• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Preventing whining?

DaisyD

New Member
I mentioned on the intro forum that we recently lost our Dobie and are currently in the process of getting a puppy. One thing I would like to know is if I can get ahead of Dobie whining?

That was our girl's only annoying habit. She whined from the moment we met her until the day she died. She was extremely manipulative with it and would use it to get her way with our other dogs- so even if we ignored her, she would whine to the other dogs and they would eventually cave and give in to whatever she wanted (the bed, the toy, etc. they had) and it stayed reinforced. She would also whine when we were in the car, at the vet, when it stormed, when she wanted to get to the cat's food- you name it. She got plenty of exercise- the whining seemed to be more about getting her way than anything else.

I know they are vocal dogs, but I figure there has to be a way to nix the whining. Any suggestions on how we can make sure the next one doesn't develop this habit? Especially as we still have the same two other dogs who are also easily annoyed by whining and just give in themselves, lol?

We have had many puppies/dogs over the years, but this Dobie was the first and only to be a whiner- it's been a decade since we got her and I've had a bunch of kids between now and then so my memories of her puppyhood are pretty much gone- I am sure there was a point we could've nipped this but we apparently missed it. I remember ear posting, and not much else of what we did/didn't do, so if anyone has tips on how to stop the whining habit before it starts it would be much appreciated!
 
Isn't the whining JUST THE WORST! :spit: It's such a Doberman thing though, I wonder if anyone here has a non-whining Doberman? We really tried to keep ours quiet as he came into a very quiet household with a perfectly behaved cat and now even the cat can't shut up lol. The animals really do learn from each other :wacky: All I know is that all whining is to be ignored. Never give in to it or else they use it against you, as you already know. To be fair, ours gets vocal when we leave him on the main floor as he's not allowed on the carpeted upstairs, so we kinda did that to ourselves. Although, when he's napping or sleeping, he has no problem being on his own. We heavily praised him for keeping Quiet, so we can get him to stop once he starts provided he's well exercised. If he's full of energy, Quiet is a hard sell, lol.
 
Ragnar was not initially a whiner and then all of a sudden he started. He would whine for food, attention, in car, etc.... I tried the “ignoring” technique but it did not stop.

This may not be the most recommended or appreciated way but I just didn’t/don’t allow it at all. I would correct him everytime he would whine. I would pay special attention and be on the spot as soon as he whined. Correcting him with a firm No at first, then a pop on the snout, or grabbing his snout. If he was out of reach, then I would have the ECollar on him and give him a very light stim or vibrate. Nothing to rock his world but just enough that when I said ”No stop whining” that he knew what I was talking about- Kinda hard to correct it when you are driving so an ECollar worked well here.

The whole idea was to make sure he knew that I was not going to allow him to whine, just not acceptable. Took a little while, as did everything else, but Ragnar does not whine. If he does, I curtly tell him to stop and he does. Now, I get that side eyed look from him, but he stops.

Gosh, I just dislike the sound of the whining....
 
Luckily my girl is generally a non-whiner (now barking is another story). That being said, when she decides she MUST HAVE SOMETHING it's a full on tantrum. Throwing herself on the floor. Whistling. Barking. Play bowing. Teeth flaring. The works. If we're eating and she feels like we've forgotten about her and she whines, we ignore her; don't even make eye contact. We've done that from day one so it's very rare she does that.

Now if she whines in the crate at night? Then it's a bathroom emergency and I'm out of bed before my eye lids are open.

I'm not sure how to prevent it from the beginning but I imagine the volume level and amount is unique to each dog. If she starts doing the same thing your last Dobe did, it's almost like she needs to be redirected away from the situation as soon as it starts so she doesn't get rewarded with what she's after. Like when they start chewing on something they shouldn't, redirect redirect redirect.
 
I personally think there are different types of whining. One to get attention/something they want, and one that they do automatically probably stemming from anticipation or anxiety.

Jasper whines every morning. I have tried correcting him with the e collar but he wasn’t getting it. So then I asked myself why is he whining? This particular whine is due to some anxiety as he waits for us to go out and exercise. I just have a gut feeling he can’t control it, so I ignore it.

However I did find if he was whining from being reactive I could correct him. I give him a “leave it” command where I expect him to chill out and stop focusing on what the distraction is. Like @Ddski5 I use the e collar in the car. Some days he just can’t stand people and dogs walking outside the car.

