How The Doberman Pinscher Temperament Has Changed

So, that Rott is Oji's weight. Small package to be sure.
Actually Tad, he may be a slightly smaller package than Oji, based on pics you've posted.

I know it's slightly off topic, but sort of not.
image.webp
I've posted this pic before but shows his size well. He's at least 5 years old in this pic in the bed of my truck on a camping trip in March of 14 I believe.
 
Actually Tad, he may be a slightly smaller package than Oji, based on pics you've posted.

I know it's slightly off topic, but sort of not.
View attachment 66851
I've posted this pic before but shows his size well. He's at least 5 years old in this pic in the bed of my truck on a camping trip in March of 14 I believe.
You're right. Oji is actually full-height for a male Dobe – 28". He is currently back down to 65 lbs., but if I can ever manage to get his body to absorb the nutrition he needs, I think he could top out at 75 pounds – maybe even 80!
 
You're right. Oji is actually full-height for a male Dobe – 28". He is currently back down to 65 lbs., but if I can ever manage to get his body to absorb the nutrition he needs, I think he could top out at 75 pounds – maybe even 80!
Hm. I wonder if feeding raw might help? It solved Kaiser's "cow patty" problem. I know another Euro owner who suggested raw as a solution for us because it worked for hers. She thinks that Euros have more sensitive stomachs. Worth a try. You'll never be happier seeing fewer smaller poops.
 
FYI. If your try it, dont be alarmed when the dog poops less. They pretty much go to pooping once a day, drink less water, and have less obvious poops.

The only times they are actually obvious is when the poops are white (like they will be if you go full raw or if you give bone marrow type treats - aka real bones).
 
FYI. If your try it, dont be alarmed when the dog poops less. They pretty much go to pooping once a day, drink less water, and have less obvious poops.

The only times they are actually obvious is when the poops are white (like they will be if you go full raw or if you give bone marrow type treats - aka real bones).
I would try raw but for the cost and the fact that we are vegetarian in our family. I realize dogs need to eat meat but we don't want to store meat in our fridge.

I can update the comment I made in this thread with this (as I did in the puppy weight-gain thread) that Oji has suddenly not only returned to 70 lbs., but 75! Actually, last two times I weighed him, he was 77! Still a freaking lightweight, and still has loose/runny stools but a major improvement toward a respectable weight for a 28" male!
 
I can update the comment I made in this thread with this (as I did in the puppy weight-gain thread) that Oji has suddenly not only returned to 70 lbs., but 75! Actually, last two times I weighed him, he was 77! Still a freaking lightweight, and still has loose/runny stools but a major improvement toward a respectable weight for a 28" male!
That's actually a great weight for a working Dobe. So work that boy :) You could try changing protein sources and maybe adding pro-biotics. Drogon is on the Lamb & Apple from Acana and his stool is solid most of the time. When he chews his knuckle bones it gets hard as a rock.
 
I can update the comment I made in this thread with this (as I did in the puppy weight-gain thread) that Oji has suddenly not only returned to 70 lbs., but 75! Actually, last two times I weighed him, he was 77!
Told ya he was going to keep filling out for a few more years. ;)

Speaking of the topic of this thread, I came across this last night. This is one of those videos I can't embed but it sort of covers the change of temperament in a Doberman.
Lola Limited – Dogs 101: Doberman – Lola on Animal Planet
 
That's actually a great weight for a working Dobe. So work that boy :) You could try changing protein sources and maybe adding pro-biotics. Drogon is on the Lamb & Apple from Acana and his stool is solid most of the time. When he chews his knuckle bones it gets hard as a rock.
Couldn't agree more.
A little lite is good for his bones and joints long term, and he's probably quite quick and agile.
I knew his weight would catch up to his height, males just take their time about it, it seems.
 
I would try raw but for the cost and the fact that we are vegetarian in our family. I realize dogs need to eat meat but we don't want to store meat in our fridge. Actually, last two times I weighed him, he was 77!
Well that makes sense. Even as a meat eater I have to admit the bones are pretty gross looking. Happy to hear about his weight gain!
 
