Practicing Obedience

Ravenbird

Moderator
$ Forum Donor $
Video is helping me see my mistakes, my posture etc. Hard to watch your dog and hold yourself properly, then to find how many bad habits were developed or cues given improperly. Note this is geared toward BH obedience, not AKC, so there are differences in the rules. It's kind of confounding - About turns always to the left instead of to the right, return to the dog is to basic position, not around the back of the dog - it goes on and on. I'm so frustrated at lack of live teachers in my life, Asha is almost 2 1/2 years old. She improves all the time, but I want and need more direction.

 
Yuupp practice, practice and more practice! That is something I need to do is a video.
Yes, we all learn bad habits.

She looked pretty good. Good focus on you. A little forging a few times. I would not call her to you (10sec. mark) from the sit position. The dog is called only from the down to you in the BH. Swings a little wide on a turn.
Practicing I would still keep her on a lead.

Do you pay (with a ball or tug) her when she is doing things right? Talking to her? Try changing your pace.
Do you do the walking down or sit first then tell her to down? Also, the walking sit. Would start practicing that because you will do that in IGP1

Keep up the good work!!!!!!!!
 
Thanks @strykerdobe - Yeah, I know about not calling from the sit in IGP, but I also do some AKC stuff where that does happen. Asha is also really bad about making up in her mind what's next so I try to mix things up a lot to prevent that. I'm actually doing the whole BH routine now, so on & off lead, including practicing how to remove it and not be clumsy or distracting while doing it (who would have even thought one needed to practice that? ...but I do now!) this is just a little video of a mix of stuff. The forging is her worst thing. All my fault and extremely hard to un-do. I use a ball or tug a lot for after we're done, but she forges worse when she knows I have it, doesn't matter if it's in the middle of my back, armpit, hidden in a pocket, if she knows I have it she wraps around front. :scratch: At the same time of course she is much more animated and turned on in her heeling. I haven't started doing the sit/down in motion yet, but I was doing it with about a 1 second pause. Now I read it has to be 3 seconds or no pause at all for the BH, no half-way... Crikey it just goes on & on. :rofl: "It's just heeling" they said. "It's easy" they said.

What about you & your youngster? Are you doing IGP with him?
 
Thanks @strykerdobe - Yeah, I know about not calling from the sit in IGP, but I also do some AKC stuff where that does happen. Asha is also really bad about making up in her mind what's next so I try to mix things up a lot to prevent that. I'm actually doing the whole BH routine now, so on & off lead, including practicing how to remove it and not be clumsy or distracting while doing it (who would have even thought one needed to practice that? ...but I do now!) this is just a little video of a mix of stuff. The forging is her worst thing. All my fault and extremely hard to un-do. I use a ball or tug a lot for after we're done, but she forges worse when she knows I have it, doesn't matter if it's in the middle of my back, armpit, hidden in a pocket, if she knows I have it she wraps around front. :scratch: At the same time of course she is much more animated and turned on in her heeling. I haven't started doing the sit/down in motion yet, but I was doing it with about a 1 second pause. Now I read it has to be 3 seconds or no pause at all for the BH, no half-way... Crikey it just goes on & on. :rofl: "It's just heeling" they said. "It's easy" they said.

What about you & your youngster? Are you doing IGP with him?

For sure it's good to do different things in a different order. Dobes are smart and they start thinking (anticipating) what is next.

That was another bad habit rewarding from the wrong hand which causes the wrap around. Sometimes I do still do the payoff with the right hand. But I fling the ball or tug behind my back over the dogs back away from them. This way they don't see the payoff coming from across the front. Most of the time I have the ball or tug cupped in my left hand and hold it over the withers.

Have you tried one of the magnetic balls, so she sees it and place it in front of your left shoulder?
For forging on lead, I have the lead run behind me holding the lead in my right hand. It might give you more control on correcting.

Always payoff when she is doing something right.

I know one thing that works for one dog might need to do something a little different for another.

Yes, our female Zara has her BH. She had issues with the dumbbells. Working on it. She never had the good focus, I would payoff a lot but she would still look away. But otherwise, her obedience is good. Her long down I can walk all the way down field. Zara is only a medium drive Dobe. Some days it just like she doesn't want to be at club.

Arson is High drive and has his BH and going for his IGP1 in spring. :fingersx: We didn't make IGP1 back in Nov. 2021, his Tracking Sucked! But his Obedience he got an 88 (needed some work on Dumbbells), cleaning up other things and his protection he got a 93. He already running all the Blinds, doing the back transport.
 
