Four month old puppy suddenly EXTREMELY possessive, aggressive

malioswa

Notable member
Hello DCF,

I have had my 4 month old girl, Blue, for about two months. She has NEVER showed aggressive or possessive habits until tonight.

She picked up a paper bag on the sidewalk and simply would not let it go, and when I tried to take it (which normally she complies with) she would not give, and ultimately got aggressive. She knows "leave it" fairly well at 4 months. Had 0 effect. Was an anomalous event, so I'm looking for feedback. Something triggered.
 
Welcome from Australia. :ntmy:

I am no expert, but my Dobie mix was a little devil at about the 4 month mark. Willful, cheeky and inclined to be defiant. What I was taking to be aggressive behaviour, and therefore very worrying, turned out to be a fairly normal part of Dobie puppy development. Such a sudden different attitude is a bit strange though. Hopefully others will have helpful advice for you. :)
 
Thank you, that calms my nerves quite a bit lol. I know puppies will be puppies. But this possessiveness is just out of left field, so to speak. She has been so good until tonight, hence why I say something "triggered" this behavior. Need to know what. :{}
 
Hey there.

Different things will show themselves as a pup matures. She may have a tendency toward possessiveness on the way.

It could be the environment – a four month old pup in the big old world feeling a bit unsure and falling back instinctively on a defensive behavior once she gets ahold of something.

It could also be there was an attractive scent on the bag. Did you happen to give it the smell test?
 
Honestly, they can be possessive over ANY object, doesn’t matter how low value you think that object is. Some dogs just think it’s acceptable to take what they want. It’s OUR job to teach them different. I would make her learn that ‘nothing is free!’ Make her earn her food and toys at home. Make her sit and wait at the door before walks, don’t let her barge past you out of the door...etc...It’s a way to reinforce good manners and teach her self-control.
Concerning the bag that she snatched...if you appeared tentative with her she most likely picked up on that. I know some people like to ‘trade’ another more acceptable object/high value treat with their dogs. Would that be rewarding the dog for their possessiveness? I’m not overly keen on the trade approach, personally.
Keep in mind, it’s all about timing. Ideally, you would step in and block or give a calm, firm “no” or “leave it” before she has a chance to grab or guard an item.
In the garden at home, put her on a leash, and set up those types of scenarios and practice in short sessions a few times per day. A firm tug on her leash as a correction, when needed.

Keep working on ‘Leave it’ & ‘drop it.’
In order to help her improve her manners overall, it is absolutely necessary to work on her basic obedience first. If you need some help, it’s OK to attend an obedience class or work one-on-one with a trainer.
 
Thank you all for the replies.

@Oh Little Oji - I think the "big world" is definitely part of it; she was calm and collected once we got inside. Thank you.

@Doberman Gang - I did get the bag from her but as I indicated, it was a struggle. Yes I told her NO, and LEAVE IT, but she didn't really care lol. I had to physically restrain her and force her to let go.

@Viemarangelrock - thank you for the response; I guess my frustration comes from the fact that I DID give her what I consider a proper correction ('no', 'leave it', pop on leash) yet she got extremely possessive for the first time I've seen. Maybe it's just the dreaded "doberteen" phase rearing it's head? Thanks again, duly noted.
 
@Oh Little Oji - I think the "big world" is definitely part of it; she was calm and collected once we got inside. Thank you.
Oh holy cats yes. Dobermans are different creatures outside compared to inside. I nearly lost my mind trying to teach my first Doberman to heel. He would so fervently ignore me and refuse to look at me outside of the house. Get inside and close the door and his attention was all mine. It made me feel much better to tell myself that we have an EXTREMELY alert breed here. That is one of the key guard dog qualities that has not been bred out of them.
 
NO, and LEAVE IT, but she didn't really care lol. I had to physically restrain her and force her to let go.
She must know you are the boss and you will back up what you say. One command and follow thru. No time outs, no counting to 10. Just a firm Out or leave it, then if she doesn’t let go firm correction. If done fair and consistent she will learn fast and let go on command.
 
Hey! I actually work for a dog trainer and my dobie did the same exact thing but his was just barking at everything. From paper bags in the road to people walking towards us and we go walking very frequently. She basically said that it’s normally for puppies to go through phases where they show fear/“aggression” ( especially dogs that are literally bred for protection aka a Doberman haha) She said not to worry about it too much but it never hurts to do a little work with it. When you take something away from her instead of just taking it away and putting it away you can play a little game with her. So if you take a plastic bag away from her then before you put it away lure her around with it and get her interested then switch it out for another toy. Now if she has a bag Of Chocolate or something that can be a different story. But basically the luring (or if she has a sock a quick game of fetch) and games makes her realize you taking something from her is fun and exciting which will avoid resource guarding in the future. Hope that helps :)
 
Muchas Gracias my friend, seriously. This esp.,

"basically said that it’s normally for puppies to go through phases where they show fear/“aggression” ( especially dogs that are literally bred for protection aka a Doberman haha)

"Perspective" is real, thank you, truly =)
 
Muchas Gracias my friend, seriously. This esp.,

"basically said that it’s normally for puppies to go through phases where they show fear/“aggression” ( especially dogs that are literally bred for protection aka a Doberman haha)

"Perspective" is real, thank you, truly =)

@Ajax422 ..
 
She must know you are the boss and you will back up what you say. One command and follow thru. No time outs, no counting to 10. Just a firm Out or leave it, then if she doesn’t let go firm correction. If done fair and consistent she will learn fast and let go on command.

Just wanted to say this is some of the best advice I've received. Ever. Thank you sir. Simple but critical. I stopped being a dope all day, meaning started being firm and consistent, as opposed to being bitchmade. Wow. She's been an angel (well.......relatively LOL) and more obedient than ever lol. But more importantly, HAPPIER (IMO!) than ever. In a day.

Point = firmness & fairness work + thank you all for the feedback
 

Back
Top