That's actually a great weight for a working Dobe. So work that boy :) You could try changing protein sources and maybe adding pro-biotics. Drogon is on the Lamb & Apple from Acana and his stool is solid most of the time. When he chews his knuckle bones it gets hard as a rock.
Agree with the probiotics. They will help!
 
Oh man I know this is an old thread. I just want to say I am glad I dont live in the states :) In South Africa guard dogs are definitely still very much sort after, be it a Boerboel, a GSD or a Dobe. I have no experience what so ever with NA Dobes. I have a euro male (90% of dobes in South Africa are european) and a rescued bitch who I am guessing is a blend, going on her head and build, of NA and Euro. My male is 15 months old and we nicknamed him the tank, because he just runs over and through things. Levi will somersault down a hill land on his head get up and keep running, no worries. I have never heard him cry out in pain. Layla has had some basic protection training but her bite is no where near as good as my Euro male, who naturally has full deep bite. However both are unafraid. My male is no scaredy cat. He pinned a black male pittie to the ground at the dog park after the pit got too rough with him. I am not advocating the behaviour but I am pointing out that he has no problem standing up for himself. I feel for you guys in the states, it all sounds so PC. We expect our dogs to guard us (I would have gotten whippets otherwise) I know a few dobes in South Africa who have thwarted burglaries, hijackings etc even one that took a bullet for his family. I also grew up with two euro dobes in the 80s, they stopped two potential burglaries to our house and my mother never worried about them with us kids. I love the breed because of what they are and I dont care for the show ring if I had the time I would def consider competing in IPO or PPS or french ring. landlpark.webp
 
My male is 15 months old and we nicknamed him the tank, because he just runs over and through things...
Your dogs are beautiful! My Kaiser is also a Euro, and there are some others here with Euros as well. They do love to run through things especially people! I spend some time with mostly American Dobes and they definitely have more of a sense of personal space than Euros do. However, with training, Kaiser is getting better with his manners, especially when taking stairs.

Are there a lot of Dobes over there then? Do you find them mostly cropped/docked or not? Looks like your male has a docked tail.

Personally, I think calling them NA is a bit PC since the difference between the 2 lines is not purely geographic. I compare it to a German Shepherd; does it become a Canadian Shepherd if he's born here? ;)

I hear it a lot from American Dobe owners that the Euros don't have an off switch, and I think that off switch makes a big difference to the average dog owner who is looking more for a family pet that fits into a lifestyle that is more active when we are - for some, that means evenings and weekends, for others it's all day out in the country with other animals around. When a family picks a Dobe as a pet, I think they are still very much looking for protection. But wouldn't any dog offer that? I'm a first time dog owner, so I don't have an answer.

All the Dobe people I know have stories about thwarted burglaries, so I do believe that part of the Doberman has not changed no matter the lineage or part of the world. I think that ultimately, pets are a reflection of the community they live in. In some parts of the world, dogs stay in the yard; in other parts, dogs are members of the family (and even share beds!). Then there's issues around weather conditions, safety, legal concerns, all of which does become very PC as humans and animals live in closer proximity.
 
@Kaiser2016 we fall under FCI regulations meaning that you will see a lot of natural tailed dobes and only natural eared dobes here. In fact way before the official ban on cropping (I'm talking 70's) most dobes in SA were docked but left natural eared. My parents' dobes were docked but ears left natural in the 80s. My boy has a terrible dock job, its too long for Euro (kinda traditional weimaraner length) and there is scar tissue on the end. The breeder that I got him from in Namibia did it himself as its also frowned upon there, so vets wont do it. I would have prefered him with a tail but he was docked by the time I saw him at 3.5 weeks, I took delivery of him at 10 weeks.

Dobermanns are not particularly common here. They were very common in the 70's and 80's but parvo did them in in the 90s as well as very bad public image. There are still enough around though. Im happy with them being on the not too popular side as you know a Dobermann is not for everyone.

