My 5 month old thinks my daughter is a toy

CrisK

Jr Member
Gypsy is now 5 months old, and she really thinks my 8-year-old is a toy. My daughter started avoiding being around her, and we have sectioned the house so that she can't roam free yet. Whenever my daughter is sitting at the breakfast counter, she tries to grab her feet or legs. She chases my daughter if she can and once she gets to her, she bites and hold. So far, she has only gotten her pants and boots. She growls when we pull her out.

We are working with a trainer who recommended counter conditioning. We are doing everything we can in terms of training and exercising her but it's so scary for my daughter. On a few occasions she got nasty teeth marks on her skin. We don't know if Gypsy would try to get her skin directly, and I don't know if that makes any difference.

Anyone here have had a similar experience and could help with how to help her stop doing this?

Thanks you!!
 
Your dog is a puppy and your kid is probably excitable which can be a challenging combination.

Your puppy is not intentionally trying to hurt your daughter but the more she runs and makes high pitched noises (which I assume she does when the puppy is going after her feet or chasing her, for instance?), the more riled up it will make the puppy.

My friend had a similar situation and she made her dog and kid go through a CGC class and test together (with her son not being much older than your daughter). Then they started agility. All while doing training at home, providing meals, etc. It helped them form a relationship of mutual respect and trust.

What is counter conditioning? What would that look like in your household?
 
^^^Agree with LOR.
Your Dobie is going through the teenage stage and this is normal behavior. How your daughter reacts to it, will determine how well training will go.

I would have your daughter keep a couple high value toys in her pocket or on her somewhere so that once the puppy starts the shark attack movements and biting she can give a firm NO and redirect the dobe to a toy she has.
She can do a couple minutes of gentle tug play with Gypsy then just walk away.
Since Gypsy is a teen she will be relentless so your daughter has to be the same with giving a firm NO or a Leave It command.

I would have your daughter hand feed her while asking Gypsy to sit or down in order to get a few pieces of food.
If she does this for one of Gypsy’s feeding, she will gain Gypsy’s respect and will less likely have Gypsy chase and bite her.

With my pup, I have to close myself in the bedroom to get dressed because Legend wants to grab my pants while I am trying to dress.
He does it while folding laundry too.

I would limit the areas that Gypsy can go and have your daughter not run away or squeal in high pitched tones whenever Gypsy is around her.

Eventually Gypsy will learn that biting is not allowed. Just be firm, fair and consistent with your commands and training and soon Gypsy and your daughter will become fast friends.

Dogs like kids love to give chase to anything that moves so it’s up to you to establish when it’s ok to play and when it’s time to time it down.

Trust me, this is normal puppy play for Dobermans and they will grow out of it with proper consistent training.

Research NILIF and practice this every day.
NILIF = Nothing In Life Is Free. Make Gypsy work for everything she gets.
Teaching NILIF is a good base for training obedience that you will continue for life with Gypsy.

We would love to see pictures of Gypsy and Welcome to DCF.
 
Hi LifeofRubie! Thanks for the reply. Counter Conditioning is when we present the stimulus and reward the puppy for looking at it at a distance. Right now, I have my daughter sit about 25 feet away from Gypsy - this is where Gypsy notices her presence but doesn't get excited - while holding her on a leash. My daughter goes into that spot, the puppy notices her, and get fed continuously until my daughter walks away. We do that for 20 seconds, my daughter walks out of sight for to 10 seconds, then comes back for another 20 seconds. It's a very methodical process, and we are aiming at doing 20 minute sessions every day. Once Gypsy starts consistently looking at me for her reward, when she sees my daughter, we will move 2 feet closer and continue the process.

I have ramped up my daughter's participation in the training too. And also encouraging her to only interact with Gypsy with a toy in her hand. I don't allow them to be unsupervised together. I am glad to hear that your friend saw results with that. I hope to get our puppy in the CGC class too. She will start basic obedience next week, and until now, we have been doing basic skills with a trainer via zoom.