Honestly I can’t see Jasper ever being a quiet dog. He whines a lot and in most situations it is ignored. Typically if its coupled with reactivity then he is corrected.
 
I wonder if anyone here has a non-whining Doberman?
The only time Della whines is if she sees a critter outside that she just "has to get" or if she really has an emergency needing to go out. Albert on the other hand is a big time whiner and I really don't think there would have been much we could have done differently when he was a pup to prevent it.
Especially as we still have the same two other dogs who are also easily annoyed by whining and just give in themselves
At least you don't have a parrot who learned to whine so perfectly that you can't tell if it's the dog or bird. LOL
 
Hey!

There is no way to prevent whining. Believe me, I wish there was. The whining is one of the factors that has me considering switching breeds.

I train my Dobes the silent command which means do not bark or vocalize. Unfortunately, I believe dogs often don't realize they're whining, so it's not possible to train and command them to not whine. I've reprimanded Oji for whining and he appears to be confused as to what he did wrong.

If he's pacing and whining because I am trying to get us ready to go for a walk or to leave the house, however, and I utter a very frustrated growly, at-my-wits-end sort of noise he knows I'm unhappy about something and he sort of moves away and lays down and watches me until I do the next step of readying at which point he jumps up, and his whining increases again.

One saving grace: If I put him on a sit-stay or down-stay his whining almost stops completely. I allow no whining during a stay, so I have to go to him an correct him if he whines on a stay.

Just remember to always clearly release your Dobe from the stay. A very very common mistake people make is to tell their dog to sit or lay down, and since the dog has stopped bugging them, they then just let the dog decide when to get up.
 
I tried the ignoring thing but it didn't work at all. The whining came with the puppy from day one, it wasn't learned, so I do think this is a genetic trait and some are much worse than others. The two Dobes I had in the 1980's and '90's never whined and Dobes were very popular then and I never knew a single one that ever whined. Like @Ddski5 I tried to ignore it since I'd read so much about it and that seems to be the #1 suggestion, but after about 2 weeks it was just getting louder and more insistent and becoming impossible to wait for a quiet period. I began saying a firm NO and if that didn't stop it then I closed my hand on her muzzle with another NO. Almost all the whining in her young days was in the crate or x-pen when I was trying to get something done without a puppy underfoot, as she got older it was barrier frustration whining & barking if she could see me but not be with me. I used NO a LOT. I never corrected her if it was night time whining to go out to potty, we'd go straight out to potty and straight back in with no words at all. Now at 8 months she is about 90% "cured".... only whines when I'm fixing her food (I don't mind that & don't correct for it) or (the last hurdle) after I put her back in the crate after her a.m. potty because I'm not ready to get up yet. I don't think the pure positive will get you very far with this breed, but once they understand no means no, it makes all the boundaries clear. Tell your puppy no when it's using whining or other tactics to order your other dogs around. Establish yourself as a strong family leader so puppy understands you control the situation all the time. I was firm and insistent, but never abusive. It took lots and lots of repetition and more patience than I knew I had.

Also she is a very vocal dog in all ways, barks at every little noise and movement. Wondering if it's a mix of the suggestions above: a dominent demanding personality, high drive and high anxiety?

I know this whining thing has been discussed many times here and I *think* there were a few people who said they never had a problem with it, but not many. And also some older folks like me, didn't recall it at all in the Dobes pre-2000'ish.

@strykerdobe is Zara the dam of the puppy you kept from your recent litter? Does the puppy whine? And if Zara doesn't whine but other Dobes in your family do, does it seem like an inherited trait?
 
