Ban of electric shock collars (UK)

Viemarangelrock

Hot Topics Subscriber
$ Forum Donor $
Ban on electric shock collars for pets

Electric shock collars for pets to be banned
  • 27 August 2018
  • UK
Share this with Email Share this with Facebook Share this with Twitter Share this with Whatsapp
Image copyrightGETTY IMAGES
_99735686_gettyimages-534332372.jpg

Electric shock collars for cats and dogs will be banned in England, the government has announced.

The training devices deliver up to 6,000 volts of electricity or spray noxious chemicals to control animals' behaviour.

Environment secretary Michael Gove said this causes unacceptable "harm and suffering".

Wales and Scotland have already taken steps to prevent the use of electric collars.

Animal charities, many of which had campaigned for the change in the law, welcomed the move.

However, some supporters of the controversial collars accused Mr Gove of making a "complete 180" after his department initially suggested there was insufficient evidence for a ban earlier this year.

A survey by the RSPCA found that 5% of dog owners reported using shock collars, suggesting that hundreds of thousands of animals would be affected by the ban.

While it supported a ban, the RSPCA criticised the decision to continue to allow electric containment fences.

A spokeswoman said: "In modern day society there is no excuse or need for the use of devices which can compromise cat and dog welfare, especially when humane and viable alternatives to training and containing dogs and cats are available."

The Dogs Trust said that electric collars could send shocks of 100 to 6,000 volts for up to 11 seconds at a time.

Dr Rachel Casey, director of canine behaviour and research at the Dogs Trust: "Scientific research has demonstrated that electronic devices which deliver an aversive stimulus have a negative impact on dog welfare, so this ban will have a major positive impact for dogs in the UK."

Image copyrightGETTY IMAGES
_99735691_gettyimages-172450461.jpg

Image captionThere is "no excuse or need" for shock collars, the RSPCA said
A ban on the devices was backed by 74% of people in a 2014 poll by the Kennel Club.

The dog welfare organisation said a ban would ensure that pets were trained with "positive methods, free from pain".

The announcement follows a government consultation, in which half of the 7,000 responses said they did not want to see containment fences banned.

Mr Gove said: "We are a nation of animal lovers and the use of punitive shock collars cause harm and suffering to our pets."

He urged pet owners to use "positive reward training methods" instead.

However, a letter sent from Mr Gove's department in February to the Royal Veterinary College - seen by the Press Association - suggested that there was insufficient evidence for supporting a ban.

Dog trainer and campaigner Jamie Penrith said Mr Gove had made an "abrupt" policy turnaround with no additional evidence.

Ian Gregory, a lobbyist for pet collar manufacturers, campaigned to prevent the ban on containment fences, arguing that they helped prevent some of the 300,000 deaths of cats in road accidents.

He said that animal charities exaggerated the impact of the shock delivered by a collar, which was about a millijoule of energy, compared to cattle fencing which was a thousand times more powerful.

"The anecdotal problems reported with pet collars can be resolved by product standards rather than by banning a proven technology," he said.

"The hundreds of thousands of dog owners using remote trainers do not deserve to be criminalised."

 
The ECollar allows me to take Ragnar from a fenced in back yard to roaming freely on a soccer complex. A big, big difference and believe me, he is much happier running freely in the wide open space of soccer fields.

I don’t have to use the ECollar often, the vibrate button to let him know he is a little too far out and time to come in some.

Only time I really use the stim buttons is when he is acting a donkey and won’t come in or he grabs something in his mouth he is not supposed to have.

Now you tell me? What’s worse or more dangerous for him? Being reminded/guided on ECollar?

OR

Eating a cut up tennis ball or golf ball that I am not fast enough to run and get out of his mouth, running after a coyote, running across a street??

smh....
 
Doesn't surprise me. The amount of hate people on facebook groups get on ecollars and usually the haters are always from the UK (no offense!) so it seems to be a commonly agreed thought over there. Its slowly becoming the case here too. I wonder what their thoughts are on electric fences to contain large animals? Large animals who may lean on physical fences and break boards, thus injuring themselves or running at large and putting people at risk?

Dogs are animals with instinct. No amount of yelling or training can 100% overcome their instinctual desires in the end. I would rather give my dog a slight discomfort, than for them to either die, another animal to die, or a car accident happen and possibly hurting a person in the process because I thought my cookie training would save them from chasing prey.

Does it make me feel good when I can call my dog off from a chase without the ecollar? Yes! But thats only from YEARS of training backed with the ecollar. Anytime without the ecollar a person is taking a risk.

I love how they emphasize the volts. Did you know carpet can generate up to 60,000 volts??? YEAH, lets ban carpet! Any intelligent person would know that volts mean nothing without a current.

I almost think that most people that have an opinion against ecollars have NEVER tried it on themselves OR have only experience with those cheap ecollars like you see in the picture. Yes, those HURT because they are crap and only have 10 levels usually so theres very little adjustability in the stimulation. Cheap ecollars are going to hurt because they are cheaply made. They aren't consistent in shock either.
 
I’ve never used one but I’m not against it, at all. I’ve educated myself about the Ecollar (mostly from you guys!) but unfortunately there’s so much misconception and misguidance around the use of the Ecollar. I see it as a tool. Used properly it can provide dogs with freedom and a level of safety they could never have without it.
Seems like this movement is based on popularity and human emotion, not the truth and results...

Make way for the ‘snowflake’ positive trainers.....:rolleyes:


Maybe they should go after the ‘gentle leader’?! Now there’s a thought! This ‘tool’ doesn’t stop them from pulling, it instead restricts and restrains them by putting pressure on a very sensitive part of their body. It does not feel natural for them and they normally have some very bad reactions.

We are so darn wet in this country and it’s got nothing to do with the damn weather.

Victoria Stilwell can go do one, too. :furious:
 
Doesn't surprise me. The amount of hate people on facebook groups get on ecollars and usually the haters are always from the UK (no offense!) so it seems to be a commonly agreed thought over there. Its slowly becoming the case here too. I wonder what their thoughts are on electric fences to contain large animals? Large animals who may lean on physical fences and break boards, thus injuring themselves or running at large and putting people at risk?

Dogs are animals with instinct. No amount of yelling or training can 100% overcome their instinctual desires in the end. I would rather give my dog a slight discomfort, than for them to either die, another animal to die, or a car accident happen and possibly hurting a person in the process because I thought my cookie training would save them from chasing prey.

Does it make me feel good when I can call my dog off from a chase without the ecollar? Yes! But thats only from YEARS of training backed with the ecollar. Anytime without the ecollar a person is taking a risk.

I love how they emphasize the volts. Did you know carpet can generate up to 60,000 volts??? YEAH, lets ban carpet! Any intelligent person would know that volts mean nothing without a current.

I almost think that most people that have an opinion against ecollars have NEVER tried it on themselves OR have only experience with those cheap ecollars like you see in the picture. Yes, those HURT because they are crap and only have 10 levels usually so theres very little adjustability in the stimulation. Cheap ecollars are going to hurt because they are cheaply made. They aren't consistent in shock either.

People have a misconception of volts, volts don’t kill. Amperage does, they just like to throw around the voltage to scare yah.
 

Back
Top