• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Having two Dobermans/dogs

THANK YOU!! My biggest worry is for one or the other just one day decided they are fed up with the arrangement.
I’ve seen some owners having the same sex for both their Dobermans and yet Dobes are known for same sex aggression, but it does not seem to manifest in all scenarios. I’ve also seen some people on Facebook who come across as idiots and yet they are able to manage 2 males or 2 females with seemingly no issues. It is a major curiosity for me because I would love 2 males (but still wouldn’t risk it!) and this presentation did give me good insight on WHY the fights can occur. Maybe the idiots aren’t so dumb after all, or maybe they are doing something right without knowing it :spit:
 
Maybe the idiots aren’t so dumb after all, or maybe they are doing something right without knowing it


HEY...HEY..HEY!!!!!waituh min-nut...I think I resemble that remark!!!!!

:rofl:

I had a LOT of concerns about having two dogs..and two male dogs.....two male DOBERMAN DOGS......OMG.

I had nightmares for the first month we had Bam in house of them getting into it and not being able to stop them from doing sever damage..or worse to each other. The damned dreams were so real I would get up and check on them...and hells bells..BAM was crated at night for the first eight months in the house!!!

But I still had to go make sure he was okay and Mo was okay.
Poor Bam would look at me with just one eye open and it was
"Lady, why do you keep waking me up????"
Mo would just snort and roll his back to me when I walked into the room at night.
(He still does..now days Bam hits the floor cuz he don't wanna miss a thing.)

We had about five weeks with Bam in house before we had him neutered and then of course we had a few months before his system was fully flushed of that "makes-a-guy-wonky" chemical stew. We didn't let Bam sleep outside his crate/ leave them alone in the house unsupervised... for eight months. Alone in the house....we worked up to that a few minutes at a time....by going outside and making them think we left.

What was awesome about what I learned in the presentation.....this is the way we have been working with both guys from the get-go.....Bam knows he is low man on the totem pole...he's always been cool with that...as long as he doesn't sense he is getting left out.

What was comical about watching that...about five minutes from the end..it dawned on me.....this is how raised our kids....there was a "healthy-in order of birth-pecking order" with them.

For the most part.... we let them settle the squabbles on their own....and a few times I think I mighta got one of them by the legs and yanked them up in the air to slow their roll with their siblings...I am saying mighta....maybe.... :innocent:
 
My experience with 2 at once is it is a completely different than one at time.
Putting aside the expense factor ,the poop factor, the training difficulties , and the simple logistics of sharing your life with 2 dobermans. Is that it changed the dynamics of the relationships I had with my dogs.

Been there done that glad I did it....Wont ever do it again!
For me having only one is not only cheeper, simpler & easier.
It is a better more close & special relationship.
When I had more than one it was different.
Not that I didn't love both dogs and they did't love me and it wasn't great!
But the reality for me is I had to divide my time attention and affection between 2 the two dogs instead of my sole focus being on just one.

Everybody is different lots of folks love big families and the more the merrier!
If you fall into that category good for you and god bless you! Go for it!


Me well I guess maybe I am just selfish.
I want the relationship I have with my dog to be something special.
Same with the relationship with my wife.
Just me and them. No splitting our time, attention or affection with anyone else .
Okay Maja loves her too! And I am good with that!
I guess I am just a one woman / one dog type of man.

Anyway thats my experience....Yours may be the complete opposite.
MR
 
So much to learn here in this thread! I have a housemate (not a Other Half situation, just a long time friend) and she got her puppy 5 years ago, so that made me the "Auntie". But Not.My.Dog. They were having so much fun training and getting multiple titles I finally decided it was time to get my own pup, but fretted like crazy how to raise a puppy in a house with not just another dog, but someone ELSE's dog. Luckily we are on the same page on training and dog psychology and everything is working out - but it would be so much easier to train & bond without a 2nd dog. Asha the puppy has to train with less freedom and more distractions and Reckless the elder no longer has the freedom she was use to. None of it would be as easy if Reckless was not trained to the hilt.
 
but fretted like crazy how to raise a puppy in a house with not just another dog, but someone ELSE's dog.


