• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Can I handle a rescue?

astraglam

New Member
Hello everyone! We have recently started to think about getting a guard dog as we live downtown Chicago. Do I need to say more after recent events? We started by looking at fully trained multi thousand dollar dogs but quickly fell in love with Dobermans as they are for no reason other than personality and look. While it would be nice to walk down the street without clutching my bag, I have come a long way from wanting one just for guarding. We have never had a dog, none of us in the family. Ever. In fact, I was bit by a pit bull and always claimed I was afraid of dogs, mainly to stop kids from asking for one. I would much prefer a rescue: they need a home and I have one and I do not think we can handle the needs of a newborn puppy. Do you think someone with zero prior dog experience can handle a rescue Doberman?
 
Welcome from Ohio! Sorry to hear reports of what's happening in your great city.

Boy, good question. I'm glad you're reaching out for advice.

The Doberman was designed to be a personal bodyguard (note, not a guard of property so much). They are people-dogs – love to be around their family.

Can you handle a rescue Doberman, you ask?

It's not like they are sharp, aggressive dogs or anything (but each one is different – especially when you don't really know their breeding and prior life experiences.) Are you committed to loving and being patient with it even if it does not seem to meet your guard dog expectations? How about your whole family? Who will give most of its care? What about when no one is home except the dog? Will you crate it to keep it from destroying things, in which case it won't be able to protect your house? Or will it be able to be trusted to be left free roaming your house? (please don't leave it alone in the yard when you're gone)

Dobes are high energy and quirky. They need a good amount of exercise and mental stimulation. They're not an easy dog, really.

I ask the question: Can a rescue Doberman handle your needs in a guard dog?

Many modern Dobes have had actual guard/protection ability bred out of them for generations. Your rescue Dobe might not step up and protect you if the need arose. One thing, however, that you will almost surely have: An alert watchdog who will bark and notify you of an intruder approaching your house. On the street? You may or may not get a dog that acts confidently around strangers.

That said, I understand your wish to get an adult dog, or at least not a young pup who will take months to even be mature enough to be a deterrent; and I understand your not wanting to spend many thousands of dollars on a trained guard dog!

@Gelcoater adopted a female adult Dobe a little while back. @Viemarangelrock adopted one or more Dobes. Who else? I bet they'll chime in tomorrow.
 
Thank you for replying!
I think the guard part was the reason we started to look for large dog options but is no longer a must. In that respect, puppy is not an issue. I just don’t know if I can handle any more getting up at night and potty training after doing it with three human children. I would let the dog roam the house- I would not be able to lock him or her up for a whole day. We do not have a yard. We do have an huge enclosed area super close. I am worried that I do not have enough experience to handle a dog that already has habits and quirks. I would be making lots of newbie mistakes and mishandling the dog instead of helping.
 
If you decide to go ahead PLEASE go through a reputable, Dobe specific rescue organization. They evaluate their dogs extensively. They will evaluate you and your family extensively to try and match you with a dog that will be a good fit. Many Dobermans in rescue are there through no fault of their own.
 
Rescue dogs can have some underlying problems that may have been created by previous owner/owners. You say you have not owned a dog before, there are training requirements for these dogs. You will need to designate time for training 1-2 times a day. A rescue can still learn and form a bond with you but you will need a good trainer to help you. Puppies will bond easier and trust will also come easier. Getting up to teach the puppy to potty is a relatively short period of time of a dogs life. That shouldn’t be your determining factor. All dogs and puppies will require your time.
 
Hi! I live outside of Chicago and we have a wonderful group called the Chicago Doberman Club (you can find us on facebook!). If you have any area specific questions, there may be someone there who can help.

EDIT: we consist of rescued, breeder, cropped/docked, natural, urban, suburban, and rurals dogs/families. Some dogs compete in a variety of things, some are "just pets." When it's not a global pandemic, they're great about putting together all different types of gatherings: we've walked in a parade, have done 5ks, do on leash walks, off leash dog parks, etc.
 
I would not be able to lock him or her up for a whole day.

