• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Preventing whining?

Maja is my 6th doberman from many different lines and breedings and none of them were whiners so I don't believe it a breed trait.
I can't stand whining of any kind it drives me nuts.(Dogs or people)
Whining & excessive barking is like any other behavior if you allow it they will do it
If you make clear from moment it starts it is not an allowed behavior they won't. It's that simple.
The problem is if you allow it until it becomes annoying & problematic its hard to train them to stop.

Much like kids dogs learn what & who they can get away with this type of behavior.
My wife take is "Oh it's ok she's just excited"...My view "No it's obnoxious bad behavior."
My other 1/2 puts up with it... I just flat out don't.


If she starts I always respond instantly with a very firm HUSH! KNOCK IT OFF!! NO WHINING right away.
No exceptions .
About the only time she does it with me anymore is when we are in the car and pulling into the parking lot of the park. She just gets so excited she barley contain herself. Again Hush Knock it OFF!
She has learned with me that she has to sit quietly, put on her leash, settle down and wait for me to tell her "good girl..and give the come command" Until she sits, is calm and quiet she is not getting out of the car.

Anyway thats my view on whining, it's on my list of things I don't let my dogs do.
Cheers
MR
 
Maja is my 6th doberman from many different lines and breedings and none of them were whiners so I don't believe its a breed trait
If she starts I always respond instantly with a very firm HUSH! KNOCK IT OFF!! NO WHINING right away.
No exceptions .
About the only time she does it with me anymore is when we are in the car and pulling into the parking lot of the park. She just gets so excited she barley contain herself. Again Hush Knock it OFF!
So they DO whine, you just don't tolerate it. :rolleyes: I don't either, but I can't say he doesn't do it. I just nip it in the bud!

 
So they DO whine, you just don't tolerate it. :rolleyes: I don't either, but I can't say he doesn't do it. I just nip it in the bud!


LOL Well of course they can and do every dog can whine.
Puppies pretty much whimper & whine from the moment they are born.

I don't believe its a coincidence that some folks say all of their dogs whine even the ones that are others breeds.
And for others here whining is not or ever been a problem.

That tells me it a training/conditioning issue.
If a puppy whines and receives attention or some other response it perceives as positive it learns to whine when it wants something. If the whining gets no response or a negative response like a strong verbal correction they learn not to do it.

No different than a baby learning every it time cries its mother picks it up.
At 1st it cries because it physically needs something, feeding, diaper changed, has gas, is sick or just over tired & needs to be put in its crib to sleep.
As it gets older it learns crying even when it needs nothing will get it
attention and thus becomes attention seeking behavior.

With all due respect to those that believe whining is a breed trait I disagree.
The breed standard states "Energetic, watchful, determined alert, fearless, loyal and obedient".
Note it does not include "Whiny"
It's a sad state that many Dobermans bred today are far from meeting that standard and are fearful, shy and now I guess whiny too.

My family has had Dobermans since 1957 probably together we have had well over 30+ dobermans from many lines and many different breeders from all over the country. None of the Dobes we as family have owned ever have been what I consider whiners.

So I stand by my view that it is attention seeking behavior that the owners have (unknowingly) reinforced from the day they brought that cute little puppy home from the breeder and was whining & crying for it mother and litter mates.

I understand what I post won't make some folks happy & they would rather blame the dog than themselves for the issue.
It is certainly easier to chalk it up as a breed trait that you just have to live with than unwanted behavior they have some responsibility for.

I would love to hear if people here that are involved with upper level obedience or schutzhund have whining problems with their dogs my guess is they do not.

Cheers
MR
 
Maja, I know my way around obedience training and other types of training.

I learned on my first Dobe. I knew nothing, really, about dog training to start with; and I took that boy to a CDX and he knew all the exercises for the UD. Thing is, he hated the obedience ring, so I hung up the gloves so to speak. The only time he NQ'd in an obedience trial? It was for...

...whining on the out-of-sight stay. It was an indoor trial and those stressed him out even more than the outdoor trials.