I dont really know what else to call an NA dobie :) a non euro one?? Well anyway the dobies here are a big mix of euro lineage from italian, polish, russian, serbian, french, uk, german etc. There was one breeder who used to import american dobies but he has not bred dobermanns in a while. I dont know of any other South African breeders that import NA dogs. My male who's lineage I know is mainly Russian with a touch of French, a touch of Serbian and touch of Dutch is a fairly common mix iof lineage here.

I think some European dobermanns are over the top as far as looks and size go. I also think some euro dobes (some rather famous ones to boot) suck as far as work temperament goes as well. You know there are working and show kennels in europe as well? Many kennels buy their work results so I wouldnt say all european doberamnns dont have an off switch.

I think ideally where ever the dobie comes from they should be brave, intelligent, elegant, quick, confident, stable,protective and obedient, at least to me that is how I imagine my ideal dobie. One that not only looks the part but acts the part too.
 
Oh by the way I have owned and worked with a large variety of breeds and no definitely not all breeds are equal when it comes to security and protection. You could never expect a Siberian Husky or a beagle to lay down its life for you or your property. Dogs were bred for specific jobs and yes most have been watered down to suit the "average" family however a good breeder should still breed for correct temperament and function. A dobe was bred as a personal protector, the only breed specifically bred for that role.
 
I dont really know what else to call an NA dobie :) a non euro one??
I just call them American Dobermans, and European Dobermans. I prefer to recognize only the 2 lines because of the two established breed standards.

I know there are "South American" Dobes too, but I think they stem from the American line. The only thing making them "south" is the location of the breeder.

I heard someone refer to Kaiser as a Canadian Doberman just because he was born here (to Serbian parents). So maybe this is a hot topic for me ;)

Also noticed that some people like to spell it Dobermann for the Euros (as you do), and I still haven't decided how I feel about that :)
 
In South Africa the breed is the Dobermann, at a dog show they are referred to as Dobermanns. We do not call the breed Doberman Pinschers.
And some say the only one that should be called Doberman Pinscher is the American. You can see why this thread carries on. I no longer say I have a DP. I just say Doberman unless someone knows the breed and then I'll clarify that's it's a euro.
 
I know there are "South American" Dobes too, but I think they stem from the American line. The only thing making them "south" is the location of the breeder.
Actually, I think there is more to it than that.
The SA dogs seem to be (and by my observation of pictures, no actual contact) a different variant. They're a bit thicker boned than the NA dogs but maybe not as big boned as the Euros.
And their coats... From a pure asthetic standpoint, their colors are more rich and vibrant. The rust is deep mahogany.
There was a lot of immigration from European countries from WW2 and after. No question all Dobes stem from Germany, but to me, the SA Dobes are unique.
 
Actually, I think there is more to it than that.
The SA dogs seem to be (and by my observation of pictures, no actual contact) a different variant. They're a bit thicker boned than the NA dogs but maybe not as big boned as the Euros.
And their coats... From a pure asthetic standpoint, their colors are more rich and vibrant. The rust is deep mahogany.
There was a lot of immigration from European countries from WW2 and after. No question all Dobes stem from Germany, but to me, the SA Dobes are unique.
Yes the source was Germany for all Dobes, but the American version was bred more for form and not so much for function: lighter and leaner, less drive than euro - rather perfect for a threatening household pet.

I wonder if the SA Dobe is the result of the decision of breeders to finally attempt to save the breed and mix Americans and Euros to each other. The pool is limited to just that. In the past month I have met 2 new pups that are combos. And they are from my own city, living right here, staying with Kaiser's own care giver. So, exponentially, there must be way more out there.

That said, it doesn't make them any more South American than it makes them Canadian. Maybe they are returning to the original Doberman. It won't have killer instincts because those types of dogs are not allowed in most parts of the world but it would explain their beautifully richer coats! (From what I've seen...which is only 2 pups - so far.)
 

Back
Top