I agree, I don't think she's trying to hurt my daughter. We need to replace that habit.
 
^^^Agree with LOR.
Your Dobie is going through the teenage stage and this is normal behavior. How your daughter reacts to it, will determine how well training will go.

I would have your daughter keep a couple high value toys in her pocket or on her somewhere so that once the puppy starts the shark attack movements and biting she can give a firm NO and redirect the dobe to a toy she has.
She can do a couple minutes of gentle tug play with Gypsy then just walk away.
Since Gypsy is a teen she will be relentless so your daughter has to be the same with giving a firm NO or a Leave It command.

I would have your daughter hand feed her while asking Gypsy to sit or down in order to get a few pieces of food.
If she does this for one of Gypsy’s feeding, she will gain Gypsy’s respect and will less likely have Gypsy chase and bite her.

With my pup, I have to close myself in the bedroom to get dressed because Legend wants to grab my pants while I am trying to dress.
He does it while folding laundry too.

I would limit the areas that Gypsy can go and have your daughter not run away or squeal in high pitched tones whenever Gypsy is around her.

Eventually Gypsy will learn that biting is not allowed. Just be firm, fair and consistent with your commands and training and soon Gypsy and your daughter will become fast friends.

Dogs like kids love to give chase to anything that moves so it’s up to you to establish when it’s ok to play and when it’s time to time it down.

Trust me, this is normal puppy play for Dobermans and they will grow out of it with proper consistent training.

Research NILIF and practice this every day.
NILIF = Nothing In Life Is Free. Make Gypsy work for everything she gets.
Teaching NILIF is a good base for training obedience that you will continue for life with Gypsy.

We would love to see pictures of Gypsy and Welcome to DCF.

Hi! Thanks for the reply and for welcoming me! I have been finding great info on dobermans here - even before welcoming Gypsy home.

Your answer is very encouraging and also tells me we are on the right track. I am getting my daughter more involved in the training and having her play tug and fetch under our supervision.
 
Looks like you've gotten some specific advice from here and from your trainer.

Taking a very broad view of this: Shut that stuff down right away.

Be serious and don't allow hyper play with/around your daughter. I would advise against your daughter playing tug with the pup until this is well under control. Other types of play that are heavy on training and obedience are wonderful for your daughter to do with the pup.

I have, and am, raising two daughters around this Doberman, and my previous one. My Dobe WILL show respect for my girls, period. If he even has incidental contact with them as they pass, I'm on him with a serious stare and/or warning, and he must show that he recognizes my displeasure.
 
I have, and am, raising two daughters around this Doberman, and my previous one. My Dobe WILL show respect for my girls, period. If he even has incidental contact with them as they pass, I'm on him with a serious stare and/or warning, and he must show that he recognizes my displeasure.

Thank you OLO! I am not sure she knows when we are displeased with her. The training style we are using is focused on rewarding the good behavior, and redirecting bad ones, when she becomes too excited we put her in her pen to calm down. I use my voice when she messes up - I say "uh-uh". When Gypsy was under 18 weeks, my daughter could do a lot more without being nipped, they played outside without needing to have Gypsy tethered. Something changed. I am not sure what.
Sometimes I wonder if the training style we adopted is the right one for a dog with her temperament.
 
Thank you OLO! I am not sure she knows when we are displeased with her. The training style we are using is focused on rewarding the good behavior, and redirecting bad ones, when she becomes too excited we put her in her pen to calm down. I use my voice when she messes up - I say "uh-uh". When Gypsy was under 18 weeks, my daughter could do a lot more without being nipped, they played outside without needing to have Gypsy tethered. Something changed. I am not sure what.
Sometimes I wonder if the training style we adopted is the right one for a dog with her temperament.
I know it must be confusing and alarming that your pup would seem to change a bit, when you were on a nice track with what you were doing.

I think someone above mentioned the "teens," and that's a thing. She's at least approaching that phase. But, as wonderful as these dogs are and as much as we give and receive love, they are, well as I think William Koehler described dogs, "the original opportunists." What's more, we wouldn't expect even a human child to always diligently adhere to rules without our making it worth their while by offering both positive and negative consequences...