That boy and I accomplished some other significant things together that I won't list here. He also got me into my locked truck twice in the same week. He also saved my life twice.

But he whined.

My second and, now, my third Doberman are whiners. Makes my wife and me want to pull our hair out.

Yes, we know very well that one should not reward whining with even negative attention.

Yes, I have tried to enforce the command to be silent. It works fine with barking, but not with whining. One thing I believe is that dogs don't always know that they are whining.

So, I guess you and your relatives have had about 10X the number of Dobermans that I have, so I have to put some stock in what you say. I just can't explain it!!

Do you count even the small, mild whines as whining?
 
I should add that I did all the training myself – never any classes or trainers. Just what I learned from reading books.
 
I would love to hear if people here that are involved with upper level obedience or schutzhund have whining problems with their dogs my guess is they do not.
Well @Doberman Gang, we are waiting to hear :D

My whining was "another breed" I did not tolerate it. I corrected it. I did not take my dog home as a puppy and coddle the behavior, I adopted her when she was a year old. I did not reward it. Unless you consider a stim on an ecollar reward. It made it worse. Whining went to louder whining to shaking if I increased the stim. I only let her out after she was quiet for a full minute. This was my method for 12 years and it never got better. I do believe the whining was due to high anxiety and how my lab was wired. No, it never went away. She only whined in a kenneled situation and there was movement around her that she was not involved in.
 
Do you count even the small, mild whines as whining?

Well now we get down to what is the definition of whining?
Is whining ever acceptable?..If so how much whining is ok etc...


What is the reason? Is it appropriate?

If my dog is pacing & whining because she needs to go outside to relive herself and is about to have an accident because she can't hold it anymore... I am perfectly good with that.

Whining because her toy or ball went under the sofa?
I am on the computer and ignoring her?
It's 1:15 and we go the park every day at 1:00..
Theres deer in the yard and she wants to go outside and chase them.
She wants affection..Not OK..

MR
 
Whining & excessive barking is like any other behavior if you allow it they will do it
If you make clear from moment it starts it is not an allowed behavior they won't. It's that simple.
The problem is if you allow it until it becomes annoying & problematic its hard to train them to stop.

If she starts I always respond instantly with a very firm HUSH! KNOCK IT OFF!! NO WHINING right away.
No exceptions .

Completely agree. Same thing here....

Labeling whining a breeding trait? Find that extremely hard to believe. More like an unwanted behavior that needs to be addressed.

Back when he was younger and we would had a 1hr drive to soccer training, he would get the verbal, the pop on snout and then ECollar stim. He learned quickly what the undesired behavior was. Ragnar hardly whines now- once/twice week maybe.

Had many dogs, only one Doberman. Treated all of them the same with whining- just not tolerated.
 
Completely agree. Same thing here....

Labeling whining a breeding trait? Find that extremely hard to believe. More like an unwanted behavior that needs to be addressed.

Back when he was younger and we would had a 1hr drive to soccer training, he would get the verbal, the pop on snout and then ECollar stim. He learned quickly what the undesired behavior was. Ragnar hardly whines now- once/twice week maybe.

Had many dogs, only one Doberman. Treated all of them the same with whining- just not tolerated.
I dunno, guys. I doubt either of you is going to out take-no-prisoners, take-no-chit me, and I have not been able to prevent whining.

By the way, it's certainly not unique to the Doberman to be whiny. I'd say it's a trait of GSDs to be whiny as well. Many other dogs, of course, too.
Of course whining is not in the breed standard guys. You know what is? "fearless." :rolleyes: I think this proves that what is in the standard is what should exist in the dog. It stands to reason that not all things that are common in the dog are in the standard.
 
With all due respect to those that believe whining is a breed trait I disagree.
The breed standard states "Energetic, watchful, determined alert, fearless, loyal and obedient".
Note it does not include "Whiny"
It's a sad state that many Dobermans bred today are far from meeting that standard and are fearful, shy and now I guess whiny too.

