keep you posted! :)
 
Thanks for all of the input here! Once again, greatly appreciated! I do use a prong collar and long lead right now. It does make me think twice about going back to using the e-collar after reading your stories.
 
I got my first dobe in Jan. Hes now 11 months old. Hes virtually never leashed (in stores only). I’m fortunate to spend all day everyday with him being self employed. I have a lot of experience training all types of different breeds over the years for an average joe. I will admit I have a massive handicap just due to the amount of time I get to spend with my dog correcting him throughout the day. All that being said, I have found the best way to train a solid recall in any dog is to just do it constantly. I make my dog come to me countless times a day for absolutely no reason other than just for some love or maybe a treat occasionally. When out running around the park as a young puppy I would call him back to me dozens and dozens of times. At the 7-10 month range he became defiant when he was more than 30yds away so I got an ecollar to correct that behavior immediately. I will wake him from an nap, call him off a bone chewing frenzy, stop him while eating, at the dog park playing, etc. and make him report to the boss. The other crucial factor in a strong recall is NEVER letting them get their way. If you call the dog back to you, they MUST get to you one way or another. If you call the dog and they don’t come, drop what you are doing and go get them. My dog was running trails today hundreds of yards away across ravines chasing squirrels and I can call him back no problem (other than him locating me in the echoing timber). Repetition and consistency.
 
I got my first dobe in Jan. Hes now 11 months old. Hes virtually never leashed (in stores only). I’m fortunate to spend all day everyday with him being self employed. I have a lot of experience training all types of different breeds over the years for an average joe. I will admit I have a massive handicap just due to the amount of time I get to spend with my dog correcting him throughout the day. All that being said, I have found the best way to train a solid recall in any dog is to just do it constantly. I make my dog come to me countless times a day for absolutely no reason other than just for some love or maybe a treat occasionally. When out running around the park as a young puppy I would call him back to me dozens and dozens of times. At the 7-10 month range he became defiant when he was more than 30yds away so I got an ecollar to correct that behavior immediately. I will wake him from an nap, call him off a bone chewing frenzy, stop him while eating, at the dog park playing, etc. and make him report to the boss. The other crucial factor in a strong recall is NEVER letting them get their way. If you call the dog back to you, they MUST get to you one way or another. If you call the dog and they don’t come, drop what you are doing and go get them. My dog was running trails today hundreds of yards away across ravines chasing squirrels and I can call him back no problem (other than him locating me in the echoing timber). Repetition and consistency.
thank you!
 
He's 2.5 years old. I did use an e-collar for a few months earlier on, but to be honest, I wanted to get away from it because I want a relationship with him only where he listens to me and not the device. He has done so much better in other areas without it. I have no doubt that it can be done. I've watched videos of others doing it, but like you said, it takes a lot of time to train this. I work and play with him for hours daily. I don't have a problem with this type of commitment. I just was curious if anyone had any other ideas or what worked for them without the ecollar that I could try. Thanks so much for the input. :)
I’m a ways behind you as far as age, but I was also reluctant to use an ecollar in the beginning. I thought I could manage without and I did well for the first 6 months. It was like a switch flipped one day and he felt free once he got so far away. We left the park and went straight to TSC and picked up their best unit. My goal is the same as you, i don’t want to be dependent on the collar long term. Once he showed dramatic improvements on the collar for a few months I started taking him out late at night without the collar on. We progressed from there to familiar places like at my parents or friends places at night. This weekend I let him go hiking without it one day. Always working the recall command consistently.
 
e-collar is not a shame thing, it's a tool like a long line or a choke chain or treats or ball. I use to think I would never need one "because I knew how to train", then I thought I could use one to get us through the teenage phase. Now I know my dogs drive is higher than I can control and the e-collar is the savior.

I'll present you with an example just happened today. My friend and I went hiking in the forest, Asha always has an e-collar on off leash, not because I need it, but in case I need it. My friends dog use to run after deer, so she used an e-collar to train her dog not to. Cranked it up extremely high, the dog went after deer and she called her back , no response, hit the stim, heard the dog squeal but still no recall, hit the stim again and the dog came back to her. This was repeated one other time and has NEVER not recalled after chasing deer again. That was years ago and today, we came across a herd of deer, her dog tore out after them, no e-collar, was called back and she returned instantly (and praised lavishly when she did). Asha watched intently but never took chase (e-collar on, but I didn't have to use it).

It's a great training tool, it can be life saving and more than that, it gives your dog more freedom for the rest of its life by being reliable off leash.
I took an e collar for my boy like 3 weeks ago and introduced slowly at level 5 sometimes in busy enviroments at level 10 and he did great till today he was off leash and he saw a small dog at the park i called him, no response he just went straight for the dog (hes not aggressive thanks god he just needs to sniff every dogs butts lol) but the owner got scaret i panicked and amped the e collar at level 100 and i keept it on recalling him for like 30 seconds till i arrived to split them but no response from the dog because of the stim he looked like he didnt care at all. Now im worried since i know i cant go more than lvl 100 and he showed that he doesnt care will this be a forever scenario? He sees a dog decides to chase i press the button at 100 and nothing? Does it have to do with the e collar brand ? I bought a “cheap one” like 80$ in amazon… or just my dog doesnt care about stim when he wants to do something
 
e-collar is not a shame thing, it's a tool like a long line or a choke chain or treats or ball. I use to think I would never need one "because I knew how to train", then I thought I could use one to get us through the teenage phase. Now I know my dogs drive is higher than I can control and the e-collar is the savior.