What is your work schedule like? These dogs really thrive on interacting with their people. Being alone whether it be in a crate, or alone in a house is not much different. I only ask because you said “whole day.”

Even eight hours left along during the daytime is too much (imo), but some people make it work. You have to ask yourself if you can handle waking up early and exercising the dog (more than just a walk). Every single day. Then coming home from work will you have enough energy to do it again? Especially a young dog. They do well with a lot of exercise. More than the average family breed.
 
yes, I saw the group
Hi! I live outside of Chicago and we have a wonderful group called the Chicago Doberman Club (you can find us on facebook!). If you have any area specific questions, there may be someone there who can help.

EDIT: we consist of rescued, breeder, cropped/docked, natural, urban, suburban, and rurals dogs/families. Some dogs compete in a variety of things, some are "just pets." When it's not a global pandemic, they're great about putting together all different types of gatherings: we've walked in a parade, have done 5ks, do on leash walks, off leash dog parks, etc.

yes, I saw the group but since I do not have the dog yet thought it would be silly to join. I was trying to find information about having a Doberman in this area. I read they do not do well in extreme cold. How do you keep yours busy in the winter months?
 
Lizbeli- sorry, cant figure out how to tag- I work from home however the day does get busy often. Not being able to provide enough exercise is what is holding us back. Seems to be a huge commitment
 
I mentioned it because of the number of rescue dogs in the group and people who do live in downtown Chicago so who may be able to talk with you about those specific challenges or concerns.

We live in the burbs with a large, fenced in yard. Our dogs go for at least one walk a day regardless of rain, sun, or snow. My dobe does have a jacket she wears if we're going to be outside in the cold for long stretches but she's always been fine.

She is trained in agility and we just recently started barn hunt; she has her CGC and Novice Trick Title. We use puzzle feeders in the winter for some extra mental exercise. When she was a puppy, I worked full-time and lived alone so she would be crated for about 4 hours, break during lunch, and then crated again for about 4 hours (even if you're home, crate training a puppy is a great idea).

We also have another dog and they generally keep each other busy.
 
. Do you think someone with zero prior dog experience can handle a rescue Doberman?
Honestly?
You might not like some of what I have to say, but I do commend you for stopping to ask questions and seek knowledge before pulling the trigger.

Like @Doberman Gang said, a rescue dog will come prewired with some traits that may be problematic, those issues would be compounded by someone who doesn’t know dogs.

All dogs have a mutual body language. Various postures some of which are very subtle and wouldn’t even be noticed by the inexperienced. Heck I’m still learning some of it, lol.

Both of mine are adopted dogs, they both came with attributes we liked and some we didn’t.
Rocky.
8005937B-4E35-428B-B188-B13A10EEB919.webp 14F4517C-4E1F-4DDF-9C34-6E626E1C0DF0.webp 2AD63313-F526-43BF-B5FB-12F3DF473C3B.webp

He came with a bad habit of aggressive fence running, and a propensity to be a complete asshole to any dog he meets. He’s still not outgrown that last one.

And when he was younger....
A1441B15-6889-4B82-9695-1D9617D70D4A.webp
He became bored rather easily. Bored dogs create their own ways of showing us, lol.
One quickly learns a tired dog is a happy dog and no longer bored;)

He also came with some great door manners, won’t rush out past you, etc. he also came Wired to NOT be on human beds. He won’t of his own accord. He might jump up if invited but once up all he wants is off.
He’s a complete sweetheart with his people, and fairly open to meeting people.
But a reality not to be forgotten is he still has this inside him
FF62C6B7-3DEE-46FD-AB11-EB52030BE268.webp


You mention kids. How old are they?

All of you! Would have to be on the same page of commitment in training, and doing it consistentl, and wanting a dog that is capable of completely ruining your stuff the moment you aren’t consistent. There’s give and take in any relationship.