I'm not sure what you're thinking when some of us say "breed trait". We are not saying breed standard! Mr. Dobermann is probably rolling over in his grave at the whining. I feel sure that it has become a trait, through genetics, not being spoiled. Certainly not all Dobermans whine, but so many of them do nowadays it can be said that it is a Doberman thing. It can and should be corrected, but if it's in the genes it will be passed on. You have so much history with this breed I'd love to know if Maja is the first one you had to correct for whining or do you remember it at all in your dogs 20 - 30 years ago? The two that I had (about 1983 to about 2003) never had a whine or whistle in their life.

I would love to hear if people here that are involved with upper level obedience or schutzhund have whining problems with their dogs my guess is they do not.

Since Asha is just 9 months old, she hasn't been titled, but her dam is IGP3 and both grandsires are IGP3, and she is a born whiner. I don't tolerate it (see my posts on page 1 of this thread), but the whines and whistles still escape her lips. She is tough as nails, independent to a fault, and her defense and protection is natural and fearless. She's also very vocal with barking and growling. I've never experienced a whining dog in my life and reading about it on this forum before getting my puppy, I was SURE it was simply behavior that escalated because handlers allowed it. And getting a proven working line dog certainly would eliminate my chances of dealing with a whiner.... haha, I've never been so wrong.

I have had an interest in genetics from my horse training days - so many behavioral traits in animals are highly genetic and the Doberman is so inbred there is no way behavioral traits won't be shared. It is well known that a handful of very popular Thoroughbred sires produced good runners but most had difficult personalities, rank & tough and sometimes near impossible to train. The endearing "Velcro" trait in our Dobermans seems to have escalated as well, from the original design of being loyal to todays dog that doesn't want to go potty in the yard without its owner (not my dog, but I read it on this forum) to separation anxiety. DNA from a small gene pool is my theory, and it's just not getting better.
 
Well @Doberman Gang, we are waiting to hear :D

My whining was "another breed" I did not tolerate it. I corrected it. I did not take my dog home as a puppy and coddle the behavior, I adopted her when she was a year old. I did not reward it. Unless you consider a stim on an ecollar reward. It made it worse. Whining went to louder whining to shaking if I increased the stim. I only let her out after she was quiet for a full minute. This was my method for 12 years and it never got better. I do believe the whining was due to high anxiety and how my lab was wired. No, it never went away. She only whined in a kenneled situation and there was movement around her that she was not involved in.
I don’t tolerate whining. If my dogs whine they get correct for it. Period, it isn’t acceptable. They will learn how to act. I reward them for good behavior but whining is
Well @Doberman Gang, we are waiting to hear :D

My whining was "another breed" I did not tolerate it. I corrected it. I did not take my dog home as a puppy and coddle the behavior, I adopted her when she was a year old. I did not reward it. Unless you consider a stim on an ecollar reward. It made it worse. Whining went to louder whining to shaking if I increased the stim. I only let her out after she was quiet for a full minute. This was my method for 12 years and it never got better. I do believe the whining was due to high anxiety and how my lab was wired. No, it never went away. She only whined in a kenneled situation and there was movement around her that she was not involved in.
I have had some that whined but I teach my negative marker to mark wrong behavior. Blaze wears an ecollar but he is more of an aggressive barker in his kennel and needs cap himself. I also teach my down and sit command as a quiet position for competition so if they are whining or making noise in their kennel I will usually give a down command to tell them to be quiet. If they do not comply they get corrected per there correction method. This way they understand what is being asked. Whining to me is a sign of insecurity or a dog with separation issues (also insecurity) confidence building is a must.
 
I have had some that whined but I teach my negative marker to mark wrong behavior
I don't think the question is whether to correct or not, but is this a Doberman "trait" that is now in our breed. I would think with your training from day one with your puppies, if it wasn't in their genes it would not ever show up in a household like yours. Which leads me back to being in the genetic makeup of our breed and we are left to manage it. Does your Mal whine? Prada? Just curious.
 
