Maja Rocks
$ Forum Donor $
Maja is my 6th doberman from many different lines and breedings and none of them were whiners so I don't believe it a breed trait.
I can't stand whining of any kind it drives me nuts.(Dogs or people)
Whining & excessive barking is like any other behavior if you allow it they will do it
If you make clear from moment it starts it is not an allowed behavior they won't. It's that simple.
The problem is if you allow it until it becomes annoying & problematic its hard to train them to stop.
Much like kids dogs learn what & who they can get away with this type of behavior.
My wife take is "Oh it's ok she's just excited"...My view "No it's obnoxious bad behavior."
My other 1/2 puts up with it... I just flat out don't.
If she starts I always respond instantly with a very firm HUSH! KNOCK IT OFF!! NO WHINING right away.
No exceptions .
About the only time she does it with me anymore is when we are in the car and pulling into the parking lot of the park. She just gets so excited she barley contain herself. Again Hush Knock it OFF!
She has learned with me that she has to sit quietly, put on her leash, settle down and wait for me to tell her "good girl..and give the come command" Until she sits, is calm and quiet she is not getting out of the car.
Anyway thats my view on whining, it's on my list of things I don't let my dogs do.
Cheers
MR
I can't stand whining of any kind it drives me nuts.(Dogs or people)
Whining & excessive barking is like any other behavior if you allow it they will do it
If you make clear from moment it starts it is not an allowed behavior they won't. It's that simple.
The problem is if you allow it until it becomes annoying & problematic its hard to train them to stop.
Much like kids dogs learn what & who they can get away with this type of behavior.
My wife take is "Oh it's ok she's just excited"...My view "No it's obnoxious bad behavior."
My other 1/2 puts up with it... I just flat out don't.
If she starts I always respond instantly with a very firm HUSH! KNOCK IT OFF!! NO WHINING right away.
No exceptions .
About the only time she does it with me anymore is when we are in the car and pulling into the parking lot of the park. She just gets so excited she barley contain herself. Again Hush Knock it OFF!
She has learned with me that she has to sit quietly, put on her leash, settle down and wait for me to tell her "good girl..and give the come command" Until she sits, is calm and quiet she is not getting out of the car.
Anyway thats my view on whining, it's on my list of things I don't let my dogs do.
Cheers
MR
I don't either, but I can't say he doesn't do it. I just nip it in the bud!