I tried the ignoring thing but it didn't work at all. The whining came with the puppy from day one, it wasn't learned, so I do think this is a genetic trait and some are much worse than others. The two Dobes I had in the 1980's and '90's never whined and Dobes were very popular then and I never knew a single one that ever whined. Like @Ddski5 I tried to ignore it since I'd read so much about it and that seems to be the #1 suggestion, but after about 2 weeks it was just getting louder and more insistent and becoming impossible to wait for a quiet period. I began saying a firm NO and if that didn't stop it then I closed my hand on her muzzle with another NO. Almost all the whining in her young days was in the crate or x-pen when I was trying to get something done without a puppy underfoot, as she got older it was barrier frustration whining & barking if she could see me but not be with me. I used NO a LOT. I never corrected her if it was night time whining to go out to potty, we'd go straight out to potty and straight back in with no words at all. Now at 8 months she is about 90% "cured".... only whines when I'm fixing her food (I don't mind that & don't correct for it) or (the last hurdle) after I put her back in the crate after her a.m. potty because I'm not ready to get up yet. I don't think the pure positive will get you very far with this breed, but once they understand no means no, it makes all the boundaries clear. Tell your puppy no when it's using whining or other tactics to order your other dogs around. Establish yourself as a strong family leader so puppy understands you control the situation all the time. I was firm and insistent, but never abusive. It took lots and lots of repetition and more patience than I knew I had.

Also she is a very vocal dog in all ways, barks at every little noise and movement. Wondering if it's a mix of the suggestions above: a dominent demanding personality, high drive and high anxiety?

I know this whining thing has been discussed many times here and I *think* there were a few people who said they never had a problem with it, but not many. And also some older folks like me, didn't recall it at all in the Dobes pre-2000'ish.

@strykerdobe is Zara the dam of the puppy you kept from your recent litter? Does the puppy whine? And if Zara doesn't whine but other Dobes in your family do, does it seem like an inherited trait?


Yes Zara is Arsons mom. Yes he does some whinning but quiets down. Our 10yr 4mo old male Yago is a whinner at times.
 
as she got older it was barrier frustration whining & barking if she could see me but not be with me.

This is something I am battling now with Jasper. It always happens when he is in our backyard and I am just outside the fence. I can hear him whining up a storm and it can last for as long as I am out there. I still haven’t found a way to fix this. Its still early in the season, I am hoping if I do this daily he will get used to it and settle. Using the e-collar just makes him bark instead of whine.
 
I mentioned on the intro forum that we recently lost our Dobie and are currently in the process of getting a puppy. One thing I would like to know is if I can get ahead of Dobie whining?

That was our girl's only annoying habit. She whined from the moment we met her until the day she died. She was extremely manipulative with it and would use it to get her way with our other dogs- so even if we ignored her, she would whine to the other dogs and they would eventually cave and give in to whatever she wanted (the bed, the toy, etc. they had) and it stayed reinforced. She would also whine when we were in the car, at the vet, when it stormed, when she wanted to get to the cat's food- you name it. She got plenty of exercise- the whining seemed to be more about getting her way than anything else.

I know they are vocal dogs, but I figure there has to be a way to nix the whining. Any suggestions on how we can make sure the next one doesn't develop this habit? Especially as we still have the same two other dogs who are also easily annoyed by whining and just give in themselves, lol?

We have had many puppies/dogs over the years, but this Dobie was the first and only to be a whiner- it's been a decade since we got her and I've had a bunch of kids between now and then so my memories of her puppyhood are pretty much gone- I am sure there was a point we could've nipped this but we apparently missed it. I remember ear posting, and not much else of what we did/didn't do, so if anyone has tips on how to stop the whining habit before it starts it would be much appreciated!
Awwwwe. I’m very sorry you lost your dog.

I was just thinking the same thing today.
He’s just walking around the house whining today for no apparent reason I think it’s just the A dobie thing? But right now he’s busy tearing the Ivy down in my backyard and redoing the landscaping for me. I can’t have anything nice. Lol. Enjoy!
 
Not just Dobermans either! Java (lab) was a huge whiner. I felt like she liked hearing herself do it. I attributed hers to anxiety and frustration. Only in the kennel she would do it. She was always go go go. Never could get her to stop, no matter how much rewarding the literal second of quiet or punishing the whine with an ecollar. I never would let her out of the kennel until she sat and was quiet. That didn't matter for the time she was in the kennel and if we were doing something outside without her. She would go in the kennel in the house quiet as a lamb and chill. But in the garage or events where people are doing things without her, GASP, nope. It was annoying (to me) for events because it was the one thing I could not fix so we always kenneled away from others.

Let me know when you figure it out. It drove me insane...
 
I do think she leaned in the anxious personality direction. She was deathly terrified of storms! But it seemed she had two gears in the house- passed out asleep, or pacing and whining. If you took her outside, she was full bore tearing around. The minute you came in, gear 1 or gear 2. There wasn't much middle ground.

