Resource guarding water?

Gelcoater

California Republican
$ Premium Subscriber $
Hot Topics Subscriber
This is a new one for me.
Never had a dog that wouldn’t share water before.
Maxie and Daisy would drink from the same bowl at the same time.
Daisy and Rocky same deal.

On camping trips where there are several off leash dogs in camp Rocky cares not if any of the dogs drink from “his” water bowl.

Millie. While drinking will stop drinking and show teeth if Rocky gets close.
Not acceptable as she found out.

2 bowls here, one in the garage another outside.

These dogs eat in the same room at the same time. Both held in a sit until bowls are down then given a release.
They lick each other’s bowls after they are finished.
So all of the sudden guarding water seems strange to me.

Any ideas?
 
This may make for a hassle for you if it means you can't just leave water down anymore.

So, did Millie learn it's unacceptable via Rocky's teaching her, or you showing her?

My wife's late Husky was known to get possessive over a little clod of dirt at the dog park. I can certainly see dogs guarding access to water.

It happens that with Oji I have always picked up water and he asks for a drink when he needs one. This started with potty training and I just kept it up. I suppose there's a slight danger of him not getting as much daily water as he needs, but he's always seemed fine.

Again, though, that would be a new hassle for you – especially with two dogs.
 
hrm... tricky one. Luckily our two have never shown water resource guarding with each other (or even with other dogs, surprising for Rubie).

Since they know to sit and wait for food, would it be of any benefit to have them sit, give Rocky the water bowl, "leave it," pick it up, give Millie the water bowl, "leave it," pick it up, etc?

Perhaps she didn't always have access to water in her previous life?
 
So what to do about this?
- let them hash it out and establish pecking order?
- stay on top of it and correct it when it happens? Details on how to do this?
- give separate water bowls and/or water separately?

Sometime or another if water is left down, there will be a reckoning.....
 
I don't expect mine to share food bowls or give them a chance to even go near the others food bowl. They should be able to eat comfortably and at their own pace without fear of another dog coming to eat it. It seems disrespectful to the other dog and opens the chance for a fight so I have always fed separate. Water though? That's kind of an odd one but I suppose it's not much different to value. She may be not resource guarding the water but her space? Especially when her head is down and another is looming over top of her. I'd provide two water bowls so someone can't control the water. No big deal, plenty of water guys you don't need to guard the sole source of water.
 
I have never heard or dealt with this. I imagine there could be several ways to go about it. But I'm wondering if you can just have two sets of water and food dishes and teach them one is for one, one for the other. Would this be just avoiding the issue? Probably. But to me it beats the chances if her reverting back to guarding and causing a fight. But then again, maybe long drawn out training will fix the behavior.

I hope you can find a solution.
 
I don't see why water would be different than any other resource, and sharing a bowl could be super uncomfortable some dogs no matter how mundane the water may be.
 
I don't expect mine to share food bowls or give them a chance to even go near the others food bowl. They should be able to eat comfortably and at their own pace without fear of another dog coming to eat it. It seems disrespectful to the other dog and opens the chance for a fight so I have always fed separate. Water though? That's kind of an odd one but I suppose it's not much different to value. She may be not resource guarding the water but her space? Especially when her head is down and another is looming over top of her. I'd provide two water bowls so someone can't control the water. No big deal, plenty of water guys you don't need to guard the sole source of water.
I should have been more clear there.
They absolutely have their own food bowls, and their respective “place” they eat.
And I hadn’t considered it may have not been about the water but the space.
Great point!
 
I don't see why water would be different than any other resource, and sharing a bowl could be super uncomfortable some dogs no matter how mundane the water may be.
I suppose that could be?
It’s just never been an issue with any other dog I can recall?
Parents, friends, etc. dogs seem to treat water as a community thing.
Even dogs that didn’t know each other yesterday, are ok with it.

I think @Rits may be onto something with it being a personal space thing.
 
I should have been more clear there.
They absolutely have their own food bowls, and their respective “place” they eat.
And I hadn’t considered it may have not been about the water but the space.
Great point!
Oh I figured! I was giving an example how I don't expect them to share food I guess I could see the same issues happening to water.
 
Oh I figured! I was giving an example how I don't expect them to share food I guess I could see the same issues happening to water.
Looking at it now, the water bowl is next to her food bowl. It’s just where it’s always been, since the Maxie and Daisy days.
Perhaps she perceives it as part of hers?

I should note here I usually leave the feed bowls down after meals.
There’s only been one instance of bowl guarding after the meal.
And it was months ago.
They will from time to time go lick their bowl, lick the others bowl, and walk around trying to convince me they are absolutely starving to death:rolleyes:

Rocky is especially talented at turning on the Puss&Boots eyes and charm. :rolleyes: The lil:mad:
Lol
 
Wait.
What?
View attachment 109003
Why is it all the way over here now?
:cool:
That buggy looks like it might be after her water too! :rofl:

Only time I've ever heard about a dog resource guarding water was when friends were going to adopt another dog and were making sure that their own dog and the new one got on before taking the next step. This dog erupted when approached while drinking, by both dog and human. Needless to say that dog stayed where it was! No doubt there had been a serious lack of basic care in that poor dogs background, but I don't reckon Millie has had such deprivations.
 
An acquaintance of mine has an Akita mix that resource guards water. It only really happens late spring-fall (when heat is blistering)

He leaves well enough alone if another person pours water, but if his owner pours it, hell might break loose. Thankfully he’s fairly well trained, we just have to watch it.

Ezri on the other hand, she’ll just lay down at the water and shove her about in it. Other dogs that we know can come next to her and take water and she doesn’t care.
 
I have two water bowls in my laundry room. The only reason I have two is just to be sure that they always have water. They never seem to be thirsty at the same time so it's usually a one-on-one type of thing.

They both get fed in the kitchen, one on either side of the island. Buddy is so relaxed about stuff like that or maybe should I say the b**** controls the house. :rolleyes: I've actually put down a plate and they both would eat out of it. But for the most part they each get their own even if it's leftovers after dinner. But Kali will always go over to Buddy's bowl or plate and lick it spotlessly clean! That's what little dogs are good for.:thumbsup2: They get every fricking scrap! Even sometimes when Buddy gets a dog treat like a big milk bone type of thing. He leaves a mess! Kali cleans it up. :D Big dog/little dog combo is the best! ;) LOL. I just always make sure that she sticks to her own bowl until Buddy is finished. She will barge right in if I don't. And he will let her:nono: :whoop:
 

Back
Top