No-pull harness

My2Girls

Notable member
Does anyone have a favorite brand for a no-pull harness? Not the muzzle types. I've tried some with no success because of the dobie deep chest. If you have a fav please share the brand. My Princess is a puller and now Shadow (the puppy) is starting to pull when I walk them together. However, when I walk Shadow alone she does not pull. TIA
 
Both my dobies like to pull...until I introduced the prong collar. It is an amazing tool with instant results. Now I can hold the leash with one finger.
 
Ditto for the prong.
Both my dobies like to pull...until I introduced the prong collar. It is an amazing tool with instant results. Now I can hold the leash with one finger.

Plus two here. Game changer.

My problem however, is if I don't use the prong now he thinks he's an Iditarod competitor.
The last few weeks I have specifically not used the prong, trying to work on his leash manners without the prong.

Also, and this is just specific to my own situation and dog. He started associating only the prong and leash as time to walk.
Any thing else like a tab or different leash, he goes the other way. He thinks it meant he's going in the truck which he does not like.
So, in the last month or so I have broken him of that, but if I have a tab or leash and say walk he's totally on board. If I say truck or ride, he'll run up stairs.

I guess my point is he started recognizing certain tools for certain purpose that wasn't accurate.
So I'm working on him and his behaviors rather than letting a tool dictate his behavior.
 
I'm another who swears by prong collars, provided they're used correctly and as long as the pup or dog is at least 6 months.
 
Yep were all about our prongs as well ! Actually phasing it out right now cuz they don't need it very much. Amazing tool though.
 
I'm going to be of little help to you as I want my dog to pull in a harness due to him participating in a canine sport.
We walk him in a neck collar, and make him walk alongside us. Any pull and it's stop and walk in a different direction.
As soon as you put the harness on he's off, literally. He's learnt to associate the harness with the sport.

Looking at the above comments it sounds like the prong is the best solution. I've never used one as its not readily available in the UK. But it does sound like a great tool if used correctly.
There are some great harnesses available but are they really no-pull? I'm not convinced (well, not for a strong breed like the Doberman anyway!!). I think if you have a strong puller a front attachment is not enough and will not give you the control.

I'm not a lover of the head-halti either. Possible concern about straining the neck if the dog lunges strongly into the collar.
 
Any pull and it's stop and walk in a different direction.



I found with Drake I could just stop walking and he figured out what I wanted. That boy likes to pull and the turning was so constant I found myself getting dizzy.


Does anyone have a favorite brand for a no-pull harness?



I have found that harnesses actually promote pulling and threw mine out within a week. Chalk another vote up for training and a properly used prong.
 
My opinion on all of the so called solutions to pulling dogs, such as the head halter and the no pull harnesses. These are designed to cause discomfort if a dog pulls same as using other training collars. The key word is training no matter what you use. The head halter to me can turn the neck and I don't want any undo stress on my dogs neck. Same reason I won't use a choker. The new no pull harness I have not checked out but it probably works by restricting or cause pressure on the front legs or chest. I still believe the prong or martingale to be the best two choices.
 
The only no pull harness I'd suggest is a front clip type and only if you dont plan on showing obedience. They work by turning the dog towards you.

Yoou could try a martingale first over a prong but its generally better to do it the other way. a martingale for a dog is the same principle of simultaneously closing but is on a flat collar.
 
Thank you for all your replies. My issue is I don't want to put stress on her neck. I have a regular harness that I used until I was told it promotes pulling. So I've switched back to the flat collar and now she just about chokes herself. I haven't used the prong since she was about a year old. She would pull with that and then get this twitch so I stopped. Again this is when I walk both of them at the same time and I don't think they get the stopping and going as I think they just try to out do each other. And I don't want the puppy to start pulling and pick up that behavior. (She does not pull when I walk her alone). Maybe I'll have to bring out the prong again and give it another go.
 
Thank you for all your replies. My issue is I don't want to put stress on her neck. I have a regular harness that I used until I was told it promotes pulling. So I've switched back to the flat collar and now she just about chokes herself. I haven't used the prong since she was about a year old. She would pull with that and then get this twitch so I stopped. Again this is when I walk both of them at the same time and I don't think they get the stopping and going as I think they just try to out do each other. And I don't want the puppy to start pulling and pick up that behavior. (She does not pull when I walk her alone). Maybe I'll have to bring out the prong again and give it another go.
Actually, I think you should continue working them individually, and often.

Not doing so was a mistake I made. I'm not saying don't walk them together but continue to work them at their own paces as well. I believe you will see better progress from both of them.
 
If shes pulling with the prong you're not being fast enough or correct about your corrections. Or perhaps the collar isnt in the right spot either up high as it goes on the neck.
 
What size prong do you have? I have been told the smaller gauge (2.25) is more effective than the larger. I have found the 2.25 is perfect size for both my 80 lb and 75 lb pullers. My boy would choke the heck out of himself with a flat collar but will not push it with the prong.
 

Back
Top