I'll present you with an example just happened today. My friend and I went hiking in the forest, Asha always has an e-collar on off leash, not because I need it, but in case I need it. My friends dog use to run after deer, so she used an e-collar to train her dog not to. Cranked it up extremely high, the dog went after deer and she called her back , no response, hit the stim, heard the dog squeal but still no recall, hit the stim again and the dog came back to her. This was repeated one other time and has NEVER not recalled after chasing deer again. That was years ago and today, we came across a herd of deer, her dog tore out after them, no e-collar, was called back and she returned instantly (and praised lavishly when she did). Asha watched intently but never took chase (e-collar on, but I didn't have to use it).

It's a great training tool, it can be life saving and more than that, it gives your dog more freedom for the rest of its life by being reliable off leash.
 
i panicked and amped the e collar at level 100 and i keept it on recalling him for like 30 seconds till i arrived to split them but no response from the dog because of the stim he looked like he didnt care at all. Now im worried since i know i cant go more than lvl 100 and he showed that he doesnt care will this be a forever scenario? He sees a dog decides to chase i press the button at 100 and nothing? Does it have to do with the e collar brand ? I bought a “cheap one” like 80$ in amazon… or just my dog doesnt care about stim when he wants to do something
Sounds like either the e-collar was not making contact or is faulty. Did your dog 100% look like he didn't feel anything? Or did feel it and didn't care? A few dogs in extremely high drive can ignore 100, but not just wanting to play. Test the collar, first on your wrist. Lay the collar on a table, lay the inside of your wrist on the contact points and try it at 3, then 5, and on up until you feel a tingle. My Dogtra goes up to 110 and I can feel the tingle at about 10 or 12 easily. If you aren't feeling anything, make sure the battery is fully charged and working. Once you are certain that the collar is in working order, put it on your dog properly: Very snug way high on his neck, just under the ears, tight enough that it won't turn. The contact points should be on the side of the neck, not under the chin and not on top of his neck. When he runs around, it should not flop down under the chin - that means it's too loose. As he's standing around in your house, put it on 5 and press the button, if no reaction turn it up. The only reaction you are looking for is something like looking around like "what was that?" - usually they look at the floor to try to find the source of the feeling. With zero distractions standing around in your home, he should show a reaction to the stimulation button.
 
That’s a hell of a bond and a shit ton of work, time and commitment right there- a lot…..so much that he will always overlook any distraction both animate and inanimate.

Ragnar was a rehome to me when he was 4-5months old so he had developed some bad habits and was very independent. He was a high drive asshat that had his own agenda when it came down to being reactionary to other dogs and this high drive made him numb to my voice during recalls.

The ECollar and prong was an absolute game changer for us but I will not delve into this but want to share with you with what did work for us other than the ECollar/prong.

All three of my daughters played competitive soccer so we were at the soccer fields every day (practices 5:00-6:30 and 6:30-8:00) and all weekend for years.

I worked with Ragnar every single day rain or shine for a solid 12-15months straight. Our bond was immense and so strong that we just were connected inside. I do agree with what @Cferg said with having to train in the highest drive possible in order to be able to gain respect and expect results when he goes into that high drive. The best most distractive environments we trained in were:
1. A packed soccer complex full of kids, people and other dogs.
2. The “outside” areas of a large packed dog park…distance from the fence would be dependent on his reaction to other dogs and how well he kept true focus on me. True focus is very important here.
3. In New Orleans- Lafrinere Park- is a very large bird sanctuary with fricking all kinds of birds everywhere and they are normalized to people and dogs. I would walk Ragnar short or long leash through 50-60 birds on the ground. It was absolutely insane the first five times and was a spectacle. The park rangers saw a black Doberman a mile away and watched us closely.

Ragnar would get sooo jacked up that it was pretty crazy. The key thing with him was to recognize his tells for when and how he amped up.
1. Extreme intense focus that just wouldn’t come off the object(s).
2. Immediate deep breathing.
3. Lip curling
4. Growl then barking
5. Full all out lunging.

I realize that your Doberman is prob much more trusting and responsive to training…I am just trying to paint the picture of how these highly distractive environments significantly helped my training.

Good luck.
When would you suggest the e collar age wise?
Also, prong collar?

Pepper is about to enter teenage times and I want to make sure she is complaint with commands. So far on her long line she will recall, but if she’s intensely sniffing I have to wait for her nose to come up to recall. She’s still young, yes, but like you said if they’re sniffing and focused on whatever it is, I don’t foresee her just recalling asap.

