• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Which walking tool works best for you?

RexsMom

Notable member
Hi everyone! Rex was always good at loose leash walking, but now he's transitioning into the dreaded Doberteen stage :facepalm: He is now starting to pull really hard, so I had the trainer over to help teach me corrections and such. He recommended using a training collar (which I knew would only be a matter of time).
Which would you guys recommend? He's been walking on a gentle leader for about 2 months now, but I've been thinking about prong? A harness he'd grow out of right away. Is there a certain one that worked best for you? :)
 
I would not recommend a "gentle leader." No offense, but not only does leading a dog by its snout just seem unfair, I feel that it puts the neck at greater risk of injury. I'm glad you're moving away from using one.

Yes, many people successfully use prong collars. The good word around here is to use a quality brand like Herm Sprenger (spelling?) and to use the collar width that is more narrow than most people would envision using on a dog the size of a Doberman. This delivers a more effective sensation to the dog.

Personally, I don't use one but we own one that my wife got years ago for her Husky. It is that larger width – larger than you want. I have tried it out on all three of my Dobermans over the years, and I have just placed it on the neck and used it like a regular collar. I did this just to see if they would overcome the collar and pull like normal (maniacally). Yes, they all very quickly did.

So (and I hope your trainer showed you properly) what you need to do is use the prong collar strategically. You don't want them just pulling against it. You ideally want to have them really only feel the collar when you give it a correction pop.

I'm sure some will weigh in here on that narrower collar width they use.
 
The other thing with a prong collar is you want to have it ride high up on the neck. This can be a challenge with a slender-necked, short-coated animal like a Dobe. Some people keep the prong collar high-up by using a flat collar below it (as in, mounted just lower than it) to keep it up high.
 
I use this one

Black Night Black Stainless Steel Collar with Center-Plate and Assembly Chain (4.0 mm x 25 inches) [HS77#1091 50045 010 (57) - 4.0 mm Dog Pinch Collar] : Prong Collars, Pinch Collars, Dog Training Collars, Curogan Collars, Chain Dog Collars, Fur Saver Collars, Choke Dog Collars, Herm Sprenger Collars, Dog Muzzles


It works well, he responds when corrected. Make sure if you use a prong it fits snug under the jaw/ear line and doesn’t sag down.

I also pair it with an e collar which helps when he’s extra motivated to not listen to me lol.
 
I don't know if this will help you out at all but we started our boy out with this at about 4 months old when he started to pull and it had worked out great. When he starts to pull it tightens on his chest and he instantly slows down and it will loosen. Now the first 2 times he did it he spun around and dropped to the ground in confusion but he made the connection very quickly.

Im not sure if this would work for you since he's bigger I'd hate for him to pull and it go too tight on him I just know for our guy starting out younger it worked
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20181216-175750_Amazon Shopping.webp
    Screenshot_20181216-175750_Amazon Shopping.webp
    51.9 KB · Views: 11
We always use a prong collar for training, all of the other training devices on the market use the same principle, they cause discomfort. Gentle leader is actually more cruel than using a prong in my opinion and could cause more damage to the neck. The no pull harnesses put pressure on the front shoulders and chest to restrict movement. The problem to me with this device is there is no way to no when it is working so timing on training a clear picture of what you want (walking on a loose leash) may not be relayed, thus the dog will look at his/her walks as times of discomfort, without the understanding of why it is happening. Being able to teach your dog what is expected will make for a much happier and less stressed dog in the long run.
 
Amazing results with prong collar.
Just have to make sure you place and work it correctly. You can find videos on Youtube or on Herm Sprenger site.

There is some difference of opinion on actual size to use: be it the 2.25” vs 3.0” vs 4.0”...... The 2.25” worked very well for me.

8477BCA2-47C5-4AE9-8B76-76E14D5414B5.webp
 
Last night, and just now this morning, I see appearing in the "Random Media" thing a photo of @JanS 's big ol' Albert and he has that smaller width prong collar on.
 
Prong collars are saviors. I have the small width Herm Sprenger for Brinks and paid a little extra to get a snap attachment on it. He has too much energy to go out without it, and I know it doesn’t hurt him because he gets so excited whenever I put it on.
 
By the way, I was told years ago to (with prong collars that do not have any sort of snap or other connector) put on the collar inside out, then turn it right side out once it's on the neck. Anyone do this?
 
put on the collar inside out, then turn it right side out once it's on the neck. Anyone do this?

I can understand why one may want to flip it. It can be a PITA to put one on but after you do it a couple of times and learn how to pinch the link just right, it is not an issue anymore.
 
We use a prong on our Dobie unless were at agility class or a trial - they don't allow prongs. She's actually pretty good on a flat/martingale in those situations BUT I'm certain it's because we've worked with her on the prong and she's more aware of what tension on her collar means - STOP. I also usually have a hand full of treats in those situations so maybe my training isn't really as good as I think is it :)

It's nice you have a trainer who is willing to help you learn to use a different tool.
 
Thank you everyone for your inputs! I think I’ll go out & buy a prong after the holidays (tight on money from them). Going to book an appointment with my trainer today so that he can show me how to use it correctly & practice with me :)
 
put on the collar inside out, then turn it right side out once it's on the neck. Anyone do this?

learn how to pinch the link just right, it is not an issue anymore.
I like the inside out way, but my hb just pinches the link. We had one trainer who suggested slipping it over their heads and not taking the links apart, but that just seemed uncomfortable passing over his ears.
 
I would not recommend a "gentle leader." No offense, but not only does leading a dog by its snout just seem unfair, I feel that it puts the neck at greater risk of injury. I'm glad you're moving away from using one.

Yes, many people successfully use prong collars. The good word around here is to use a quality brand like Herm Sprenger (spelling?) and to use the collar width that is more narrow than most people would envision using on a dog the size of a Doberman. This delivers a more effective sensation to the dog.

Personally, I don't use one but we own one that my wife got years ago for her Husky. It is that larger width – larger than you want. I have tried it out on all three of my Dobermans over the years, and I have just placed it on the neck and used it like a regular collar. I did this just to see if they would overcome the collar and pull like normal (maniacally). Yes, they all very quickly did.

So (and I hope your trainer showed you properly) what you need to do is use the prong collar strategically. You don't want them just pulling against it. You ideally want to have them really only feel the collar when you give it a correction pop.

I'm sure some will weigh in here on that narrower collar width they use.
Hi that's exactly it!
mine will do anything I want except heel when he's interested in something and I don't want him hurting himself pulling on the collar he has no pain threshold! Once watched him run full pelt into a wall shake his head and carry on -he was trying to jump over it
 

Back
Top