It's encouraging to see you are having such great results, a solid testament to how much responsibility comes with being an owner and how much of the weight of things working out for all falls on the shoulders of the owner.

That had to make for some interesting moments. It's awkward at times when we go visit our daughter. We all know we have to be able to correct all the animals..but have to be respectful of the methods we each use.

Luckily we are on the same page on training and dog psychology and everything is working out

That's the saving grace, for sure!


Every time I open this thread I think about a work acquaintance that had a Boxer.....that was a wild child.

The dog had the basics...but that was IT!

The guy was half hearted at making the dog do anything. When I found out he got another Boxer....I thought
"OH BOY...this isn't going to end well."
and it didn't.

He ended up re homing both boys...to two different homes, they weren't good together and that had to do with the fact...he was irresponsible with one...two just doubled up on his lack heart to train and equaled two messed up dogs. We ran into him not knowing he'd re homed the dogs......I asked how they were doing...and got the news he didn't have them anymore. The end of the conversation...was the real stunner tho.
He said
"I got another Boxer because I figured since they were the same breed, they'd get along without a lot of work."

(My husband got me by the arm....and started tugging on me, quickly making an exit.... stage left.....saying our "well got go...good to see ya" goodbyes to the joker...and then was shoving me further out...LOL.
Yeah...my man..he knows me:laughing:)

Another thing that comes with having two of the same breed.....it's double the curiosity attention.

I say "same breed" cuz a friend has two Aussie heelers. When we decided to keep Bam, he warned about the double curiosity thing. He said when he got his first Aussie girl...people for the most part...didn't pay a lot of attention to him when he was out with her....when he got the second girl.......he said people noticing them ampped up a lot and he got a lot more questions about his girls. We noticed the same thing after we added Bam to the mix.

It really clicked for me when I noticed...out with one....people notice but keep moving..out with both of them we get a lot more people noticing and asking questions......and this is where we all could probably write a list three miles long about "The stupid stuff people say" *face/palm*.

We didn't bring Bam home with the intent of keeping him.....we just wanted him OUT of the enviroment he was in and we had planned ahead to get him healthy and get home re-homed, but he settled in so well...by the end of the second month....we knew he was "re homed"....with us.
 
Other issues I have always wondered.....


Copy and paste from @Gelcoater post as to not detail his thread.

Rocky, ever the button pusher pushed her buttons. She was, in this pic getting ready to roll over, jump up and snarl, gnash teeth, bark and tell him to :censored: Off! in Doberman language.


It’s interesting that some times he becomes really possessive of a toy, yet other times he will let her literally take it out of his mouth and walk off with it?

How do you know when to step in and correct unwanted behavior? Who gets the toy? Who gets the pillow? One being a complete jackhole??

What kind of interdiction is warranted? Scold? Separation of rooms?

When do you know just to sit back and let them determine heirarchy status? It’s time for her to step up and stop taking shit??
 
Other issues I have always wondered.....


Copy and paste from @Gelcoater post as to not detail his thread.

Rocky, ever the button pusher pushed her buttons. She was, in this pic getting ready to roll over, jump up and snarl, gnash teeth, bark and tell him to :censored: Off! in Doberman language.


It’s interesting that some times he becomes really possessive of a toy, yet other times he will let her literally take it out of his mouth and walk off with it?

How do you know when to step in and correct unwanted behavior? Who gets the toy? Who gets the pillow? One being a complete jackhole??

What kind of interdiction is warranted? Scold? Separation of rooms?

When do you know just to sit back and let them determine heirarchy status? It’s time for her to step up and stop taking shit??
If one of them becomes overly possessive with something I remind them that Everything! is mine!
So it’s now my toy/pillow/whatever.
They can have it back later.

Stepping in is usually when one changes tone and or gets snappy. I try to tone them down before they get that far. It’s a constant learning curve learning the dog language. Subtle and not so subtle body movements, postures, tone of voice.

I can usually stop them with a clap to grab attention and a verbal command.
This new one has some serious focus.
I’ve found having a water bottle around handy.
On the second or third verbal she’s getting a quick splash. I have her complete attention at that point.