Our first Schutzhund trainer had 2 Dobermans. A Euro male from more conformation lines (like my whiner) and another Euro from working lines, both whine. I’ll never forget the first time I heard the male whining - my heart skipped a beat because I had put Kaiser away in my hb’s car and I thought he escaped - he has never escaped and we are both very careful about this, but the whining was exactly like Kaiser so you can imagine my panic. When I headed for the door, acting all calm and collected of course lol, guess who was waiting their turn to come in? The male Dobe, not mine lol, what a relief! He now has his IGP2. She can correct him for whining and he does stop, but then he just picks it up again, like seconds later, it’s like excitement whining. I agree that sometimes they are not aware they are doing it. In our current club, one guy used to have Dobermans and he said whining was not a thing - this was maybe in the 90s? I can’t remember, but I should compare notes with him.

I kinda suspect it has been inadvertently bred in. Because it is just a sound and not something physical we can see, no one caught on to the whining becoming an inherited trait. Like Dobermans being notorious for swallowing non-food items (pica), that has got to be a trait that can be traced back to the parents. Along with the whining, pica is on my list of questions for the next breeder.
 
Nero used to whine a lot Now he licks his chops when he used to whine for attention. He will still whine and get noisy when he sees something "weird" in the back yard, or a dog he wants to play with on a walk. Immediate "hush!" He doesn't wear a collar in the house but a stim collar probably would curb those unwanted behaviors. I don't know what's more annoying, the whining or the chewing and lip licking.
 
I don't think the question is whether to correct or not, but is this a Doberman "trait" that is now in our breed. I would think with your training from day one with your puppies, if it wasn't in their genes it would not ever show up in a household like yours. Which leads me back to being in the genetic makeup of our breed and we are left to manage it. Does your Mal whine? Prada? Just curious.
Mal’s don’t whine, Prada and Redman do not whine either. Blaze is an aggressive barker and has to be capped frequently. His drive is very high and not a fun house dog but on the training field is amazing. Definitely would not be a good pet home dog. Yes I agree whining is a genetic flaw but I think can also be trained if the dog is not raised properly. ( if the dog whines then get attention it reinforces that behavior). Fearful dogs is also poor genetics
 
She can correct him for whining and he does stop, but then he just picks it up again, like seconds later, it’s like excitement whining.
Exactly was this for Java. She knew if she wanted out she had to stop whining and she would eventually, moments before being let out. No way she would stop whining the entire time being in the kennel. It was excitement/anticipation to play. She would stop if I told her to...but pick it back up. Do I endlessly nag and correct her? Up the stim to a level where whining equals not desirable at all for her and it'd turn into muscle shaking. In that case I'd wait until she stopped shaking for a second. Well now shes shaking, but hey she's not whining! :woot2: I can't imagine correcting her for shaking so I would only reward when she would put her head down and sigh to let that frustration out. I'll admit as we went to more dog shows, she got better but it never truly went away despite being consistent with her every. single. time. Maybe I should have gone to loads more shows, I'll tell that to my husband next time :D

By the way this was only when crated for sports or outside. Indoors, angel. Sleep all day. Not a peep. No separation anxiety.
 
That tells me it a training/conditioning issue.
If a puppy whines and receives attention or some other response it perceives as positive it learns to whine when it wants something. If the whining gets no response or a negative response like a strong verbal correction they learn not to do it.

With the next one, I would take an even more firm correction with whining so that it never becomes a habit. Maybe with it becoming a habit it also becomes self soothing and therefore harder to break. So earlier intervention with a stronger aversive.

Mr. Dobermann is probably rolling over in his grave at the whining.
Ya, like whose idea was it for such fierce looking dogs to cry like bitches! Good thing they have their looks so it’s easier to forgive them haha.

reading about it on this forum before getting my puppy, I was SURE it was simply behavior that escalated because handlers allowed it.
I know right! I keep thinking that since my hb raised Kaiser he must have rewarded the whining somehow, but if you knew about it and still couldn’t avoid it, that definitely supports the argument for a genetic component.
 

Back
Top