We also have travel soccer with my younger son and I would like to being her to practice and games. As for now I do think she’d be fine, we could work on it, but once over threshold she may melt down.
 
Sounds like either the e-collar was not making contact or is faulty. Did your dog 100% look like he didn't feel anything? Or did feel it and didn't care? A few dogs in extremely high drive can ignore 100, but not just wanting to play. Test the collar, first on your wrist. Lay the collar on a table, lay the inside of your wrist on the contact points and try it at 3, then 5, and on up until you feel a tingle. My Dogtra goes up to 110 and I can feel the tingle at about 10 or 12 easily. If you aren't feeling anything, make sure the battery is fully charged and working. Once you are certain that the collar is in working order, put it on your dog properly: Very snug way high on his neck, just under the ears, tight enough that it won't turn. The contact points should be on the side of the neck, not under the chin and not on top of his neck. When he runs around, it should not flop down under the chin - that means it's too loose. As he's standing around in your house, put it on 5 and press the button, if no reaction turn it up. The only reaction you are looking for is something like looking around like "what was that?" - usually they look at the floor to try to find the source of the feeling. With zero distractions standing around in your home, he should show a reaction to the stimulation button.
The collar itself works but maybe the lvl 100 is not really a lvl 100 because after we started walking away from the dog i was giving corrections at the level 5-10 and he was responding and i could see his neck twitching a little
 
When would you suggest the e collar age wise?
Also, prong collar?

Pepper is about to enter teenage times and I want to make sure she is complaint with commands. So far on her long line she will recall, but if she’s intensely sniffing I have to wait for her nose to come up to recall. She’s still young, yes, but like you said if they’re sniffing and focused on whatever it is, I don’t foresee her just recalling asap.

We also have travel soccer with my younger son and I would like to being her to practice and games. As for now I do think she’d be fine, we could work on it, but once over threshold she may melt down.
Just start reeeaaally slow low level stim with a leash on always. I speak from experience when i say leeeeash on lol mine when he felt the stim for the first time tried to escape my backyard lol
 
When would you suggest the e collar age wise?
Also, prong collar?
I don't start the prong until at least 6 months and the e-collar a little later than that. Olive is 11+ months now and she still hasn't needed either since a slip lead works fine. I didn't start Elroy on the prong until he was close to a year but he's never really given me a reason to do much of a correction with it.
 
I don't start the prong until at least 6 months and the e-collar a little later than that. Olive is 11+ months now and she still hasn't needed either since a slip lead works fine. I didn't start Elroy on the prong until he was close to a year but he's never really given me a reason to do much of a correction with it.
I wonder how she’ll do and I’ll wait and see. Really at this point she isn’t a crazy puller and does recall really well on long line. So no rush at all.

Thanks so much for the advice appreciate it.
 
I don't start the prong until at least 6 months and the e-collar a little later than that. Olive is 11+ months now and she still hasn't needed either since a slip lead works fine. I didn't start Elroy on the prong until he was close to a year but he's never really given me a reason to do much of a correction with it.
I wonder how she’ll do and I’ll wait and see. Really at this point she isn’t a crazy puller and does recall really well on long line. So no rush at all.
Yes - train the dog in front of you. Some never need it! Rejoice over that!

Just start reeeaaally slow low level stim with a leash on always. I speak from experience when i say leeeeash on lol mine when he felt the stim for the first time tried to escape my backyard lol
Please go slow with this, be sure you understand the pressure & release. A dog/puppy should never ever choose to leave you or their safe yard when they feel a stim. They should come to you and stick like glue. There should never be a flee response, rather it should be an instant desire to come to you - you should be his safety zone and the place he values the most. These reactions you describe suggest he is not understanding the circumstance.
 
When would you suggest the e collar age wise?
Also, prong collar?

Pepper is about to enter teenage times and I want to make sure she is complaint with commands. So far on her long line she will recall, but if she’s intensely sniffing I have to wait for her nose to come up to recall. She’s still young, yes, but like you said if they’re sniffing and focused on whatever it is, I don’t foresee her just recalling asap.

We also have travel soccer with my younger son and I would like to being her to practice and games. As for now I do think she’d be fine, we could work on it, but once over threshold she may melt down.
Both are absolutely great tools!!

Prong collar- I started both of mine at 6months, absolute game changer. From a consistent hard roll to nicely walking next to you. With Ragnar, it was a permanent tool that had to used. Freyja is very sensitive to it and reacts as soon as there is tension.

ECollar- I think this is more of a maturity issue…I did not start using the ECollar until they were well with obedience and discipline. They know all the rules of the game. I think this is better because they have a full understanding for who you are, what your expectations are and they know for sure what the rules are with consequences of breaking them.

A young pup is still flighty, jumping around in all joy of being outside. A 10month old who has been obedience trained is structured and hardened somewhat, has experience….they focus a lot more rather than chasing butterflies in the wind.

I just love the ECollar, I feel extremely confident with it being my invisible leash.
 

Back
Top