She’s thoroughly entrenched in the Doberteens, so she’s extra challenging atm.;)
Feisty, quick, a bit stubborn, and very perceptive.
She’s very much a morning dog, while none of the rest of us including Rocky are, lol. :rolleyes:
 
When do you know just to sit back and let them determine heirarchy status? It’s time for her to step up and stop taking shit??

Stepping in is usually when one changes tone and or gets snappy. I try to tone them down before they get that far. It’s a constant learning curve learning the dog language. Subtle and not so subtle body movements, postures, tone of voice.

^^^^That...lots and lots of watching them play and noting dog distinct body language and posturing....and reinforcing the commands to slow them down.

Our boys know "OUT!" as the command to chill NOW!!! It took Bam longer to it get than Moose....we use this command when they are getting to over charged with anything.....each other...us...toys....just being buttheads.

Also..I don't know if the info is here on site....but search ( or google) sneeze communicating. As soon as one of the guys STOPS the fake snort sneeze communicating...we are getting them OUT and disengaged.
 
I can't seem to find any info here on site about sneeze communication....and don't want to drop unverified links into the site....so google "why dogs sneeze" and there's plenty of info out there about the subject. This is one of the "I know that" things my husband came equipped with waaaaayyy back when we got our first doberguy...and it saved my sanity when we were around other dogs. I'd never had a "pet" much less an indoor pet...until I got married....grew up around dogs and cats..BUT the dogs weren't pets..they were working dogs blue/red heelers...and barn cats....feral barn cats:shock:.


My husband spent more time training me then he did the pup.

Me..trying to get the dog off the sofa
"GET DOWN!"
Dog..lays down on sofa looking proud he followed a command...waiting for praise.
Me...
"DOWN!!"
Dog trying to hunker down lower on sofa....and now looking very confused.
Me..
Yelling at husband :censored::censored::censored::censored::censored:Dog won't mind!!

Husband in walks and say's
"Off"
Pup gets off sofa and goes to husband for praise.

Next event...husband sitting down at table and creating a "commands"crib sheet for me to study.


It’s a constant learning curve

Sometimes...the learning curve ain't just for the dog.
 
I kinda figured if I poked enough I would find something in the scope of:
(I'm wearing the search function out...so glad the site doesn't charge "per search!!)


What kind of interdiction is warranted? Scold? Separation of rooms?

When do you know just to sit back and let them determine heirarchy status? It’s time for her to step up and stop taking shit??

On site:

How to: Interpret dog communication, a beginners g

I didn't see anything about sneeze communicating. I've had some owners/trainers tell me this isn't something dogs do...and I am reading something into nothing...but it has been our experience both boys track with the info out there about sneeze communicating and I know that both boarding facilitates we use train their employees to pay attention to sneeze communicating.


Recognizing dominant behavior
We've found that what goes for one of the guys trying push Alpha with us...they will do to each other...so "fine tune by watching" each one of them helps us spot things sometimes before they even get a chance to follow thru.

We also stop them mid play..even when things are going along fine so they know we say OUT...they stop. What we have to watch when we do this..Bam will almost always....try to get one more punch thrown:laughing:.

We randomly walk between them when they are rough housing.....with our hands either in our pockets or at our side....it is a reminder we can and will get between them when we want to. We keep our hands down so we don't leave them with the impression we want to play to. I always go in hip first....cuz if I don't...they will clobber me like a punching bag.
 
Another thought hit me...the double poop duty thing.


It has been raining in sheets here since about 6 a.m......the boys got out and got the morning business done just before it started. We got a break in the hard rain about 15 minutes ago...so I ran out to do poop duty......thanks to the rain it wasn't gonna be scoop duty..it was hose it down duty.

I have read others here in other threads talking about how they are "poo inspectors" .....made me feel a WHOLE lot better about my habit of inspecting the poo!! I thought I was being a freaky helicopter Ma!

I was thinking about after we got Bam home..I needed a stool sample for the vet....and I said to the vet
"OKAY...HOW am I suppose to know whose poo is whose????"

Vet gave me some TOTAL SANITY SAVING ADVICE!!

Pick a vegie that stays evident in the stool...and assign each dog...a vegie.

When we need to get a stool sample or I need to figure out which one is doing what when stools look wonky......Mo gets two tablespoons of frozen corn nibblets in his feedings, Bam gets 2 tablespoons of diced beets, if you choose beets don't freak out...beets will give the stool a reddish hue.

