Euro or American Lines for me...?

123dobie

New Member
I owned a female NA doberman many years ago and loved this dog to death. She had the typical doberman traits, but seemed a little lower energy than some of the dogs I see people describing. Also, she had no protective instinct whatsoever.

I am wondering if getting a euro dog would maybe give me a better chance at getting a dog with a more of a protective nature and, but worried that maybe a dog from a "working" line may have more energy? Or be more difficult? I really don't know much which is why I am asking.

I am still a little ways out from purchasing a dog, but it is going to happen and I am so excited! I just want to make sure I get the best fit for me and my family.

Thanks!
 
I have one of each, both females, actually 1 is 3/4 European and 1 is 3/4 North American. You said your last Dobe had no protective instinct whatsoever, to me that has to do with her breeding, not Euro vs NA. I would make sure of the health and temperament of a breeder's dogs before I choose where to get a pup from. Euro's usually come from more solid working dog lines with high prey drive and high energy. They also tend to be larger than NA's. That does not mean that you can't get high energy and protection from an NA. Both my girls, (the Sinsiters), are high energy and very protective. My Euro, Dauntless, is larger than my NA, Candor, and that is the only difference between them other than they each have their own quirky personality traits! Both are Obedience trained and have done Rally and Agility. Both are amazing! Just do a ton of research to find the right breeder for you!
 
I have one of each, both females, actually 1 is 3/4 European and 1 is 3/4 North American. You said your last Dobe had no protective instinct whatsoever, to me that has to do with her breeding, not Euro vs NA. I would make sure of the health and temperament of a breeder's dogs before I choose where to get a pup from. Euro's usually come from more solid working dog lines with high prey drive and high energy. They also tend to be larger than NA's. That does not mean that you can't get high energy and protection from an NA. Both my girls, (the Sinsiters), are high energy and very protective. My Euro, Dauntless, is larger than my NA, Candor, and that is the only difference between them other than they each have their own quirky personality traits! Both are Obedience trained and have done Rally and Agility. Both are amazing! Just do a ton of research to find the right breeder for you!

It is the "high energy" part that seems to be more associated with the euro bred dogs that concerns me a bit. Does high energy mean the dogs don't calm down very well in the house? Or that you have to work the hell out of them to be satisfied? Can you explain what "high energy" means to you and your dogs?

Thanks for the response!
 
Again, I think it has much more to do with breeding, than NA or Euro. I think Euro working line dogs are generally smaller, more agile, than strictly conformation dogs? Do your research for a breeder who will have what you want, not just based on geography.
 
I have a 19month NA from show lines and he is high drive and protective. Only two things slow him down, the heat of the sun and putting him in the crate.

Does high energy mean the dogs don't calm down very well in the house? Or that you have to work the hell out of them to be satisfied?

I would say yes to both of these questions. If you don’t physically and mentally stimulate them on a daily basis, they will make your life hell inside the house. I like the way a member said one time, “If you don’t occupy or work their energy, then they will find a way on their terms”.

You have the time, energy and will power to work a Euro? then get a Euro, just be careful what you wish for..... otherwise, find a breeder that has 1/2 & 1/2 or find a long standing great breeder that knows how to judge pups that can place you a NA with the qualities you are looking for.

The Euros will chime in shortly.
 
Can you explain what "high energy" means to you and your dogs?

The high energy is more work, you must give them enough physical and mental stimulation or you will have problems with them turning into Dober Devils! I work my girls on and off all day. Hubby works with them in the morning as he works 2nd shift and I work them in the afternoon and evening. We train, play, run, hike etc., anything to keep them mentally and physically alert. In the later part of the evening they turn into couch potatoes! They love to cuddle after a long day of fun! I also take them to work with me a few times a week, the employees love it and so do the girls!
 
I usually feel the need to remind folks not to equate Euro with Working. There are plenty of Euro conformation Dobes. At the same time, yes, the presence of working titles is probably more prevalent, overall, in Euros. I think the mindset that a working dog should prove its working ability before being allowed to be breed is alive more in Europe than in America.

So, to me, there are four major aspects that comprise what a Dobe could be made of: Euro, NA, Confo., Working.

I currently own a Working Dobe that, yes, is a Euro. Believe me, he is not big and bulky. Hardcore working Dobes are built for speed and agility. They also have pronounced drives, with prey drive usually through the roof (though most all Dobes have major high prey drive). Working Dobes, as I describe it, are not as good at being pets. Yes, they have the Doberman lovingness and sensitivity and clownishness, but they are a pain! I don't recommend them for the owner who does not know what they're getting into. That said, a serious working breeder would not sell to someone they don't find qualified to own one.

Your former girl having no protective qualities is rare. Seems to me that most all Dobes have a very high degree of alertness, and tend to be protective (even if many of them would back down to a real threat).

Overall, I would think that you would find what you need in any of a number of NA conformation breeders. A well-bred Dobe from such lines should be alert and protective and (though you never can say for certain) not real over the top drivey and high strung.
 
