DaisyD
New Member
I mentioned on the intro forum that we recently lost our Dobie and are currently in the process of getting a puppy. One thing I would like to know is if I can get ahead of Dobie whining?
That was our girl's only annoying habit. She whined from the moment we met her until the day she died. She was extremely manipulative with it and would use it to get her way with our other dogs- so even if we ignored her, she would whine to the other dogs and they would eventually cave and give in to whatever she wanted (the bed, the toy, etc. they had) and it stayed reinforced. She would also whine when we were in the car, at the vet, when it stormed, when she wanted to get to the cat's food- you name it. She got plenty of exercise- the whining seemed to be more about getting her way than anything else.
I know they are vocal dogs, but I figure there has to be a way to nix the whining. Any suggestions on how we can make sure the next one doesn't develop this habit? Especially as we still have the same two other dogs who are also easily annoyed by whining and just give in themselves, lol?
We have had many puppies/dogs over the years, but this Dobie was the first and only to be a whiner- it's been a decade since we got her and I've had a bunch of kids between now and then so my memories of her puppyhood are pretty much gone- I am sure there was a point we could've nipped this but we apparently missed it. I remember ear posting, and not much else of what we did/didn't do, so if anyone has tips on how to stop the whining habit before it starts it would be much appreciated!
That was our girl's only annoying habit. She whined from the moment we met her until the day she died. She was extremely manipulative with it and would use it to get her way with our other dogs- so even if we ignored her, she would whine to the other dogs and they would eventually cave and give in to whatever she wanted (the bed, the toy, etc. they had) and it stayed reinforced. She would also whine when we were in the car, at the vet, when it stormed, when she wanted to get to the cat's food- you name it. She got plenty of exercise- the whining seemed to be more about getting her way than anything else.
I know they are vocal dogs, but I figure there has to be a way to nix the whining. Any suggestions on how we can make sure the next one doesn't develop this habit? Especially as we still have the same two other dogs who are also easily annoyed by whining and just give in themselves, lol?
We have had many puppies/dogs over the years, but this Dobie was the first and only to be a whiner- it's been a decade since we got her and I've had a bunch of kids between now and then so my memories of her puppyhood are pretty much gone- I am sure there was a point we could've nipped this but we apparently missed it. I remember ear posting, and not much else of what we did/didn't do, so if anyone has tips on how to stop the whining habit before it starts it would be much appreciated!
It's such a Doberman thing though, I wonder if anyone here has a non-whining Doberman? We really tried to keep ours quiet as he came into a very quiet household with a perfectly behaved cat and now even the cat can't shut up lol. The animals really do learn from each other
My hb doesn't read minds like Kaiser does, so he finally says to him, Quiet. Then Kaiser responds with a yawn which sounded like a nose whistle coming from his throat, and three seconds later he groans and a quieter level whining starts
Guess I better get up 