Starting with the first feeding of the day...by the evening potty run.....I can tell who pooed which poo!!
 
Hierarchy status is determined by you. Once they understand their place in the hierarchy they are less stressed with trying to battle for it between themselves. They will know it and accept it and be calmer for it.

If you allow human emotion into it, you will feel guilty constantly. You have to do it, feel comfortable with it, honor it and they will not be stressed by your emotions battling over your decision.

Dogs do not like not knowing their place in the home, it creates confusion for them and can cause unwanted behavior.
Just as you have made your family higher in the pack than Ragnar, then you must do the same with a second dog.

It was hard for me at first but I took my time watching their interaction and reading their body language.
You will be amazed at how well you learn their little nuances that other people would miss, the signs that play is starting to turn to posturing and challenge.
It takes a split second for it to go South so you have to watch and listen when they wrestle and you can see and hear the cues when it’s starting to change. That’s when you intervene and have them come to you and sit or down.

Two are also notorious for stalking each other face to face. The twins can start out with 20’ between them and take 10 minutes to slowly stalk and then get nose to nose and start the wrestling. If they get their heads side by side and posture I call them Out.
Their play is rough but you will learn when the time to end it arrives.

Maybe my advantage was they are littermates and I am not introducing a new dog into the home but the same principle applies.
 
You will be amazed at how well you learn their little nuances that other people would miss, the signs that play is starting to turn to posturing and challenge.
So much can be avoided if you can stop it before it starts. Bri, I know you know how it is riding a horse and before any onlooker could ever see it, you can feel a horse begin to stiffen and you know he's about to blow up. Even from the ground, just leading a horse you can feel what's going on, if you are in tune. Same with dogs.
 
@Tropicalbri's ...do Bogie and Bacall do the sneeze communicating?

Yes, it’s like a snort sneeze. I hear that and I will immediately call one to me or just use the tone on their e collar. I trained them to the come command with the tone function.

We get dogs coming in the clinic that will do a short forced sneeze and then body stiffen, eyes dilated. I will usually get a muzzle when this occurs because usually a fireball is headed down the pike.


Bri, I know you know how it is riding a horse and before any onlooker could ever see it, you can feel a horse begin to stiffen and you know he's about to blow up. Even from the ground, just leading a horse you can feel what's going on, if you are in tune. Same with dogs.

Absolutely correct. My one mare had a tell that I always watched and that was a certain way she would twitch her mane. You could feel the subtle body change through your entire body and knew something was up. I was a glutton for punishment with her because she was a cutting mare and I would trail ride and do some training under English tack to improve my balance and flexibility.
Quite a few times I was on the south side looking up.
I had a beautiful Billy Cook basket weave cutting saddle with a 3” horn I used for competitions. My balance improved enough that I didn’t have to lock my elbow into my hip when I used the horn when she got low on a cow. She could work a cow like nobody’s business. She was also a cold back. I always dreaded those first 10min on her back. Lol

Thinking back on all my horses they all had a tell that was totally different from the others. Damn I miss my horses. :(
 
Yes, it’s like a snort sneeze. I hear that and I will immediately call one to me or just use the tone on their e collar. I trained them to the come command with the tone function.

That's interesting...with these two..the snort sneeze...... is a sign everything is fine....it is when they stop sneezing we see their body language start to shift to..."Okay...I'm not playing any more!!" and we start calling them out.

Mo uses his snort sneeze to get Bam to play.....it always the same sound sneeze...LOL....like they have their own Morse code. They have been stuck in the house all day today cuz the rain just isn't letting up....Mo keeps walking up to Bam...poking at him with his nose and sneezing....and Bam keeps looking at me like
"I know Mom....we can't play in the house.....tell HIM that!!":laughing:


Their play is rough

It is so hard to make people who don't understand how they play..understand they aren't fighting to the death.
About four months after we got Bam...twice animal control showed up at our place looking for the "Doberman and Pit mix I had that was always fighting in the front yard." Bam isn't sleek....he's small and stout (sometimes his nickname is Teapot)from the back...at a distance.....people mistake him for some kind of pit mix.....often.