It is the "high energy" part that seems to be more associated with the euro bred dogs that concerns me a bit. Does high energy mean the dogs don't calm down very well in the house? Or that you have to work the hell out of them to be satisfied? Can you explain what "high energy" means to you and your dogs?
We have one Euro, our first Doberman and dog, and let me say that the energy level from these psycho puppies is no joke. For the longest time I couldn’t understand why anyone would pay for this torture :spit:

The first year was pure mayhem and required a lot of dedicated time and “high energy” FROM US to keep up with him. I was very often unwilling to help out, so my hb bore the brunt of the responsibility, so definitely talk this over with your spouse first! The fact that you are at all concerned about high energy means you should pause and think about your next steps. You say your first one wasn’t protective at all. Was she from a reputable breeder? If not, I would think that explains the lack of protective instinct. Compared to the pool of American Dobermans around us locally, Kaiser is the Doberman on crack, lol, he is always the last one to stop moving. Now that he is nearing 3 years old, it is almost easy and almost comical to recall the insanity of the early days. My hb is still recovering from the experience haha, so I guess we won't be entertaining another one for a while yet :wacky:

Also, I have come to the conclusion that this breed (when bred to standard) is supposed to be a handful, but working line Dobermans should not be owned by anyone that is not going to WORK the dog. They require an outlet to keep their sanity, and you will require it to keep yours.

Do let us know what you choose. Dobermans are truly amazing and unlike any other dogs as you figured out with your last one, just be aware of how much energy is suitable for your household and lifestyle.
 
It is the "high energy" part that seems to be more associated with the euro bred dogs that concerns me a bit. Does high energy mean the dogs don't calm down very well in the house? Or that you have to work the hell out of them to be satisfied? Can you explain what "high energy" means to you and your dogs?

Thanks for the response!
Well, this is interesting.

One thing that I have long said is one of the best qualities of the Doberman is that they tend to be calm in the house.

Maybe I've been lucky. I'm on my second Dobe that is from serious working lines and while they are a pain, I don't find it nearly as difficult and demanding as Ddski or Kaiser's Mom describes. Is it something about me? Am I that strict a leader – such a hard-nosed guy that has made it clear from the start what my Dobe can and cannot expect out of life? Right now, Oji is laying on the living room rug as I laze on the couch poking around Doberman-chat. He knows he will (probably) get his late night walk at some point. The only other specific exercise/activity I have given him today is a nice walk this morning about 16 hours ago.

To me, "high energy" means mostly a few things:

1. WHINING!!!!!

2. Pacing and being underfoot as they try to influence you to take them out for some activity

3. Being extremely hard to walk on a leash. In fairness, my first Dobe who was not from working lines and was in fact not from any real sort of lines you could quantify – he was from a hobby breeder whose key claim they could offer was that he was AKC – was also extremely hard to walk on a leash. Yes, I always train my Dobes to heel with precision; but I don't consider having them on a heel the whole walk to be much of a walk at all. So I have a horse lead I tie around my waist and I let them PULL. Each walk is like a weight-pulling training session.

4. The threat of tearing up, chewing and (most scary part) swallowing things they tear up.

Numbers 1, 2 and 4 can all be made better by providing enough mental and physical stimulation as you have time for in your life. Again though, for me, that is not all that much. I think you should be able to have your Dobe adapt to your lifestyle if are simply consistent and firm.
 
I would recommend for you to go through a show breeder who can match the right pup with you’re family. They can choose the more calm one out of the litter if that is what you are looking for and still have a protective side to them. Don’t confuse calm though with not having to still work them everyday to have them be mannered and balanced in the home. But sounds like that would be a better fit for you then a very high drive Dobe who needs way more work. My boy is from Show lines and can be pretty calm compared to other Doberman’s I have been around. He also never has been destructive in my home and was trusted to be left alone out of a crate from 8 months and on. He still has to be exercised and worked daily though. If he doesn’t have at least some kind of outlet for energy then he starts to spin and do zoomies and throw his bed lol. Those times are on rainy days. So we play hide and seek in the house. Haha! Good luck.
 
I think many many times when a dog is bred hardcore for a certain purpose, its overall makeup suffers. This includes physical appearance. Yes, we hear of some breeders claiming to breed the "complete" Doberman. If I could find one that satisfied me that they actually lived up to that claim, I'd be hounding them for a pup.

Mystic mentioned crate training above, I believe. With my Oji? He peed and pooped in his crate every time I put him in there and left the house. This continued for months, and you can imagine that it felt like it would never end. Today, at 4 3/4 years of age, his (repaired) crate is still not safe from chewing damage if he's not happy about being in there. Strangely though, he has never been a chewer outside of confinement. As of maybe about a year ago, he has finally earned free-reign of the house when we leave, and I wonder if he would have done better if we just gave that to him early on instead of fighting tooth and nail to fully crate train him.
 
Strangely though, he has never been a chewer outside of confinement. As of maybe about a year ago, he has finally earned free-reign of the house when we leave, and I wonder if he would have done better if we just gave that to him early on instead of fighting tooth and nail to fully crate train him
I wonder whether it’s logical to crate a breed that is designed to patrol its environment. Aren’t they the original junk yard dog? Roaming the property when the humans weren’t around, every sound investigated to ensure nothing was amiss. How is that dog supposed to handle confinement? It would be like claustrophobia no?
 