Millie.
She came to us at the beginning of the year.
She is also a big seeetheart with the family. BAE2FFD8-90D8-4852-B199-6B7E3347E5B4.webp9746E9A4-1E3F-442F-A67A-77E17627346C.webp

But make no mistake. Under that unassuming pretty face lurks a snarky little wench when riled.
B18BC89C-27CD-4671-A311-D109025CB9BE.webp

She is our 4th dog in 20+ years and our 3rd Doberman. She is the first dog we have had to crate, both for her own good and our sanity.
A couple of weeks ago she literally went through our back screen door after a squirrel. Blew it apart, lol.
She can not be trusted home alone.
Besides the destruction there’s a real possibility she eats something she couldn’t. I’ve read some real horror stories here about bowel obstructions.
Some people have lost dogs because of it.

There’s so much to consider, many obstacles you would need to overcome.
And it won’t be easy.
It’s not easy for the experienced, it could be a nightmare for the inexperienced.
Of it sounds like I’m trying to talk you out of it? To a certain degree I am.

A lot of research is needed on your part. Perhaps some soul searching too.
Owning dogs like these requires certain adjustments ones lifestyle. And sort of becomes it’s own lifestyle.
You need to sure these are changes and a lifestyle you are willing to accept.
Best of luck to you, and please.
Continue to ask questions. Do some searches here of concerns you might have and don’t be surprised if some of what you read spawns yet more questions.


Sorry for writing a novel here, lol.
 
Firstly, a very warm welcome to you! You’ve come to a great place :thumbsup2:

Having raised 2 rescues and 2 breeder puppies I can tell you now....rescues aren’t plain sailing. I would say it’s the most rewarding but the most challenging job you’ll ever face. Of course, there are exceptions to every rule, and all behaviours and personalities will be assessed on a case-by-case basis. But, loving and training a rescue dog can be hard work.
We have successfully taken on dogs that were both neglected and abused. You layer their issues on top of their breed quirks and trust me, you’ve got your hands full!!!!!

You need to think long and hard about some of the issues listed below and whether you could handle the situation and keep a cool head...

Firstly, destruction....

Destructive behavioral problems are usually linked to separation anxiety or excessive energy. When dogs are anxious or bored they might engage in destructive behavior simply for something to do or to calm their nerves.
Reprimanding a dog that is showing destructive behaviours is not the answer. Dogs are not acting this way out of spite, this is a way for them to tell you something isn't quite right.

Food aggression/resource guarding....

This is a big, understandable, issue with some rescues. This sometimes prevents dogs from going to homes with children. Dogs that have been neglected, or a stray for a long time, get protective of their food.

They may have lived day to day having to fight for food or not knowing when they were going to get their next meal. So when they do have food, they get protective- sometimes snarling and even biting because they feel threatened.

Fear...

This is a very common and very unique hurdle for each dog. Each dog will have different fears, different levels of fear, as well as different reactions.
Usually when faced with fear dogs have a fight or flight response, each of which is equally dangerous. If a dog responds to fear with a fight response, that is a big issue and puts potential owners at risk. A dog responding to fear with a flight response can be an issue as well. When left alone, dogs have been known to chew through walls to get away from whatever is scaring them.

Housebreaking...

For shelter dogs that have never been taught where to go to the bathroom, housebreaking can be a big issue that sometimes lands dogs back in the shelter.

More times than not, they have been reprimanded severely for accidents when they simply don't understand where they should be eliminating.


For most rescue dogs, the most important thing is that you are able to provide them with the stability and security that they have not had so far. Many rescue dogs have already been through a lot, and they need somebody who is patient and committed to them for the rest of their lives.

There really is plenty to chew over. I wish you all the very best in your decision. To be honest, if I were you I would look into fostering a Dobermann, just to get a good feel for the breed. They aren’t everyone’s cup of tea. We say here that there are dogs and then there are Dobermanns Lol.

If you do decide to foster/adopt then please look at Dobermann specific rescues/shelters. They are much more knowledgeable of the breed.
 
Seems to be a huge commitment

Some great post up there.

The best thing I could add would be a Doberman is not a dog, it is a Doberman.

