• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Training collar help

haunani

Member
I need help with ideas for a training collar for my girl, Kaia. She's currently 17 months old.

She does well with her prong when we're out in public (I use a Keeper Collar, so it's a hidden prong), but we can't really use it when we're in our obedience and/or agility classes for training. She does well with her regular martingale collar at home, but once we get away from home, she just completely ignores it.

For a little bit, I have been using a choke chain with key rings added to help make it fit a bit smaller and not slide down her neck when released, but the collar doesn't slide as well through them and the key rings end up bent after a couple sessions.

Does anyone have any ideas of something I can use for classes until I can get her to be more responsive in the martingale away from home?

Pic of my pretty girl for attention.

51349014831_bc6779dc9e_w.jpg
 
I feel your pain. My dog works beautifully in a prong and tends to ignore me or lean on a choke chain or flat collar or martingale. Those are my only choices in AKC classes, so I'm in the same boat. Mine is almost 2 now and much better than she use to be, but still... Most interesting thing is that my dog works better off leash than with a leash that she can lean into the collar. At home I do my obedience work with the prong and a short tab, but the leash on the "legal" collar, so she doesn't get to practice wrong behavior (tight vs. loose leash) - I can give her a reminder with the tab. The more they get to practice wrong behavior the more they want to do it. I did get permission from my AKC teacher to do the first round of work with a prong then switch to a choke chain for the rest of the hour.

Your girl is really pretty!!!
 
Sucks that so many places do t allow proper training equipment. The AKC Club I used to teach at actually sold prong collars, they called them training collars though😜. Ecollars were allowed if it was in my classes that I taught. Not sure what they allow now. I have not taught there for almost 6 years now that I have my own training. My suggestion would be use the martingale collar and stick with leash pressure training in class. Then practice at home with the prong collar. I would also ditch the hidden prong for training and use the real thing. The hidden is ok if your in public and are worried about what others might think or say but at home training the regular prong is much more effective. Timing is important and the hidden prongs rarely fit properly or work snappy enough. Good luck with your training, always make it fun.
 
Also if using a prong collar proper fitment is very important. High up on the neck and below the jaw. Tight enough where it will not slide down the neck.

As with any collar proper use is very important.
 
Most interesting thing is that my dog works better off leash
We have the same ‘problem‘. I love that he’s so reliable off leash because he used to be such a maniac when he was younger that I never thought he’d grow out of that behavior.

I agree with all the advice given. Years ago we did Rally Obedience and could only use a martingale and it was awful, I couldn’t get control over Kaiser with that stupid collar, so I would just arrive with the prong and only switch to martingale when class started and all the dogs were appropriately distanced. The instructor lost her mind when she saw him in a prong even though he was perfectly behaved - you just can’t win with those types of people!
 
We have the same ‘problem‘. I love that he’s so reliable off leash because he used to be such a maniac when he was younger that I never thought he’d grow out of that behavior.

I agree with all the advice given. Years ago we did Rally Obedience and could only use a martingale and it was awful, I couldn’t get control over Kaiser with that stupid collar, so I would just arrive with the prong and only switch to martingale when class started and all the dogs were appropriately distanced. The instructor lost her mind when she saw him in a prong even though he was perfectly behaved - you just can’t win with those types of people!
Just tell the instructor “Trust me, you don’t want
Me to remove any of these collars. Especially the two box ecollar. “ 😂😂😂
02D96F86-9321-417C-9476-319C217475A1.webp
 
Thank you everyone!

The club does allow the prongs in class, just not for the title testing (CGC, CGCA, etc.). I figure if I'm moving up to the Novice classes, I should be practicing in what I'll be using in the ring, but it also makes sense to school in a prong to fine-tune and teach, then make the switch later to a ring-legal collar.

She does fairly well if the martingale is up behind her ears at home, but it's when we go anywhere else that she loses her ever loving mind and pressure = nothing to her. :banghead:
 
Thank you everyone!

The club does allow the prongs in class, just not for the title testing (CGC, CGCA, etc.). I figure if I'm moving up to the Novice classes, I should be practicing in what I'll be using in the ring, but it also makes sense to school in a prong to fine-tune and teach, then make the switch later to a ring-legal collar.

She does fairly well if the martingale is up behind her ears at home, but it's when we go anywhere else that she loses her ever loving mind and pressure = nothing to her. :banghead:
When training I always put on the fursaver first then the prong abs if using an ecollar it goes in last. The leash can be on the fursaver the entire training session but the others are there if needed. Eventually the prong an ecollar go in my pocket during training but if my dog acts up I can take them out at an instant and out them on. This way if the dog becomes collar smart, the dog now knows that tge collars are on my person and can come out at anytime. Similar to people always wanting to get away from giving treats, you will always need to reward your dogs behavior just as you will always need to be able to correct behavior. Duration will vary but the expectation still needs to be present so that your dog stays focused and in drive.
 