I wonder whether it’s logical to crate a breed that is designed to patrol its environment. Aren’t they the original junk yard dog? Roaming the property when the humans weren’t around, every sound investigated to ensure nothing was amiss. How is that dog supposed to handle confinement? It would be like claustrophobia no?
I agree with your point, but some details not quite.

Maybe you're mixing up that Herr Doberman took dogs from the local pound and bred them to start to build toward the dog he envisioned; but the original intention for the breed was not to be a property patrol dog. It was to be a personal bodyguard. It's one of the few breeds ever specifically designed for this sole purpose.

But yes, if you consider that the Doberman just wants to be with us and (should) want to protect us, it must be hard for them to accept being locked in a crate and having us leave the premises. Unfortunately, that's the reality of life, and most domesticated dogs have it bred into them to accept the owners leaving and returning.

Oji, I think, just feels freaked out by being confined. Weird, though, because at the same time I see that he has that typical canine attraction to being cloistered in a smallish, dark, safe calm place at times.

The thing with Oji is his separation anxiety.

That, and the little killer likes his comfort. A winter puppy, it was the day that it finallly warmed up to a rather hot sunny set of conditions and I had taken him for a walk or run then brought him home where I had happened to choose to switch back to the plastic crate and put it back in the darkish cool basement – it was on this day that he finally stopped peeing in his crate. He liked the crate compared to the oppressive :facepalm: conditions outside. This taught me something I will try to use in the future in dog training.
 
I think many many times when a dog is bred hardcore for a certain purpose, its overall makeup suffers. This includes physical appearance. Yes, we hear of some breeders claiming to breed the "complete" Doberman. If I could find one that satisfied me that they actually lived up to that claim, I'd be hounding them for a pup.

Mystic mentioned crate training above, I believe. With my Oji? He peed and pooped in his crate every time I put him in there and left the house. This continued for months, and you can imagine that it felt like it would never end. Today, at 4 3/4 years of age, his (repaired) crate is still not safe from chewing damage if he's not happy about being in there. Strangely though, he has never been a chewer outside of confinement. As of maybe about a year ago, he has finally earned free-reign of the house when we leave, and I wonder if he would have done better if we just gave that to him early on instead of fighting tooth and nail to fully crate train him.
Yea I did the crate for a few months but slowly started to see if he did ok with being alone in the house around 6 months. Just short trips to the store then I came back. He always seemed ok but if I had to be gone longer I was still nervous even though he didn’t destroy anything. Finally 8 months I just left him out for a long while and went somewhere. Came back and he was just relaxing on his bed. I pretty much knew he was good after that. I never did much like the crate. It helped when he was just a new pup in the beginning but I was happy to not have to use it long at all. He also never was crated at night I might add. I know some have to but I just had him in his own bed next to our bed and would wake up once with him for potty and he always went back to sleep.
 
I imported a 100% European male with half show lines and half working lines.

His sister is a great pet - calm in the house, but active outside. Bane on the other hand, he was a tough puppy to handle. He is my first working dog that had working lines, and my god, the working lines uppercut me hardcore. He is always go go go, not calm in the house, extremely high energy... I was finally able to get into Schutzhund with him and WOW he is a whole new dog! Even though he is half and his siblings are not as high energy as him, he absolutely needed a job and LOVES it. Much more stable, etc. Even now, just over a year old, he is A LOT of dog for a normal owner.

Ultimately comes down to breeding. If you have a bloodline that is entirely show, you will likely get a pretty doberman but no working drive. Though I have seen some 100% show line german shepherds in my IPO club that put working shepherds into shame.
 
I also know plenty of 100% European dobermans from the same litter and all puppies have different temperaments. One puppy has absolutely ZERO drive... Like she won't even chase a ball or anything. Her sibling, crazy drive and willing to please.

I'm not breeder, but I find no puppy is the same even if they're from same litter.
 
My NA dog from champion conformation show dogs (not a brag) is always suspicious, has prey drive, and is up for anything at anytime BUUUUUT she is also the BEST snuggler I've ever met. She would sleep till noon everyday if she could. She's in a crate during the day and at night (both our dogs are). Either way you choose to go, letting a breeder know up-front what you're looking for in a dog will help them pick the puppy that best matches your needs.
 
Thanks for all the great comments!!

I will be going with another NA doberman thanks to the helpful insight from all of you. I am located in the Northwest and have my eyes on several breeders in the Oregon/Washington area. I do have my name on a couple of waiting lists but I don't have anything looking certain at this point.

The yard at my current residence isn't properly fenced so I would either put up a temporary fenced area (20x20) or wait until after I move in the next year or two. I live in a great area for dog walking, live very close to a dog park, and I have 3-4 days off/week so I am thinking I may just put up the temporary 20x20 kennel in the yard and bring a puppy home sometime in the Fall.

Thanks again for the advice!
 

Back
Top