Both times I brought the boys out to the deck...made them stay..invited the officer into the yard to meet them.....both times they both said "I see two dobermans....is there a pit here you aren't telling me about?":facepalm:I assured them nope......these were the only two dogs here...to feel free to ask my neighbors how many/what dogs are in my yard at anytime. I gave him our vets name...told him to contact them about the guys.

For a few weeks.....they would drive by our place at least once a day...I'd smile and wave.

That stopped.....but a couple months later...I hear someone honk from my drive way....it's animal control.

I was at a point I was loosing my cool over the whole deal..but thank goodness I didn't that day.

The officer waved at me from the truck with a big smile and said he got a call about the vicious dogs at this address again...he said as soon as he saw the address he knew it Mo and Bam....but he had to "make an appearance" he gave me a thumbs up, backed out and went on his way....after that...they would drive by...slow down...honk and wave...and go on.


Double devil dogs....double bedeviling attention of neighbors who need to get their own flippin' lives.
 
Double devil dogs....double bedeviling attention of neighbors who need to get their own flippin' lives.

This is a problem when you have nosy neighbors or neighbors without pets. They don’t come and ask you about it to understand, they just report you.
All my neighbors know how my dogs sound when they play and think it’s amazing that they sound so vicious with each other when playing then they share a water bowl and a toy.

I made sure all of them understood about how Dobermanns play and sound.
I also told them if someone comes up to our gate they could tell the difference between play and getting serious, because my two will NOT allow you in the gate without me there even if they know you.

It’s the crazy tourists that rent in the neighborhood and get upset when my dogs (all the dogs on our street) bark at them when they walk their dog. It’s exhausting dealing with these people during season. They let their dogs crap and pee in your yard then get huffy when you tell them to clean it up.
Makes me want to bring mine out to just sit in the driveway with me when they walk by just to keep their dogs out of my yard. Bet that would keep them to the other side of the street. Lol
 
All my neighbors know how my dogs sound when they play and think it’s amazing that they sound so vicious with each other when playing then they share a water bowl and a toy.

It's so much fun to watch people "get that" clue.....see the wonder on their face when they get...it's all fun and games.:)

I had the clue before we got Bam watching our daughter's two play.....I'm not sure how I would have dealt with Mo and Bam doing if I hadn't been around hers.


It’s the crazy tourists that rent in the neighborhood and get upset when my dogs (all the dogs on our street) bark at them when they walk their dog. It’s exhausting dealing with these people during season. They let their dogs crap and pee in your yard then get huffy when you tell them to clean it up.

Bingo.
We deal with that where we are right now....the majority of people who are here in the RV park..are long term, they are working at the plant DH is at...but we have over nighters/in for a few days then out...and they are the ones who leave the messes for the rest of us to clean up.

We had a couple here a while back that had two mid sized dog...and they never cleaned up after them.

One day I figured out which spot they were parked in and had half a mind to take my daily scoops from the boys and dump it RIGHT under the door of their travel tailor....let them deal with stepping in CRAP! Word around the park is they were asked to leave because they weren't cleaning up after their dogs....YAY management!!
 
It's so much fun to watch people "get that" clue.....see the wonder on their face when they get...it's all fun and games.:)

I had the clue before we got Bam watching our daughter's two play.....I'm not sure how I would have dealt with Mo and Bam doing if I hadn't been around hers.




Bingo.
We deal with that where we are right now....the majority of people who are here in the RV park..are long term, they are working at the plant DH is at...but we have over nighters/in for a few days then out...and they are the ones who leave the messes for the rest of us to clean up.

We had a couple here a while back that had two mid sized dog...and they never cleaned up after them.

One day I figured out which spot they were parked in and had half a mind to take my daily scoops from the boys and dump it RIGHT under the door of their travel tailor....let them deal with stepping in CRAP! Word around the park is they were asked to leave because they weren't cleaning up after their dogs....YAY management!!
How can anyone be so lazy and careless not to clean up behind their dogs?!?
I clean up behind mine every time they take a dump. Nothing worse than stepping in dog poop especially when it isn’t your own dogs.:mad:
Nasty people!!
 

Back
Top