...which leads me to my final point: I don't believe positive-only training works for most dogs. You might have a sweet, happy-go-lucky Dobe, but it is a breed that was designed to be determined and intense. Positive-only is not a good choice for the breed in most cases. What's more, a dominant dog of one of these guarding breeds will always challenge you for leadership role as the years go on. Just as the weak Alpha wolves are challenged and replaced, a weak leader will be overcome.

It's not doom and gloom. :) Your Doberman will be your family's best friend and a sensational beloved pet if you provide the leadership they need.

By the way, the Dobe in your avatar is so pretty! I love how rich and shiny her coat and the markings look.
 
It's not doom and gloom. :) Your Doberman will be your family's best friend and a sensational beloved pet if you provide the leadership they need.

By the way, the Dobe in your avatar is so pretty! I love how rich and shiny her coat and the markings look.

Yes, I am coming to believe my particular pup needs a multi-approach to her training. We started implementing more firm "no's" and we hold her by her collar. Someone told me about holding the scruff of her neck, but there's just so much skin there! hahahah! I tried holding it but my hand is not big enough to grab enough skin to have an impact. Another long time doberman owner told me about having a can with rocks inside and when she starts acting up, throw it near her. There are just so many ways, I guess the trick is finding the one that works for a particular dog.

I want to believe things are improving, as I see my daughter spending more time around Gypsy without being nipped. At one point, as soon as Gypsy saw her, she would go straight to nipping mode that was very annoying and made my daughter start avoiding her.

"No doom and gloom" - thanks for the encouragement :)

Thanks for the compliment on Gypsy! I do think she's a gorgeous looking creature! All dobes are
 
I don't believe positive-only training works for most dogs. You might have a sweet, happy-go-lucky Dobe, but it is a breed that was designed to be determined and intense. Positive-only is not a good choice for the breed in most cases. What's more, a dominant dog of one of these guarding breeds will always challenge you for leadership role as the years go on. Just as the weak Alpha wolves are challenged and replaced, a weak leader will be overcome.
So agree with this. I have a 4 year old male Dobe and I’ve had to get tough with him all over again. Since I’d been working from home, I guess I got too comfortable and now I have to make him understand I’m serious. For trainers, look for trainers who work with working breeds/dog sport/police dogs. They will know how to get a Dober sorted.
 
What Oji & Kaiser said. Pure or mostly positive will not get this type of dog trained and it will likely make her more & more opportunistic. They respond best to no-nonsense, clear instructions. I wouldn't toss a can of rocks, personally. Distraction should come from you & get her attention to you, not to the noise maker. And also depending on your dog, she might LIKE the noisemaker. My dogs favorite outdoor toy is a big plastic bottle with about 10 rocks in it. The louder the better! Keep us posted on your progress, sounds like you are going the right direction.
 
What Oji & Kaiser said. Pure or mostly positive will not get this type of dog trained and it will likely make her more & more opportunistic. They respond best to no-nonsense, clear instructions. I wouldn't toss a can of rocks, personally. Distraction should come from you & get her attention to you, not to the noise maker. And also depending on your dog, she might LIKE the noisemaker. My dogs favorite outdoor toy is a big plastic bottle with about 10 rocks in it. The louder the better! Keep us posted on your progress, sounds like you are going the right direction.

I tried the can, and that broke her concentration when she was focused and barking at the cats. At this time, she won't look at us when we try to interrupt her with our voice. The can made her stop, but she went for it curiously. I am sure she's the type who will play with a can full of rocks!

What would you do specifically to try to stop her from lunging at a child? I started doing the following: when she lunges at my daughter I give her a firm no, and immediately remove her from the room my daughter is in. I keep her away for a minute or two and then bring her back. We have it setup so she can never succeed at actually getting my daughter - either by having her tethered or having my daughter sit in a place where she will have to go by us to get to her.