Mine is far far away from being a couch lap dog as per Lassie. Mine must be trained and stimulated daily, if not you can see it in his demeanor. He looks and yearns for it as to satisfy a hunger. If he doesn’t get it, then he is not happy. Go too long and he satisfies that hunger his way.

Good Luck to you.
 
Not being able to provide enough exercise is what is holding us back. Seems to be a huge commitment

You’re not wrong there. It’s a HUGE commitment. Fulfilling their daily exercise needs alongside plenty of mental stimulation must be priority. It’s what makes them well-adjusted. Unfortunately, some people don’t think enough about exercise when selecting a breed, and they choose a dog who needs more than they’re willing or have time to provide.
 
You’re not wrong there. It’s a HUGE commitment. Fulfilling their daily exercise needs alongside plenty of mental stimulation must be priority. It’s what makes them well-adjusted. Unfortunately, some people don’t think enough about exercise when selecting a breed, and they choose a dog who needs more than they’re willing or have time to provide.
Yep.
Mental stimulation is an absolute must. They are a very perceptive breed.

Last night I was trying to teach Millie to roll over from a sit/down.
Once I made a complete fool of myself literally laying on the ground next to her with her toy as reward, she finally did it.
I think she made me act a fool on purpose. The lil snot:rofl:
 
If you work with a rescue or reputable breeder and give them your exact needs/wants, they will do everything in their power to find you the right dog BUT it could take time, they will ask you ALL the questions, and may even do a home visit.

My last boy and female Dobe before were rescues. My female was 7 months old when I got her out of a shelter. My male was 3 years old and needed rehomed because the family just didn't have time.

Both were wonderful. The 7 month old was still a puppy so had all the energy and eagerness one could hope for (she had been gifted to an elderly owner who couldn't keep up with her). Given rules, boundaries, and an outlet, she was a dream. My d*ckhead boyfriend at the time snuck behind my back and legally registered her in his name so I had no legal recourse to take her when we split up (that was a hard learned lesson). I'm not sure how she is doing.

My boy came from a home with several young children. Since he was older, he was pretty chill and more than happy to spend his day on the couch. When it came to seeing kids in public, he'd walk right up to them and lick them from their chin to their forehead, nub going a mile a minute (he was also 95lbs). He passed away when he was almost 5 from complications after surgery but from X-Rays, it was apparent he was going to have a lot of arthritis issues as he aged.

My current Dobe is from a breeder and is either sleeping or a total spitfire. When she trusts someone, she will literally melt into you but she is cautious of strangers, not particularly fond of other dogs, and doesn't care for children (not a concern for us as we aren't having any). She's put together wonderfully and will eagerly go on any adventure we put forth. She does need extra consideration to be set-up for success but it's worth it in every way. I would say she has much more of the typical Doberman sensibilities than my first two.

There are as many stories about dogs as their dogs - regardless of where they came from but they ALL take work.
 
Great that you are asking questions now! I do have reservations about you never having owned a dog before but don't want to put you off either. The research I did before committing to a Dobe mix girl was extensive, but there is a HUGE difference in reading about high intelligence and high energy to actually experiencing these things. Although not a first time dog owner and having had high energy working breeds I thought I knew what I was doing! Dobes are different! They are the most rewarding dog, but they reward your hard work, and it is hard work in the initial stages for someone who is getting their first experience! But sooooo worth it when you reach that level of trust and loyalty where they read your mind! :love:

Whether a puppy or a rescue there will be many challenges. You have children so you have probably had training challenges before! :rofl:

Seriously, I would get involved with the Doberman Group that @LifeofRubie mentioned. Sounds friendly and you can get some first hand knowledge from people in your area. Maybe meet some Dobermans before you make your commitment? :thumbsup2:
 
@Gelcoater
Thank you so much for such thorough response. Your dogs are stunning. I definitely needed to hear all that. I will be definitely asking a lot of questions. My kids are 10, 15 and 22. 10 year old is all in. 15 year old could care less but would help if asked. 22 year old would do anything to have this dog but she lives in another city. So me and my youngest are driving force behind this.
 

Back
Top