Does anyone have experience owning German Shepherds?

AndrewT93

Novitiate
Hi all, thinking of getting a new dog next year and am thinking about Dobermans as an alternative to the German Shepherd, the only dogs I've ever owned were German Shepherds. The amount of fur produced by the German Shepherd is the reason I am considering alternatives. Does anyone have experience with or owning German Shepherds whether working or West German Showlines? To be frank, I am absolutely not looking to work the dog. Maybe a bitework session here and there for fun but nothing serious. Mainly looking for a family and traveling companion that has decent watchdog abilities since I am moving into a home surrounded by a good amount of land. Any comparisons to the German Shepherd in regards to temperament, personality, health, everyday care etc.?

As of right now I am still unsure if I should be consider America v. European lines and Show v. Working lines.
 
My wife wanted a German Shepherd. I told her that she complained too much about my yellow lab blowing coats, what did she think would happen with a GS.

Have to say this was one of the pros that steered me towards the Doberman.
 
I'm around a lot of GSD's and they're great dogs, but like you said, I don't like the amount of hair they produce.
Mainly looking for a family and traveling companion that has decent watchdog abilities
That's definitely a Doberman as long as you're a strong owner who won't let them try to outsmart you.
Any comparisons to the German Shepherd in regards to temperament, personality, health, everyday care etc.?
It's important to find a reputable breeder who does the health testing on the parents and socializes them well as pups. Personality wise I think they're a little more velcro to you since they have the natural instinct to guard their owner/s and home and they definitely need to be in the house rather than kept outside in the yard or something.

Welcome from Minnesota!
 
While they are not shed-free, the shedding of a Dobe is nothing like a GS. The fact that you have a lot of land is already a huge plus because these beasts require plenty of free running if you want to stay sane.

There have been former GS owners signing on here asking for help with their Doberman puppies if that tells you anything ;) Some of them have even been dog trainers or had lifelong experience with dogs. I always thought that perhaps all working breeds have the same level of crazy, but this doesn’t seem to be the case :spit:

For the love of god don’t get a working line Doberman - they demand to be worked. Showlines are great but the breed standard includes crazy as an actual requirement. Ok, so the standard technically calls it “energetic”, but this is way beyond any Energizer bunny you might be imagining, more like a bunny on steroids and crack at the same time, with fangs and a death stare. Other than that, they are amazing! :dobe: :D
 
A breeder that I have been considering has both GSD and doberman. Her fiance is a GSD guy, and shes the doberman girl! She has been amazing to tall to and answer my questions, I'm sure she wouldnt mind talking to you either, and she can give first hand, I currently live with both breeds, comparison for you!
 
Welcome!

Well, let's see:

I agree with @Kaiser2016 above that you don't want a working-line Dobe unless you want extra high drive, possible sharpness and frankly, a Dobe that is not that attractive in most cases. Then again, a working breeder won't sell to someone who can't satisfy to them that a working Doberman should be placed in their home.

Kaiser's mom, there, is a first-time Dobe owner and I am entertained by her sometimes dramatic descriptions. :thumbsup2: I think there are many breeds who match the Doberman in terms of energy and need for exercise/stimulation.

I was roommates with a friend years ago and we each got pups about the same time – me a Doberman and him a GSD. So I'm not at all an expert on GSDs but I've got a few general ideas. This GSD was from a sort of hobby breeder in rural Minnesota. Nothing notable in its pedigree, and the dog cost like 5 or 6 hundred bucks.

It was a great dog! Rather large at just over 100 lbs. Plenty of energy and need for exercise. A rather hard and sharp dog! Rather dominant and dog-aggressive. He was a bully and would not stop fighting when the other dog submitted (ask me how I know). This led to my belief that GSDs are not dogs that you want to let your dog get in a confrontation with. I feel that the breeds that are closer to their wild ancestors have more of that maniacal, wild ferocious fighting ability in them.

The GSD was a bit obsessive and you could see the herding instincts. He had an annoying habit of trying to pick up large rocks, when for instance romping in a stream. I know he would dive underwater to try to pick some up.

My friend, who suffers from some emotional problems, did not give him enough exercise. The dog did get overweight as it aged, and his hips began to become a problem.

But then, were you more asking about Dobermans? :lolsign:
 
My neighbor, a local Police Officer has a GSD as his K9 partner. Beautiful dog but OMG! the hair! It clumps in little balls and floats all over your floor.
I will add to this...
It's important to find a reputable breeder who does the health testing on the parents and socializes them well as pups.

I would also look for a breeder that doesn't breed for that ridiculous crouched down look where the dog can barely walk. It's painful to me to watch that.
 
Hello and welcome! Oh Little Oji is right, I do have a Doberman GSD mix and a purebred GSD. Both boys! Since you are familiar with GSDs, my pup is a mix of WGSL from the sire and the dam a Czech/DDR. He is an absolutely wonderful dog in every way, and he does not shed much more than my other two short haired dogs. He does have a shorter coat than most GSDs, and I’ve heard that the amount of shedding does depend on genetics and diet can also play a role. I sweep my floors daily anyway so the hair has been a non issue for me.