Aside from that, we are doing the counter conditioning and having my daughter participate more and more in her training. My goal is to teach Gypsy that it will be way more fun to play with toys rather than try to get my daughter. We will see.
 
Maeve was a terror when she was a puppy. Always going after my teenage daughters and my husband at times.

Always under supervision, she would drag a leash. It gave me a chance to correct her quickly or her leash was attached to me.
Wherever I went she went. Cleaning /cooking etc she was by my side. She learned pretty quickly if she wanted freedom she had to earn it. It's a very hard stage to get through but well worth it. Good luck!
 
Maeve was a terror when she was a puppy. Always going after my teenage daughters and my husband at times.

Always under supervision, she would drag a leash. It gave me a chance to correct her quickly or her leash was attached to me.
Wherever I went she went. Cleaning /cooking etc she was by my side. She learned pretty quickly if she wanted freedom she had to earn it. It's a very hard stage to get through but well worth it. Good luck!

Thank you! I am so happy to have started this thread! I feel so much better after reading all the comments here! It is starting to sound like it's normal puppy behavior that will eventually go away. We will keep on working with her, and communicating to her it's not acceptable to lunge and nip my child - or the cats. She's nuts about the cats, and tries to invade their space regardless of the cats swatting her.
 
Ah puppies. I think you are on the right track with the leash, reading her body language before she pounces, correction, and redirect with something else. The only other thing I can think of is take advantage of that energy and turn it into training sessions. Hide her kibble around the house and tell her to search. Do some sit stays for 15 seconds and build on it. A little heeling through the house. Short sessions but it will make a load of difference when you mentally stimulate her and tire her out. Less of that bound up energy ready to explode the better she will listen! And you will build a bond and build that desire to focus on you.

After you train her, give her something engaging to do as a reward and to continue to distract herself with. A puzzle toy is great like a snuffle mat, kong with treats and peanut butter frozen inside, or a ball that dispenses treats. This will buy you some time to do your own thing, hah!

I have a 6 month old puppy that loves the kitties and her 13 year old BFF Paige. They don't appreciate her puppy energy that much. I find she doesn't bother them as much the more mentally stimulated she is. And as she progresses in training, so does her ability to listen to me.

But this age is right where they are getting bigger and feeling some independence. Keep working on it and it shall pass!
 
I tried the can, and that broke her concentration when she was focused and barking at the cats. At this time, she won't look at us when we try to interrupt her with our voice. The can made her stop, but she went for it curiously. I am sure she's the type who will play with a can full of rocks!

What would you do specifically to try to stop her from lunging at a child?

I think you are on the right track. I think the can is fine for shaking & distracting (it does work!), just not tossing it. You really want her attention to redirect to you, not just anything else, if that makes sense. My other thing I was going to say is basic obedience training, lots & lots of short lessons throughout the day. @Rits laid it out like I would have said it, no need to repeat it!
 
For anyone who comes across this thread with a similar question. About 20 days have passed since I started this thread, and things are progressing. Gypsy seems to be losing interested in my daughter. Interactions (100% supervised) between them have been positive. On several occasions my daughter has walked by Gypsy and been ignored by her. Today we tried leaving her loose in the kitchen while my daughter was eating dinner. Gypsy walked by her a few times, until my daughter started to pat her. That was enough to get Gypsy thinking she could interact more closely and she tried to nip my daughter's pants. This was, however, such a gentle nip. Regardless, we said no and closed up her pen again. We have also taught my daughter to say "no" to gypsy instead of screaming and running. I feel this puts her in a position of power and is helping Gypsy respect my daughter a little more.

We have been doing lots of training, and have been involving my daughter as much as we can. Today for example, I was trimming Gypsy's nails while my daughter delivered her the rewards ever so often. My daughter also gives her meal, but has her do some work for it. A simply sit, a shake and a wait seems to go a long way. Keeping in mind the NILIF approach, she gets to work for us even for toys.

We are making slow progress, but I am optimistic we will get where we need to be eventually!
 

Back
Top