Not dropping toys

Dobielover78

New Member
Training with Sergeant is going amazing! Although, there is one problem area I can’t seem to get through. Dropping toys. When it comes to dropping other items, he’s not supposed to have, he’s great at releasing them. Toys on the other hand, not so much. When I ask him to drop it, he interprets it as “let’s play tug of war and I’m going to clamp down on this toy as hard as I can”. I am a stickler for not playing any sort of tug of war and really rough play, but I can’t get him to listen to me without me prying open his jaws and then getting it.

Help!
 
Will he release it for food? Make it a specific training session in a room with one toy and a pocket full of high value treats. Give him his command once, and as soon as he releases it, YES! reward. Release him to the toy, rinse, repeat. That's what I'd do, anyway!!

When he's got that, to engage in tug, actively play by swinging your arm around. As soon as you stop engaging and command him, he should release it.

I will also play with my Dobe by chasing her when she has a toy she wants to keep away but when I stop the chase and tell her to drop it, the expectation is that she does.

It's great you're working on this very value command!
 
I had that problem when mine was a pup. How old id Sergeant? Asha was very possessive of a toy if it was hers but would never play keep away if it was a "stolen" item like a shoe or a glove. Good idea what @LifeofRubie said, making it a specific training session. And make a trade if you have to at first so he always feels like he's winning by giving it up. Then when playing tug use the word Out when you quit tugging so it is still. When he outs, make it move and give it back within seconds, so he understands it becomes MORE fun to out & regrip than to just tug tug tug. Hope this makes sense.
 
but I can’t get him to listen to me without me prying open his jaws and then getting it
I would aim to avoid this, although it's a tough one during puppy stages. Do you put the toy away once you get it? I wouldn't. Reward him for giving you the toy with continued play, so that it breaks the association that you put an end to his fun. Agree with all the advice, lots of ideas to try out.
 
I would aim to avoid this, although it's a tough one during puppy stages. Do you put the toy away once you get it? I wouldn't. Reward him for giving you the toy with continued play, so that it breaks the association that you put an end to his fun. Agree with all the advice, lots of ideas to try out.
Agreed.
Millie was doing what Sarge is doing too. Same. Will drop most anything on first call. But a toy? :nono:
She is figuring out she needs to drop the ball if I’m going to throw it again, lol.
 
I had that problem when mine was a pup. How old id Sergeant? Asha was very possessive of a toy if it was hers but would never play keep away if it was a "stolen" item like a shoe or a glove. Good idea what @LifeofRubie said, making it a specific training session. And make a trade if you have to at first so he always feels like he's winning by giving it up. Then when playing tug use the word Out when you quit tugging so it is still. When he outs, make it move and give it back within seconds, so he understands it becomes MORE fun to out & regrip than to just tug tug tug. Hope this makes sense.
Sergeant is 4 months and 6 days old :)
 
First off why do you not play tug with your dog? This is the best bond building exercise you can do, it will make for a more obedient and focused dog. You just need to teach your dog the rules of play and outing doesn’t mean you are winning and taking the toy away. When I ask for the out the toy remains in place, sometimes I immediately Mark and let them rebite the toy other times I may ask for sone form of obedience to earn the right to access the toY again. Here is the out picture, there is always a consequence for not outing and for taking the toy without permission. B9EACF76-03C4-401A-B08F-12E8C0949169.webp
 
First off why do you not play tug with your dog? This is the best bond building exercise you can do, it will make for a more obedient and focused dog. You just need to teach your dog the rules of play and outing doesn’t mean you are winning and taking the toy away. When I ask for the out the toy remains in place, sometimes I immediately Mark and let them rebite the toy other times I may ask for sone form of obedience to earn the right to access the toY again. Here is the out picture, there is always a consequence for not outing and for taking the toy without permission. View attachment 116392
Not playing tug of war at this moment is a personal choice I’ve made. Thank you for the information though.
 
I've had great luck with playing "two ball" as a way of starting to work on "drop it". The game is obviously played with two balls. You throw the first one, and while the pup is playing with or bringing back the first one, you start playing with the second one like some sort of fool like the second ball is the most wonderful and fun thing ever. Pup drops first ball, and you throw second ball. Rinse and repeat :D
 
I've had great luck with playing "two ball" as a way of starting to work on "drop it". The game is obviously played with two balls. You throw the first one, and while the pup is playing with or bringing back the first one, you start playing with the second one like some sort of fool like the second ball is the most wonderful and fun thing ever. Pup drops first ball, and you throw second ball. Rinse and repeat :D
I’ve started doing that and that seems to be working! Thank you all for the helpful information.
 

Back
Top