I will say with age it got worse, and we were suspecting dementia over the last six months- she had a few weird quirks pop up and the whining became almost enough to drive us to the brink. The vet ran a million tests and she failed part of the neurological exam (one nostril wouldn't react but the other side she would), but despite all of testing, nothing came out in the results. They put her on a med called Selegiline which was a miracle drug though. In all the years it was the only thing that reduced the whining for the last few months.

It's interesting to hear we are not the only ones to deal with this! It makes me feel a bit better than I didn't make some horrible puppy rearing mistake. She was very vocal. I think I miss her little happy groans and grunts as she would lie down at night, the most. Our other dogs are quiet unless something/one is approaching the house. Dobies are like noise machines I guess!
 
@LifeofRubie I am the same way with Remi during the night if I hear a whine. If I put her in the crate to during the day for anything whether it be leave for work or run an errand she has a full blown hissy fit. But we learned when DH closes crate for work she has no problem. He thinks for some reason it bothers her when I do it. So we changed our morning leave for work routine. But now I have been home for 6 weeks and she has been with me almost 24/7. The 5 times she wasn't with me DH was home with her.
She whines when she sees a squirrel in the yard, but thats about all.
 
I'm on my 5th dobie and haven't had a whiner yet so there is hope!
I think Rumor is the quietest one yet. I've never heard her even make a noise that sounds close to a whine. She has been by far the easiest to live with. That is until she's hungry, she's still pretty quiet by likes to do the nose poke dance until her full bowl is in front of her.
 
This is something I am battling now with Jasper. It always happens when he is in our backyard and I am just outside the fence. I can hear him whining up a storm and it can last for as long as I am out there. I still haven’t found a way to fix this. Its still early in the season, I am hoping if I do this daily he will get used to it and settle. Using the e-collar just makes him bark instead of whine.
Yes, that's exactly it: barrier frustration. I used "No" a lot, to no avail, but I still would shout it across the way to show my disapproval. Now at 8 months just beginning to use the e-collar pairing a nick when I use the word "no". She's beginning to understand now that "no" really means "stop whatever you're doing, right now" and it doesn't matter how far away I am. But actually she has gotten better and better before the e-collar, I'd say the last two months. The pre-6 months old period, I thought I was spinning my wheels and nothing was going to work.

@GennyB - Until I got my puppy, I was just sure the whining I'd heard about was due to spoiled dogs, but now I know it's really a Doberman thing. If you wouldn't mind I'd love to see pedigrees of non-whiners, just for curiosity sake.
 
Kaiser is hanging out with my hb on the main floor and is low level whining because he knows I'm awake but lounging in bed. How dare I, right? :rolleyes: My hb doesn't read minds like Kaiser does, so he finally says to him, Quiet. Then Kaiser responds with a yawn which sounded like a nose whistle coming from his throat, and three seconds later he groans and a quieter level whining starts :rofl: Guess I better get up :wacky:
 
Did you ever notice when you give a dog a command (not like in formal obedience, but just like the "Quiet" command you mentioned) they YAWN. It's like a kid sulking "oh, alright, why do you always pick on me for nothing" :rofl:
 
This may not be the most recommended or appreciated way but I just didn’t/don’t allow it at all. I would correct him everytime he would whine.

I personally think there are different types of whining.

I agree with both of you! I know there are times when Buddy is trying to tell me something with a little whine. It could be that he wants to go outside. But, for the most part, I feel he's telling me it's time to do something! I swear that dog has a built in clock for a routine. He knows when I have breakfast, he knows when I get up, he knows when I'm going out to the barn, he knows when we're going to bed! If I'm not doing some of those things, I get the whine! OMG sometimes I actually will scream at him, "Listen!!! I'll tell you when it's time to (fill in the blank). When I'm good and ready!! LOL He does know the word, 'quiet!' And he will be quiet. But it just drive me batty sometime when he's trying to tell me I am out of sync with my routine. Or if I'm just too damn slow getting on with the routine. I never react to the whine. In fact, if he whines and I told him to be quiet, I take my time. I don't want him to think that he whines and I jump! :nono:

T'wat you say, Buddy?

Oh, yea? :martini:
 

Back
Top