Yeah, no need to be embarrassed! We do the best we can with the information we've got and pet food has become a very confusing industry.
Going through my dog food order history, we've tried:
- Solid Gold
- Solid Gold - different formula
- Solid Gold - back to original one
- Annamaet
- Blue Buffalo Wilderness (1 4.5lb bag, what was I thinking?!)
- Annamaet again
- ACANA which we were on a for a long time
- Holistic Select Adult Healthy Anchovy, Sardine and Salmon is what we just bought to try
The food we just bought is not grain-free and is rated 4 stars on dogfoodadvisor.com but I just saw there is a grain-free that is rated 4.5 so that will be what I do next (not sure how I missed that the first time. REPEAT: we do the best we can with the information we have!). She seems eager to eat it and the her transition has been seamless (no runny poo and I would say it's even a bit more firm and smaller - that's a great indicator of how they're doing on their food).
We're getting a new puppy in about 3 weeks and the breeder has some strong recommendations for food so we might explore those and cross reference in the interest of HOPEFULLY getting both dogs on one type of food at some point.
Raw is a very good direction to go but it does take education to do properly. I've fed raw in the past and we've talked about going back to it but again, bringing another pup on-board, it might be something we hold off on for a bit, yet. If it's something you would like to pursue, there is a wealth of knowledge on this site!
I think what
@Kaiser2016 said is what we followed when she was a pup - we were on an all life stages food, not a puppy food.
Also, if you're buying on-line, chewy.com may have somethings that other sites like petflow.com might and vice versa so worth checking both out (love those autoship discounts!).
Clear as mud, right?!