Collar smart is a problem. I put the e collar on rose for a week before I ever turned it on. After the first correction she wouldn't leave my side even to chase her Frisbee. As soon as I took it off she went back to playing. Bery frustrating
 
Thank you everyone!

The club does allow the prongs in class, just not for the title testing (CGC, CGCA, etc.). I figure if I'm moving up to the Novice classes, I should be practicing in what I'll be using in the ring, but it also makes sense to school in a prong to fine-tune and teach, then make the switch later to a ring-legal collar.

She does fairly well if the martingale is up behind her ears at home, but it's when we go anywhere else that she loses her ever loving mind and pressure = nothing to her. :banghead:
Just keep working at it in small sessions. Start where you know you'll succeed without the prong. Work your way up with gradual pressure and distractions. IE: Works well on flat inside? Change environment and move outside. Works well in backyard? Add distractions such as toys on the ground, another dog etc. Working well in backyard with distractions? Change environment and go to a quiet park. Slowly build up and proof your dog. The two things they need to understand to have your dog heel well on a flat is: leash pressure and what heeling position. So I would find literature to help support that training, build the foundation for it first, then start working on it in varying environments and with varying distractions. If you ever need to, you can warm up on the prong then remove. Put it back on if needed. Try to get success where you can, if you remove the prong and can only obtain heel position for 5 steps, call that good and praise like crazy and play play play.

It is never talked about but heeling is probably one of the harder skills to teach a dog. It takes a lot of foundation work and then constant training every day to proof. A lifetime of following through your training so bad habits don't develop. One of the top obedience people I follow does not go for their CD until the dog is around 2. They care about high scores and setting their dog up right and believe they aren't mentally mature or ready in their training until then. It takes a lot of everyday work but if you see it through it is possible!

For CGC specific, my advice is to take advantage of your leash and voice. You have 6ft of leash, hold the handle and keep it planted to your core. Let the rest of the leash hang loose so you do not get a fail for tight leash.. Your dog does not have to have a perfect heel for the CGC. You are allowed to use your voice to give commands and encourage your dog to come back to your side throughout the test. So if they walk out of a heel you have up to 6 ft before it gets tight to pat your leg and call your dog! :thumbsup:
 
Collar smart is a problem. I put the e collar on rose for a week before I ever turned it on. After the first correction she wouldn't leave my side even to chase her Frisbee. As soon as I took it off she went back to playing. Bery frustrating
Try leaving it on all day while you have a normal day until she can do normal play, rest, train a little etc with it on and not be super-sticky to you. Mine definitely minds better & instantly with it on (no need to use a stem) so collar wise is ok in that respect. But she also acts completely normal hanging out with it on.
 
Is there a trick to keep the collar up in the neck? At the moment, we are using a martingale which is causing her neck fur to thin. I want to get something else. I saw in this threat that some of you use Fur Saver collars , do those have a mechanism that can keep it in place on walks? Does that choke the dog if they pull? All lastly, any resources you recommend where I can buy them? :)

Thanks!
 
Is there a trick to keep the collar up in the neck? At the moment, we are using a martingale which is causing her neck fur to thin. I want to get something else. I saw in this threat that some of you use Fur Saver collars , do those have a mechanism that can keep it in place on walks? Does that choke the dog if they pull? All lastly, any resources you recommend where I can buy them? :)
Only the prong collar or e-collar is fitted high up the neck behind the ears. Your martingale or chain collars fit loose so that they slide when you use leash pressure. And yes a slip collar will tighten and can choke a dog - the use in training is quick snap & release, not constant pull. If your dog is leaning into this kind of collar they can damage their trachea - and never ever leave it on a dog unattended. If your dogs hair is wearing off from the martingale I must ask if she wears it all day or just on walks or training? My dog never wears a collar in the house or yard. Just for training or traveling (always wears a flat collar with ID in the vehicle). Well, actually when a puppy she wore a collar and had a leash on in the house for corrections or to tie her to me, but that period is over, thank goodness.
 
Yes, she does wear the collar all the time. I remove it at night. I feel she needs to have something so I can grab her if I need to. This morning, for example, she didn’t have the collar on and she found a way out of the kitchen to upstairs and chased the cat. I had a hard time getting grabbing her because she didn’t have a collar and was in the zone not listening.
Do you think a thin, leather flat collar would be better for all day use?
 
Yes, a soft leather collar wouldn't rub the hair so much. Some say the rolled leather is nicer to hair coats, but I don't know. I do understand about a collar to grab making things easier. I've been known to grab the loose skin at the neck when she was rocketing around not listening to me. If you have deep pockets, look for a padded soft leather collar, Italian glove leather is tops.... LOL, just kidding. Or not, because if I had deep pockets and needed a collar on all day, that's what I'd get.
 

Back
Top