My other boy is mixed but from what I’ve gathered his personality is mostly dobe. He is also a great dog but he can be reactive to other dogs and he is innately more suspicious of going ons around the house. Both require daily exercise or they will drive you nuts, but this can be them just running around playing for a couple hours outside. Since you have land, I think you’d be just fine. Rio, my GSD is a great traveler but my mix can get anxious in the car at times. He usually settles down after he realizes we’re not stopping at his friends house within 20 minutes!
 
Definitely get a Doberman if you hate the shedding of a GSD. But if you want to do bite work only on occasion you will need to research working line breeders to have that option. Then there is living with a working line doberman vs. a show line. When you say maybe a bitework session every now and then for fun, why? Working dogs thrive on the work, and a non working doberman probably won’t do bite work,especially if you are not training them on a consistent basis. Were your GSD’s pets or working dogs? Were they house dogs or live in a kennel? Dobermans don’t do well as outside kennel dogs. Which ever you decide have fun and enjoy your journey. I have Dobermans and GSDs that train with me and they all have different personalities. Some have natural abilities in Protection some need time and training to build confidence. Good luck
 
Definitely get a Doberman if you hate the shedding of a GSD. But if you want to do bite work only on occasion you will need to research working line breeders to have that option. Then there is living with a working line doberman vs. a show line. When you say maybe a bitework session every now and then for fun, why? Working dogs thrive on the work, and a non working doberman probably won’t do bite work,especially if you are not training them on a consistent basis. Were your GSD’s pets or working dogs? Were they house dogs or live in a kennel? Dobermans don’t do well as outside kennel dogs. Which ever you decide have fun and enjoy your journey. I have Dobermans and GSDs that train with me and they all have different personalities. Some have natural abilities in Protection some need time and training to build confidence. Good luck

The reason I would only participate in bitework sessions here and there is due to the fact that I travel for work. I'm sometimes on the road for months on end (all my dogs come with me). I did a few bitework training sessions with my prior dogs, both they and I really enjoyed but due to time constraints we were never able to get serious with it. If I end up getting a dog that doesn't have the drive to do that kind of activity, no big deal. My past GSDs were mainly pets with a few "working" activities here and there. Two were showlines and one was a working line (lower drive/active family level). All my dogs live in the house. I've been looking at pictures quite a bit the last few weeks and I for sure don't want the Dobermans that look like they could pass for a micro Great Dane or a fairly scrawny/skinny Doberman either.
 
I have both!
I enjoy both, my Doberman is out of working lines, My Shepherd is pet lines.
My Shepherd doesn’t shed much but i do a lot of coat maintenance. The biggest difference I’ve really experienced that stuck out to me is, while both are Velcro dogs, my Shepherd is content just being in the same room as me while my Doberman wants to be on top of me and have all my attention.

If you like a pushy clingy dog that thinks it’s still a baby and actively wants hugs and to be in your lap. Then yeah Doberman 100%
I personally like my space so this is a big adjustment for me
But atleast I feel loved.
 
The biggest difference I’ve really experienced that stuck out to me is, while both are Velcro dogs, my Shepherd is content just being in the same room as me while my Doberman wants to be on top of me and have all my attention.
:spit: Reading that, I'm thinking, how much more than "Velcro" is there? Oh, being on top of you. :rofl: Yea, that's a Doberman. :thumbsup2:
 
I enjoy both, my Doberman is out of working lines, My Shepherd is pet lines.
By the way, I'd love to find a Dobe from working lines that is as attractive as yours. He seems to have conformation-line good looks. I forget how old he is. What's he tipping the scales at, if I may ask?
 
By the way, I'd love to find a Dobe from working lines that is as attractive as yours. He seems to have conformation-line good looks. I forget how old he is. What's he tipping the scales at, if I may ask?
Thank you! he's going to be 3 in March and last weighed was around 65lbs. But he's packed on a lot of muscles and gained since then so its probably changed some.
He comes heavy in lines like Ascomannis, Bayern, Germania, and Kondorstrand on both sides, but I think some Euro Working/Conf lines were added in too a few generations back
 
Thank you! he's going to be 3 in March and last weighed was around 65lbs. But he's packed on a lot of muscles and gained since then so its probably changed some.
He comes heavy in lines like Ascomannis, Bayern, Germania, and Kondorstrand on both sides, but I think some Euro Working/Conf lines were added in too a few generations back
Ah. Cool! Well, that is certainly a working-Dobe bodyweight. :sonic:
 
Getting a little off topic but can anyone explain why the slope back has been bred into the GS line.

I don’t like it at all. Those that do like it- can you tell me why?

F0BC2CEC-8786-4674-830A-FFAD23CF1B09.webp
 
The “slope back” is a result of show ring trends. Movement has been awarded to an extreme where the dogs become severely over angulated but they exhibit breed standard movement to an exaggeration. They’re a herding breed and should have a low, ground covering gait with minimal effort so they can stay on the move with as little impact as possible all day. The show ring has taken function out of the picture, as it has for many other working breeds.

The particular lines in GSD although considered technically one breed, GSD people separate. They are like different breeds within themselves. Show lines tend to stick to show lines and working lines do the same.
 

Back
Top