I fling the ball or tug behind my back over the dogs back away from them. This way they don't see the payoff coming from across the front. Most of the time I have the ball or tug cupped in my left hand and hold it over the withers.
I'll have to try this. I've tried to fling it behind but she's so fast and goes up & at my hand. I'll try over the withers in the left hand. LOL, I imagine I'll need the prong to get that done the first few times.
Have you tried one of the magnetic balls, so she sees it and place it in front of your left shoulder?
I haven't tried the magnetic ball yet, that may go on my list...

For forging on lead, I have the lead run behind me holding the lead in my right hand. It might give you more control on correcting.
Yes, I do lots of this. I'll for sure do it when I try to heel her with the ball in my left hand over her withers.

Always payoff when she is doing something right.
I do this. One of my mistakes - again, working alone with no experienced person observing to shout at me - was too much duration before reward. I should have been doing tiny baby steps right before I tried 10 or 15 steps. Live & learn.
Yes, our female Zara has her BH. She had issues with the dumbbells. Working on it. She never had the good focus, I would payoff a lot but she would still look away. But otherwise, her obedience is good. Her long down I can walk all the way down field. Zara is only a medium drive Dobe. Some days it just like she doesn't want to be at club.

Arson is High drive and has his BH and going for his IGP1 in spring. :fingersx: We didn't make IGP1 back in Nov. 2021, his Tracking Sucked! But his Obedience he got an 88 (needed some work on Dumbbells), cleaning up other things and his protection he got a 93. He already running all the Blinds, doing the back transport.
Congrats on all that!!! We need more pictures and updates in the IGP thread! Hint hint.
 
I love those dramatic little sounds she makes every so often though. LOL
She leaks. There was a ball on the ground that I let her go get when we're done and she just about can't stand it. But it increases her drive & I'm trying to capture that. Training without the toy she only leaks on a long down. Cold weather, cold ground, she can get pretty pitiful. :facepalm:
 
You guys are doing great!! I wish you had someone in person to work with too. I know exactly how frustrating it can be to work alone.

I know not enough about IGP and my comment would be to back up a little with the leash still to correct some behaviors and/or reward sooner, but you touched on that in a reply above! You can see where she starts leaking/getting frustrated, I think just before that may be her limit before you can work off leash for that long.

Super off leash heeling! Thanks for sharing. I'll eagerly be watching this thread for tips 😊 I always like the inside about turn anyways. The dog really has to move out of your way and have more hind end awareness.
 
She looks good to me! I love those dramatic little sounds she makes every so often though. LOL
She leaks. There was a ball on the ground that I let her go get when we're done and she just about can't stand it. But it increases her drive & I'm trying to capture that. Training without the toy she only leaks on a long down. Cold weather, cold ground, she can get pretty pitiful. :facepalm:
Her little vocals, means she has some attitude. I love that.
First I wondered why do you call it 'leaking', then I realized that's because they're not supposed to do it, do you lose points for that in a competition situation?

If I were making competition point rules I would want to add points for expressive character like that, lol.
 
Good job, I agree with what was said above. I never recall from a sit. I do AKC as well, trust me she will come when you call, I just like a super stable sit position. More rewards, either throwing the ball straight to the left or dog goes behind you to get ball from your right side. This will help with forging. You can also, when stopped bring your right hand with ball over the top of your left shoulder mark and drop the ball down straight. Only mark and reward perfect position. Have a friend spot for you to see if she is straight. I practice standing in front of a mirror and reward basic position at home. Reward with food or toys. Call her from different angles while you face the mirror. If she comes in and is crooked, just give a simple negative reinforcer and take her back and try again. No readjusting in basic. If it is not perfect the first time, do it again. She will learn rewards only come from the correct basic, this will help once moving again. Then same thing when moving, if she forged or her butt is out just use your negative reinforcer tell her fuss or back if she knows that command, then immediately mark and reward her being correct. She will figure it out. Good luck, feel free to message me if you have questions anytime. Have fun
 
Good job, I agree with what was said above. I never recall from a sit. I do AKC as well, trust me she will come when you call, I just like a super stable sit position. More rewards, either throwing the ball straight to the left or dog goes behind you to get ball from your right side. This will help with forging. You can also, when stopped bring your right hand with ball over the top of your left shoulder mark and drop the ball down straight. Only mark and reward perfect position. Have a friend spot for you to see if she is straight. I practice standing in front of a mirror and reward basic position at home. Reward with food or toys. Call her from different angles while you face the mirror. If she comes in and is crooked, just give a simple negative reinforcer and take her back and try again. No readjusting in basic. If it is not perfect the first time, do it again. She will learn rewards only come from the correct basic, this will help once moving again. Then same thing when moving, if she forged or her butt is out just use your negative reinforcer tell her fuss or back if she knows that command, then immediately mark and reward her being correct. She will figure it out. Good luck, feel free to message me if you have questions anytime. Have fun
This is so helpful to read:). Training by oneself sometimes gets the mind kinda stuck. Thanks @Doberman Gang! And thank you @Ravenbird for starting the thread. Even for us with 'just a companion pet' this is such good inspiration for training.
 
I realized that's because they're not supposed to do it, do you lose points for that in a competition situation?
Correct, yes. It's actually stress, even if it's happy stress, if that makes sense. Like children getting out of control, even if it's a happy out of control.

Good job, I agree with what was said above. I never recall from a sit. I do AKC as well, trust me she will come when you call, I just like a super stable sit position.

OK, that's two votes to quit recalls from the sit, I'd better stop! She does have an excellent recall from any distance, so you're right, no worries about that.

More rewards, either throwing the ball straight to the left or dog goes behind you to get ball from your right side. This will help with forging. You can also, when stopped bring your right hand with ball over the top of your left shoulder mark and drop the ball down straight. Only mark and reward perfect position.
So even in a two minute session, several ball reward breaks? If I do the BH routine, I try to break it up so she doesn't anticipate the pattern, but we have done the pattern several times and is pretty good. Break that into sections with play between each one?

I did try re-doing my throw and realized when I lift my arm to toss, my arm comes forward first, then toss back. As soon as she sees the forward motion of my arm (left or right) she jumps in front of me, then either spins to go get the ball to the left or runs around to go right, but she constantly comes forward the second I make a motion with my ball hand. Correct that? If I keep my arm straight down and just flick it backward with my wrist it's not going to go very far, but I'll try that. I need to see a slow mo video of how you guys get it to go behind you, LOL!

Only mark and reward perfect position. Have a friend spot for you to see if she is straight. I practice standing in front of a mirror and reward basic position at home. Reward with food or toys. Call her from different angles while you face the mirror. If she comes in and is crooked, just give a simple negative reinforcer and take her back and try again. No readjusting in basic. If it is not perfect the first time, do it again. She will learn rewards only come from the correct basic, this will help once moving again. Then same thing when moving, if she forged or her butt is out just use your negative reinforcer tell her fuss or back if she knows that command, then immediately mark and reward her being correct. She will figure it out. Good luck, feel free to message me if you have questions anytime. Have fun
I've used a mirror at the end of my long hallway to practice the basic and focus so I don't have to twist to see what she's doing. It helped a LOT. I don't have a mirror or place that I can think of to use a mirror for recall though. "Call from different angles" - do you mean not down the field in front of you? Over to one side or another so she comes in at an angle and has to straighten herself for the front? I don't want to call her to basic at this point as it took me ages to un-do her going from front to basic before I asked.

We are having fun, she has improved tons since I learned to increase drive with the ball/tug. She still has tons of food drive. I so badly need an instructor in real time, even watching the videos I can see what needs improvement but don't know how to go about it.

Thanks All, for the compliments and the suggestions. Onward and forward - !
 
Correct, yes. It's actually stress, even if it's happy stress, if that makes sense. Like children getting out of control, even if it's a happy out of control.



OK, that's two votes to quit recalls from the sit, I'd better stop! She does have an excellent recall from any distance, so you're right, no worries about that.


So even in a two minute session, several ball reward breaks? If I do the BH routine, I try to break it up so she doesn't anticipate the pattern, but we have done the pattern several times and is pretty good. Break that into sections with play between each one?

I did try re-doing my throw and realized when I lift my arm to toss, my arm comes forward first, then toss back. As soon as she sees the forward motion of my arm (left or right) she jumps in front of me, then either spins to go


I've used a mirror at the end of my long hallway to practice the basic and focus so I don't have to twist to see what she's doing. It helped a LOT. I don't have a mirror or place that I can think of to use a mirror for recall though. "Call from different angles" - do you mean not down the field in front of you? Over to one side or another so she comes in at an angle and has to straighten herself for the front? I don't want to call her to basic at this point as it took me ages to un-do her going from front to basic before I asked.
Yes lots of rewards done randomly. Always put your dog into the highest state of drive before you train. Either back tie and crack a whip saying revere to get her barking and jumping. Cap with a sit, unhook back tie then start training. Or hold the ball and make her her miss several times then ask for a sit and start. If she is not loaded your routine will suffer at the trial. Dogs naturally get amped at a trial so you need to try to create that type of drive before you start training.

My club people only so the BH pattern by themselves, no dog. The dog doesn’t need to learn it only follow us. I always just train random heeling. All moving exercise done with a random number of build up steps. I use cues for my dog so it knows what I about to ask.

I never finish my dog from a front until my finishes are solid and my dog understands my cues. To not contaminate any exercises, I will make missed with the ball while working sit, down and Stand. From different positions here I will put myself in random places to the dogs position sone times over exaggerating the finish (dog may have to go 270 degrees to get there).
Once I am confident with e the position and speed I will start teaching cues. It is as simple. If I am not looking at my dog, my dog should never leave a position. I will correct them if they do.
Picking your dog up from the long down; once you return you must look at the judge to tell you to sit your dog. So you are not looking at your dog, judge signals for you to sit your dog, you slowly look down to your dog and say sit. I practice this pretendingbto look at a judge, this works for IGP and AKC, you will not get pointed fir handler help if you a subtle with your head movement.
Same on recall, go your 30 paces turn and only look at the judge. When judge signals recall, slowly look to your dog the call here. I look my dog all the way in them immediately look back to the judge. There is no cue from judge on the finish but I just count to 3 then look back and ask for fuss.
Going back to the position exercise; then after asking for a sit, down or stand, as you change positions to ask for a finish do not look at your dog. Now you can either ask for a finish or a new position. Sit to down or stand, stand to down or sit, ect.. this will now help with the AKC position exercises and reinforce the communication the a command is coming when you look to your dog.
Sorry for the long message. Hope this helps.
 
That's a great sign & excellent reminder. I totally get it - but when & how do you fade treats & balls so you can trial without? I know you keep using them forever in training. I've been alternating - a longish session like the video above but 3 or 4 minutes, always ending in a play session. Then a few days with very short drills, about 1 minute, then a ball, then a drill, then a ball. After a long down (she can do 10 minutes now) I walk calmly back, have her sit, then heel a few feet then we party. I don't want her to think she can party as soon as I return, but I want her to have big rewards for that long down.
 
That's a great sign & excellent reminder. I totally get it - but when & how do you fade treats & balls so you can trial without? I know you keep using them forever in training. I've been alternating - a longish session like the video above but 3 or 4 minutes, always ending in a play session. Then a few days with very short drills, about 1 minute, then a ball, then a drill, then a ball. After a long down (she can do 10 minutes now) I walk calmly back, have her sit, then heel a few feet then we party. I don't want her to think she can party as soon as I return, but I want her to have big rewards for that long down.
It is all done with random reinforcement. I always play ball before I go on the field. I then either hand the ball off to someone or place the ball somewhere before entering the field. When I am training I will always have a se big ball hidden so I can reward behavior. Of course, you won’t have one during a trial but you need to maintain the same picture fir your dog. I train for the check in and check out, sometimes I reward immediately other times I naybheel to the start or long down then reward. Other times it can come during a portion of heeling (never training the pattern.) sometimes I may reward basic position at the start of an exercise. I want my dog to think that the next thing he does correct is what gets him his ball. So rewarding at all these different times builds his focus. What then occurs is the longer you go without giving a reward the more driven and focused they will become anticipating the reward. This is why random rewards, sone times given repetitively in a single position snd sometimes not given fir long durations are necessary. When I train I train for a specific thing. Say, if I am working on heeling one day. I will start with the check in to a judge, then either go straight to the start line or go over and do a long down. Then pick up my dog and go to the start. Then go thru heeling, random speed changes, rights lefts, about turns ect… maybe working on position or possible just working on my turns. Always using the precursor for what comes before. This is a cue for the dog on what is next and expected. For instance, if I want to work moving exercises I start by doing the figure 8 thru the group then back to start to work those exercises. Fir dumbbells I start with a running stand, the last exercise before dumbbells. You can the dog front, 3 seconds then finish, another 3 seconds. Then heeling to the dumbbell rack a say “are you ready to do dumbbells” or just the word dumbbells. It us a cue again to focus on what is next during a trial. I am giving my dog a picture so he is thinking about what we are doing. This way I am not pattern training the entire routine and I can spend more time on individual elements to perfect things. My cue fir the send out is hanging the dumbbell after the retrieve over the wall. I heel over to the dumbbell rack pick up the one dumbbell, look at my dog and whisper “are you ready” then set the dumbbell down. The judge is watching the other persons pick up their dog, and is not focused on you. You cannot cue your dog at the start line so this is how I give my dog info on what is next. So if I put 6 balls at the end of the field, everytime I send my dog to get a ball, I then start by heeling back to the dumbbell rack and do that same process.
 

Back
Top